{"as_of":"2026-08-08T12:48:00Z","caps":{"database_statements":6,"inbound":100,"outbound":100},"context_digest":"sha256:d4068162e9f22fc060c2f35931b7bb19b1c30c976362e49b4039dda881c02df4","coverage":[{"denominator":0,"lane":"reference_resolution","note":"Typed states for the displayed outbound observations.","records_observed":0,"source":"paper_references, paper_reference_links","source_observed_at":null,"state":"measured"},{"denominator":12,"lane":"standing_notices","note":"One-hop event checks from named stored sources.","records_observed":12,"source":"scholarly_work_events, retraction_status_cache","source_observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:32:00.761636+00:00","state":"measured"},{"denominator":12,"lane":"inbound_itemization","note":"Pith citing papers itemized under the disclosed page cap.","records_observed":12,"source":"paper_references, paper_reference_links","source_observed_at":"2026-08-07T12:12:36.352474Z","state":"measured"},{"denominator":1,"lane":"external_citation_measurements","note":"A source-named dated measurement, never combined with another source.","records_observed":0,"source":"arxiv_reference","source_observed_at":"2026-05-23T17:35:43.992836Z","state":"measured"}],"external_citation_measurements":[],"inbound":[{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","last_updated":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-06T16:04:11.116224Z","submitted_at":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","title":"Shepherd: A Critic for Language Model Generation","version":1},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","doi":null,"metadata_source":"arxiv_reference","pith_arxiv_id":"2308.04592","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-06-05T21:23:00.469572Z","title":"Shepherd: A critic for language model generation","venue":null,"work_id":"c244d3ec-b6bf-40bb-960f-24a7c5e76c9e","year":2023},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2310.01798","last_updated":"2024-03-14T04:27:52Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-06T02:11:23.670680Z","submitted_at":"2023-10-03T04:56:12Z","title":"Large Language Models Cannot Self-Correct Reasoning Yet","version":2},"reference_index":19,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-05-12T05:48:24.133045Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/2308.04592","citing_paper":"/paper/2310.01798"},"observation_digest":"sha256:801841124659c50316bccf7f3c331e819c88f9417d390b28a2681f2038b95cd0","observation_id":"be7f4ce0-1816-411e-b669-6da173afed77","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-05-12T05:48:27.119090Z","resolver_source":"arxiv_id","status":"metadata_mismatch"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-08T06:32:00.761636+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:32:00.761636+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:31:55.24221+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","last_updated":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-06T16:04:11.116224Z","submitted_at":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","title":"Shepherd: A Critic for Language Model Generation","version":1},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","doi":null,"metadata_source":"arxiv_reference","pith_arxiv_id":"2308.04592","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-06-05T21:23:00.469572Z","title":"Shepherd: A critic for language model generation","venue":null,"work_id":"c244d3ec-b6bf-40bb-960f-24a7c5e76c9e","year":2023},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2411.15594","last_updated":"2025-10-19T10:32:43Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-02T10:23:50.881300Z","submitted_at":"2024-11-23T16:03:35Z","title":"A Survey on LLM-as-a-Judge","version":6},"reference_index":163,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-05-23T17:33:13.394338Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/2308.04592","citing_paper":"/paper/2411.15594"},"observation_digest":"sha256:1aef245df545bf910518b5db0ee056bbcdeb51d7b7e18d95f32d42ea0f9d14a4","observation_id":"95f367e4-9055-43fa-b6d2-7909ae475abf","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-05-23T17:35:43.995480Z","resolver_source":"arxiv_id","status":"verified_exact"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-08T06:32:00.761636+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:32:00.761636+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:31:55.24221+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","last_updated":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-06T16:04:11.116224Z","submitted_at":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","title":"Shepherd: A Critic for Language Model Generation","version":1},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","doi":null,"metadata_source":"arxiv_reference","pith_arxiv_id":"2308.04592","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-06-05T21:23:00.469572Z","title":"Shepherd: A critic for language model generation","venue":null,"work_id":"c244d3ec-b6bf-40bb-960f-24a7c5e76c9e","year":2023},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2412.05579","last_updated":"2024-12-10T05:49:12Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-31T01:42:39.468673Z","submitted_at":"2024-12-07T08:07:24Z","title":"LLMs-as-Judges: A Comprehensive Survey on LLM-based Evaluation Methods","version":2},"reference_index":241,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-05-11T23:08:34.312466Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/2308.04592","citing_paper":"/paper/2412.05579"},"observation_digest":"sha256:5c3e12a5ae3bee30a156a45c59ef1914ec55553c0401d1297942321f000559f6","observation_id":"785ceb04-4501-4828-9b9c-0298c0b1ab02","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-05-11T23:08:35.631356Z","resolver_source":"arxiv_id","status":"verified_exact"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-08T06:32:00.761636+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:32:00.761636+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:31:55.24221+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","last_updated":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-06T16:04:11.116224Z","submitted_at":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","title":"Shepherd: A Critic for Language Model Generation","version":1},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","doi":null,"metadata_source":"arxiv_reference","pith_arxiv_id":"2308.04592","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-06-05T21:23:00.469572Z","title":"Shepherd: A critic for language model generation","venue":null,"work_id":"c244d3ec-b6bf-40bb-960f-24a7c5e76c9e","year":2023},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2412.18925","last_updated":"2024-12-25T15:12:34Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-06T02:11:23.670680Z","submitted_at":"2024-12-25T15:12:34Z","title":"HuatuoGPT-o1, Towards