{"arxiv_id":"0909.2299","incoming":{"papers":4,"sentences":8,"groups":[],"unlabelled_sentences":8},"outgoing":{"papers":2,"sentences":2,"groups":[],"unlabelled_sentences":2},"claims":[{"relation":"same_result","label":"States the same result","papers":[{"arxiv_id":"0910.0875","url":"/paper/0910.0875","title":"Unprecedented accurate abundances: signatures of other Earths?","main_claim":"The peculiarities in the solar chemical composition can be explained as signatures of the formation of terrestrial planets like our own Earth.","p":0.93}]}],"thresholds":{"intent_p":0.8,"supports_p":0.95,"contests_p":0.7},"method":"Citing sentences come from each paper's LaTeX source; every \\cite marks the sentence and the works it cites. Pith's classifier typed each sentence. A label is shown at intent probability 0.8 or more (0.95 for support), a contest at 0.7 or more. Measured accuracy against two blind model families is at https://pith.science/accuracy. The quoted sentences are the citing authors' own.","held_up":{"arxiv_id":"0909.2299","kind":"model","paper_version":1,"prompt_version":"held-up-v3.5","generated_at":"2026-10-27T20:44:39+00:00","loaded_at":"2026-10-28T01:03:56.045447+00:00","evidence":"substantial","account":[],"groups":[{"kind":"method_or_tool","label":"Uses its method or tool","papers":2,"entries":[],"papers_all":6,"self_papers":2,"self_entries":[{"p":0.86,"quote":null,"citing":[{"self":true,"year":2018,"title":"The Chemical Homogeneity of Sun-like Stars in the Solar Neighborhood","arxiv_id":"1802.02576"}],"verified":true,"paraphrase":"Followed this paper to calculate the abundances of a typical solar twin and compare this abundance pattern to that of the Sun."},{"p":1.0,"quote":null,"citing":[{"self":true,"year":2023,"title":"C3PO: Towards a complete census of co-moving pairs of stars. I. High precision stellar parameters for 250 stars","arxiv_id":"2309.01546"}],"verified":true,"paraphrase":"Used the differential analysis techniques pioneered by this paper to obtain high precision relative chemical abundance measurements of a large sample of co-moving pairs of stars."}]},{"kind":"data_used","label":"Uses its data or values","papers":1,"entries":[{"p":0.84,"quote":null,"citing":[{"self":false,"year":2020,"title":"Fingerprints of giant planets in the composition of solar twins","arxiv_id":"2002.11135"}],"verified":true,"paraphrase":"Used this paper's average of the solar twins of 0.04 dex, or 10 per cent, to compare the photospheric composition of models with a planet to a reference model without planets."}],"papers_all":4,"self_papers":0,"self_entries":[]}],"counts":{"by_kind":{"contests":2,"data_used":4,"comparison":6,"method_or_tool":6,"supports_this_paper":3},"dropped":{"relied_on":0,"unknown_ids":0,"account_lines":0,"contest_vetoed":0,"below_threshold":0,"contest_drawback":0,"contest_without_basis":0,"contest_not_one_sentence":0,"contest_on_group_citation":0},"papers_read":17,"self_papers":20,"citing_papers":64,"sentences_read":20,"citing_sentences":137,"unambiguous_read":20,"typed_independent":11,"independent_papers":44,"by_kind_independent":{"contests":1,"data_used":4,"comparison":4,"method_or_tool":1,"supports_this_paper":3}},"input_sha256":"fd82536b945fa38bdb2eda6c7adb73bf6b5562b27d041a16f2378b9e84f9f4f1","method":"For a paper with five or more citing arXiv papers, Pith selected up to 40 citing sentences its citation classifier typed, read those whose citation markers point at this paper alone, and wrote one paraphrase for each later paper in each group, each resting on one sentence. A later paper is listed under a label only when the classifier gives one of its sentences that label at intent probability 0.8 or more (0.95 for support), Pith's reading of the sentence finds that the citing paper itself did it, and a second check of the paraphrase against the sentence passes. The section lists uses only: building on the paper, using its method, tool, data or values, comparing with it and citing it as support. It does not list criticism or disagreement, so their absence says nothing about how the paper has been received. Code counted the papers, wrote the summary from the listed entries, set the evidence level and linked each entry to its citing paper. Quotes are copied from the citing sentence and shown only when the citing paper's licence is CC BY, CC BY-SA or CC0; otherwise the paraphrase is shown. Papers that share an author with this one are listed apart. A paper with fewer citing papers gets a line counted by code, which names uses only: a later paper whose only label is a contest is counted as not described.","line":null,"summary":"1 later paper by other authors is listed below: 1 used its data or values. 2 more papers by the same authors are listed: 2 used its method or tool."},"_links":{"html":"https://pith.science/paper/0909.2299"}}