{"bundle_type":"pith_open_graph_bundle","bundle_version":"1.0","pith_number":"pith:2021:ZD6SBDBVR6NH6X74ZJREIBIATD","short_pith_number":"pith:ZD6SBDBV","canonical_record":{"source":{"id":"2109.09774","kind":"arxiv","version":1},"metadata":{"license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","primary_cat":"cs.DL","submitted_at":"2021-09-20T18:06:22Z","cross_cats_sorted":["cs.LG"],"title_canon_sha256":"3c8dfc0b62e7af8f27af3baa6741697ddc69a0e8858fbd961556d4de71a2f270","abstract_canon_sha256":"068287cf4243dd10a2b4348d1f3fb7b9b823aed8739f723e958f68a0ad098014"},"schema_version":"1.0"},"canonical_sha256":"c8fd208c358f9a7f5ffcca6244050098e7447682f95228aa41ce2b0daa3dfa14","source":{"kind":"arxiv","id":"2109.09774","version":1},"source_aliases":[{"alias_kind":"arxiv","alias_value":"2109.09774","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54Z"},{"alias_kind":"arxiv_version","alias_value":"2109.09774v1","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54Z"},{"alias_kind":"doi","alias_value":"10.48550/arxiv.2109.09774","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54Z"},{"alias_kind":"pith_short_12","alias_value":"ZD6SBDBVR6NH","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54Z"},{"alias_kind":"pith_short_16","alias_value":"ZD6SBDBVR6NH6X74","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54Z"},{"alias_kind":"pith_short_8","alias_value":"ZD6SBDBV","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54Z"}],"events":[{"event_type":"record_created","subject_pith_number":"pith:2021:ZD6SBDBVR6NH6X74ZJREIBIATD","target":"record","payload":{"canonical_record":{"source":{"id":"2109.09774","kind":"arxiv","version":1},"metadata":{"license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","primary_cat":"cs.DL","submitted_at":"2021-09-20T18:06:22Z","cross_cats_sorted":["cs.LG"],"title_canon_sha256":"3c8dfc0b62e7af8f27af3baa6741697ddc69a0e8858fbd961556d4de71a2f270","abstract_canon_sha256":"068287cf4243dd10a2b4348d1f3fb7b9b823aed8739f723e958f68a0ad098014"},"schema_version":"1.0"},"canonical_sha256":"c8fd208c358f9a7f5ffcca6244050098e7447682f95228aa41ce2b0daa3dfa14","receipt":{"kind":"pith_receipt","key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","algorithm":"ed25519","signed_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54.424078Z","signature_b64":"udGzoyDt837TDl0/P1k0g6Kv1+J/7D5Vy6nQkLeuqxaCwsrq8fVUsHbylazAgqY9tf/rYAmH8K8mFGNlLUzADw==","signed_message":"canonical_sha256_bytes","builder_version":"pith-number-builder-2026-05-17-v1","receipt_version":"0.3","canonical_sha256":"c8fd208c358f9a7f5ffcca6244050098e7447682f95228aa41ce2b0daa3dfa14","last_reissued_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54.423633Z","signature_status":"signed_v1","first_computed_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54.423633Z","public_key_fingerprint":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54"},"source_kind":"arxiv","source_id":"2109.09774","source_version":1,"attestation_state":"computed"},"signer":{"signer_id":"pith.science","signer_type":"pith_registry","key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","public_key_fingerprint":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54"},"created_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54Z","supersedes":[],"prev_event":null,"signature":{"signature_status":"signed_v1","algorithm":"ed25519","key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","public_key_fingerprint":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54","signature_b64":"iN59m2Oo8wzzJt6wEUKqdSB2MIou4nvhS4QFfTMszwXea9y5g1de2epNq1hyqB0POPQrAmtrTmR9x35ZIQMiAA==","signed_message":"open_graph_event_sha256_bytes","signed_at":"2026-08-03T18:50:49.467862Z"},"content_sha256":"0e0ee3f09d63c25c7ba1e84a48e4397ef61488e24914947f599d9cfb468b5e12","schema_version":"1.0","event_id":"sha256:0e0ee3f09d63c25c7ba1e84a48e4397ef61488e24914947f599d9cfb468b5e12"},{"event_type":"graph_snapshot","subject_pith_number":"pith:2021:ZD6SBDBVR6NH6X74ZJREIBIATD","target":"graph","payload":{"graph_snapshot":{"paper":{"title":"Inconsistency