Medical Complex Reasoning with LLMs","version":1},"reference_index":78,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-05-15T12:36:50.060335Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/2308.04592","citing_paper":"/paper/2412.18925"},"observation_digest":"sha256:d49f75d191b3ea783054894a7ae30c6581903efd909516994115bacf0a2d01d1","observation_id":"830c0775-43ec-4910-8ac5-6d22604b3beb","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-05-15T12:36:50.215433Z","resolver_source":"arxiv_id","status":"verified_exact"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-08T06:32:00.761636+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:32:00.761636+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:31:55.24221+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","last_updated":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-06T16:04:11.116224Z","submitted_at":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","title":"Shepherd: A Critic for Language Model Generation","version":1},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","doi":null,"metadata_source":"arxiv_reference","pith_arxiv_id":"2308.04592","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-06-05T21:23:00.469572Z","title":"Shepherd: A critic for language model generation","venue":null,"work_id":"c244d3ec-b6bf-40bb-960f-24a7c5e76c9e","year":2023},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2504.12501","last_updated":"2026-08-03T01:47:58Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-07T16:01:39.307745Z","submitted_at":"2025-04-16T21:36:46Z","title":"Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback","version":9},"reference_index":293,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-05-22T19:27:40.991325Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/2308.04592","citing_paper":"/paper/2504.12501"},"observation_digest":"sha256:57fef5886bba320aa7b0b16fae21cda0068d87e766b2f4593386e075424b1d4c","observation_id":"1d23d641-c885-4c6d-9156-b90c64e84549","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-05-22T19:32:01.170999Z","resolver_source":"arxiv_id","status":"verified_exact"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-08T06:32:00.761636+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:32:00.761636+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:31:55.24221+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","last_updated":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-06T16:04:11.116224Z","submitted_at":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","title":"Shepherd: A Critic for Language Model Generation","version":1},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":"2308.04592","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-07T12:12:36.352474Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":2023},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2506.00319","last_updated":"2025-05-31T00:08:59Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T05:48:50.179328Z","submitted_at":"2025-05-31T00:08:59Z","title":"SkillVerse : Assessing and Enhancing LLMs with Tree Evaluation","version":1},"reference_index":28,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-07T12:12:36.352474Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/2308.04592","citing_paper":"/paper/2506.00319"},"observation_digest":"sha256:70bab69489e7338537eed6fe0fbb0d8f57f5002d8229a66a7c18d840eecb8dfc","observation_id":"56ae71b1-4c32-4e6b-bd47-4094ef1b9bac","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-07T12:12:36.352474Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","last_updated":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-06T16:04:11.116224Z","submitted_at":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","title":"Shepherd: A Critic for Language Model Generation","version":1},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","doi":null,"metadata_source":"arxiv_reference","pith_arxiv_id":"2308.04592","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-06-05T21:23:00.469572Z","title":"Shepherd: A critic for language model generation","venue":null,"work_id":"c244d3ec-b6bf-40bb-960f-24a7c5e76c9e","year":2023},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2506.02546","last_updated":"2026-04-14T05:32:17Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-06T02:11:23.670680Z","submitted_at":"2025-06-03T07:32:57Z","title":"To trust or not to trust: Attention-based Trust Management for LLM Multi-Agent Systems","version":2},"reference_index":24,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-05-19T11:30:47.877793Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/2308.04592","citing_paper":"/paper/2506.02546"},"observation_digest":"sha256:273d4c0e1dd980f4aab0553327227612f301bbc32894fd9cb907c6a74b561c28","observation_id":"98891d74-f711-49f2-b972-8e3616af3e5c","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-05-19T11:32:17.409057Z","resolver_source":"arxiv_id","status":"verified_exact"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-08T06:32:00.761636+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:32:00.761636+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:31:55.24221+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","last_updated":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-06T16:04:11.116224Z","submitted_at":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","title":"Shepherd: A Critic for Language Model Generation","version":1},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":"2308.04592","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-07T11:04:00.133441Z","title":"Shepherd: A critic for language model generation.arXiv preprint arXiv:2308.04592, 2023","venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":2023},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2506.03573","last_updated":"2025-06-04T04:43:15Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:29:45.695775Z","submitted_at":"2025-06-04T04:43:15Z","title":"Exchange of Perspective Prompting Enhances Reasoning in Large Language Models","version":1},"reference_index":29,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-07T11:04:00.133441Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/2308.04592","citing_paper":"/paper/2506.03573"},"observation_digest":"sha256:57ed48c713b76ca52c74f3927e6a7a73816a614482c11024cb400b5288986f3d","observation_id":"da1e0fd0-387e-432e-ae69-46dc55fc6705","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-07T11:04:00.133441Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","last_updated":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-06T16:04:11.116224Z","submitted_at":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","title":"Shepherd: