{"bundle_type":"pith_open_graph_bundle","bundle_version":"1.0","pith_number":"pith:2021:ZGYGHNATNDH6MDU64DGO2A2MMI","short_pith_number":"pith:ZGYGHNAT","canonical_record":{"source":{"id":"2107.14641","kind":"arxiv","version":2},"metadata":{"license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","primary_cat":"cs.DL","submitted_at":"2021-07-30T14:07:34Z","cross_cats_sorted":["cs.CL"],"title_canon_sha256":"3147552845d3cb814fdf496bf5406eec69ce8577b06022062e3da1bbde4e7d23","abstract_canon_sha256":"5726c7b8a239df2e6f4de9518297b61f7b430cf986c70d184f5a3c8ea8f32453"},"schema_version":"1.0"},"canonical_sha256":"c9b063b41368cfe60e9ee0cced034c6214c52bc34cfd00c6d6319eb11db67f0b","source":{"kind":"arxiv","id":"2107.14641","version":2},"source_aliases":[{"alias_kind":"arxiv","alias_value":"2107.14641","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43Z"},{"alias_kind":"arxiv_version","alias_value":"2107.14641v2","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43Z"},{"alias_kind":"doi","alias_value":"10.48550/arxiv.2107.14641","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43Z"},{"alias_kind":"pith_short_12","alias_value":"ZGYGHNATNDH6","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43Z"},{"alias_kind":"pith_short_16","alias_value":"ZGYGHNATNDH6MDU6","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43Z"},{"alias_kind":"pith_short_8","alias_value":"ZGYGHNAT","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43Z"}],"events":[{"event_type":"record_created","subject_pith_number":"pith:2021:ZGYGHNATNDH6MDU64DGO2A2MMI","target":"record","payload":{"canonical_record":{"source":{"id":"2107.14641","kind":"arxiv","version":2},"metadata":{"license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","primary_cat":"cs.DL","submitted_at":"2021-07-30T14:07:34Z","cross_cats_sorted":["cs.CL"],"title_canon_sha256":"3147552845d3cb814fdf496bf5406eec69ce8577b06022062e3da1bbde4e7d23","abstract_canon_sha256":"5726c7b8a239df2e6f4de9518297b61f7b430cf986c70d184f5a3c8ea8f32453"},"schema_version":"1.0"},"canonical_sha256":"c9b063b41368cfe60e9ee0cced034c6214c52bc34cfd00c6d6319eb11db67f0b","receipt":{"kind":"pith_receipt","key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","algorithm":"ed25519","signed_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43.466914Z","signature_b64":"2z5ojVHMgXmVYk+5n0w1kWdPiVyEv0BApSzkeKsIAdFzU0RPuKrlR3FQazTWSR685e82Ai6s0JJlAYTpfI50BA==","signed_message":"canonical_sha256_bytes","builder_version":"pith-number-builder-2026-05-17-v1","receipt_version":"0.3","canonical_sha256":"c9b063b41368cfe60e9ee0cced034c6214c52bc34cfd00c6d6319eb11db67f0b","last_reissued_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43.466381Z","signature_status":"signed_v1","first_computed_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43.466381Z","public_key_fingerprint":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54"},"source_kind":"arxiv","source_id":"2107.14641","source_version":2,"attestation_state":"computed"},"signer":{"signer_id":"pith.science","signer_type":"pith_registry","key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","public_key_fingerprint":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54"},"created_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43Z","supersedes":[],"prev_event":null,"signature":{"signature_status":"signed_v1","algorithm":"ed25519","key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","public_key_fingerprint":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54","signature_b64":"+vbYgXrU0GSgd5KAjF08QVsrI0NkgJcAadIwyGCFcnqPLVbDhrbqhTBv+6fn0pFVFVHIiOJr0r0CVzSPvVgKBg==","signed_message":"open_graph_event_sha256_bytes","signed_at":"2026-08-12T09:52:11.505340Z"},"content_sha256":"58a7169ad25de3b3f8252f90df992e488a803037c43e6f7f54d5cd696c8dd439","schema_version":"1.0","event_id":"sha256:58a7169ad25de3b3f8252f90df992e488a803037c43e6f7f54d5cd696c8dd439"},{"event_type":"graph_snapshot","subject_pith_number":"pith:2021:ZGYGHNATNDH6MDU64DGO2A2MMI","target":"graph","payload":{"graph_snapshot":{"paper":{"title":"Investigating