{"schema":"https://pith.science/schemas/pith-integrity/v1.json","pith_number":"2607.24571","arxiv_id":"2607.24571","integrity":{"available":true,"endpoint":"/pith/2607.24571/integrity.json","summary":{"critical":5,"advisory":1,"informational":0,"by_detector":{"doi_compliance":{"total":6,"critical":5,"advisory":1,"informational":0}}},"clean":false,"detectors_run":[{"name":"doi_title_agreement","version":"1.0.0","status":"completed","ran_at":"2026-08-04T13:38:59.426618Z","findings_count":0},{"name":"doi_compliance","version":"1.1.0","status":"completed","ran_at":"2026-08-04T12:20:18.077659Z","findings_count":6},{"name":"ai_meta_artifact","version":"1.0.0","status":"skipped","ran_at":"2026-08-04T06:08:57.452302Z","findings_count":0},{"name":"claim_evidence","version":"1.0.0","status":"completed","ran_at":"2026-08-03T13:08:24.427686Z","findings_count":0},{"name":"external_links","version":"1.0.0","status":"completed","ran_at":"2026-07-28T23:34:50.629339Z","findings_count":0},{"name":"shingle_duplication","version":"0.1.0","status":"skipped","ran_at":"2026-07-28T17:54:07.546545Z","findings_count":0},{"name":"citation_quote_validity","version":"0.1.0","status":"skipped","ran_at":"2026-07-28T07:57:55.707690Z","findings_count":0},{"name":"cited_work_retraction","version":"1.0.0","status":"completed","ran_at":"2026-07-28T05:24:13.463859Z","findings_count":0}],"findings":[{"detector":"doi_compliance","finding_type":"unresolvable_identifier","severity":"critical","verdict_class":"cross_source","note":"Identifier '10.1109/visual.2019' is syntactically valid but the DOI registry (doi.org) returned 404, and Crossref / OpenAlex / internal corpus also have no record. The cited work could not be located through any authoritative source.","detected_doi":"10.1109/visual.2019","detected_arxiv_id":null,"ref_index":43,"audited_at":"2026-07-31T11:42:16.464591Z"},{"detector":"doi_compliance","finding_type":"unresolvable_identifier","severity":"critical","verdict_class":"cross_source","note":"Identifier '10.1109/tvcg.2022' is syntactically valid but the DOI registry (doi.org) returned 404, and Crossref / OpenAlex / internal corpus also have no record. The cited work could not be located through any authoritative source.","detected_doi":"10.1109/tvcg.2022","detected_arxiv_id":null,"ref_index":66,"audited_at":"2026-07-31T11:42:16.464591Z"},{"detector":"doi_compliance","finding_type":"unresolvable_identifier","severity":"critical","verdict_class":"cross_source","note":"Identifier '10.1109/access.2022' is syntactically valid but the DOI registry (doi.org) returned 404, and Crossref / OpenAlex / internal corpus also have no record. The cited work could not be located through any authoritative source.","detected_doi":"10.1109/access.2022","detected_arxiv_id":null,"ref_index":73,"audited_at":"2026-07-31T11:42:16.464591Z"},{"detector":"doi_compliance","finding_type":"unresolvable_identifier","severity":"critical","verdict_class":"cross_source","note":"Identifier '10.1109/tvcg.2016' is syntactically valid but the DOI registry (doi.org) returned 404, and Crossref / OpenAlex / internal corpus also have no record. The cited work could not be located through any authoritative source.","detected_doi":"10.1109/tvcg.2016","detected_arxiv_id":null,"ref_index":48,"audited_at":"2026-07-31T11:42:16.464591Z"},{"detector":"doi_compliance","finding_type":"recoverable_identifier","severity":"advisory","verdict_class":"incontrovertible","note":"DOI in the printed bibliography is fragmented by whitespace or line breaks. A longer candidate (10.1109/tvcg.2004.1260759) was visible in the surrounding text but could not be confirmed against doi.org as