Pith. sign in

The vicissitudes of "cannonballs": a response to criticisms by A.M. Hillas and a brief review of our claims

1 Pith paper cite this work. Polarity classification is still indexing.

1 Pith paper citing it
abstract

A.M. Hillas, in a review of the origins of cosmic rays, has recently criticized the "cannonball" (CB) model of cosmic rays and gamma-ray bursts. We respond to this critique and take the occasion to discuss the crucial question of particle acceleration in the CB model and in the generally accepted models. We also summarize our claims concerning the CB model.

fields

hep-ph 1

years

2024 1

verdicts

REJECT 1

representative citing papers

A revamped understanding of Cosmic Rays and Gamma-Ray Bursts

hep-ph · 2024-11-24 · reject · novelty 4.0

The paper claims new GRB and cosmic-ray data validate the Cannonball Model, with knees and positrons explained by relativistic supernova ejecta, though several 'predictions' rely on fitted parameters.

citing papers explorer

Showing 1 of 1 citing paper.

  • A revamped understanding of Cosmic Rays and Gamma-Ray Bursts hep-ph · 2024-11-24 · reject · none · ref 20 · internal anchor

    The paper claims new GRB and cosmic-ray data validate the Cannonball Model, with knees and positrons explained by relativistic supernova ejecta, though several 'predictions' rely on fitted parameters.