in Conference Peer Review: Revisiting the 2014 NeurIPS Experiment","license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","headline":"","cross_cats":["cs.LG"],"primary_cat":"cs.DL","authors_text":"Corinna Cortes, Neil D. Lawrence","submitted_at":"2021-09-20T18:06:22Z","abstract_excerpt":"In this paper we revisit the 2014 NeurIPS experiment that examined inconsistency in conference peer review. We determine that 50\\% of the variation in reviewer quality scores was subjective in origin. Further, with seven years passing since the experiment we find that for \\emph{accepted} papers, there is no correlation between quality scores and impact of the paper as measured as a function of citation count. We trace the fate of rejected papers, recovering where these papers were eventually published. For these papers we find a correlation between quality scores and impact. We conclude that t"},"claims":{"count":0,"items":[],"snapshot_sha256":"258153158e38e3291e3d48162225fcdb2d5a3ed65a07baac614ab91432fd4f57"},"source":{"id":"2109.09774","kind":"arxiv","version":1},"verdict":{"id":null,"model_set":{},"created_at":null,"strongest_claim":"","one_line_summary":"","pipeline_version":null,"weakest_assumption":"","pith_extraction_headline":""},"integrity":{"clean":true,"summary":{"advisory":0,"critical":0,"by_detector":{},"informational":0},"endpoint":"/pith/2109.09774/integrity.json","findings":[],"available":true,"detectors_run":[],"snapshot_sha256":"c28c3603d3b5d939e8dc4c7e95fa8dfce3d595e45f758748cecf8e644a296938"},"references":{"count":0,"sample":[],"resolved_work":0,"snapshot_sha256":"258153158e38e3291e3d48162225fcdb2d5a3ed65a07baac614ab91432fd4f57","internal_anchors":0},"formal_canon":{"evidence_count":0,"snapshot_sha256":"258153158e38e3291e3d48162225fcdb2d5a3ed65a07baac614ab91432fd4f57"},"author_claims":{"count":0,"strong_count":0,"snapshot_sha256":"258153158e38e3291e3d48162225fcdb2d5a3ed65a07baac614ab91432fd4f57"},"builder_version":"pith-number-builder-2026-05-17-v1"},"verdict_id":null},"signer":{"signer_id":"pith.science","signer_type":"pith_registry","key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","public_key_fingerprint":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54"},"created_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54Z","supersedes":[],"prev_event":null,"signature":{"signature_status":"signed_v1","algorithm":"ed25519","key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","public_key_fingerprint":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54","signature_b64":"vQFwcqHrU5K6Of9jcLc2KIszoJPFZVdCrhOtFTWKYT6d6zoRR1f6OzEOuFSQ8oFDOS2fTWMd9cxU+a0fLZ7wBA==","signed_message":"open_graph_event_sha256_bytes","signed_at":"2026-08-03T18:50:49.468536Z"},"content_sha256":"f6161a93c0c1ac5669967701b648c5a2d57be7123bd92af9e5adb116fcae22ff","schema_version":"1.0","event_id":"sha256:f6161a93c0c1ac5669967701b648c5a2d57be7123bd92af9e5adb116fcae22ff"}],"timestamp_proofs":[],"mirror_hints":[{"mirror_type":"https","name":"Pith Resolver","base_url":"https://pith.science","bundle_url":"https://pith.science/pith/ZD6SBDBVR6NH6X74ZJREIBIATD/bundle.json","state_url":"https://pith.science/pith/ZD6SBDBVR6NH6X74ZJREIBIATD/state.json","well_known_bundle_url":"https://pith.science/.well-known/pith/ZD6SBDBVR6NH6X74ZJREIBIATD/bundle.json","status":"primary"}],"public_keys":[{"key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","algorithm":"ed25519","format":"raw","public_key_b64":"stVStoiQhXFxp4s2pdzPNoqVNBMojDU/fJ2db5S3CbM=","public_key_hex":"b2d552b68890857171a78b36a5dccf368a953413288c353f7c9d9d6f94b709b3","fingerprint_sha256_b32_first128bits":"RVFV5Z2OI2J3ZUO7ERDEBCYNKS","fingerprint_sha256_hex":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54","rotates_at":null,"url":"https://pith.science/pith-signing-key.json","notes":"Pith uses this Ed25519 key to sign canonical record SHA-256 digests. Verify with: ed25519_verify(public_key, message=canonical_sha256_bytes, signature=base64decode(signature_b64))."