Disagreement in the Scientific Literature","license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","headline":"","cross_cats":["cs.CL"],"primary_cat":"cs.DL","authors_text":"(2) SciTech Strategies, (3) \\'Ecole de biblioth\\'economie et des sciences de l'information, (4) School of Informatics, Albuquerque, Canada, Cassidy R. Sugimoto (4), Computing, Dakota Murray (4) ((1) Centre for Science, Engineering, IN, Inc., Indiana University Bloomington, Kevin Boyack (2), Leiden, Leiden University, Ludo Waltman (1), Nees Jan van Eck (1), Netherlands, NM, Technology Studies, Universit\\'e de Montr\\'eal, USA, USA), Vincent Larivi\\`ere (3), Wout S. Lamers (1)","submitted_at":"2021-07-30T14:07:34Z","abstract_excerpt":"Disagreement is essential to scientific progress. However, the extent of disagreement in science, its evolution over time, and the fields in which it happens, remains poorly understood. Leveraging a massive collection of English-language scientific texts, we develop a cue-phrase based approach to identify instances of disagreement citations across more than four million scientific articles. Using this method, we construct an indicator of disagreement across scientific fields over the 2000-2015 period. In contrast with black-box text classification methods, our framework is transparent and easi"},"claims":{"count":0,"items":[],"snapshot_sha256":"258153158e38e3291e3d48162225fcdb2d5a3ed65a07baac614ab91432fd4f57"},"source":{"id":"2107.14641","kind":"arxiv","version":2},"verdict":{"id":null,"model_set":{},"created_at":null,"strongest_claim":"","one_line_summary":"","pipeline_version":null,"weakest_assumption":"","pith_extraction_headline":""},"integrity":{"clean":true,"summary":{"advisory":0,"critical":0,"by_detector":{},"informational":0},"endpoint":"/pith/2107.14641/integrity.json","findings":[],"available":true,"detectors_run":[],"snapshot_sha256":"c28c3603d3b5d939e8dc4c7e95fa8dfce3d595e45f758748cecf8e644a296938"},"references":{"count":0,"sample":[],"resolved_work":0,"snapshot_sha256":"258153158e38e3291e3d48162225fcdb2d5a3ed65a07baac614ab91432fd4f57","internal_anchors":0},"formal_canon":{"evidence_count":0,"snapshot_sha256":"258153158e38e3291e3d48162225fcdb2d5a3ed65a07baac614ab91432fd4f57"},"author_claims":{"count":0,"strong_count":0,"snapshot_sha256":"258153158e38e3291e3d48162225fcdb2d5a3ed65a07baac614ab91432fd4f57"},"builder_version":"pith-number-builder-2026-05-17-v1"},"verdict_id":null},"signer":{"signer_id":"pith.science","signer_type":"pith_registry","key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","public_key_fingerprint":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54"},"created_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43Z","supersedes":[],"prev_event":null,"signature":{"signature_status":"signed_v1","algorithm":"ed25519","key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","public_key_fingerprint":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54","signature_b64":"kPn34RlSD5+o86bWqO3uIrPBc20+Q009uOAP3gIbZEgkmwDEhzw9OMUcS0a4sXHvMMsBECmZvWee08umeU3YAg==","signed_message":"open_graph_event_sha256_bytes","signed_at":"2026-08-12T09:52:11.505894Z"},"content_sha256":"b33722e2c8f0998bd61534b0c20ef6d196c3b9c982b8be5e2205d1f4e75c22be","schema_version":"1.0","event_id":"sha256:b33722e2c8f0998bd61534b0c20ef6d196c3b9c982b8be5e2205d1f4e75c22be"}],"timestamp_proofs":[],"mirror_hints":[{"mirror_type":"https","name":"Pith Resolver","base_url":"https://pith.science","bundle_url":"https://pith.science/pith/ZGYGHNATNDH6MDU64DGO2A2MMI/bundle.json","state_url":"https://pith.science/pith/ZGYGHNATNDH6MDU64DGO2A2MMI/state.json","well_known_bundle_url":"https://pith.science/.well-known/pith/ZGYGHNATNDH6MDU64DGO2A2MMI/bundle.json","status":"primary"}],"public_keys":[{"key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","algorithm":"ed25519","format":"raw","public_key_b64":"stVStoiQhXFxp4s2pdzPNoqVNBMojDU/fJ2db5S3CbM=","public_key_hex":"b2d552b68890857171a78b36a5dccf368a953413288c353f7c9d9d6f94b709b3","fingerprint_sha256_b32_first128bits":"RVFV5Z2OI2J3ZUO7ERDEBCYNKS","fingerprint_sha256_hex":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54","rotates_at":null,"url":"https://pith.science/pith-signing-key.json","notes":"Pith uses this Ed25519 key to sign canonical record SHA-256 digests. Verify with: ed25519_verify(public_key, message=canonical_sha256_bytes, signature=base64decode(signature_b64))."