{"id":"6db280ad-a0a4-4d94-9b0f-92e9f9031c76","arxiv_id":"2610.19951","paper_version":1,"verdict":"CONDITIONAL","confidence":"HIGH","novelty_score":7.0,"correctness_risk":"medium","formal_verification":"none","parameter_count":6,"one_line_summary":"AtomSearch uses tree search with contrastive atomic edits to discover compact and effective agent skills, outperforming SkillOpt on most tasks across five target models.","lead":"AtomSearch optimizes agent skills by making small, traceable edits to instructions and using tree search to evaluate whether those edits lead to better skills later, even if they don't immediately improve performance. This matters because it finds more compact, effective skills than existing methods, and it shows that exploring paths through temporarily weaker states can uncover the best final skill.","discovery_kind":"new_method","skeptic_critique":{"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","headline":"The 67% statistic for non-myopic paths may reflect validation noise rather than genuine search benefit; the paper does not quantify score uncertainty.","rationale":"The reader's weakest assumption identified the representativeness of the validation set and the risk of overfitting, which is related but not identical. The load-bearing concern here is more specific: the 67% statistic, which is central to the strongest claim (that non-greedy search discovers better skills via weak intermediates), may be inflated by noise because the validation panels are small and score differences are not quantified with uncertainty. The paper acknowledges the limitation but still uses the statistic as key evidence. The concrete test would directly assess the robustness of that statistic. The CONDITIONAL verdict already reflects caution, so no change is needed, but if the test shows instability, the strongest claim would require significant qualification. Since no new evidence is presented to overturn the verdict, UNCHANGED is appropriate.","tokens_in":15829,"tokens_out":2171,"duration_ms":18483,"concrete_test":"For the 20 AtomSearch searches on NDR (105-item validation panel), bootstrap the validation scores of all visited states with 1000 resamples. For each search, compute the proportion of resamples in which the best final validation state has at least one ancestor that was not the highest-scoring state at its depth. If the median proportion across searches is significantly below 67% (e.g., <50%), then the observed statistic is consistent with noise rather than a systematic non-myopic effect.","verdict_should_be":"UNCHANGED","load_bearing_attack":"The central claim that non-greedy search over skill edits yields better final skills relies heavily on the observation that in 67% of completed searches, the best validation state has an ancestor that was not highest-scoring at its depth (Section 4.4). The paper presents this as evidence that locally weaker states lead to better outcomes, supported by the example in Figure 4 where node 4 (2.9 points below its parent) eventually leads to the best state. However, the validation panels for these searches are small (e.g., 105 items for NDR, 40 for SpreadsheetBench, Table 4). With such panels, a difference of 2.9 points on NDR corresponds to roughly 3 items; a few items’ stochastic execution can easily flip the ordering. The paper acknowledges (Section 5, b203) that 'finite validation panels and stochastic execution limit the precision of small score differences,' but it does not quantify the uncertainty of the state scores used to define the 67% statistic. Without bootstrapping or confidence intervals, it is unclear how many of the observed 'non-myopic' paths would persist under repeated evaluation on the same panel. The statistic could be substantially inflated by ranking noise. Consequently, the strongest empirical support for the claim that local weak states systematically lead to better skills is less robust than presented.","agreement_with_reader":"partial"},"referee_report":{"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","summary":"AtomSearch proposes a tree-search algorithm for optimizing agent skills (external instructions) by keeping revisions local (one primitive edit per action) while allowing the value of a revision path to be evaluated over multiple steps. The method combines three components: (i) contrastive atomic editing, which links each edit to failed/successful executions and a behavioral hypothesis; (ii) Skill-State Tree Search (STS), an MCTS variant that evaluates short, deterministic rollouts and keeps compositions that beat their primitive child; and (iii) outcome memory, which supplies later proposal rounds with observed repair/regression statistics.  The paper evaluates AtomSearch against SkillOpt across four tasks (NDR, SpreadsheetBench, SearchQA, LiveMathematicianBench) and five target models.  