{"id":"38b3a2eb-67aa-4a37-8226-f2a550d8a1d1","arxiv_id":"2611.17188","paper_version":1,"verdict":"CONDITIONAL","confidence":"HIGH","novelty_score":6.0,"correctness_risk":"medium","formal_verification":"none","parameter_count":4,"one_line_summary":"A three-particle spectral criterion is introduced to optimize band-projected interactions for Moore-Read states, applied to Landau levels and twisted MoTe2, but many-body calculations do not provide compelling evidence for Moore-Read order in the regimes studied.","lead":"This paper proposes a framework to optimize interactions in moiré materials to favor the non-Abelian Moore-Read state, a topological phase that could be used for quantum computing. The authors develop a cost function based on three-particle spectra and apply it to Landau levels and twisted MoTe2, but find that stabilizing the Moore-Read state in twisted MoTe2 remains challenging.","discovery_kind":"new_method","skeptic_critique":{"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","headline":"Cost function for Chern bands relies on an ambiguous L-sector assignment that is not validated by many-body results, undermining the central claim that the criterion can guide Moore-Read searches.","rationale":"The reader's weakest_assumption correctly identifies that the cost function's reliability as a proxy for the many-body phase is unproven, and that the paper itself provides a counterexample in twisted MoTe2. My stress-test agrees with this assessment and sharpens it: the Chern-band cost function has an additional, acknowledged ambiguity in L-sector assignment that is not resolved, and the paper does not explain the discrepancy. The reader's verdict is CONDITIONAL, and I agree that this is appropriate. The paper's LL results are sound and the inverse-designed interaction is a nice contribution, but the central claim regarding Chern bands is not supported. The paper honestly states the limitation, but the limitation is load-bearing: without a resolution, the method's utility for Chern bands is unclear. I recommend keeping the CONDITIONAL verdict, as the paper could be strengthened by addressing this issue, but the current version does not meet the threshold for acceptance as a fully validated method. The agreement_with_reader is 'agree' because the reader's weakest_assumption and my concern are essentially the same, though I have emphasized the Chern-band ambiguity more explicitly.","tokens_in":19100,"tokens_out":702,"duration_ms":8320,"concrete_test":"Perform a controlled test of the Chern-band cost function on a system where the Moore-Read phase is known to exist, e.g., the n=1 LL on a torus with a small lattice discretization that breaks rotational symmetry. Compute the cost function using the Chern-band prescription (Eq. 12) and compare the resulting cost to the known phase. If the cost function fails to identify the known Moore-Read phase, then the ambiguity in L-sector assignment is fatal. If it succeeds, then the failure in twisted MoTe2 may be due to other factors, but the paper would need to address those.","verdict_should_be":"CONDITIONAL","load_bearing_attack":"The paper's central claim is that the three-particle spectral cost function L (Eq. 8 for LLs, Eq. 12 for Chern bands) can be used to optimize band-projected interactions to favor the Moore-Read state. For Chern bands, the cost function requires assigning three-particle eigenstates to nominal L sectors (Eq. 12), but the authors acknowledge (sentence [b92]–[b93]) that relative angular momentum is not a good quantum number in a Chern band, and that the assignment becomes ambiguous for larger L. The paper then applies this cost function to twisted MoTe2, identifies a low-cost region, but finds that many-body ED does not provide compelling evidence for Moore-Read order (sentences [b107], [b112]). This is a direct failure of the cost function as a proxy for the many-body phase. The paper does not explain why the cost function fails in this case, nor does it propose a resolution or a modified criterion. The load-bearing assumption—that the cost function is a reliable guide to Moore-Read order in Chern bands—is therefore unsupported by the paper's own evidence. The LL results are internally consistent, but the extension to Chern bands, which is a major advertised contribution, is not validated.","agreement_with_reader":"agree"},"referee_report":{"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","summary":"The paper proposes a cost function based on the three-particle spectrum of a projected two-body interaction to quantify how closely the interaction resembles the Moore-Read parent Hamiltonian. In Landau levels, the cost function is analytically expressed in terms of Haldane pseudopotentials and correctly identifies the n=1 LL as most favorable. The authors then use the cost function as a design principle to engineer a two-body interaction that shows enhanced Moore-Read signatures in exact diagonalization. The framework is extended to Chern bands, with an application to twisted MoTe2, where a low-cost region is identified but many-body ED does not provide compelling evidence for Moore-Read order.","tokens_in":19423,"tokens_out":2001,"duration_ms":18601,"significance":"The paper introduces a novel and computationally efficient criterion for searching for non-Abelian states in Chern bands, going beyond simple LL mimicry. The analytic mapping in LLs is a useful contribution. The inverse design demonstration is a