On the large-scale vertical velocity intermittency of turbulent wall flows
Pith reviewed 2026-06-26 13:30 UTC · model grok-4.3
The pith
A dominant balance between inertial and pressure forces predicts the flatness factor of large-scale vertical velocity intermittency from second-order statistics alone.
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
Core claim
In neutrally stratified wall-bounded turbulent flow at very high Reynolds numbers, a dominant balance between inertial and pressure forces permits prediction of the flatness factor FF_w, which measures large-scale vertical velocity intermittency, directly from second-order statistics while explicitly accommodating large-scale energy anisotropy. This leads to FF_w collapsing onto a universal trend in the inertial sublayer across laboratory and field configurations with varied surface roughness.
What carries the argument
The dominant balance between inertial and pressure forces in the Navier-Stokes equations under high-Re wall-flow conditions, which reduces the flatness factor FF_w to an expression involving only second-order velocity moments.
If this is right
- FF_w collapses to a universal trend for all flow configurations within the inertial sublayer.
- FF_w reaches a common minimum value above the inertial sublayer.
- The prediction holds across laboratory to field Reynolds numbers and varied surface roughness conditions.
- Down-gradient closure approximations used in meteorological and climate models cannot describe FF_w.
Where Pith is reading between the lines
- The result implies that large-scale vertical velocity intermittency is controlled by a local force balance rather than by the detailed geometry of coherent structures.
- Replacing gradient-diffusion closures with this balance in large-scale models could improve predictions of vertical transport without requiring higher-order moment equations.
- The same inertial-pressure framework may extend to mildly stratified cases, offering a route to test how buoyancy alters the universal FF_w trend.
Load-bearing premise
The derivation assumes a dominant balance between inertial and pressure forces holds in neutrally stratified wall-bounded turbulent flow at very high Reynolds numbers.
What would settle it
A data set at sufficiently high Reynolds number in which the measured flatness factor FF_w in the inertial sublayer deviates from the value computed from the observed second-order moments would falsify the theory.
Figures
read the original abstract
Large-scale intermittency in the vertical velocity (LSI) has received significant attention in studies of coherent structures and their detection using data-driven approaches. However, a theory that predicts the origin of LSI from the Navier-Stokes equations or some approximated version of them at very high Reynolds numbers is yet to be achieved. This letter proposes such a theory for a neutrally stratified wall-bounded turbulent flow based on a dominant balance between inertial and pressure forces. Using multiple flume and wind tunnel experiments, it is shown that the flatness factor ($FF_w$) measuring LSI collapses to a universal trend for all flow configurations within the inertial sublayer (ISL) before reaching a common minimum value above the ISL. A theory that predicts $FF_w$ using second-order statistics and explicitly accommodates large-scale energy anisotropy is tested against a wide range of Reynolds numbers from laboratory to field settings with varied surface roughness conditions. The theory also demonstrates why $FF_w$ cannot be described using down-gradient closure approximations routinely employed in large-scale meteorological and climate models.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The manuscript proposes a theory for large-scale intermittency in the vertical velocity (LSI) of neutrally stratified wall-bounded turbulent flows at high Reynolds number. The central claim is that a dominant balance between inertial and pressure forces in the vertical momentum equation allows prediction of the flatness factor FF_w (a measure of LSI) directly from second-order statistics while retaining large-scale energy anisotropy. Experiments across flume, wind-tunnel, and field settings are reported to show that FF_w collapses to a universal trend inside the inertial sublayer (ISL) before reaching a common minimum above it; the theory is also used to explain why down-gradient closures cannot capture FF_w.
Significance. If the derivation and supporting evidence hold, the work would supply a first-principles route from the Navier-Stokes equations to a measurable intermittency statistic, with immediate implications for subgrid modeling in meteorological and climate simulations. The explicit retention of anisotropy and the reported collapse across Reynolds numbers and roughness conditions constitute genuine strengths. The manuscript tests the prediction over a wide parameter range, which is a positive feature.
major comments (2)
- [theory derivation / abstract] The derivation (abstract and theory section) rests on the assertion that inertial-pressure balance dominates the vertical momentum equation inside the ISL at high Re. No term-by-term budget is presented from the hot-wire, PIV, or pressure-probe data to demonstrate that viscous and buoyancy contributions remain negligible at the scales that determine FF_w. This verification is load-bearing for the claimed closure from second-order moments.
- [theory section] The mapping from second-order statistics to FF_w is presented as a prediction, yet the manuscript does not show an explicit equation or step-by-step reduction that would allow an independent reader to confirm the relation is not a fitted mapping between moments. Without this, the degree of circularity cannot be assessed.