The main reported results are that AtomSearch achieves higher test scores on most task–model pairs (e.g., +9.68 percentage points on LiveMathematicianBench with deepseek-v4-flash), produces final skills that are 2.3–19.7× shorter than SkillOpt's, and that in 67% of completed searches the best validation state has an ancestor that was not the highest-scoring at its depth—a finding used to argue that non-greedy search over skill edits is beneficial.","tokens_in":16165,"tokens_out":2687,"duration_ms":25364,"significance":"If the reported improvements are robust, AtomSearch provides a principled way to decouple the granularity of skill edits from the evaluation horizon, addressing a known weakness of local greedy methods.  The contrastive atomic editing interface is well-motivated and makes each revision traceable; the tree search over full skill states is a natural extension of MCTS to the skill-optimization setting.  The concrete finding that locally weaker intermediate states can lead to better final skills (illustrated in Figure 4) is potentially important for the design of future agent skill optimizers, but this claim rests heavily on a single aggregate statistic whose uncertainty is not quantified.  The empirical evaluation covers a reasonable range of tasks and models, and the paper honestly reports limitations, including small validation panels and the fact that the component ablation covers only one setting.  The compactness of the resulting skills is an interesting emergent property that the paper does not explicitly optimize for.","major_comments":[{"comment":"The 67% statistic (20 out of 30 completed searches) is presented as evidence that 'the best validation state passes through an ancestor that was not highest-scoring at its depth' and is used to motivate the tree search over greedy approaches.  However, the validation panels used to compute state scores are small: 105 items for NDR, 40 for SpreadsheetBench, 18 for LiveMathematicianBench, and 200 for SearchQA (Table 4).  As the paper itself acknowledges (b203), 'finite validation panels and stochastic execution limit the precision of small score differences.'  The difference of 2.9 points on NDR (Figure 4) corresponds to roughly 3 items out of 105; stochastic execution could easily flip such a ranking.  The paper does not provide any uncertainty quantification (e.g., bootstrapping, confidence intervals) for the 67% figure, so it is unclear how many of these 'non-myopic paths' would persist under repeated evaluation on the same validation panel.  This is a load-bearing issue because the non-myopic path claim is the main empirical justification for the STS component.  The authors should estimate the uncertainty of the 67% statistic—for example by repeatedly resampling the validation set or by re-running the search with different noise seeds—and report a range or confidence interval.  If the statistic is not robust, the paper's central motivation for the tree search is weakened.","section":"Section 4.4, Table 4, and the paper's own limitation b203","authors_acknowledge":"Repeated evaluation of fixed checkpoints would be needed to quantify their uncertainty and separate selection effects from differences in the learned skills. 15","authors_acknowledge_p":0.74},{"comment":"Table 2 reports that AtomSearch achieves a median gain ratio (Δtest/Δval) of 124% versus 82% for SkillOpt, and the paper uses this to argue that AtomSearch generalizes better from validation to test.  The authors appropriately note in Appendix C that these ratios are computed from point estimates, that initial scores can differ between methods, and that a small denominator can inflate the ratio (b329–b331, b335).  However, the main text (Section 4.3) presents the ratio as a descriptive comparison without reiterating these caveats, and no uncertainty is attached to the 124% vs. 82% difference.  Because the ratio comparisons are not the primary result and the paper explicitly states they are descriptive, this is a moderate concern.  I recommend adding a brief statement in Section 4.3 that references the Appendix caveats, or moving the ratio analysis entirely to Appendix C to avoid over-interpretation.","section":"Section 4.3 and Appendix C (Table 2, validation-to-test gain ratio)","authors_acknowledge":"These are point estimates, not significance claims.","authors_acknowledge_p":0.82}],"minor_comments":[{"comment":"The sentence 'In 20 of 30 completed searches (67%)...' should clarify what constitutes a 'completed search.'  From context, it appears to mean searches that reached the maximum number of attempts (20 or 30, Table 5), but this could be stated explicitly.  Also, it would be helpful to show how the 30 searches are distributed across the different tasks and models, given that validation panel sizes vary substantially.","section":"Section 4.4","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"The navigation set D_nav is defined, but the paper later uses both 'validation set' and 'navigation set' interchangeably.  