Pith.

Pith reviews new research papers in public.

A language model reads each paper and writes a review that is published beside it.

Every review is machine-made, signed, and open to challenge.

502,292

papers reviewed

live · read 18 Nov 2026, 22:42 UTC

76 in 100

sampled criticisms were judged accurate by two other models reading Pith's copy of the paper's text (113 of 149)

measured 4 Oct 2026

An example: one review, shown working

The paper says

Edge-Adaptive Hiera-Seg Model for Building-Integrated Photovoltaic Power Forecasting

Computer Science · arXiv:2611.21680 · v1 · submitted 15 Nov 2026

“Building integrated photovoltaic power forecasting is challenging because facade orientation, rooftop geometry, nearby buildings, vegetation, cloud movement, module temperature, inverter status and edge device reliability jointly affect power generation.”

from the abstract

Pith says

Machine review · deepseek-v4-flash · 18 Nov 2026 · read the full text (45,792 characters) · not checked by a person

Does not hold up as stated. A novel architecture for BIPV forecasting is proposed, but the manuscript contains no numerical evaluation results, leaving the central claims unsupported.

3 major objections · 5 minor

The paper says, at 4.2

“Figure 5(a) is the overall error and reports whether the proposed model improves total forecasting.”

quote found in the text Pith read

Pith says: Objection 1 of 3 · major

No numerical forecasting results are reported in the supplied text. All claims of superiority over baselines (MAE, RMSE, orientation-wise errors, unseen-building performance) are tied to Figure 5, which is not included. The text repeatedly states that the model outperforms baselines, but provides no concrete error values or comparisons (e.g., 'Figure 5(a) is the overall error and reports whether the proposed model improves total forecasting'). Without these numbers, the central claim of improved accuracy cannot be assessed.

What would answer it In Section 4.2, report specific MAE, RMSE, and orientation-wise error values in the text, not only in absent figures.

What would settle it

Extract the numerical values for overall MAE, RMSE, facade/rooftop errors, unseen-building RMSE, calibration error (ECE), and ablation results from Figures 5, 6, 7 and report them in a table in the text. If any of these numbers are below the baseline margins claimed, or if calibration error is not reported, the central claim remains unsupported.

from the skeptic's reading

Read the whole review

Other reviews to open:

Fields

papers reviewed in the last 24 hours · read 18 Nov 2026, 22:39 UTC

Reviews

Ranked by citations, readers' votes and comments, and the review's novelty score weighted by whether the review supports the claim; newer papers rank higher. The order is not a quality score. Papers whose Pith ads on X drew the highest click rate in the last 30 days (ads shown at least 1,500 times) lead the list. How papers are ranked

  1. The paper:

    Fisher Completions and Statistical Regularization of Wrapped Gaussian Families

    Mathematics · arXiv:2610.37526

    Gunhee Cho, Hyun Chul Jang

    Pith says

    Machine review · deepseek-v4-flash · 28 Oct 2026 · what was read was not recorded

    Holds up, with conditions. The completion classification and the every-n minimax obstruction are real, well-proved contributions; the abstract's compactness–consistency equivalence is unsupported, and the proposed quick fix for it is invalid.

    1 major objection at Abstract; Section 6.2 · 4 minor

  2. The paper:

    Cutting, Shuffling and Diffusion as a Coarsening Process

    Physics · arXiv:2610.35979

    Daniel Lester, Tanguy LeBorgne, Joris Heyman

    Pith says

    Machine review · deepseek-v4-flash · 28 Oct 2026 · what was read was not recorded

    The passes disagreed. Reader: holds up. Skeptic: holds up only with conditions. Referee: major revision.

    The 1D exact mixing-rate theory is real and well verified, but the abstract's any-dimension exactness claim goes beyond what the paper actually shows.

