A Critical Examination of Hypernova Remnant Candidates in M101. I. MF83

The SNR candidate MF83 in M101 is coincident with a very luminous X-ray source. Based on the high X-ray luminosity, it has been suggested that MF83 is a "hypernova remnant" requiring an explosion energy about two orders of magnitude higher than normal supernovae. We have analyzed high-quality ground-based and HST observations of MF83, and find that MF83 is a star formation region, consisting of a large ionized gas shell and four HII regions along its periphery. Continuum images show OB associations in these HII regions and within the large shell. The shell has an expansion velocity of $\sim$50 km/s and a diameter of $\sim$270 pc. The optical properties of this shell in MF83 are similar to those of X-ray-bright superbubbles in the Large Magellanic Cloud. If the X-ray emission is indeed diffuse, the implied thermal energy in MF83 is high, a few $\times10^{52}$ ergs. This amount of thermal energy requires a large number of concentrated supernova explosions or one powerful explosion. Future X-ray observations with a high angular resolution are needed to resolve the diffuse emission and point sources in MF83, in order to determine more accurately the thermal energy in the shell interior and its required explosion energy.