Steady-state spin order and superradiance beyond the Dicke limit

Spontaneous collective decay in incoherently driven atomic ensembles can generate macroscopic coherence in the steady state, as exemplified by steady-state superradiance in single-mode cavities. Whether spontaneous order persists beyond the Dicke limit, where competing collective decay channels and light propagation might preclude an ordered phase, remains an open question. We address it by analyzing incoherently pumped atoms coupled to one-dimensional electromagnetic baths through two models: a ring cavity with two bright decay channels, and a bidirectional waveguide where propagation additionally induces Hamiltonian dipole-dipole interactions. We find that both systems sustain steady-state phase order with intensity scaling as $N^2$, but that the order takes two qualitatively distinct forms, neither described by a single macroscopic dipole. In the ring cavity, individual trajectories spontaneously break mirror symmetry, locking the atomic phases and the emitted field to one of two chiral orders. In the waveguide, coherent interactions instead enforce a phase-separated steady state in which the two chiral orders coexist, each dominating one end of the array. Our results show how competition and propagation shape emergent order beyond the Dicke limit.