{"id":"34a9b693-a9b1-48e7-98e0-f5bdc04a096b","arxiv_id":"2610.17860","paper_version":1,"verdict":"ACCEPT","confidence":"HIGH","novelty_score":7.0,"correctness_risk":"medium","formal_verification":"none","parameter_count":0,"one_line_summary":"Interleaving expert guidance with student-led practice produces more transferable agent skills than post-hoc teaching or direct expert authorship.","lead":"This paper introduces Socratic Skill Learning (SSL), a method where an AI agent (Student) practices tasks while an Educator guides its investigation without taking control. On a new benchmark of 408 tasks across six domains, SSL improved transfer to unseen task variants by 3-8 percentage points over existing skill-learning methods, using up to 62% fewer expert tokens.","discovery_kind":"new_method","skeptic_critique":{"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","headline":"Missing confidence interval for the primary utility comparison between Issue-Guided SSL and Fixed-Window SSL on the main cohort; the claim of preserved utility rests on a 0.004 difference without reported uncertainty.","rationale":"The reader's weakest assumption focused on generalization from a single anchor, which is acknowledged as a limitation. My concern is different: the statistical rigor around the primary efficiency comparison is incomplete. However, this concern does not undermine the core claim that interleaved guidance beats post-hoc teaching, which is well-supported across three model pairs with reported intervals. The efficiency claim is important but secondary; the missing CI is a flaw in presentation but not fatal. Therefore the reader's ACCEPT verdict remains appropriate. The agreement is partial because the reader identified a different weakest point (single-anchor generalization), while I identify a statistical support gap for the efficiency claim. Both are load-bearing but neither changes the overall verdict.","tokens_in":24430,"tokens_out":3419,"duration_ms":31640,"concrete_test":"Compute the 95% paired family-bootstrap confidence interval for the difference in family-macro Avg@3 utility between Issue-Guided SSL and Fixed-Window SSL (g=10) on the Qwen 22-family main cohort, using the same resampling procedure as in Table 8 (resample whole families with replacement, 10,000 repetitions). Report the interval and the proportion of resamples where Issue-Guided SSL is worse than Fixed-Window SSL. If the interval contains zero and the one-tailed p-value for superiority is >0.05, the claim of preserved utility is supported.","verdict_should_be":"UNCHANGED","load_bearing_attack":"The paper's central efficiency result (RQ4) states that Issue-Guided SSL reaches 0.805 utility versus 0.801 for Fixed-Window SSL (g=10) while reducing Educator tokens by 61.7%. This 0.004 difference (0.5 percentage points) is small, yet no confidence interval or statistical test is reported for this comparison, unlike the headline contrasts in Table 8. The bootstrap procedure used elsewhere (resampling families) could straightforwardly be applied here. Without it, the reader cannot assess whether the utility is statistically unchanged (supporting 'preserves transfer') or if there is a meaningful (possibly negative) shift. The paper's strongest efficiency claim depends on this being a true preservation, not a degradation hidden by noise. The omission is notable because the paper does report a narrow CI for Fixed-Window SSL vs. Trace2Skill. This is a load-bearing methodological gap for the efficiency part of the argument, though it does not affect the main interleaving-versus-post-hoc comparison.","agreement_with_reader":"partial"},"referee_report":{"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","summary":"The paper introduces Socratic Skill Learning (SSL), a method in which an Educator guides a Student during ongoing practice while the Student remains the sole environment operator and Skill author. The authors construct SkillTransferBench, a benchmark of 35 task families (408 cases) across six domains with public family specifications and held-out evaluation. On the main 22-family cohort, Fixed-Window SSL achieves 0.801 utility, outperforming adapted Trace2Skill (0.761) and SKILL-KD (0.751) with 95% CIs that exclude zero. Issue-Guided SSL, which schedules review based on unresolved learning issues, reaches 0.805 utility with 61.7% fewer Educator tokens than Fixed-Window SSL. Process analyses and case studies illustrate how guidance enters Skill development. Experiments across three model pairs (Qwen, DeepSeek, Kimi) show that interleaved protocols outperform expert authoring and post-hoc teaching.","tokens_in":24730,"tokens_out":3148,"duration_ms":27842,"significance":"If the results hold, SSL provides a principled way to combine expert guidance with student-led practice for learning transferable agent skills, reducing expert supervision cost while maintaining or improving transfer utility. The construction of SkillTransferBench with public