proof of principle. However, the central claim that the cost function can guide Moore-Read searches in Chern bands is not validated by the paper's own many-body results for twisted MoTe2, which show a failure of the criterion. The paper is honest about this limitation, but it significantly weakens the advertised contribution.","major_comments":[{"comment":"The paper's central claim is that the three-particle spectral cost function can be used to optimize interactions for Moore-Read states in Chern bands. However, the application to twisted MoTe2 (the only Chern band example) yields a negative result: the low-cost region does not correspond to Moore-Read order in many-body ED (sentences [b107], [b112]). The authors acknowledge this failure but do not analyze why the cost function fails, nor do they propose a modified criterion or a diagnostic to distinguish cases where the cost function works from those where it does not. This undermines the load-bearing claim that the cost function is a reliable guide for Moore-Read searches in Chern bands. The paper would be significantly strengthened by a systematic study of the failure mode, e.g., by examining the three-particle spectrum structure at the low-cost point (Fig. 4b) and identifying why the many-body state is not Moore-Read, or by testing the cost function on a Chern band model where Moore-Read order is known to exist (e.g., from the literature). Without such validation, the Chern band part of the paper remains a proposal without demonstrated predictive power.","section":"Generalization to Chern bands, Eq. (12) and Fig. 4","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"The cost function involves arbitrary weights w_L and cutoff L_max. The authors show in the SM (Fig. 5) that the ranking of LLs is robust for a range of choices, which is good. However, the absolute value of the cost and the optimal interaction obtained from inverse design depend on these choices. The inverse design uses a surrogate cost (Eq. 39) with different weights (w_3=10, w_L=1/L^2 for L>3) and a large cutoff L_max=21, while the evaluation cost uses w_L=exp(-(L-3)) and L_max=8. This inconsistency is not justified. The authors should explain why the surrogate cost with those specific weights is a good proxy for the evaluation cost, or show that the resulting engineered interaction is robust to reasonable variations in the design parameters.","section":"Cost function definition, Eq. (8) and Eq. (12)","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"The engineered interaction is obtained by minimizing a least-squares cost with ridge regularization. The resulting interaction is then tested in many-body ED and shows enhanced Moore-Read signatures. However, the paper does not discuss the physical realizability of the engineered interaction. The parameterization in Eq. (10) is a sum of Gaussians with polynomial prefactors, which may not correspond to any realistic screened Coulomb interaction in a material. The authors should comment on whether such an interaction could be realized, e.g., by dielectric engineering or by tuning the band structure. Without this, the inverse design remains a theoretical exercise.","section":"Inverse design, Eq. (10) and Fig. 2","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null}],"minor_comments":[{"comment":"The abstract states 'Our approach compares band-projected three-particle spectra to that of the Moore-Read parent Hamiltonian'. This is accurate, but it would be helpful to explicitly state that the cost function is defined in terms of the three-particle spectrum of the projected two-body interaction, not the parent Hamiltonian itself.","section":"Abstract","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"The sentence 'Our approach compares the three-particle spectrum of a projected interaction directly to that of the Moore-Read parent Hamiltonian by using a three-body generalization of Haldane pseudopotentials' is slightly misleading: the paper does not introduce a three-body generalization of Haldane pseudopotentials; it uses the existing three-body basis and maps two-body pseudopotentials to three-particle energies. Rephrase for clarity.","section":"Introduction, paragraph 3","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"The table lists U_L for L=3,5,6,7,8. It would be helpful to include the expressions for L=4 as well, even if it is not used, for completeness. Also, note that L=4 is not allowed for fermions due to antisymmetry; this should be stated explicitly.","section":"Table I","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"The caption says 'The legend shows the corresponding values of the Moore-Read cost function, L defined in the main text.' The values are given in the figure, but the font is small. Consider enlarging or listing them in the caption.","section":"Fig. 1 caption","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"The cost function is defined as a sum over L>3,i. The notation U_{L,i} is used for eigenvalues in multi-dimensional L sectors. It would be clearer to define U_{L,i} explicitly as the i-th eigenvalue of the three-particle Hamiltonian in sector L.","section":"Eq. (8)","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"The generalized cost for Chern bands includes a sum over momentum sectors K. The definition of U_i^L(K) as the i-th eigenvalue in the triplet assigned to nominal L sector in momentum sector K should be stated more clearly. The sentence 'We assign