For clarity, choose one term (e.g., 'validation set') throughout, or explicitly state that they are the same.","section":"Section 3, Equation (1) and surrounding text","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"The caption says 'Both paths include a score decrease before reaching their maxima.'  Consider adding a note about the SpreadsheetBench path's specific dip (validation accuracy falls from 52.50 to 49.50) to help readers interpret the non-monotonicity.","section":"Figure 3 caption","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"The table shows that contrastive atomic editing alone yields 75.71% test accuracy with 2,352 characters, while the full method yields 78.21% with 2,936 characters.  The incremental gain from tree search and outcome memory is small (2.5 points) and comes from one setting.  The paper acknowledges this limitation (b204), but the main text could more prominently note that the search and memory components provide only modest improvements in this ablation.","section":"Table 3","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"The paper cites Cawley & Talbot (2010) on overfitting, which is appropriate.  However, the paper does not discuss the specific risk of overfitting to the validation set over multiple tree expansions when the validation panel is small (e.g., 40 items for SpreadsheetBench).  Adding a brief note about how the number of candidate comparisons interacts with validation set size would strengthen the limitation statement.","section":"Section 5, discussion of overfitting","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null}],"recommendation":"major_revision"},"author_rebuttal":null,"desk_editor":{"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","letter":"Here's my take on AtomSearch. The paper does something genuinely useful: it decouples revision granularity from valuation horizon by combining contrastive atomic edits with a tree search over full skill states. The idea that a locally weak edit can enable later improvements is well-motivated, and the empirical demonstration that such paths occur (67% of searches) is interesting if true. The compact skills and the validation-to-test ratio analysis (124% vs 82%) are also notable.\n\nThe honest and direct limitation statements (Section 5) deserve credit. The authors say outright these are point estimates, that validation panels are finite, that the component ablation covers one task, and that the 67% figure may reflect noise. That is refreshing.\n\nNow the soft spots. The 67% statistic is the headline evidence for non-myopic search, but it sits on shaky ground. NDR validation panel has 105 items; a 2.9-point gap is about 3 items. With stochastic execution and no bootstrapping, the statistic could be substantially inflated by ranking noise. The authors acknowledge the concern in prose but do not quantify it. The stress-test note is right: without confidence intervals, we have no way to know how many of those 'non-myopic' paths would replicate on repeated evaluation.\n\nSecond, the component ablation (Table 3) covers only one task-target setting. The increments from search and memory are tiny (1.4 and 1.0 points) and could be noise. Extending ablation across tasks is essential before claiming generalizability.\n\nThird, code and data are not released, and NDR is an in-house dataset. That limits reproducibility, though the public benchmarks help.\n\nWho is this for? Researchers working on LLM agent customization and prompt optimization. It is a solid engineering paper with a clear method and honest reporting, but the central claim about non-myopic paths needs stronger evidence before it becomes a settled result.\n\nFor peer review: I would send this to review, because the method is novel and the problem is relevant. But I would flag the need for uncertainty quantification, multi-task ablation, and open-source code as conditions for acceptance.","headline":"A useful engineering contribution that combines atomic edits and MCTS for skill optimization, but the key 67% statistic is less robust than presented due to small validation panels and no uncertainty quantification.","tokens_in":16710,"tokens_out":1029,"duration_ms":9894},"pith_extraction":{"msc":[],"pacs":[],"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","headline":"AtomSearch uses tree search over local skill edits to find better agent skills than greedy optimization, with 67% of best paths passing through non-maximal intermediate states.","keywords":["agent skills","skill optimization","tree search","prompt optimization","contrastive editing","MCTS","non-greedy search","LLM agents"],"falsifier":"Run AtomSearch and a greedy baseline (e.g., SkillOpt) on a task with a known non-monotonic improvement landscape (e.g., one where the best skill requires first adding a rule that temporarily degrades performance before a second rule fixes it). If AtomSearch does not consistently find the better skill while the greedy baseline fails, the central claim about non-greedy search is falsified.","tokens_in":17276,"feed_emoji":"🔍","tokens_out":1949,"duration_ms":19043,"temperature":0.7,"pith_summary":"AtomSearch proposes a method for optimizing agent skills (external instructions for frozen models) by keeping each revision action as a single local edit, but using a tree search to evaluate short compositions of edits and retain promising states. The core claim is that this decoupling of edit granularity from evaluation horizon allows the search to discover useful revision paths that a greedy optimizer would discard. The paper demonstrates that in 67% of completed searches, the best final validation state had an ancestor that was not the highest-scoring at its depth, confirming that locally weaker states can lead to better overall skills. Across four tasks and five target models, AtomSearch often outperforms the baseline SkillOpt while producing significantly shorter skills.","feed_headline":"Tree search over local edits finds better agent skills","feed_subtitle":"67% of best paths go through intermediate states that greedy optimization would discard – AtomSearch yields skills up to 19 times shorter","key_machinery":"Skill-State Tree Search (STS) is the central mechanism. It uses a Monte Carlo Tree Search backbone with progressive widening and UCT selection, where each node is a complete executable skill. The action space is contrastively grounded primitive edits (add, rewrite, delete), each justified by a specification linking it to evidence. STS decouples the local edit from its valuation by allowing short deterministic rollouts (up to two additional edits) to test whether a primitive edit becomes more valuable after further composition. If the rollout yields a higher score than the primitive child alone, the composition is kept as a persistent state. Outcome memory records repair/regression statistics per edit direction and feeds them to later proposal rounds without affecting UCT values.","core_discovery":"AtomSearch establishes that contrastive atomic editing—where each primitive rule edit is linked to failed and successful executions, a behavioral hypothesis, and intended scope—can serve as the action unit in a tree search over complete executable skills. Skill-State Tree Search (STS) applies these edits locally, evaluates short rollouts of up to two further edits, and retains compositions only if they score strictly higher than the primitive child. The key result is that 67% of the best validation states in completed searches trace back to an ancestor that was not the highest-scoring state at its depth, showing that non-greedy exploration over edit combinations can find stronger skills than local greedy optimization. This demonstrates that the horizon over which a revision's value is judged can be longer than the revision itself, and that keeping intermediate states that are not locally optimal can pay off.","pith_inferences":["The method's reliance on a held-out validation set for scoring introduces a risk of overfitting, especially given small validation panels (e.g., 18 items for LiveMathematicianBench) and stochastic model outputs, which the paper acknowledges but does not quantify.","AtomSearch's tree search increases offline compute (optimizer calls 16–45 per run). This trade-off is worthwhile when the resulting skill is reused many times, but for one-off tasks the search cost may outweigh the benefit.","The contrastive atomic editing step itself requires a method for mining behavioral hypotheses from failed/successful executions; the paper does not deeply analyze failures of this mining step, which may limit applicability to tasks where failure patterns are not easily separable.","The component ablation covers only one task-target setting (SpreadsheetBench+deepseek-v4-flash), so the marginal contributions of STS and outcome memory are not yet broadly validated."],"forward_implications":["If AtomSearch's method is adopted, agent skill optimization can become more sample-efficient in terms of final skill quality per retained edit, as the paper shows shorter skills achieving higher or comparable scores.","The decoupling of local edits from long-term valuation suggests that other iterative improvement tasks (e.g., prompt optimization, code repair) could benefit from tree search over atomic revisions rather than greedy acceptance.","The 67% finding implies that validation-set-driven greedy optimization may systematically miss better solutions that require temporarily worse intermediate states, challenging common practice.","The