printed.","detected_doi":"10.1109/tvcg.2004.1260759","detected_arxiv_id":null,"ref_index":77,"audited_at":"2026-07-31T11:42:16.464591Z"},{"detector":"doi_compliance","finding_type":"unresolvable_identifier","severity":"critical","verdict_class":"cross_source","note":"Identifier '10.1177/147387162210818' is syntactically valid but the DOI registry (doi.org) returned 404, and Crossref / OpenAlex / internal corpus also have no record. The cited work could not be located through any authoritative source.","detected_doi":"10.1177/147387162210818","detected_arxiv_id":null,"ref_index":26,"audited_at":"2026-07-31T11:42:16.464591Z"}],"snapshot_sha256":"828faefc6e1bbc890375afd93f589cf50b22cc63905550c2b2a9221e4a8a1bcc"},"events":[{"event_id":14346,"event_type":"pith.integrity.v1","payload_sha256":"a636ecc1a3ffdd386a53f4d90f349a4d3eef1262ff3329be9608a54d61d45152","signature_b64":null,"signing_key_id":null,"created_at":"2026-07-31T11:46:12.482044+00:00","payload":{"note":"DOI in the printed bibliography is fragmented by whitespace or line breaks. A longer candidate (10.1109/tvcg.2004.1260759) was visible in the surrounding text but could not be confirmed against doi.org as printed.","snippet":"M. Tory and T. Möller. Human factors in visualization research.IEEE Trans. Vis. Comput. Graph., 10(1):72–84, 2004. doi: 10.1109/TVCG.2004 .1260759 9","arxiv_id":"2607.24571","detector":"doi_compliance","evidence":{"ref_index":77,"verdict_class":"incontrovertible","resolved_title":null,"printed_excerpt":"10.1109/tvcg.2004","reconstructed_doi":"10.1109/tvcg.2004.1260759"},"severity":"advisory","ref_index":77,"audited_at":"2026-07-31T11:42:16.464591Z","event_type":"pith.integrity.v1","detected_doi":"10.1109/tvcg.2004.1260759","detector_url":"https://pith.science/pith-integrity-protocol#doi_compliance","external_url":null,"finding_type":"recoverable_identifier","evidence_hash":"e7924fb3d219993acf405a3b5d4cb3a304ce8f708affeb351647d5290c28179e","paper_version":1,"verdict_class":"incontrovertible","resolved_title":null,"detector_version":"1.1.0","detected_arxiv_id":null}},{"event_id":14345,"event_type":"pith.integrity.v1","payload_sha256":"207929a934b7f458f9b61fc02858ebef1fe08c475026dbb6af81858638b2795a","signature_b64":null,"signing_key_id":null,"created_at":"2026-07-31T11:46:12.405998+00:00","payload":{"note":"Identifier '10.1109/access.2022' is syntactically valid but the DOI registry (doi.org) returned 404, and Crossref / OpenAlex / internal corpus also have no record. The cited work could not be located through any authoritative source.","snippet":"H. M. Shakeel, S. Iram, H. Al-Aqrabi, T. Alsboui, and R. Hill. A com- prehensive state-of-the-art survey on data visualization tools: Research developments, challenges and future domain specific visualization frame- work.IEEE Access, 10:965","arxiv_id":"2607.24571","detector":"doi_compliance","evidence":{"doi":"10.1109/access.2022","arxiv_id":null,"ref_index":73,"raw_excerpt":"H. M. Shakeel, S. Iram, H. Al-Aqrabi, T. Alsboui, and R. Hill. A com- prehensive state-of-the-art survey on data visualization tools: Research developments, challenges and future domain specific visualization frame- work.IEEE Access, 10:96581–96601, 2022. doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2022. 