Simulated Author's Rebuttal
We thank the referee for the constructive report and positive assessment of the work's significance. We address each major comment below and indicate planned revisions.
read point-by-point responses
-
Referee: [theory derivation / abstract] The derivation (abstract and theory section) rests on the assertion that inertial-pressure balance dominates the vertical momentum equation inside the ISL at high Re. No term-by-term budget is presented from the hot-wire, PIV, or pressure-probe data to demonstrate that viscous and buoyancy contributions remain negligible at the scales that determine FF_w. This verification is load-bearing for the claimed closure from second-order moments.
Authors: We agree that direct term-by-term budgets from the present datasets would strengthen the argument. The inertial sublayer is defined precisely as the region where viscous contributions become negligible relative to inertial and pressure terms at high Re; the experiments are all neutrally stratified, so buoyancy is identically zero. The large scales that set FF_w lie well within this regime according to established wall-turbulence scaling. In the revised manuscript we will add a concise paragraph in the theory section that recalls these standard arguments and cites prior experimental and DNS budget studies confirming inertial-pressure dominance at the relevant scales and Reynolds numbers. revision: partial
-
Referee: [theory section] The mapping from second-order statistics to FF_w is presented as a prediction, yet the manuscript does not show an explicit equation or step-by-step reduction that would allow an independent reader to confirm the relation is not a fitted mapping between moments. Without this, the degree of circularity cannot be assessed.
Authors: We accept that the derivation must be fully explicit. The relation follows directly from substituting the inertial-pressure balance into the vertical momentum equation, taking the fourth moment, and normalizing to obtain FF_w while retaining the measured large-scale anisotropy; no empirical fitting is involved. The revised version will insert the complete algebraic steps from the approximated Navier-Stokes equation through to the final expression for FF_w, allowing readers to verify the mapping independently. revision: yes
Circularity Check
No circularity: derivation rests on external NS balance assumption with independent experimental test
full rationale
The abstract and description state that a dominant inertial-pressure balance from the Navier-Stokes equations is used to derive a prediction for FF_w from second-order statistics while retaining anisotropy. No equations, self-citations, fitted parameters renamed as predictions, or ansatzes are supplied in the provided text that would allow the output to reduce to the inputs by construction. The experimental collapse across Re and roughness is presented as an external test rather than the source of the relation. The load-bearing assumption (balance validity in the ISL) is falsifiable by term-by-term budgets outside the present derivation and is not shown to be smuggled in via prior self-work. This is the normal case of a self-contained first-principles claim.
Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger
axioms (1)
- domain assumption Dominant balance between inertial and pressure forces holds in neutrally stratified wall-bounded turbulent flow at very high Reynolds numbers.
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
Boundary-Layer Meteorology , volume=
Third-order moment closure through a mass-flux approach , author=. Boundary-Layer Meteorology , volume=. 2000 , publisher=
2000
-
[2]
S. Alberghi and A. Maurizi and F. Tampieri. Relationship between the Vertical Velocity Skewness and Kurtosis Observed during Sea-Breeze Convection. Journal of Applied Meteorology. 2002. doi:10.1175/1520-0450(2002)041<0885:RBTVVS>2.0.CO;2
-
[3]
Turbulence approximation for inhomogeneous flows: Part
Andr. Turbulence approximation for inhomogeneous flows: Part. Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences , volume=
-
[4]
Physiscs of Fluids , volume=
Logarithmic scaling in the longitudinal velocity variance explained by a spectral budget , author=. Physiscs of Fluids , volume=. 2013 , publisher=
2013
-
[5]
Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres , volume=
A single compartment relaxed eddy accumulation method , author=. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres , volume=. 2024 , publisher=
2024
-
[6]
Atmospheric Environment (1967) , volume=
B. Atmospheric Environment (1967) , volume=. 1984 , publisher=
1967
-
[7]
Boundary-Layer Meteorology , volume=
Relationships between second and third moments in the surface layer under different stratification over grassland and urban landscapes , author=. Boundary-Layer Meteorology , volume=. 2023 , publisher=
2023
-
[8]
Journal of Geophysical Research , volume=
The vertical distribution of wind and turbulent exchange in a neutral atmosphere , author=. Journal of Geophysical Research , volume=. 1962 , publisher=
1962
-
[9]
