pith. sign in

arxiv: 1907.11169 · v1 · pith:V5YBHHKLnew · submitted 2019-06-20 · ⚛️ physics.hist-ph

Majorana equation and its consequences in physics and philosophy

Daniel Parrochia This is my paper

Pith reviewed 2026-05-25 19:15 UTC · model grok-4.3

classification ⚛️ physics.hist-ph
keywords Majorana equationDirac equationneutral fermionsvariational principlecondensed matter physicsquantum computingphilosophy of physicselectron-positron symmetry
0
0 comments X

The pith

Majorana derived a symmetrical electron-positron theory from a general variational principle in 1937, yielding neutral fermions with direct mappings to condensed-matter systems and quantum-computing proposals.

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The paper reconstructs the historical and mathematical steps by which Majorana obtained his equation from a variational principle that treats the electron and positron symmetrically, in contrast to Dirac's original formulation. It rewrites that equation in present-day notation and traces its consequences for the existence of particles that are their own antiparticles. These consequences are then followed into condensed-matter realizations of Majorana fermions and into possible hardware for topological quantum computation, while the final section examines the philosophical repercussions of the underlying symmetry.

Core claim

Majorana's 1937 equation, obtained by imposing a variational principle that makes the electron and positron interchangeable, describes a neutral spin-1/2 particle identical to its antiparticle; when expressed in contemporary language this equation supplies the theoretical template for Majorana zero modes observed in certain superconductors and for the braiding operations proposed in topological quantum computing, while the same symmetry principle carries over into philosophical reflections on identity and duality.

What carries the argument

Majorana equation obtained from a variational principle enforcing electron-positron symmetry; the equation encodes the condition that the particle equals its own antiparticle.

If this is right

  • Neutral fermions obeying the Majorana equation appear as zero modes at the ends of superconducting nanowires.
  • Braiding of these modes supplies a route to fault-tolerant quantum gates.
  • The same symmetry principle alters how one conceives of particle identity in relativistic quantum theory.
  • Philosophical accounts of duality and self-identity must accommodate a particle that is indistinguishable from its antiparticle.

Where Pith is reading between the lines

These are editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

  • If the variational structure survives the mapping to real materials, then any observed deviation in mode statistics would falsify the direct applicability rather than the original equation.
  • The philosophical section invites comparison with other symmetry-based identities in physics, such as charge-conjugation invariance, without requiring new experimental input.
  • A natural extension would be to ask whether the same variational starting point yields analogous equations for higher-spin fields that have not yet been tested in condensed matter.

Load-bearing premise

The 1937 variational derivation can be rewritten in modern notation and transferred to condensed-matter models without altering its original structure or requiring system-specific corrections.

What would settle it

A concrete condensed-matter platform predicted by the rewritten Majorana equation to host zero-energy modes that is experimentally shown to contain none under conditions where the variational symmetry is preserved.

read the original abstract

We focus here on the work of the italian physicist Ettore Majorana, and more particularly on his 1937 article on the symmetrical theory of the electron and the positron, probably one of the most important theory for contemporary thought. We recall the context of this article (Dirac relativistic electron wave equation) and analyze how Majorana deduces his own equation from a very general variational principle. After having rewritten Majorana equation in a more contemporary language, we study its implications in condensed matter physics and their possible applications in quantum computing. Finally, we describe some of the consequences of Majorana approach to philosophy.

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, simulated authors' rebuttal, and a circularity audit. Tearing a paper down is the easy half of reading it; the pith above is the substance, this is the friction.

Referee Report

2 major / 1 minor

Summary. The manuscript reviews Ettore Majorana's 1937 symmetrical theory of the electron and positron in the context of Dirac's equation, analyzes its derivation from a general variational principle, rewrites the equation in contemporary language, explores resulting implications for condensed-matter physics and quantum-computing applications, and outlines philosophical consequences of the Majorana approach.