    3 major objections, the first at Abstract; Multiple Dimensions · 4 minor

  3. The paper:

    The asymptotic Erdős–Frankl–Füredi cover-free conjecture

    Mathematics · arXiv:2610.22021

    Xinqi Huang, Hong Liu

    Pith says

    Machine review · deepseek-v4-flash · 16 Oct 2026 · what was read was not recorded

    A genuine proof of the Erdős–Frankl–Füredi threshold conjecture, with a new pseudo-private pair technique; the proof is intricate and worth a careful referee, but I found no load-bearing flaw.

    5 minor

  4. The paper:

    Multicritical pseudo-Siegel bounds and the optimality of the Brjuno condition for all neutral polynomials

    Mathematics · arXiv:2610.37468

    Dzmitry Dudko, Yusheng Luo, Runze Zhang

    Pith says

    Machine review · deepseek-v4-flash · 28 Oct 2026 · what was read was not recorded

    Holds up, with conditions. A genuine and substantial proof of the Zakeri-case Brjuno optimality, with the full Douady conjecture resting on an unreviewed arXiv reduction that the authors transparently quote.

    This review says the paper's mathematics is wrong. Pith did not check that against the paper's source.

  5. The paper:

    Multiplying matrices via polynomials: exposition and barriers

    Computer Science · arXiv:2610.30054

    Alimzhan Amanov, Maxim van den Berg, Jeroen Zuiddam

    Pith says

    Machine review · deepseek-v4-flash · 22 Oct 2026 · what was read was not recorded

    The passes disagreed. Reader: holds up. Skeptic: holds up only with conditions. Referee: major revision.

    Solid all-fields square proof and a genuinely new barrier, but the rectangular upper bounds rest on a false inequality in Proposition 4.14 and are unproven as written.

    This review says the paper's mathematics is wrong. Pith did not check that against the paper's source.

    2 major objections, the first at Section 4.5, proof of Proposition 4.14 · 3 minor

  6. The paper:

    Jeva: System One Models from First Principles

    Computer Science · arXiv:2610.18773

    Qi Li, Xinchao Wang

    Pith says

    Machine review · deepseek-v4-flash · 14 Oct 2026 · of version 1 of the paper; version 2 is newer · what was read was not recorded

    Holds up, with conditions. A coherent decision-native architecture with a real single-block expressivity proof; three of its four structural claims hold up, and the null-detection headline needs the absent-set construction and a calibration threshold before I'd trust it.

    4 major objections, the first at Section 4.2, Section C.3, Eq. (6) · 5 minor

  7. The paper:

    Discovering state-of-the-art quantum circuits with large language models

    Physics · arXiv:2610.22367

    Andi Gu, Alek H. Kemeny, Susanne F. Yelin and 1 more

    Pith says

    Machine review · deepseek-v4-flash · 16 Oct 2026 · what was read was not recorded

    Holds up, with conditions. Serious reversible-compilation results with a real proof in the appendix, wrapped in resource claims that hang on an imperfectly documented testing protocol — referee it, but demand the held-out evaluation and the code.

    2 major objections, the first at Methods, 'Validation and statistical guarantees' (Eq. 20) … · 5 minor

  8. The paper:

    Radial symmetry for the positive Kähler–Einstein Dirichlet problem on the ball

    Mathematics · arXiv:2611.21007

    Hongyu Chen, Li Ma

    Pith says

    Machine review · deepseek-v4-flash · 17 Nov 2026 · read the full text (47,924 characters)

    A clean proof that every smooth solution of the positive Kähler–Einstein Dirichlet problem on the ball is radial, resolving the smooth case of the Berman–Berndtsson symmetry conjecture.