Geoscientific Model Development , volume=
Unified parameterization of the planetary boundary layer and shallow convection with a higher-order turbulence closure in the Community Atmosphere Model: Single-column experiments , author=. Geoscientific Model Development , volume=. 2012 , publisher=
2012
-
[10]
Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=
On the role of return to isotropy in wall-bounded turbulent flows with buoyancy , author=. Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=. 2018 , publisher=
2018
-
[11]
Proceedings of the Royal Society of London
The nature of turbulent motion at large wave-numbers , author=. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A. Mathematical and Physical Sciences , volume=. 1949 , publisher=
1949
-
[12]
Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=
The vertical-velocity skewness in the inertial sublayer of turbulent wall flows , author=. Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=. 2024 , publisher=
2024
-
[13]
Physics of Fluids , volume=
The vertical-velocity skewness in the atmospheric boundary layer without buoyancy and Coriolis effects , author=. Physics of Fluids , volume=. 2024 , publisher=
2024
-
[14]
Physical Review Fluids , volume=
Level crossings reveal organized coherent structures in a turbulent time series , author=. Physical Review Fluids , volume=. 2024 , publisher=
2024
-
[15]
Physical Review Fluids , volume=
Revisiting “bursts” in wall-bounded turbulent flows , author=. Physical Review Fluids , volume=. 2023 , publisher=
2023
-
[16]
Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=
Visibility network analysis of large-scale intermittency in convective surface layer turbulence , author=. Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=. 2021 , publisher=
2021
-
[17]
Second-order closure
Canuto, VM and Minotti, F and Ronchi, C and Ypma, RM and Zeman, O , journal=. Second-order closure. 1994 , publisher=
1994
-
[18]
Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres , volume=
The role of surface characteristics on intermittency and zero-crossing properties of atmospheric turbulence , author=. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres , volume=. 2012 , publisher=
2012
-
[19]
Boundary-Layer Meteorology , volume=
Buoyancy and the sensible heat flux budget within dense canopies , author=. Boundary-Layer Meteorology , volume=. 2006 , publisher=
2006
-
[20]
Journal of the Meteorological Society of Japan
Stability dependence of the vertical wind velocity skewness in the atmospheric surface layer , author=. Journal of the Meteorological Society of Japan. Ser. II , volume=. 1978 , publisher=
1978
-
[21]
Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=
The return to isotropy of homogeneous turbulence , author=. Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=. 2001 , publisher=
2001
-
[22]
A nonlinear return-to-isotropy model with
Chung, MK and Kim, SK , journal=. A nonlinear return-to-isotropy model with. 1995 , publisher=
1995
-
[23]
Advances in Geophysics , volume=
Limitations of gradient transport models in random walks and in turbulence , author=. Advances in Geophysics , volume=. 1975 , publisher=
1975
-
[24]
Davidson , Date-Added =
P.A. Davidson , Date-Added =. Turbulence: An Introduction for Scientists and Engineers , Year =
-
[25]
The Physics of Fluids , volume=
Closure of second-and third-moment rate equations for diffusion in homogeneous turbulence , author=. The Physics of Fluids , volume=. 1978 , publisher=
1978
-
[26]
Journal of Geophysical Research , volume=
Theoretical expression for the countergradient vertical heat flux , author=. Journal of Geophysical Research , volume=. 1972 , publisher=
1972
-
[27]
Statistical Models and Turbulence , pages=
Some observed properties of atmospheric turbulence , author=. Statistical Models and Turbulence , pages=. 1972 , publisher=
1972
-
[28]
Vertical drafts and mixing in stratified turbulence: Sharp transition with
Feraco, Fabio and Marino, Raffaele and Pumir, Alain and Primavera, Leonardo and Mininni, Pablo Daniel and Pouquet, Annick and Rosenberg, Duane , journal=. Vertical drafts and mixing in stratified turbulence: Sharp transition with. 2018 , publisher=
2018
-
[29]
Progress in Aerospace Sciences , volume=
The incompressible zero-pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layer: an assessment of the data , author=. Progress in Aerospace Sciences , volume=. 1996 , publisher=
1996
-
[30]
Linking meteorology, turbulence, and air chemistry in the
Fuentes, Jose D and Chamecki, Marcelo and Dos Santos, Rosa Maria Nascimento and Von Randow, Celso and Stoy, Paul C and Katul, Gabriel and Fitzjarrald, David and Manzi, Antonio and Gerken, Tobias and Trowbridge, Amy and others , journal=. Linking meteorology, turbulence, and air chemistry in the. 2016 , publisher=
2016
-
[31]
Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=
A simple dynamical model of intermittent fully developed turbulence , author=. Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=. 1978 , publisher=
1978
-
[32]
Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society , volume=
