Argues that Bell's 'infamous boundary' may sit at the scale of macromolecules, where the choice of thermal ensemble and Hund's paradox decide whether cooled asymmetric molecules appear as mixtures or superpositions.
On Schr\"odingerist Quantum Thermodynamics
1 Pith paper cite this work. Polarity classification is still indexing.
abstract
From the point of view of Schr\"odingerism, a wavefunction-only philosophy, thermodynamics must be recast in terms of an ensemble of wavefunctions, rather than classical particle configurations or "found" values of Copenaghen Quantum Mechanics. Recapitulating the historical sequence, we consider here several models of magnets that classically can exhibit a phase transition to a low-temperature magnetized state. We formulate wavefunction analogues including a "Schr\"odingerist QUantum Ising Model" (SQUIM), a "Schr\"odingerist Curie-Weiss Model"(SCWM), and others. We show that the SQUIM with free boundary conditions and distinguishable "spins" has no finite-temperature phase transition, which we attribute to entropy swamping energy. The SCWM likewise, even assuming exchange symmetry in the wavefunction (in this case the analytical argument is not totally satisfactory and we helped ourself with a computer analysis). But a variant model with "Wavefunction Energy" (introduced in prior communications about Schr\"odingerism and the Measurement Problem) does have a phase transition to a magnetised state. The three results together suggest that magnetization in large wavefunction spin chains appears if and only if we consider indistinguishable particles and block macroscopic dispersion (i.e. macroscopic superpositions) by energy conservation. Our principle technique involves transforming the problem to one in probability theory, then applying results from Large Deviations, particularly the G\"artner-Ellis Theorem. Finally, we discuss Gibbs vs. Boltzmann/Einstein entropy in the choice of the quantum thermodynamic ensemble, as well as open problems. PhySH: quantum theory, quantum statistical mechanics, large deviation & rare event statistics. https://github.com/leodecarlo/Computing-Large-Deviation-Functionals-of-not-identically-distributed-independent-random-variables
citation-role summary
citation-polarity summary
fields
quant-ph 1years
2025 1verdicts
REJECT 1roles
background 1polarities
unclear 1representative citing papers
citing papers explorer
-
Can the Infamous Boundary Be Found in Macromolecules? Also, von Neumann vs. Schroedinger ensembles, and `Hund's Paradox' in quantum chemistry
Argues that Bell's 'infamous boundary' may sit at the scale of macromolecules, where the choice of thermal ensemble and Hund's paradox decide whether cooled asymmetric molecules appear as mixtures or superpositions.