Pith. sign in

Constructive Axiomatics in Spacetime Physics Part I: Walkthrough to the Ehlers-Pirani-Schild Axiomatisation

1 Pith paper cite this work. Polarity classification is still indexing.

1 Pith paper citing it
abstract

The Ehlers-Pirani-Schild (EPS) constructive axiomatisation of general relativity, published in 1972, purports to build up the kinematical structure of that theory from only axioms which have indubitable empirical content. It is, therefore, of profound significance both to the epistemology and to the metaphysics of spacetime theories. This axiomatisation is, however, self-consciously terse, rendering it difficult to ascertain whether it succeeds. In this article, we provide a pedagogical walkthrough to the EPS axiomatisation, filling relevant conceptual and mathematical gaps and rendering explicit controversial assumptions. There are two companion papers, in which we discuss the significance of constructive approaches to spacetime structure more generally (Part II), and (with Emily Adlam) consider extensions of the EPS axiomatisation towards quantum general relativity based upon quantum mechanical inputs (Part III).

citation-role summary

background 1

citation-polarity summary

fields

gr-qc 1

years

2025 1

verdicts

REJECT 1

roles

background 1

polarities

unclear 1

representative citing papers

Curved spacetimes from quantum mechanics

gr-qc · 2025-02-11 · reject · novelty 6.0

The paper constructs, for any local C^2 Lorentzian metric, six Poincaré-invariant quantum systems whose empirical distance observable reproduces the local geodesic lengths and thus the curvature, but only because the curvature is built into the chosen states.

citing papers explorer

Showing 1 of 1 citing paper.

  • Curved spacetimes from quantum mechanics gr-qc · 2025-02-11 · reject · none · ref 12 · internal anchor

    The paper constructs, for any local C^2 Lorentzian metric, six Poincaré-invariant quantum systems whose empirical distance observable reproduces the local geodesic lengths and thus the curvature, but only because the curvature is built into the chosen states.