Significance. If the rewriting preserves the original variational structure without introducing extraneous terms or approximations, the work would usefully connect a foundational 1937 derivation to modern condensed-matter realizations; the paper's strength lies in its explicit historical framing rather than in new derivations or falsifiable predictions.

major comments (2)
  1. [Abstract / rewriting paragraph] Abstract and the paragraph on rewriting: the claim that implications in condensed matter follow directly after rewriting requires an explicit demonstration (e.g., side-by-side comparison of the 1937 variational principle with its modern form) that no effective terms, boundary conditions, or approximations are added; without this, the mapping to condensed-matter systems is not secured.
  2. [Implications in condensed matter physics] Section on implications in condensed matter physics: the asserted applications to quantum computing rest on the assumption that the 1937 derivation translates intact, yet the text provides no explicit calculation showing preservation of the original variational structure under the model-specific adjustments typical of condensed-matter realizations.
minor comments (1)
  1. The manuscript would benefit from a dedicated subsection explicitly comparing the original 1937 variational functional with its rewritten counterpart, including any differences in the resulting Euler-Lagrange equations.

Simulated Author's Rebuttal

2 responses · 0 unresolved

We thank the referee for the careful reading and constructive comments. We address the major comments point by point below, agreeing that explicit demonstrations would strengthen the manuscript and indicating the revisions we will make.

read point-by-point responses

  1. Referee: [Abstract / rewriting paragraph] Abstract and the paragraph on rewriting: the claim that implications in condensed matter follow directly after rewriting requires an explicit demonstration (e.g., side-by-side comparison of the 1937 variational principle with its modern form) that no effective terms, boundary conditions, or approximations are added; without this, the mapping to condensed-matter systems is not secured.

    Authors: We agree that an explicit side-by-side comparison would better secure the mapping from the 1937 variational principle to its modern form. In the revised manuscript we will insert a dedicated comparison (table or subsection) that directly juxtaposes the original variational principle with the rewritten contemporary version, explicitly verifying that no effective terms, boundary conditions or approximations are introduced. This addition will make the subsequent discussion of condensed-matter implications more rigorous. revision: yes

  2. Referee: [Implications in condensed matter physics] Section on implications in condensed matter physics: the asserted applications to quantum computing rest on the assumption that the 1937 derivation translates intact, yet the text provides no explicit calculation showing preservation of the original variational structure under the model-specific adjustments typical of condensed-matter realizations.

    Authors: We acknowledge that the present text does not contain a new, self-contained calculation demonstrating preservation of the variational structure under every model-specific adjustment. The discussion draws on the established literature in which the Majorana equation is mapped to condensed-matter systems while retaining its core structure. To address the referee's concern we will add a concise paragraph (or short appendix) that outlines, with reference to standard derivations in the field, how the original variational principle remains intact in the typical realizations used for Majorana zero modes and quantum-computing applications. This constitutes a partial revision, as a full independent recalculation lies outside the historical-review scope of the paper. revision: partial

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged

No circularity: purely historical and interpretive analysis with no derivations or fitted predictions.

full rationale

The paper is a descriptive historical review of Majorana's 1937 work. It recalls the Dirac context, summarizes the deduction from a variational principle (without re-deriving it), rewrites the equation in modern notation, and discusses implications interpretively. No new equations, parameters, or predictions are introduced that reduce to the paper's own inputs by construction. No self-citations form load-bearing steps, and the mapping to condensed-matter systems is presented as exploratory rather than a deductive claim. This matches the default expectation for non-deductive papers.

Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger

0 free parameters · 0 axioms · 0 invented entities

The paper is a historical and philosophical review rather than a theoretical derivation. No free parameters are fitted, no new axioms are introduced, and no invented entities are postulated by the authors.

pith-pipeline@v0.9.0 · 5615 in / 1093 out tokens · 23939 ms · 2026-05-25T19:15:02.251861+00:00 · methodology

discussion (0)

Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

34 extracted references · 34 canonical work pages · 1 internal anchor

  1. [1]

    Aste, A., «A direct road to Majorana fields», Symmetry 2 (2010) 1776–1809

    work page 2010

  2. [2]

    Basdevant, J.-L., Le principe de moindre action et les principes variationnel s en physique, Paris, Editions Vuibert, 2010

    work page 2010

  3. [3]

    Dirac, P. A. M., «The Quantum Theory of the Electron», Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 1, vol. 117, No 778, (1928), 610-624

    work page 1928

  4. [4]

    Dirac, P. A. M., The Principles of Quantum Mechanics (1930), Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1989

    work page 1930

  5. [5]

    P., Leighton, R

    Feynman, R. P., Leighton, R. B., et Sands, M., The Feynman Lectures on Physics, New York, Addison-Wesley,1964

    work page 1964

  6. [6]

    M., «Comments on a Paper by Majorana Concerni ng Elementary Particles», American Journal of physics , Volume 34, Issue 4 (1966), 314-318

    Fradkin, D. M., «Comments on a Paper by Majorana Concerni ng Elementary Particles», American Journal of physics , Volume 34, Issue 4 (1966), 314-318. Re- publié dans Electronic Journal of Theoretical Physics (EJTP) , 3, No. 10 (2006), 305–314

    work page 1966

  7. [7]

    (ed.), Kamerlingh Onnes, Heike, Through mea- surement to knowledge : the selected papers of Heike Kamerli ngh Onnes (1853- 1926)

    Gavroglou K and Goudaroulis Y. (ed.), Kamerlingh Onnes, Heike, Through mea- surement to knowledge : the selected papers of Heike Kamerli ngh Onnes (1853- 1926). Dordrecht, Boston, Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1991. 16

    work page 1926

  8. [8]

    Ginzburg V. L. and Landau, L. D., Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 20, 1064 (1950), trad. angl. dans: L. D. Landau, Collected papers, Oxford, Pergamon Press, 1965, p. 546

    work page 1950

  9. [9]

    Jordan, P., Wigner, E., «Über das Paulische Äquivalenzv erbot», Zeitschrift für Physik, 47, No 9 (1928), 631-651

    work page 1928

  10. [10]

    L., «Topological Insulator: An Insulator with a Twist»

    Kane, C. L., «Topological Insulator: An Insulator with a Twist». Nature 4 (5)(2008), 348

    work page 2008

  11. [11]

    L., Mele, E

    Kane, C. L., Mele, E. J. (30 September 2005). «Z2 Topolog ical Order and the Quantum Spin Hall Effect», Physical Review Letters 95 (14), 2005

    work page 2005

  12. [12]

    L., Moore, J

    Kane, C. L., Moore, J. E., «Topological Insulators», Physics World 24 (2011), 32

    work page 2011

  13. [13]

    Klein, E., En cherchant Majorana, le physicien absolu , Paris, Flammarion, 2013

    work page 2013

  14. [14]

    M., Plissard, S

    Mourik1, V., Zuo, K., Frolov S. M., Plissard, S. R., Bakk ers, E. P. A. M., Kouwenhoven, L. P., «Signatures of Majorana Fermions in Hybrid Superconductor-Semiconductor Nanowire Devices», Science, Vol. 336 No. 6084 (2012), 1003-1007

    work page 2012

  15. [15]

    M., Sau, J

    Lutchyn, R. M., Sau, J. D., and Das Sarma, S., «Majorana F ermions and a Topological Phase Transition in Semiconductor-Supercon ductor Heterostruc- tures», Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 077001

    work page

  16. [16]

    W., «Induced representations of locally com pact groups», I, Annals of Mathematics , 55, (1952), 101-139

    Mackey, G. W., «Induced representations of locally com pact groups», I, Annals of Mathematics , 55, (1952), 101-139

    work page 1952

  17. [17]

    W., «Induced representations of locally com pact groups», II, Annals of Mathematics , 58, (1953), 193-221

    Mackey, G. W., «Induced representations of locally com pact groups», II, Annals of Mathematics , 58, (1953), 193-221

    work page 1953

  18. [18]