variation specifications is itself a contribution that enables future work on guided skill acquisition. The process analysis linking teaching to student writing and revision offers empirical evidence for the role of interactive guidance.","major_comments":[{"comment":"The central efficiency claim (RQ4) that Issue-Guided SSL preserves transfer utility while reducing Educator tokens rests on a utility comparison of 0.805 versus 0.801 for Fixed-Window SSL (g=10). This 0.004 difference is reported without a confidence interval or statistical test, unlike the headline comparisons in Table 8 (e.g., Fixed-Window SSL vs. Trace2Skill, which has a 95% CI of [1.45, 6.49]). The bootstrap procedure used elsewhere (family resampling) could straightforwardly be applied here. Without uncertainty quantification, the reader cannot assess whether the utility is statistically unchanged (supporting 'preserves transfer') or whether there is a meaningful (possibly negative) shift. The paper's strongest cost-efficiency argument depends on this being a true preservation. I request that the authors compute and report the 95% CI (or an equivalent test) for the Issue-Guided SSL versus Fixed-Window SSL comparison on the main cohort.","section":"§5.4, Table 17 and Figure 5","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"The headline claim that 'interleaved guidance outperforms expert authoring and post-hoc teaching' is supported on the main Qwen cohort with narrow CIs. However, on the shared 10-family subset for DeepSeek and Kimi, the 95% paired family-bootstrap intervals for Fixed-Window SSL versus Expert Authoring include zero (DeepSeek: [-1.93, 7.15]; Kimi: [-2.33, 7.98]). The intervals for Issue-Guided SSL versus Fixed-Window SSL also include zero across all three pairs. The paper should explicitly discuss the limited statistical power of these cross-model comparisons, particularly for the lite subset, and temper the claim accordingly.","section":"§5.2, Table 13","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null}],"minor_comments":[{"comment":"The abstract states 'Issue-Guided SSL reaches 0.805 utility with 61.7% fewer Educator tokens and 16.9% fewer total acquisition tokens than Fixed-Window SSL on the main cohort.' The 16.9% acquisition-token reduction is specific to Qwen; Table 18 shows that for DeepSeek, total acquisition tokens increase by 1.101M per run. Please qualify the token-savings claim as model-specific, or state the qualification already present in the supplementary cost analysis.","section":"Abstract and §5.4","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"The caption says 'Panels show (a) anchor scores and teaching rates at regular reviews, (b) teaching–silence differences ...' but the panels are labelled 1, 2, 3 in the figure, not a, b, c. Ensure the caption matches the sub-figure labels.","section":"§5.3, Figure 4 caption","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"The definition of transfer utility U_f uses an expectation over D_f, but the evaluation (Eq. 2) averages over a fixed set of held-out cases with equal weight. Clarify that D_f is the empirical distribution over the available test cases.","section":"§3.1, Eq. (1)","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null}],"recommendation":"major_revision"},"author_rebuttal":null,"desk_editor":{"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","letter":"This paper makes a real contribution. The Socratic Skill Learning framework—especially the idea that an Educator guides during student-led practice rather than after—is well-motivated and backed by clear empirical work on three model pairs. SkillTransferBench is a useful new resource with 35 families and held-out evaluation. The main result is solid: Fixed-Window SSL beats Trace2Skill and SKILL-KD on the 22-family cohort with a statistically significant 3.99-point gain (CI [1.45, 6.49]). The process analysis linking lessons to file edits and package revisions is a nice addition, and the code and data release is thorough.\n\nNow the soft spot, which the stress-test note nails. RQ4 claims that Issue-Guided SSL reaches 0.805 utility versus 0.801 for Fixed-Window SSL (g=10) while cutting Educator tokens 61.7%. That 0.004 difference has no confidence interval or significance test, unlike every other headline contrast in the paper. The bootstrap procedure they use for family-level CIs would work here. This is a load-bearing gap for the efficiency argument because the claim of \"preserving utility\" depends on that 0.004 not being noise. It doesn't affect the main interleaving-vs-post-hoc findings, which have proper CIs, but it needs to be addressed. The authors acknowledge the single-anchor limitation, which is fine, and the CIs for the shared 10-family subset are wide, but the main cohort comparisons are solid.