compact final skills, attained without explicit length penalty, indicate that tree search over local edits can automatically prune redundant rules, reducing inference cost and complexity."],"supporting_citations":[{"why":"Provides the primary baseline SkillOpt against which AtomSearch is compared, using bounded edit operations and validation-based selection.","marker":"Yang et al., 2026"},{"why":"Proposes Skill-α, a method for sequential edit evaluation that AtomSearch extends by incorporating tree search and lookahead.","marker":"Shen et al., 2026"},{"why":"Introduces SkillRevise, which diagnoses defects from execution traces—a concept AtomSearch leverages for contrastive atomic editing.","marker":"Liu et al., 2026"},{"why":"Describes bilevel skill optimization with MCTS, providing a tree-based approach that AtomSearch adapts with primitive edit actions.","marker":"Huang et al., 2026"},{"why":"Presents SkillHEX, which maintains persistent revision branches; AtomSearch's tree search shares the idea of preserving alternative revision paths.","marker":"Feng et al., 2026"},{"why":"Supplies the UCT selection rule that AtomSearch uses for balancing exploration and exploitation in the tree.","marker":"Kocsis & Szepesvári, 2006"},{"why":"Provides the MCTS survey that informs the progressive widening and robust-child recommendation used by AtomSearch.","marker":"Browne et al., 2012"}],"fun_headline_variants":["AtomSearch finds skills up to 19 times shorter","Non-greedy tree search beats local optimization for agent skills","67% of best skills come from discarded intermediate states","Local edits, global search: AtomSearch boosts agent skill compactness","Tree search over atomic edits yields better agent skills"],"cache_read_input_tokens":0,"weakest_assumption_plain":"The method assumes that the held-out validation set is large enough and representative enough to reliably distinguish skill quality, and that the contrastive mining step produces edit candidates that are genuinely useful for improving the skill; if the validation set is small or noisy, the tree search may overfit, as the paper acknowledges.","fun_headline_variants_meta":{"raw":{"variants":["AtomSearch finds skills up to 19 times shorter","Non-greedy tree search beats local optimization for agent skills","67% of best skills come from discarded intermediate states","Local edits, global search: AtomSearch boosts agent skill compactness","Tree search over atomic edits yields better agent skills"]},"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","effort":"low","cost_usd":0.000279,"raw_usage":{"cost":0.00027944,"is_byok":false,"cost_details":{"upstream_inference_cost":0.00027944,"upstream_inference_prompt_cost":0.00012936,"upstream_inference_completions_cost":0.00015008},"total_tokens":1460,"prompt_tokens":924,"completion_tokens":536,"prompt_tokens_details":{"audio_tokens":0,"video_tokens":0,"cached_tokens":0,"cache_write_tokens":0},"completion_tokens_details":{"audio_tokens":0,"image_tokens":0,"reasoning_tokens":455}},"tokens_in":924,"tokens_out":536,"cost_source":"openrouter_usage","duration_ms":5855,"image_pages":[],"temperature":1.0,"billed_attempts":1,"reasoning_tokens":455,"transport_provider":"openrouter","cache_read_input_tokens":0,"cache_creation_input_tokens":0},"cache_creation_input_tokens":0},"created_at":"2026-10-15T13:12:15.262852+00:00","model_set":{"reader":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash"},"pipeline_version":"pith-pipeline@v1.4.1-daily-deepseek-or-medium","input_kind":null,"input_chars":null,"input_total_chars":null,"passes_missing":null,"published_standing":null,"published_confidence":null,"objection_audit":null,"run_record":null,"basis":{"kind":"not_recorded","source":null,"chars_given":null,"chars_total":null},"receipt":null,"falsifier":"Run AtomSearch and a greedy baseline (e.g., SkillOpt) on a task with a known non-monotonic improvement landscape (e.g., one where the best skill requires first adding a rule that temporarily degrades performance before a second rule fixes it). If AtomSearch does not consistently find the better skill while the greedy baseline fails, the central claim about non-greedy search is falsified.","supporting_citations":[{"cited_title":"Progressive Agent Skill Generation via Reinforcement Learning","cited_arxiv_id":"2608.01678","evidence_quote":"Proposes Skill-α, a method for sequential edit evaluation that AtomSearch extends by incorporating tree search and lookahead."},{"cited_title":"Bandit based monte-carlo planning","cited_arxiv_id":null,"evidence_quote":"Supplies the UCT selection rule that AtomSearch uses for balancing exploration and exploitation in the tree."}],"lane_accuracy":{"status":"not yet measured","lane":{"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","input_kind":null},"url":"https://pith.science/accuracy"},"review_version":1}