Citation notice #7741 · 2026-07-12 06:30:07.876564+00:00

A new model of quasar mass evolution

Retraction Retraction Watch Open

cites Effect of the seed black hole mass, which carries a retraction notice . One-hop deterministic notice: the citation edge exists in the Pith bibliography graph; no model judged whether the citation was load-bearing.

This is not a judgment on the citing paper.

Citing paper Event page Original DOI Notice DOI File a formal challenge All reference changes

01Evidence

Raw extraction · bibliography line · bibliography index 17

Withdrawn as Duplicate: Theoretical reevaluations of the black hole mass - bulge mass relation - I. Effect of the seed black hole mass. MNRAS , year = 2019, month = mar, volume = 484, pages =. doi:10.1093/mnrasl/slw125 , adsurl =

Parser render (TeX stripped for reading; raw above is the evidence)

Withdrawn as Duplicate: Theoretical reevaluations of the black hole mass - bulge mass relation - I. Effect of the seed black hole mass. MNRAS, year = 2019, month = mar, volume = 484, pages =. doi:10.1093/mnrasl/slw125, adsurl =

02Event

Type: Retraction
Source: Retraction Watch
Original DOI: 10.1093/mnrasl/slw125
Notice DOI: 10.1093/mnrasl/slw125
Date: —
Title: Theoretical reevaluations of the black hole mass - bulge mass relation - 1. Effect of the seed black hole mass
Reasons: ['Duplication of Content through Error by Journal/Publisher']
Work: Effect of the seed black hole mass (2019)

Schema constants (for re-runners): retraction · retraction_watch

03Dispute this notice

If this citation does not depend on the flagged claim, or the event is wrong, say so. Disputes are public. For a signed challenge against the paper itself, use the formal challenge form.