{"arxiv_id":"2610.30478","title":"Externalise the Memory: A Pre-Registered Study of Where an Embodied Agent's Experience Should Live","abstract":"Should an embodied agent's experience be baked into its policy weights, or kept external and retrieved at inference? A memory-augmented teacher (a VLM that retrieves lessons, with their episode images, from its own past attempts) produces trajectories on a vision-conditioned reach task; from the same trajectories we distil LoRA student policies and evaluate them under matched protocols, including one that re-attaches the teacher's frozen retrieval buffer to a fixed set of student weights. We pre-registered the hypotheses, arms, tests, and analysis rules before training and before any p-value. Distilling the memory-augmented behaviour into weights beat an action-only control by +1 pp (n.s.); the registered test proves underpowered for its own minimum effect, so we withdraw - rather than refute - the memory-in-weights claim. Attaching retrieval to a fixed set of student weights added +34 pp (z=5.15), reaching the pooled memory-augmented teacher reference (49.3%); the pre-registered protocol contrast agrees (+23 pp, z=3.36); under a pre-registered auto-reset sensitivity count the two are +36 and +29 pp. An exploratory behavioural probe with pre-registered per-arm predictions is consistent with behavioural distillation transferring the marginal correction but not the conditional, situation-specific correction that retrieval supplies. The recipe that follows is to externalise the memory: in follow-up controls registered before they ran, the same frozen buffer lifts the base model with no adapter to 48% (sensitivity 48%) and the other three adapters from 19-26% to 53-55% (sensitivity 17-21% to 50-55%), and the adapter adds nothing detectable once the buffer is attached. On a second, harder task, the retrieval advantage points the same direction but falls short of significance (+6 pp, 95% CI [-4.5, +16.4]); exploratory diagnostics tie the attenuation to memory coverage.","primary_cat":"cs.RO","cross_cats":["cs.AI"],"submitted_at":"2026-10-21T21:54:57+00:00","latest_version":1,"source":"arxiv","source_label":"arXiv","source_url":null,"has_pdf":true,"has_source":false,"verdict":"ACCEPT","confidence":"HIGH","one_line_summary":"In a pre-registered embodied-agent reach task, inference-time retrieval of past experience added +34 percentage points to success over loading the same experience into the policy weights via distillation, which added only +1 point.","novelty_score":7.0,"correctness_risk":"low","formal_verification":"none","upvotes":0,"downvotes":0,"pith_score":0,"inbound_count":1,"_links":{"html":"https://pith.science/paper/2610.30478","verdict":"/api/v1/verdicts/2610.30478"}}