The non-local character of turbulence asymmetry in the convective atmospheric boundary layer , author=. Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society , volume=. 2017 , publisher=
2017
-
[33]
The Physics of Fluids , volume=
Breakdown of eddies and probability distributions for small-scale turbulence , author=. The Physics of Fluids , volume=. 1967 , publisher=
1967
-
[34]
Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics , volume=
One-point closure models for buoyancy-driven turbulent flows , author=. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics , volume=. 2002 , pages =
2002
-
[35]
Reassessment of modeling turbulence via
Hanjali. Reassessment of modeling turbulence via. Physics of Fluids , volume=. 2021 , publisher=
2021
-
[36]
Part I: Theory , author=
Stochastic climate model. Part I: Theory , author=. Tellus , volume=
-
[37]
Physical Review Fluids , volume=
Velocity asymmetry and turbulent transport closure in smooth-and rough-wall boundary layers , author=. Physical Review Fluids , volume=. 2020 , publisher=
2020
-
[38]
Turbulent pipe flow at extreme
Hultmark, M and Vallikivi, M and Bailey, SCC and Smits, AJ , journal=. Turbulent pipe flow at extreme. 2012 , publisher=
2012
-
[39]
Physical Review Fluids , volume=
Profiles of high-order moments of longitudinal velocity explained by the random sweeping decorrelation hypothesis , author=. Physical Review Fluids , volume=. 2022 , publisher=
2022
-
[40]
Boundary-Layer Meteorology , pages=
Velocity and Temperature Dissimilarity in the Surface Layer Uncovered by the Telegraph Approximation , author=. Boundary-Layer Meteorology , pages=. 2021 , publisher=
2021
-
[41]
Assessing
Huang, M and Xiao, H and Wang, M and Fast, JD , journal=. Assessing. 2020 , publisher=
2020
-
[42]
Boundary-Layer Meteorology , volume=
Towards reconciling the large-scale structure of turbulent boundary layers in the atmosphere and laboratory , author=. Boundary-Layer Meteorology , volume=. 2012 , publisher=
2012
-
[43]
Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society: A Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences, Applied Meteorology and Physical Oceanography , volume=
Vertical velocity variance and skewness in clear and cloud-topped boundary layers as revealed by Doppler lidar , author=. Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society: A Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences, Applied Meteorology and Physical Oceanography , volume=. 2009 , publisher=
2009
-
[44]
Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=
Turbulent fluctuations above the buffer layer of wall-bounded flows , author=. Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=. 2008 , publisher=
2008
-
[45]
Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics , volume=
Cascades in wall-bounded turbulence , author=. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics , volume=
-
[46]
Turbulence and Coherent Structures , pages=
Spectra and correlation functions of surface layer atmospheric turbulence in unstable thermal stratification , author=. Turbulence and Coherent Structures , pages=. 1991 , publisher=
1991
-
[47]
Application of the stochastic closure theory to the
Kaminsky, J and Klewicki, J and Birnir, B , journal=. Application of the stochastic closure theory to the. 2019 , publisher=
2019
-
[48]
Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres , volume=
Turbulent eddy motion at the forest-atmosphere interface , author=. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres , volume=. 1997 , publisher=
1997
-
[49]
Boundary-Layer Meteorology , volume=
A theoretical and experimental investigation of energy-containing scales in the dynamic sublayer of boundary-layer flows , author=. Boundary-Layer Meteorology , volume=. 1998 , publisher=
1998
-
[50]
Boundary-Layer Meteorology , volume=
An investigation of higher-order closure models for a forested canopy , author=. Boundary-Layer Meteorology , volume=. 1998 , publisher=
1998
-
[51]
Physical Review Letters , volume=
Mean velocity profile in a sheared and thermally stratified atmospheric boundary layer , author=. Physical Review Letters , volume=. 2011 , publisher=
2011
-
[52]
Bottlenecks in turbulent kinetic energy spectra predicted from structure function inflections using the von
Katul, GG and Manes, C and Porporato, A and Bou-Zeid, E and Chamecki, M , journal=. Bottlenecks in turbulent kinetic energy spectra predicted from structure function inflections using the von. 2015 , publisher=
2015
-
[53]
Physics of Fluids , volume=
Generalized logarithmic scaling for high-order moments of the longitudinal velocity component explained by the random sweeping decorrelation hypothesis , author=. Physics of Fluids , volume=. 2016 , publisher=
2016
-
[54]
1955 , institution=
Characteristics of turbulence in a boundary layer with zero pressure gradient , author=. 1955 , institution=
1955
-
[55]
Journal of Applied Meteorology and Climatology , volume=
An investigation of the conditional sampling method used to estimate fluxes of active, reactive, and passive scalars , author=. Journal of Applied Meteorology and Climatology , volume=