    W., «Infinite dimensional group representat ions», Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society , 69, (1963) 628-686

    Mackey, G. W., «Infinite dimensional group representat ions», Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society , 69, (1963) 628-686

    work page 1963

  19. [19]

    W., «Harmonic Analysis as the Exploitation o f Symmetry - A histor- ical survey», Bulletin (New Series) of the American Mathematical Society , Volume 3, No 1 (1980), 543-698

    Mackey, G. W., «Harmonic Analysis as the Exploitation o f Symmetry - A histor- ical survey», Bulletin (New Series) of the American Mathematical Society , Volume 3, No 1 (1980), 543-698

    work page 1980

  20. [20]

    14 (1937), 171–184

    Majorana, E., «Teoria simmetrica dell’ elettrone e del positrone», Nuovo Cim. 14 (1937), 171–184

    work page 1937

  21. [21]

    14, 1937, pp

    Majorana, E., «A symmetric theory of electrons and posi trons», translated from Il Nuovo Cimento , vol. 14, 1937, pp. 171-184, by Luciano Maiani in Soryushiron Kenkyu, 63 (1981) 149-462. 17

    work page 1937

  22. [22]

    36, Febbraio- Marzo (1942), 58-66; trad

    Majorana, E., «Il valore delle leggi statistiche nella fisica e nelle scienze sociali», Scientia, Quarta serie, vol. 36, Febbraio- Marzo (1942), 58-66; trad . anglaise : E. Majorana, «The value of statistical laws in physics and soci al sciences», Quanti- tative Finance 5, (2005), 133–140

    work page 1942

  23. [23]

    Pal, Palash B., «Dirac, Majorana and Weyl Fermions», Am. J. Phys. , vol. 79 (2011), 485-498

    work page 2011

  24. [24]

    Parrochia, D., Les grandes révolutions scientifiques du XX e siècle, Paris, P.U.F., 1997

    work page 1997

  25. [25]

    Parrochia, D., Micali, A., Anglès, P., L’unification des mathématiques, algèbres géométriques, géométrie algébrique et philosophie de Lang lands, Paris, Hermès- Lavoisier, 2013

    work page 2013

  26. [26]

    Pedro, L., «The Majorana spinor representation of the P oincare group», site internet : viXra:1305.0201

    work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv

  27. [27]

    Rééd., Presso Di Renzo Editor e, Rome, 2008

    Recami, E., Il caso Majorana: epistolario, documenti, testimonianze , Milan, Oscar Mondadori, 1987 et 1991. Rééd., Presso Di Renzo Editor e, Rome, 2008

    work page 1987

  28. [28]

    S., «A solid case for Majorana fermions», Nature, 483 (2012), 132

    Reich, E. S., «A solid case for Majorana fermions», Nature, 483 (2012), 132

    work page 2012

  29. [29]

    Saunder s and H

    Saunders, S., «The Negative-Energy Sea», in S. Saunder s and H. Brown (ed.), The Philosophy of Vacuum , Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1991, 65-109

    work page 1991

  30. [30]

    Revue de Synthèse , «Ettore Majorana, de la légende à la Science», Volume 134, No 1, Mars 2013

    work page 2013

  31. [31]

    Thaller, B., The Dirac Equation, Berlin, Heidelberg, New-York, Springer-Verlag, 1992

    work page 1992

  32. [32]

    Mandelstam, S., Variational Principles in Dynamics and Quan- tum Theory , New York, Dover Publications, 1979

    Yourgrau, W. Mandelstam, S., Variational Principles in Dynamics and Quan- tum Theory , New York, Dover Publications, 1979

    work page 1979

  33. [33]

    Wigner, E., «On Unitary Representations of the Inhomog eneous Lorentz Group», The Annals of Math- ematics 40, No 1 (1939), 149

    work page 1939

  34. [34]

    Wilzec, F., «Majorana return», Nature Physics 5, (2009), 614 - 618. 18

    work page 2009