3205115 2","parse_status":"well_formed","verdict_class":"cross_source","checked_sources":["crossref_by_doi","openalex_by_doi","doi_org_head"],"resolution_status":"hard_miss"},"severity":"critical","ref_index":73,"audited_at":"2026-07-31T11:42:16.464591Z","event_type":"pith.integrity.v1","detected_doi":"10.1109/access.2022","detector_url":"https://pith.science/pith-integrity-protocol#doi_compliance","external_url":null,"finding_type":"unresolvable_identifier","evidence_hash":"a8e79d28ac4a117ec4262bd8ce0288689968770b18b1b6c0b444731af87fee44","paper_version":1,"verdict_class":"cross_source","resolved_title":null,"detector_version":"1.1.0","detected_arxiv_id":null}},{"event_id":14344,"event_type":"pith.integrity.v1","payload_sha256":"c394b0c822bdd985586a792e5812b960a126409f31231e11d1fb384510f21b8a","signature_b64":null,"signing_key_id":null,"created_at":"2026-07-31T11:46:12.250549+00:00","payload":{"note":"Identifier '10.1109/tvcg.2022' is syntactically valid but the DOI registry (doi.org) returned 404, and Crossref / OpenAlex / internal corpus also have no record. The cited work could not be located through any authoritative source.","snippet":"N. Rakotondravony, Y . Ding, and L. Harrison. Probablement, wahrschein- lich, likely? a cross-language study of how people verbalize probabilities in icon array visualizations.IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 29(1):","arxiv_id":"2607.24571","detector":"doi_compliance","evidence":{"doi":"10.1109/tvcg.2022","arxiv_id":null,"ref_index":66,"raw_excerpt":"N. Rakotondravony, Y . Ding, and L. Harrison. Probablement, wahrschein- lich, likely? a cross-language study of how people verbalize probabilities in icon array visualizations.IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 29(1):1189–1199, 2023. doi: 10.1109/TVCG.2022. 3209367 2, 9","parse_status":"well_formed","verdict_class":"cross_source","checked_sources":["crossref_by_doi","openalex_by_doi","doi_org_head"],"resolution_status":"hard_miss"},"severity":"critical","ref_index":66,"audited_at":"2026-07-31T11:42:16.464591Z","event_type":"pith.integrity.v1","detected_doi":"10.1109/tvcg.2022","detector_url":"https://pith.science/pith-integrity-protocol#doi_compliance","external_url":null,"finding_type":"unresolvable_identifier","evidence_hash":"9d6ff02843558bc2d2f1e4827fe2f16222c880de8d21a3ea9dca77af24f9a98c","paper_version":1,"verdict_class":"cross_source","resolved_title":null,"detector_version":"1.1.0","detected_arxiv_id":null}},{"event_id":14343,"event_type":"pith.integrity.v1","payload_sha256":"14e63a7c9c8755650bdb1f065124a03962c1255b6db959220bda3aa2a7e6d23e","signature_b64":null,"signing_key_id":null,"created_at":"2026-07-31T11:46:12.154730+00:00","payload":{"note":"Identifier '10.1109/tvcg.2016' is syntactically valid but the DOI registry (doi.org) returned 404, and Crossref / OpenAlex / internal corpus also have no record. The cited work could not be located through any authoritative source.","snippet":"S. Lee, S. H. Kim, and B. C. Kwon. VLAT: Development of a Visual- ization Literacy Assessment Test.IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 23(1):551–560, 2017. doi: 10.1109/TVCG.2016. 2598920 9","arxiv_id":"2607.24571","detector":"doi_compliance","evidence":{"doi":"10.1109/tvcg.2016","arxiv_id":null,"ref_index":48,"raw_excerpt":"S. Lee, S. H. Kim, and B. C. Kwon. VLAT: Development of a Visual- ization Literacy Assessment Test.IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 23(1):551–560, 2017. doi: 10.1109/TVCG.2016. 2598920 9","parse_status":"well_formed","verdict_class":"cross_source","checked_sources":["crossref_by_doi","openalex_by_doi","doi_org_head"],"resolution_status":"hard_miss"},"severity":"critical","ref_index":48,"audited_at":"2026-07-31T11:42:16.464591Z","event_type":"pith.integrity.v1","detected_doi":"10.1109/tvcg.2016","detector_url":"https://pith.science/pith-integrity-protocol#doi_compliance","external_url":null,"finding_type":"unresolvable_identifier","evidence_hash":"e42e789cfa6c6b79f49f9b411ec357f9d23a2e272888be1100d26a787985806a","paper_version":1,"verdict_class":"cross_source","resolved_title":null,"detector_version":"1.1.0","detected_arxiv_id":null}},{"event_id":14342,"event_type":"pith.integrity.v1","payload_sha256":"55116cead76ea08dc0db95eee1a63313cadea0ac7617ca91125760e497b66914","signature_b64":null,"signing_key_id":null,"created_at":"2026-07-31T11:46:12.068285+00:00","payload":{"note":"Identifier '10.1109/visual.2019' is syntactically valid but the DOI registry (doi.org) returned 404, and Crossref / OpenAlex / internal corpus also have no record. The cited work could not be located through any authoritative source.","snippet":"H. Kim, J. Oh, Y . Han, S. Ko, M. Brehmer, and B. C. Kwon. Thumbnails 10 © 2026 IEEE. This is the author’s version of the article that has been published in IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics. The final version of this","arxiv_id":"2607.24571","detector":"doi_compliance","evidence":{"doi":"10.1109/visual.2019","arxiv_id":null,"ref_index":43,"raw_excerpt":"H. Kim, J. Oh, Y . Han, S. Ko, M. Brehmer, and B. C. Kwon. Thumbnails 10 © 2026 IEEE. This is the author’s version of the article that has been published in IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics. The final version of this record is available at: xx.xxxx/TVCG.201x.xxxxxxx/ for Data Stories: A Survey of Current Practices.2019 IEEE Visualization Conference, VIS 2019, pp. 116–120, 2","parse_status":"well_formed","verdict_class":"cross_source","checked_sources":["crossref_by_doi","openalex_by_doi","doi_org_head"],"resolution_status":"hard_miss"},"severity":"critical","ref_index":43,"audited_at":"2026-07-31T11:42:16.464591Z","event_type":"pith.integrity.v1","detected_doi":"10.1109/visual.2019","detector_url":"https://pith.science/pith-integrity-protocol#doi_compliance","external_url":null,"finding_type":"unresolvable_identifier","evidence_hash":"94c0e0d3732ba705636fcb2ecdab17e940a48d364685a8fbc4271e3e59daf611","paper_version":1,"verdict_class":"cross_source","resolved_title":null,"detector_version":"1.1.0","detected_arxiv_id":null}},{"event_id":14341,"event_type":"pith.integrity.v1","payload_sha256":"801fc565a628c8d647c33380ab1e98de5102bd953d45e653a1a1b9b68db38f90","signature_b64":null,"signing_key_id":null,"created_at":"2026-07-31T11:46:11.964202+00:00","payload":{"note":"Identifier '10.1177/147387162210818' is syntactically valid but the DOI registry (doi.org) returned 404, and Crossref / OpenAlex / internal corpus also have no record. The cited work could not be located through any authoritative source.","snippet":"E. E. Firat, A. Joshi, and R. S. Laramee. Interactive visualization literacy: The state-of-the-art.Information Visualization, 21(3):285–310, 2022. doi: 10.1177/147387162210818 9","arxiv_id":"2607.24571","detector":"doi_compliance","evidence":{"doi":"10.1177/147387162210818","arxiv_id":null,"ref_index":26,"raw_excerpt":"E. E. Firat, A. Joshi, and R. S. Laramee. Interactive visualization literacy: The state-of-the-art.Information Visualization, 21(3):285–310, 2022. doi: 10.1177/147387162210818 9","parse_status":"well_formed","verdict_class":"cross_source","checked_sources":["crossref_by_doi","openalex_by_doi","doi_org_head"],"resolution_status":"hard_miss"},"severity":"critical","ref_index":26,"audited_at":"2026-07-31T11:42:16.464591Z","event_type":"pith.integrity.v1","detected_doi":"10.1177/147387162210818","detector_url":"https://pith.science/pith-integrity-protocol#doi_compliance","external_url":null,"finding_type":"unresolvable_identifier","evidence_hash":"c550f86c02e8f1ed809c96728ddf2344704681cf213c535a88684eb738f704bb","paper_version":1,"verdict_class":"cross_source","resolved_title":null,"detector_version":"1.1.0","detected_arxiv_id":null}}],"endpoint_self":"/pith/2607.24571/integrity.json","protocol_url":"https://pith.science/pith-integrity-protocol"}