}],"merge_version":"pith-open-graph-merge-v1","built_at":"2026-08-12T09:52:11Z","links":{"resolver":"https://pith.science/pith/ZGYGHNATNDH6MDU64DGO2A2MMI","bundle":"https://pith.science/pith/ZGYGHNATNDH6MDU64DGO2A2MMI/bundle.json","state":"https://pith.science/pith/ZGYGHNATNDH6MDU64DGO2A2MMI/state.json","well_known_bundle":"https://pith.science/.well-known/pith/ZGYGHNATNDH6MDU64DGO2A2MMI/bundle.json"},"state":{"state_type":"pith_open_graph_state","state_version":"1.0","pith_number":"pith:2021:ZGYGHNATNDH6MDU64DGO2A2MMI","merge_version":"pith-open-graph-merge-v1","event_count":2,"valid_event_count":2,"invalid_event_count":0,"equivocation_count":0,"current":{"canonical_record":{"metadata":{"abstract_canon_sha256":"5726c7b8a239df2e6f4de9518297b61f7b430cf986c70d184f5a3c8ea8f32453","cross_cats_sorted":["cs.CL"],"license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","primary_cat":"cs.DL","submitted_at":"2021-07-30T14:07:34Z","title_canon_sha256":"3147552845d3cb814fdf496bf5406eec69ce8577b06022062e3da1bbde4e7d23"},"schema_version":"1.0","source":{"id":"2107.14641","kind":"arxiv","version":2}},"source_aliases":[{"alias_kind":"arxiv","alias_value":"2107.14641","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43Z"},{"alias_kind":"arxiv_version","alias_value":"2107.14641v2","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43Z"},{"alias_kind":"doi","alias_value":"10.48550/arxiv.2107.14641","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43Z"},{"alias_kind":"pith_short_12","alias_value":"ZGYGHNATNDH6","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43Z"},{"alias_kind":"pith_short_16","alias_value":"ZGYGHNATNDH6MDU6","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43Z"},{"alias_kind":"pith_short_8","alias_value":"ZGYGHNAT","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43Z"}],"graph_snapshots":[{"event_id":"sha256:b33722e2c8f0998bd61534b0c20ef6d196c3b9c982b8be5e2205d1f4e75c22be","target":"graph","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43Z","signer":{"key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","public_key_fingerprint":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54","signer_id":"pith.science","signer_type":"pith_registry"},"payload":{"graph_snapshot":{"author_claims":{"count":0,"snapshot_sha256":"258153158e38e3291e3d48162225fcdb2d5a3ed65a07baac614ab91432fd4f57","strong_count":0},"builder_version":"pith-number-builder-2026-05-17-v1","claims":{"count":0,"items":[],"snapshot_sha256":"258153158e38e3291e3d48162225fcdb2d5a3ed65a07baac614ab91432fd4f57"},"formal_canon":{"evidence_count":0,"snapshot_sha256":"258153158e38e3291e3d48162225fcdb2d5a3ed65a07baac614ab91432fd4f57"},"integrity":{"available":true,"clean":true,"detectors_run":[],"endpoint":"/pith/2107.14641/integrity.json","findings":[],"snapshot_sha256":"c28c3603d3b5d939e8dc4c7e95fa8dfce3d595e45f758748cecf8e644a296938","summary":{"advisory":0,"by_detector":{},"critical":0,"informational":0}},"paper":{"abstract_excerpt":"Disagreement is essential to scientific progress. However, the extent of disagreement in science, its evolution over time, and the fields in which it happens, remains poorly understood. Leveraging a massive collection of English-language scientific texts, we develop a cue-phrase based approach to identify instances of disagreement citations across more than four million scientific articles. Using this method, we construct an indicator