}],"merge_version":"pith-open-graph-merge-v1","built_at":"2026-08-03T18:50:49Z","links":{"resolver":"https://pith.science/pith/ZD6SBDBVR6NH6X74ZJREIBIATD","bundle":"https://pith.science/pith/ZD6SBDBVR6NH6X74ZJREIBIATD/bundle.json","state":"https://pith.science/pith/ZD6SBDBVR6NH6X74ZJREIBIATD/state.json","well_known_bundle":"https://pith.science/.well-known/pith/ZD6SBDBVR6NH6X74ZJREIBIATD/bundle.json"},"state":{"state_type":"pith_open_graph_state","state_version":"1.0","pith_number":"pith:2021:ZD6SBDBVR6NH6X74ZJREIBIATD","merge_version":"pith-open-graph-merge-v1","event_count":2,"valid_event_count":2,"invalid_event_count":0,"equivocation_count":0,"current":{"canonical_record":{"metadata":{"abstract_canon_sha256":"068287cf4243dd10a2b4348d1f3fb7b9b823aed8739f723e958f68a0ad098014","cross_cats_sorted":["cs.LG"],"license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","primary_cat":"cs.DL","submitted_at":"2021-09-20T18:06:22Z","title_canon_sha256":"3c8dfc0b62e7af8f27af3baa6741697ddc69a0e8858fbd961556d4de71a2f270"},"schema_version":"1.0","source":{"id":"2109.09774","kind":"arxiv","version":1}},"source_aliases":[{"alias_kind":"arxiv","alias_value":"2109.09774","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54Z"},{"alias_kind":"arxiv_version","alias_value":"2109.09774v1","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54Z"},{"alias_kind":"doi","alias_value":"10.48550/arxiv.2109.09774","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54Z"},{"alias_kind":"pith_short_12","alias_value":"ZD6SBDBVR6NH","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54Z"},{"alias_kind":"pith_short_16","alias_value":"ZD6SBDBVR6NH6X74","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54Z"},{"alias_kind":"pith_short_8","alias_value":"ZD6SBDBV","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54Z"}],"graph_snapshots":[{"event_id":"sha256:f6161a93c0c1ac5669967701b648c5a2d57be7123bd92af9e5adb116fcae22ff","target":"graph","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54Z","signer":{"key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","public_key_fingerprint":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54","signer_id":"pith.science","signer_type":"pith_registry"},"payload":{"graph_snapshot":{"author_claims":{"count":0,"snapshot_sha256":"258153158e38e3291e3d48162225fcdb2d5a3ed65a07baac614ab91432fd4f57","strong_count":0},"builder_version":"pith-number-builder-2026-05-17-v1","claims":{"count":0,"items":[],"snapshot_sha256":"258153158e38e3291e3d48162225fcdb2d5a3ed65a07baac614ab91432fd4f57"},"formal_canon":{"evidence_count":0,"snapshot_sha256":"258153158e38e3291e3d48162225fcdb2d5a3ed65a07baac614ab91432fd4f57"},"integrity":{"available":true,"clean":true,"detectors_run":[],"endpoint":"/pith/2109.09774/integrity.json","findings":[],"snapshot_sha256":"c28c3603d3b5d939e8dc4c7e95fa8dfce3d595e45f758748cecf8e644a296938","summary":{"advisory":0,"by_detector":{},"critical":0,"informational":0}},"paper":{"abstract_excerpt":"In this paper we revisit the 2014 NeurIPS experiment that examined inconsistency in conference peer review. We determine that 50\\% of the variation in reviewer quality scores was subjective in origin. Further, with seven years passing since the experiment we