A Critic for Language Model Generation","version":1},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":"2308.04592","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T14:26:03.582133Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":2023},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.06503","last_updated":"2025-07-25T15:56:25Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-07T10:30:17.548016Z","submitted_at":"2025-07-25T15:56:25Z","title":"Understanding Human Limits in Pattern Recognition: A Computational Model of Sequential Reasoning in Rock, Paper, Scissors","version":1},"reference_index":59,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T14:26:03.582133Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/2308.04592","citing_paper":"/paper/2508.06503"},"observation_digest":"sha256:e0e7c566f53d439c96e9f3ebebfd679260ed6b838fa44a50943e389c775db1a7","observation_id":"43ef97b8-84fb-400b-b6f3-4abebaaa0c3e","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T14:26:03.582133Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","last_updated":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-06T16:04:11.116224Z","submitted_at":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","title":"Shepherd: A Critic for Language Model Generation","version":1},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","doi":null,"metadata_source":"arxiv_reference","pith_arxiv_id":"2308.04592","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-06-05T21:23:00.469572Z","title":"Shepherd: A critic for language model generation","venue":null,"work_id":"c244d3ec-b6bf-40bb-960f-24a7c5e76c9e","year":2023},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.15815","last_updated":"2026-04-19T06:21:12Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-04T00:23:39.759653Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-16T20:33:09Z","title":"User-Assistant Bias in LLMs","version":3},"reference_index":17,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-05-18T22:51:02.400926Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/2308.04592","citing_paper":"/paper/2508.15815"},"observation_digest":"sha256:80e28f783a4d9eed0a6ae8215dd5910ae9eb05eafba22fc967658a6d2caa0780","observation_id":"cb10a7f6-4dd5-403f-b8af-675e9a7cf402","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-05-18T22:51:53.108335Z","resolver_source":"arxiv_id","status":"metadata_mismatch"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-08T06:32:00.761636+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:32:00.761636+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:31:55.24221+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","last_updated":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-06T16:04:11.116224Z","submitted_at":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","title":"Shepherd: A Critic for Language Model Generation","version":1},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","doi":null,"metadata_source":"arxiv_reference","pith_arxiv_id":"2308.04592","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-06-05T21:23:00.469572Z","title":"Shepherd: A critic for language model generation","venue":null,"work_id":"c244d3ec-b6bf-40bb-960f-24a7c5e76c9e","year":2023},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2605.15207","last_updated":"2026-07-08T14:36:15Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-12T17:52:34.996306Z","submitted_at":"2026-05-01T23:42:57Z","title":"TeamTR: Trust-Region Fine-Tuning for Multi-Agent LLM Coordination","version":1},"reference_index":39,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-05-19T18:01:06.649723Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/2308.04592","citing_paper":"/paper/2605.15207"},"observation_digest":"sha256:b23ac61e60c3af7eaab5d95e8ef9532d212c8030976a7efcc743e9be693e3d0e","observation_id":"61b259b0-be66-419e-8f3f-b5a29f70e516","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-05-19T18:02:42.359251Z","resolver_source":"arxiv_id","status":"metadata_mismatch"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-08T06:32:00.761636+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:32:00.761636+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:31:55.24221+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","last_updated":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-06T16:04:11.116224Z","submitted_at":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","title":"Shepherd: A Critic for Language Model Generation","version":1},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":"2308.04592","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-01T03:14:12.848281Z","title":"arXiv:2308.04592","venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":null},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2607.26094","last_updated":"2026-07-28T02:09:26Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-05T20:24:58.318060Z","submitted_at":"2026-07-28T02:09:26Z","title":"Meta-Learned Reward Shaping for Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback","version":1},"reference_index":15,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-01T03:14:12.848281Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/2308.04592","citing_paper":"/paper/2607.26094"},"observation_digest":"sha256:e7022be270d248bac7e0390b56a5c520d34178af36bd307a2d4ac9d02e3d8ef0","observation_id":"b7d42c34-5f16-46a9-9cb9-82521729b748","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-01T03:14:12.848281Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}}],"links":{"evidence":"/evidence","html":"/paper/2308.04592/citation-record","integrity":"/paper/2308.04592/integrity","json":"/paper/2308.04592/citation-record.json","paper":"/paper/2308.04592"},"outbound":[],"paper":{"arxiv_id":"2308.04592","last_updated":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","latest_version":1,"primary_category":"cs.CL","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-06T16:04:11.116224Z","submitted_at":"2023-08-08T21:23:23Z","title":"Shepherd: A Critic for Language Model Generation"},"reference_resolution":{"displayed":0,"state_counts":{"malformed_identifier":0,"metadata_mismatch":0,"parse_uncertain":0,"unresolved":0,"verified_exact":0,"verified_fuzzy":0},"total_outbound_references":0},"refusal":"A citation records a reference. It does not transfer a finding from one paper to another.","schema":"pith.paper-citation-record.v1","standing_sources":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:32:00.761636+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-08T06:31:55.24221+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"thesis":"As of 8 August 2026, this Paper Citation Record lists 0 of 0 outbound references and 12 inbound Pith citation observations for arXiv:2308.04592."}