\n\nWho this is for: anyone working on LLM agent skill acquisition, curriculum learning, or human-in-the-loop agent training. The paper deserves a serious referee. I'd ask the authors to add CIs for the Issue-Guided vs Fixed-Window comparison and to discuss what magnitude of utility change would count as meaningful degradation. After that, publish.","headline":"Solid paper: interleaved teaching clearly beats post-hoc methods for agent skill transfer, but the efficiency claim (Issue-Guided SSL preserves utility with fewer tokens) lacks a reported confidence interval for the utility difference, which the authors should fix.","tokens_in":25208,"tokens_out":1354,"duration_ms":15138},"pith_extraction":{"msc":[],"pacs":[],"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","headline":"Socratic Skill Learning interleaves expert guidance with student practice to produce more transferable agent skills than post-hoc teaching or direct expert authorship.","keywords":["Socratic Skill Learning","Agent Skills","Skill Transfer","Task Families","Issue-Guided Review","LLM Agents","Benchmark","Transferable Skills"],"falsifier":"If varying the choice of anchor task within the same family leads to statistically significant differences in the transfer utility of the acquired skill (for example, using an easier anchor produces skills that fail on complex family variants), then the method's robustness to anchor selection would be questioned. Alternatively, if ablating the student model's capability (e.g., using a weaker model) eliminates the advantage of interleaved guidance over post-hoc teaching, then the method's reliance on student model competence would be exposed.","tokens_in":25951,"feed_emoji":"🎓","tokens_out":3900,"duration_ms":34783,"temperature":0.7,"pith_summary":"Socratic Skill Learning (SSL) is a method for acquiring transferable agent skills by interleaving expert teaching with student practice. Unlike prior approaches that offer feedback after task attempts or distill static trajectories, SSL allows an Educator to guide investigation while the Student remains the sole environment operator and skill author. The paper evaluates SSL on a new benchmark, SkillTransferBench (35 task families, 408 cases), and shows that both Fixed-Window SSL and Issue-Guided SSL outperform direct expert authoring, post-hoc teaching, and adapted trajectory-distillation methods across three model pairs. Issue-Guided SSL further reduces Educator token use by 62 percent while maintaining transfer utility, by tracking unresolved learning issues to selectively trigger reviews.","feed_headline":"Interleaved teaching boosts agent skill transfer by up to 8 points","feed_subtitle":"Socratic Skill Learning combines expert guidance with student practice, achieving higher held-out utility and 62% fewer teaching tokens.","key_machinery":"Two core mechanisms carry the argument. First, Socratic Skill Learning (SSL): during ongoing student practice, an Educator observes recent work and the live skill, then explains, challenges, diagnoses, or remains silent; the Student operates the environment and authors the package, able to question, test, and adapt advice. Second, Issue-Guided SSL: a persistent tree of learning issues tracks unresolved questions across revisions; a review is triggered only when an issue opens, changes, or reopens, and the Educator receives focused context around that issue. This selective review reduces unnecessary expert calls while retaining the ability to redirect investigation when new evidence contradicts prior conclusions.","core_discovery":"The central discovery is that interleaving expert guidance with student practice during skill acquisition produces more transferable skills than providing the same guidance after the student completes its work. The Educator reviews ongoing work, challenges assumptions, and suggests investigations, while the Student tests, adapts, and decides what to retain. This process is instantiated in Fixed-Window SSL (review every g tool calls) and Issue-Guided SSL (review on unresolved issue transitions). Across experiments on 22 task families with 155 held-out cases, Fixed-Window SSL achieves 0.801 utility (compared to 0.723 without a skill, 0.761 for Trace2Skill, and 0.751 for SKILL-KD). Issue-Guided SSL matches this performance at 0.805 utility while using 61.7 percent fewer Educator tokens and 16.9 percent fewer total acquisition tokens than Fixed-Window SSL at g equals 10.","pith_inferences":["The effectiveness of SSL may partly stem from the generation effect: students who construct skills themselves retain knowledge better than those who receive static instructions, and the guidance ensures productive exploration directions.","Issue-Guided SSL's issue tree could naturally extend to continual learning settings, where past unresolved issues from previous tasks could inform review priorities in a lifelong agent.","If the student model lacks sufficient capacity to benefit from Socratic dialogue (e.g., weaker models cannot effectively test and adapt advice), the advantage of interleaving may diminish, suggesting a dependency on student model