Frustrated classical Heisenberg and XY models in 2 dimensions with nearest neighbor exchange: exact solution for the ground state phase diagram

The ground state phase diagram is determined exactly for the frustrated classical Heisenberg model plus nearest-neighbor biquadratic exchange interactions on a 2-dimensional lattice. A square- and a rhombic-symmetry version are considered. There appear ferromagnetic, incommensurate-spiral, "up-up-down-down" (uudd) and canted ferromagnetic states, a non-spiral coplanar state that is an ordered vortex lattice, plus a non-coplanar ordered state (a "conical vortex lattice"). In the rhombic case, which adds biquadratic terms to the Heisenberg model used widely for insulating manganites, the uudd state found is the E-type state observed; this along with accounting essentially for the variety of ground states found in these materials, shows that this model probably contains the long-sought mechanism behind the uudd state.