-
[56]
Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=
The anatomy of large-scale motion in atmospheric boundary layers , author=. Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=. 2019 , publisher=
2019
-
[57]
Boundary-Layer Meteorology , volume=
Ejective and sweeping motions above a peatland and their role in relaxed-eddy-accumulation measurements and turbulent transport modelling , author=. Boundary-Layer Meteorology , volume=. 2018 , publisher=
2018
-
[58]
Klewicki, JC and Foss, JF and Wallace, JM , booktitle=. High. 1998 , publisher=
1998
-
[59]
The local structure of turbulence in incompressible viscous fluid for very large
Kolmogorov, AN , journal=. The local structure of turbulence in incompressible viscous fluid for very large. 1991 , publisher=
1991
-
[60]
The local structure of turbulence in incompressible viscous fluid for very large
Kolmogorov, AN , journal=. The local structure of turbulence in incompressible viscous fluid for very large
-
[61]
Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=
Experiment on the geometry of the fine-structure regions in fully turbulent fluid , author=. Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=. 1972 , publisher=
1972
-
[62]
Progress in the development of a
Launder, BE and Reece, GJr and Rodi, W , journal=. Progress in the development of a. 1975 , publisher=
1975
-
[63]
Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences , volume=
Some observations of vertical velocity skewness in the convective planetary boundary layer , author=. Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences , volume=
-
[64]
Boundary-Layer Meteorology , volume=
A comparison of higher-order vertical velocity moments in the convective boundary layer from lidar with in situ measurements and large-eddy simulation , author=. Boundary-Layer Meteorology , volume=. 2012 , publisher=
2012
-
[65]
Atmospheric Environment , volume=
A random walk model for dispersion in inhomogeneous turbulence in a convective boundary layer , author=. Atmospheric Environment , volume=. 1989 , publisher=
1989
-
[66]
Advances in Applied Mechanics , volume=
Computational modeling of turbulent flows , author=. Advances in Applied Mechanics , volume=. 1979 , publisher=
1979
-
[67]
Journal of Engineering Mechanics , volume=
Wall similarity in turbulent open-channel flow , author=. Journal of Engineering Mechanics , volume=. 1999 , publisher=
1999
-
[68]
An updated
Li, T and Wang, M and Guo, Z and Yang, B and Xu, Y and Han, X and Sun, J , journal=. An updated. 2022 , publisher=
2022
-
[69]
Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=
Turbulent boundary layers over permeable walls: scaling and near-wall structure , author=. Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=. 2011 , publisher=
2011
-
[70]
Derivation of third--order vertical velocity turbulence moment in the convective boundary layer from
Maldaner, S and Degrazia, GA and Rizza, U and Moreira, VS and Puhales, FS and Acevedo, OC and Alves, I and da Costa Carvalho, J , journal=. Derivation of third--order vertical velocity turbulence moment in the convective boundary layer from. 2013 , publisher=
2013
-
[71]
Nonlinear Processes in Geophysics , volume=
On the dependence of third-and fourth-order moments on stability in the turbulent boundary layer , author=. Nonlinear Processes in Geophysics , volume=. 2006 , publisher=
2006
-
[72]
Velocity probability density functions in
Maurizi, A and Tampieri, F , journal=. Velocity probability density functions in. 1999 , publisher=
1999
-
[73]
1990 , publisher=
The physics of fluid turbulence , author=. 1990 , publisher=
1990
-
[74]
Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics , volume=
Stably stratified atmospheric boundary layers , author=. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics , volume=. 2014 , publisher=
2014
-
[75]
Physics of Fluids , volume=
The statistical behaviour of attached eddies , author=. Physics of Fluids , volume=. 2015 , pages=
2015
-
[76]
Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics , volume=
Attached eddy model of wall turbulence , author=. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics , volume=. 2019 , publisher=
2019
-
[77]
Physics of Fluids , volume=
Streamwise turbulence intensity formulation for flat-plate boundary layers , author=. Physics of Fluids , volume=. 2003 , publisher=
2003
-
[78]
Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=
On the logarithmic region in wall turbulence , author=. Journal of Fluid Mechanics , volume=. 2013 , publisher=
2013
-
[79]
Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences , volume=
Large-eddy simulation of the convective atmospheric boundary layer , author=. Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences , volume=
-
[80]
Physics of Fluids , volume=
Mean-velocity profile of smooth channel flow explained by a cospectral budget model with wall-blockage , author=. Physics of Fluids , volume=. 2016 , publisher=
2016
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.