capability."],"forward_implications":["If SSL is correct, agent skill learning systems can more efficiently use expert knowledge by providing timely guidance during exploration, reducing the need for costly post-hoc revisions.","The method may extend to other human-in-the-loop or intelligent tutoring scenarios where transferable procedures need to be learned from limited practice.","Issue-Guided SSL's adaptive review strategy offers a concrete path to lowering supervision costs in large language model interactions: by tracking unresolved issues, the system can focus expert attention where it matters most.","The SkillTransferBench benchmark (35 families, 408 cases) with public variation specifications and held-out evaluation provides a standardized testbed for future research on transferable agent skills."],"supporting_citations":[{"why":"Provides the trajectory distillation baseline (Trace2Skill) that SSL is compared against on held-out transfer.","marker":"[Ni et al., 2026]"},{"why":"Provides the contrastive skill distillation baseline (SKILL-KD) that SSL is compared against on held-out transfer.","marker":"[Shi et al., 2026]"},{"why":"Provides the SkillLearnBench benchmark with teacher feedback after failure, which SSL extends to interleaved guidance during practice.","marker":"[Zhong et al., 2026]"},{"why":"Provides the SkillsBench benchmark for measuring skill utility, which informs the evaluation methodology.","marker":"[Li et al., 2026b]"},{"why":"Supports the educational theory of active construction during tutoring, which the Socratic dialogue design draws on.","marker":"[Chi et al., 2001]"},{"why":"Provides the feedback classification framework (task, process, self-regulation) used to code Educator intents in the process analysis.","marker":"[Hattie and Timperley, 2007]"}],"fun_headline_variants":["Interleaved guidance beats delayed teaching for skill transfer","Socratic training matches skill transfer with 62% fewer tokens","Students test and adapt expert advice for more transferable skills","Issue-guided review cuts teaching cost without losing utility"],"cache_read_input_tokens":0,"weakest_assumption_plain":"The paper assumes that learning from a single anchor practice task per family, guided by an Educator, yields skills that generalize to unseen variants described by the family specification, an assumption the authors acknowledge as a limitation.","fun_headline_variants_meta":{"raw":{"variants":["Interleaved guidance beats delayed teaching for skill transfer","Socratic training matches skill transfer with 62% fewer tokens","Students test and adapt expert advice for more transferable skills","Issue-guided review cuts teaching cost without losing utility"]},"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","effort":"low","cost_usd":6.6e-05,"raw_usage":{"cost":6.601756e-05,"is_byok":false,"cost_details":{"upstream_inference_cost":6.601756e-05,"upstream_inference_prompt_cost":3.878196e-05,"upstream_inference_completions_cost":2.72356e-05},"total_tokens":1366,"prompt_tokens":1011,"completion_tokens":355,"prompt_tokens_details":{"audio_tokens":0,"video_tokens":0,"cached_tokens":0,"cache_write_tokens":0},"completion_tokens_details":{"audio_tokens":0,"image_tokens":0,"reasoning_tokens":289}},"tokens_in":1011,"tokens_out":355,"cost_source":"openrouter_usage","duration_ms":10865,"image_pages":[],"temperature":1.0,"billed_attempts":1,"reasoning_tokens":289,"transport_provider":"openrouter","cache_read_input_tokens":0,"cache_creation_input_tokens":0},"cache_creation_input_tokens":0},"created_at":"2026-10-14T14:36:27.608274+00:00","model_set":{"reader":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash"},"pipeline_version":"pith-pipeline@v1.4.1-daily-deepseek-or-medium","input_kind":null,"input_chars":null,"input_total_chars":null,"passes_missing":null,"published_standing":null,"published_confidence":null,"objection_audit":null,"run_record":null,"basis":{"kind":"not_recorded","source":null,"chars_given":null,"chars_total":null},"receipt":null,"falsifier":"If varying the choice of anchor task within the same family leads to statistically significant differences in the transfer utility of the acquired skill (for example, using an easier anchor produces skills that fail on complex family variants), then the method's robustness to anchor selection would be questioned. Alternatively, if ablating the student model's capability (e.g., using a weaker model) eliminates the advantage of interleaved guidance over post-hoc teaching, then the method's reliance on student model competence would be exposed.","supporting_citations":[{"cited_title":"The power of feedback","cited_arxiv_id":null,"evidence_quote":"Provides the feedback classification framework (task, process, self-regulation) used to code Educator intents in the process analysis."}],"lane_accuracy":{"status":"not yet measured","lane":{"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","input_kind":null},"url":"https://pith.science/accuracy"},"review_version":1}