Pith. sign in
def

witness_p

definition
show as:
module
IndisputableMonolith.Verification.DimensionLinking
domain
Verification
line
73 · github
papers citing
none yet

plain-language theorem explainer

For spatial dimension D, the same-sector linking witness is the integer p = (D-1)/2. Anyone proving the converse half of the allowed-dimension set A_A = {3,5,7,...} cites this formula: it supplies the complementary sphere dimension so that two standard p-spheres in R^{2p+1} have linking number ±1. The body is a one-line arithmetic definition.

Claim. Given a natural number $D$, define the witness defect dimension by $p(D) := \lfloor (D-1)/2 \rfloor$. For odd $D \ge 3$ this is exactly $p = (D-1)/2$, so that $D = 2p+1$.

background

The module formalizes two paper claims on linking nontriviality. U5 is the Alexander-duality selector: loop-loop linking ($p=1$) forces $D=3$ via $H_1(S^D \setminus K) \cong \mathbb{Z}$. U10 is the converse direction of Proposition 3.5: every odd $D \ge 3$ should support nontrivial same-sector linking, not merely by parity but by an explicit geometric witness.

In $\mathbb{R}^{2p+1}$, two standard $p$-spheres placed in complementary position have linking number $\pm 1$. The integer $p$ is therefore the defect (sphere) dimension dual to ambient $D$. Upstream constants pin the physical spatial dimension at $D=3$ (T8/T9), which recovers the classical loop-loop case $p=1$; the same arithmetic is kept parametric so the full odd ray can be certified.

proof idea

Pure definition: the body is the natural-number expression $(D-1)/2$ (integer division). No lemmas, tactics, or hypotheses. Downstream facts such as $p \ge 1$ when $D \ge 3$, and the reconstruction $D = 2p+1$ for odd $D$, are proved separately by unfolding and omega/decide.

why it matters

This is the explicit witness construction demanded by U10 / paper Proposition 3.5. The characterization theorem for the allowed set $A_A$ uses it on the converse arm: every odd $D \ge 3$ admits $p = (D-1)/2 \ge 1$ with $D = 2p+1$. Concrete evaluations (witness_D3 through witness_D9) and the inequality $p \ge 1$ are immediate corollaries. In the forcing chain this sits under T8 ($D=3$ spatial) and the same-sector parity filter: loop-loop specialization $p=1$ recovers $D=3$, while the general odd ray remains available for the topological audit of nontrivial linking.

Switch to Lean above to see the machine-checked source, dependencies, and usage graph.