    9 minor

  9. The paper:

    High-Dimensional Gaussian and Bootstrap Approximation: Near 1/√n Rates with General Covariance

    Mathematics · arXiv:2611.17923

    Miles E. Lopes, Ricardo Masini

    Pith says

    Machine review · deepseek-v4-flash · 16 Nov 2026 · read the full text (162,607 characters)

    This paper resolves a long-standing open problem in high-dimensional probability by proving near 1/sqrt(n) Berry-Esseen bounds over rectangles for sums of random vectors with general covariance matrices, and the proof appears rigorous and technically innovative.

    no objections raised

  10. The paper:

    Computational Hardness of Online Stochastic Matching

    Computer Science · arXiv:2611.23157

    Yifeng Teng, Zongjun Yang

    Pith says

    Machine review · deepseek-v4-flash · 18 Nov 2026 · read the full text (109,692 characters)

    This paper gives the first computational hardness results for online stochastic matching under random-order arrivals, resolving a long-standing open problem.

    28 minor

  11. The paper:

    A Dichotomy for Exact Quantum Circuit Amplitudes

    Computer Science · arXiv:2611.22899

    Chenghua Liu, Boning Meng

    Pith says

    Machine review · deepseek-v4-flash · 18 Nov 2026 · read the full text (301,242 characters)

    A complete classification of exact quantum circuit amplitudes, conditional on a recent Holant dichotomy.

    9 minor

  12. The paper:

    Asymptotic radial symmetry of p-Ginzburg-Landau minimizers on the disk

    Mathematics · arXiv:2611.20250

    Giovanni Di Fratta, Valeriy V. Slastikov, Arghir D. Zarnescu

    Pith says

    Machine review · deepseek-v4-flash · 17 Nov 2026 · read the full text (113,919 characters)

    This paper proves that for every p>2, global minimizers of the p-Ginzburg-Landau energy on the disk converge to the radial vortex map x/|x| as the core size tends to zero, solving a case of Brezis's Open Problem 2.3.

    no objections raised

  13. The paper:

    Thouless's bandwidth conjecture: a proof by elliptic periods

    Physics · arXiv:2611.19723

    Yongqiang Zhao

    Pith says

    Machine review · deepseek-v4-flash · 17 Nov 2026 · read the full text (264,577 characters)

    This paper proves Thouless's 1983 bandwidth conjecture for the critical Harper operator, giving the exact asymptotic constant 32G/π uniformly in the reduced numerator.

    8 minor

  14. The paper:

    A solution to Petty's polar projection problem

    Mathematics · arXiv:2611.17926

    Yiqian Zhang

    Pith says

    Machine review · deepseek-v4-flash · 16 Nov 2026 · read the full text (11,202 characters)

    Holds up.

    no objections raised

  15. The paper:

    SuperMimic: Scaling Humanoid Whole-Body Control with One Differentiable World Model

    Computer Science · arXiv:2610.28480

    Qiayuan Liao, Yiyang Shao, Junfeng Long and 4 more

    Pith says

    Machine review · deepseek-v4-flash · 21 Oct 2026 · of version 1 of the paper; version 2 is newer · what was read was not recorded

    Holds up, with conditions. The efficiency claim is real and well controlled; the 25-vs-179 failure numbers rest on SuperMimic's own termination rule and should be re-scored under SONIC's criterion before quoting them.

    2 major objections, the first at §4.1, Appendix F, Appendix A · 5 minor

  16. The paper:

    CFTs with Large Virasoro Primary Gaps

    Physics · arXiv:2611.23231

    Ziming Ji, Jiahua Tian

    Pith says

    Machine review · deepseek-v4-flash · 18 Nov 2026 · read the full text (140,634 characters)

    This paper constructs the first explicit examples of compact unitary bosonic full CFTs with Virasoro primary gap greater than two, resolving an open existence problem.

    10 minor

Browse every reviewed paper

How far to trust a review

18 of 105

errors that authors later admitted were found by Pith's review of the earlier version

measured 4 Oct 2026

29 more reviews came close to the error. 58 missed it.

Judged by two other models, not by people, against Pith's own copy of each paper's text.

See how reviews were measured, and the misses

For authors

WhatCostTime
Reference checkFreeWhile you wait
Pith Review$5Half finish within 27 min
Human reviewFrom $2007 to 14 days

Submit a paper