find that for \\emph{accepted} papers, there is no correlation between quality scores and impact of the paper as measured as a function of citation count. We trace the fate of rejected papers, recovering where these papers were eventually published. For these papers we find a correlation between quality scores and impact. We conclude that t","authors_text":"Corinna Cortes, Neil D. Lawrence","cross_cats":["cs.LG"],"headline":"","license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","primary_cat":"cs.DL","submitted_at":"2021-09-20T18:06:22Z","title":"Inconsistency in Conference Peer Review: Revisiting the 2014 NeurIPS Experiment"},"references":{"count":0,"internal_anchors":0,"resolved_work":0,"sample":[],"snapshot_sha256":"258153158e38e3291e3d48162225fcdb2d5a3ed65a07baac614ab91432fd4f57"},"source":{"id":"2109.09774","kind":"arxiv","version":1},"verdict":{"created_at":null,"id":null,"model_set":{},"one_line_summary":"","pipeline_version":null,"pith_extraction_headline":"","strongest_claim":"","weakest_assumption":""}},"verdict_id":null}}],"author_attestations":[],"timestamp_anchors":[],"storage_attestations":[],"citation_signatures":[],"replication_records":[],"corrections":[],"mirror_hints":[],"record_created":{"event_id":"sha256:0e0ee3f09d63c25c7ba1e84a48e4397ef61488e24914947f599d9cfb468b5e12","target":"record","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54Z","signer":{"key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","public_key_fingerprint":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54","signer_id":"pith.science","signer_type":"pith_registry"},"payload":{"attestation_state":"computed","canonical_record":{"metadata":{"abstract_canon_sha256":"068287cf4243dd10a2b4348d1f3fb7b9b823aed8739f723e958f68a0ad098014","cross_cats_sorted":["cs.LG"],"license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","primary_cat":"cs.DL","submitted_at":"2021-09-20T18:06:22Z","title_canon_sha256":"3c8dfc0b62e7af8f27af3baa6741697ddc69a0e8858fbd961556d4de71a2f270"},"schema_version":"1.0","source":{"id":"2109.09774","kind":"arxiv","version":1}},"canonical_sha256":"c8fd208c358f9a7f5ffcca6244050098e7447682f95228aa41ce2b0daa3dfa14","receipt":{"algorithm":"ed25519","builder_version":"pith-number-builder-2026-05-17-v1","canonical_sha256":"c8fd208c358f9a7f5ffcca6244050098e7447682f95228aa41ce2b0daa3dfa14","first_computed_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54.423633Z","key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","kind":"pith_receipt","last_reissued_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54.423633Z","public_key_fingerprint":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54","receipt_version":"0.3","signature_b64":"udGzoyDt837TDl0/P1k0g6Kv1+J/7D5Vy6nQkLeuqxaCwsrq8fVUsHbylazAgqY9tf/rYAmH8K8mFGNlLUzADw==","signature_status":"signed_v1","signed_at":"2026-07-05T03:15:54.424078Z","signed_message":"canonical_sha256_bytes"},"source_id":"2109.09774","source_kind":"arxiv","source_version":1}}},"equivocations":[],"invalid_events":[],"applied_event_ids":["sha256:0e0ee3f09d63c25c7ba1e84a48e4397ef61488e24914947f599d9cfb468b5e12","sha256:f6161a93c0c1ac5669967701b648c5a2d57be7123bd92af9e5adb116fcae22ff"],"state_sha256":"82ed1a875eb4a3c41700ca92434a4c37a25adaf199a34696d1d3a754b3c21686"},"bundle_signature":{"signature_status":"signed_v1","algorithm":"ed25519","key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","public_key_fingerprint":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54","signature_b64":"4d7fskMP86PV6PsFFF2Ui+Wm1kREFfexo0gfboFXZYyjQVtZTmNycMruL0Z2Sp2w2HAFDLq4LJ6+6Ido2OXQBg==","signed_message":"bundle_sha256_bytes","signed_at":"2026-08-03T18:50:49.508113Z","bundle_sha256":"df407c600e0761e4ad1d7aef9b75081d9f5ffb7c39239dee18fe6f41ef659caa"}}