{"schema":"pith.mesh-hub.v1","observed_at":"2026-08-15T18:54:00Z","mode":"dossier","identity":{"status":"resolved","submitted":"2605.17534","normalized":"2605.17534","resolved_id":"2605.17534","aliases":["2605.17534"],"title":"The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms","note":"Resolved against the papers table. Legacy arxiv_id remains authoritative."},"counts":[{"label":"integrity findings","value":"20,018","href":"/findings"},{"label":"claim nodes","value":"1,226,148","href":"/tools/novelty-check"},{"label":"open flags","value":"9,398","href":"/flags"}],"lanes":[{"name":"integrity","route":"available","store":"populated","coverage":"covered","public_mode":"live","query":"ok","count":1,"observed_at":"2026-08-15T18:54:00Z","human_href":"/paper/2605.17534/integrity","machine_href":"/pith/2605.17534/integrity.json","strength_bound":"Detector result on named evidence, not a paper verdict.","records":[{"type":"integrity_finding","detector":"cited_work_retraction","severity":"critical","finding_type":"cited_work_retracted","note":"Cited reference [24] (DOI 10.1007/bf01488952) is flagged as retracted by 2 authoritative source(s). Readers relying on this citation should treat the cited work accordingly.","date":"2026-05-23"}],"scope":"paper_query","preview":false},{"name":"claims","route":"available","store":"populated","coverage":"covered","public_mode":"live","query":"ok","count":4,"observed_at":"2026-08-15T18:54:00Z","human_href":"/claims/2605.17534","machine_href":"/claims/2605.17534","strength_bound":"Extracted claim text and dependency edges; not settled truth.","records":[{"type":"claim_node","role":"machinery","text":"Investigation of the circulation history of the essays, which demonstrates that multiple-format republication was standard practice in early 20th-century scientific publishing.","date":"2026-07-09"},{"type":"claim_node","role":"falsifier","text":"Contemporary documents from the 1940s criticizing Planck's republications as improper or revealing scientific flaws in the essays would undermine the claim that the retractions are purely anachronisti","date":"2026-07-09"},{"type":"claim_node","role":"premise","text":"The retractions result solely from contemporary digitization and copyright-management procedures applied anachronistically to the historical publications rather than from any scientific or ethical iss","date":"2026-07-09"},{"type":"claim_node","role":"claim","text":"By tracing how Planck's 1940 and 1942 essays moved through different publication formats, the authors show that such republication followed common and legitimate practices of the period. The retractio","date":"2026-07-09"}],"scope":"paper_query","preview":false},{"name":"citations","route":"available","store":"populated","coverage":"covered","public_mode":"live","query":"ok","count":28,"observed_at":"2026-08-15T18:54:00Z","human_href":"/paper/2605.17534/citation-record","machine_href":"/paper/2605.17534/citation-record.json","strength_bound":"Resolved reference and quoted context; not dependence.","records":[],"scope":"paper_query","preview":false},{"name":"flags","route":"available","store":"populated","coverage":"covered","public_mode":"live","query":"ok","count":2,"observed_at":"2026-08-15T18:54:00Z","human_href":"/flags","machine_href":"/flags","strength_bound":"Neutral one-hop delivery of an external event notice.","records":[{"type":"flag","id":"31","status":"open","event_type":"retraction","event_title":"Naturwissenschaft und reale Aussenwelt","date":"2026-07-08"},{"type":"flag","id":"30","status":"open","event_type":"retraction","event_title":"Naturwissenschaft und reale Aussenwelt","date":"2026-07-08"}],"scope":"paper_query","preview":false},{"name":"mesh_objects","route":"unavailable","store":"unavailable","coverage":"not_collected","public_mode":"shadow","query":"unsupported","count":null,"observed_at":"2026-08-15T18:54:00Z","human_href":"/evidence","machine_href":"/mesh.json?paper_id=2605.17534","strength_bound":"Shadow only until preregistered pilot gates pass.","records":[],"scope":"","preview":false}],"relation":[{"surface":"Evidence Mesh","responsibility":"Content-addressed objects, checks, chronology, and a receipt-backed paper biography fold.","strength_bound":"Object type controls effect. Custody is not correctness.","public_mode":"shadow","human":"/evidence","machine":"/mesh.json"},{"surface":"Integrity","responsibility":"Continuous detectors, signed findings, challenges, Pith Number bundles.","strength_bound":"A finding is a named detector result, not a paper verdict.","public_mode":"live","human":"/integrity","machine":"/pith/{id}/integrity.json"},{"surface":"Tools","responsibility":"Point the same review machinery at a bibliography, claim, or falsifier you bring.","strength_bound":"Instrument coverage is local; silence is not a certificate.","public_mode":"live","human":"/tools","machine":"/tools/reference-audit.json"},{"surface":"Citations","responsibility":"Resolved references, quoted contexts, foundational works.","strength_bound":"A citation edge is evidence of reference, not dependence or fault.","public_mode":"live","human":"/citations","machine":"/citations/search.json"},{"surface":"Flags","responsibility":"Events-only one-hop notices near cited works.","strength_bound":"Delivery only. Never adverse inheritance through a bare citation.","public_mode":"live","human":"/flags","machine":"/flags"}],"agent":{"schema_version":"pith.mesh-hub.v1","html":"/evidence?paper_id=2605.17534","json":"/mesh.json?paper_id=2605.17534","examples":["curl -sS 'https://pith.science/mesh.json'","curl -sS 'https://pith.science/mesh.json?paper_id=0704.0001'","curl -sS --get 'https://pith.science/mesh.json' --data-urlencode 'paper_id=math/0211159'"],"acceptance_policy_specimens":[{"name":"kernel_accept only","rule":"Treat only kernel_accept transcripts as acceptance transitions; custody_only is notice."},{"name":"custody_only as notice","rule":"Render custody_only objects as delivery notices, never as peers of kernel_accept."},{"name":"pin this fork","rule":"Consumers pin a chosen lineage; the protocol has no global latest truth."}]},"specimen":{"profile":"pith.paper-biography.v0","subject_id":"paper:arxiv:<id>","subject_version_id":"paper-version:arxiv:<id>:v<n>","as_of":"<RFC3339>","collection_frontier_hash":"sha256:<manifest>","identity_snapshot_digest":"sha256:<aliases-and-resolutions>","event_frontier_hash":"sha256:<operator-checkpoints>","reducer_digest":"git:<commit>","policy_fingerprint":"sha256:<behavioral-policy>","output_hash":"sha256:<render-model>","coverage":{"state":"complete_within_manifest | partial","receipt_ids":["..."]},"note":"Schema-true specimen only. The paper-biography fold is not a public default read."},"challenge":{"findings":"/findings","challenges":"/challenges","protocol":"/pith-integrity-protocol","flags":"/flags","note":"File a challenge against a specific attributed finding or claim; disagreement stays on the public record."},"architecture":{"href":"/evidence#architecture","label":"Evidence Mesh architecture and preregistered gates","note":"Preregistered Mesh gates live in the architecture decision; this page does not paint gate status by hand."},"render_provenance":{"context_digest":"sha256:d9f8f787c7dc8b5f46f9cae2f4abf82889bf774e717b2becb0a226edccfc5d03","template_digest":"mesh_hub.html","rendered_at":"2026-08-15T18:54:00Z"},"context_digest":"sha256:d9f8f787c7dc8b5f46f9cae2f4abf82889bf774e717b2becb0a226edccfc5d03","counts_status":"ok","featured_example":null,"try_links":[]}