the three largest eigenvalues in each K sector to the L=3 triplet and group the remaining eigenvalues into successive triplets in descending energy order' is in the text but could be repeated in the equation caption.","section":"Eq. (12)","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"The color scale for the cost in Fig. 4(a) is not labeled. Add a color bar. Also, the caption says 'at V_g=0' but the figure shows a 2D plot over theta and V; specify that V_g=0 is fixed.","section":"Fig. 4","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"The sentence 'Three-fold degeneracy also occurs in the atomic limit of triangular lattice Hubbard models, but in that case only for the highest energy.' is a footnote reference [54]. It is unclear how this relates to the main text. Consider moving to a footnote or removing.","section":"Page 4, column 2, paragraph 2","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"The caption says 'Comparison of the analytical three body spectrum... to the numerical 3-body ED spectrum'. The figure shows good agreement, but the axes are not labeled. Add axis labels.","section":"SM, Fig. 7 caption","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"The cost function in the SM is written with a different normalization than in the main text. The main text Eq. (8) has a factor 1/N, while the SM Eq. (38) has 1/N. Check consistency. Also, the SM uses L_max while the main text uses L_max; ensure consistent notation.","section":"SM, Eq. (38)","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null},{"comment":"There are a few typographical errors: 'diagonlization' in the Acknowledgments should be 'diagonalization'; 'enginnered' in SM line [b250] should be 'engineered'. Also, in the SM, the reference to Eq. (38) should be to Eq. (8) in the main text.","section":"General","authors_acknowledge":null,"authors_acknowledge_p":null}],"recommendation":"major_revision"},"author_rebuttal":null,"desk_editor":{"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","letter":"The paper introduces a new three-particle spectral criterion for assessing whether a band-projected two-body interaction favors the Moore-Read state. The analytic mapping between two-body Haldane pseudopotentials and three-particle energies in Landau levels (Eq. 7, Table I) is clean and independently useful. The inverse-designed interaction genuinely improves Moore-Read signatures in LL exact diagonalization—larger gaps, correct degeneracy patterns—so the method demonstrably works when the underlying Hilbert space has the right structure.\n\nThe soft spot is the extension to Chern bands. The cost function requires assigning three-particle eigenstates to nominal angular momentum sectors, which the authors acknowledge is ambiguous for larger L (sentence [b92]–[b93]). They then apply it to twisted MoTe2, find a low-cost region, but the many-body ED does not show Moore-Read order (sentences [b107], [b112]). This is a direct failure of the cost function as a proxy for the many-body phase. The paper is honest about this—they say so explicitly—but they do not explain why the criterion fails or propose a fix. The reader's concern that this undermines the central claim for Chern bands is fair. However, I think the paper is still valuable: it gives the community a tool that works in LLs, shows where it breaks down, and thereby clarifies what additional physics (band geometry, form factors, higher-body interactions) matters for non-Abelian states in Chern bands.\n\nMinor issues: the cost function has free parameters (weights w_L, cutoff L_max) and the results depend on them, though the authors check sensitivity in the SM. The generalization to Chern bands is heuristic and the L-sector assignment ambiguity is real.\n\nWho this is for: researchers working on non-Abelian FCI design, especially those who want a diagnostic that goes beyond n=1 LL mimicry. The paper deserves a serious referee—the LL part is solid, the Chern part is honest about its limitations, and the negative result is informative. I would accept peer review.\n\nRecommendation: publish after the authors add a discussion of why the cost function fails in Chern bands (e.g., role of band geometry, form factor effects, or the need for three-body interactions) and possibly test on a Chern band where Moore-Read is known to exist. The paper as is is borderline for PRL but would be a strong PRB.","headline":"A technically solid cost-function framework for Moore-Read states that works beautifully in Landau levels but fails to predict the phase in Chern bands—the paper is honest about the failure, which actually makes it more useful than a paper that only showed successes.","tokens_in":19995,"tokens_out":605,"duration_ms":8319},"pith_extraction":null,"created_at":"2026-11-13T09:26:18.665561+00:00","model_set":{"reader":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash"},"pipeline_version":"pith-pipeline@v1.4.1-daily-deepseek-or-medium","input_kind":null,"input_chars":null,"input_total_chars":null,"passes_missing":null,"published_standing":null,"published_confidence":null,"objection_audit":null,"run_record":null,"basis":{"kind":"not_recorded","source":null,"chars_given":null,"chars_total":null},"receipt":null,"falsifier":null,"supporting_citations":[],"lane_accuracy":{"status":"not yet measured","lane":{"model":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash","input_kind":null},"url":"https://pith.science/accuracy"},"review_version":1}