of disagreement across scientific fields over the 2000-2015 period. In contrast with black-box text classification methods, our framework is transparent and easi","authors_text":"(2) SciTech Strategies, (3) \\'Ecole de biblioth\\'economie et des sciences de l'information, (4) School of Informatics, Albuquerque, Canada, Cassidy R. Sugimoto (4), Computing, Dakota Murray (4) ((1) Centre for Science, Engineering, IN, Inc., Indiana University Bloomington, Kevin Boyack (2), Leiden, Leiden University, Ludo Waltman (1), Nees Jan van Eck (1), Netherlands, NM, Technology Studies, Universit\\'e de Montr\\'eal, USA, USA), Vincent Larivi\\`ere (3), Wout S. Lamers (1)","cross_cats":["cs.CL"],"headline":"","license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","primary_cat":"cs.DL","submitted_at":"2021-07-30T14:07:34Z","title":"Investigating Disagreement in the Scientific Literature"},"references":{"count":0,"internal_anchors":0,"resolved_work":0,"sample":[],"snapshot_sha256":"258153158e38e3291e3d48162225fcdb2d5a3ed65a07baac614ab91432fd4f57"},"source":{"id":"2107.14641","kind":"arxiv","version":2},"verdict":{"created_at":null,"id":null,"model_set":{},"one_line_summary":"","pipeline_version":null,"pith_extraction_headline":"","strongest_claim":"","weakest_assumption":""}},"verdict_id":null}}],"author_attestations":[],"timestamp_anchors":[],"storage_attestations":[],"citation_signatures":[],"replication_records":[],"corrections":[],"mirror_hints":[],"record_created":{"event_id":"sha256:58a7169ad25de3b3f8252f90df992e488a803037c43e6f7f54d5cd696c8dd439","target":"record","created_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43Z","signer":{"key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","public_key_fingerprint":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54","signer_id":"pith.science","signer_type":"pith_registry"},"payload":{"attestation_state":"computed","canonical_record":{"metadata":{"abstract_canon_sha256":"5726c7b8a239df2e6f4de9518297b61f7b430cf986c70d184f5a3c8ea8f32453","cross_cats_sorted":["cs.CL"],"license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","primary_cat":"cs.DL","submitted_at":"2021-07-30T14:07:34Z","title_canon_sha256":"3147552845d3cb814fdf496bf5406eec69ce8577b06022062e3da1bbde4e7d23"},"schema_version":"1.0","source":{"id":"2107.14641","kind":"arxiv","version":2}},"canonical_sha256":"c9b063b41368cfe60e9ee0cced034c6214c52bc34cfd00c6d6319eb11db67f0b","receipt":{"algorithm":"ed25519","builder_version":"pith-number-builder-2026-05-17-v1","canonical_sha256":"c9b063b41368cfe60e9ee0cced034c6214c52bc34cfd00c6d6319eb11db67f0b","first_computed_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43.466381Z","key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","kind":"pith_receipt","last_reissued_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43.466381Z","public_key_fingerprint":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54","receipt_version":"0.3","signature_b64":"2z5ojVHMgXmVYk+5n0w1kWdPiVyEv0BApSzkeKsIAdFzU0RPuKrlR3FQazTWSR685e82Ai6s0JJlAYTpfI50BA==","signature_status":"signed_v1","signed_at":"2026-07-05T03:26:43.466914Z","signed_message":"canonical_sha256_bytes"},"source_id":"2107.14641","source_kind":"arxiv","source_version":2}}},"equivocations":[],"invalid_events":[],"applied_event_ids":["sha256:58a7169ad25de3b3f8252f90df992e488a803037c43e6f7f54d5cd696c8dd439","sha256:b33722e2c8f0998bd61534b0c20ef6d196c3b9c982b8be5e2205d1f4e75c22be"],"state_sha256":"a219129859123f119e10b56ce18ce4c37308b3c4bcb30e5296e9fea1601f1658"},"bundle_signature":{"signature_status":"signed_v1","algorithm":"ed25519","key_id":"pith-v1-2026-05","public_key_fingerprint":"8d4b5ee74e4693bcd1df2446408b0d54","signature_b64":"Jxs6l1gl9PKIMOgEFsRiaxAEWZRx+XLRSR2bBzBHQVgPb2A0/BxuJELBCU/M1QBlhnAi/n4BFsan1pTwpC84Cw==","signed_message":"bundle_sha256_bytes","signed_at":"2026-08-12T09:52:11.511272Z","bundle_sha256":"f3d3d3acdd91fb4251dc00988c317b8e827c4dc98feee54ea09ff87fbf9b1d8e"}}