Pith. sign in

REVIEW 3 major objections 4 minor 300 references

Research on the Interstellar Medium and Star Formation in the Galaxy: An Indian Perspective

T0 review · 3 major / 4 minor · reviewed 2026-08-10 · deepseek-v4-flash

Challenge this review Re-run · record.json Download PDF Read on arXiv ↗ Review JSON

Pith's one-line read This white paper argues that India's interstellar-medium and star-formation community needs guaranteed access to state-of-the-art sub-mm/mm and large optical telescopes to stay competitive, and it lays out a phased facility roadmap for…

desk verdict A competent, honest white paper that maps Indian ISM/star formation research and offers a reasonable facility roadmap; the main soft spot is an unquantified claim about the sub-mm access bottleneck. read the letter →

arxiv 2501.04290 v1 pith:4F5ZAHTQ submitted 2025-01-08 astro-ph.GA

Bhaswati Mookerjea , Maheswar G. , Kinsuk Acharyya , Tapas Baug , Prasun Datta , Jessy Jose , D. K. Ojha , Jagadheep D. Pandian
show 19 more authors
Nirupam Roy Manash Samal Saurabh Sharma Archana Soam Sarita Vig Ankan Das Lokesh Dewangan Somnath Dutta C. Eswariah Liton Majumdar Kshitiz Kumar Mallick Soumen Mondal Joe P. Ninan Neelam Panwar Amit Pathak Shantanu Rastogi Dipen Sahu Anandmayee Tej Veena V.S
This is my paper · ORCID
classification astro-ph.GA
keywords interstellarmediumstarformationsubmillimetreastronomyobservatoryplanningmagneticfieldsprotostarsandoutflowsinitialmassfunctionastrochemistry
verification ladder T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal

The pith

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The reading

This invited vision white paper argues that the Indian interstellar-medium and star-formation community, currently about 100-150 active researchers, has produced valuable science largely from archival and collaborative data but is being held back by the absence of domestic sub-millimetre and millimetre facilities. The authors claim that to address the field's core questions—how filaments fragment into cores, how magnetic fields and turbulence regulate collapse, how jets and outflows are launched, and how chemistry builds prebiotic molecules—Indian researchers need guaranteed access to state-of-the-art telescopes, not one-off collaborations. They therefore recommend a phased plan: upgrade existing 2-3-m optical telescopes and polarimeters now, build or join a 10-20-m single-dish sub-mm/mm observatory and a 10-m class optical telescope in the medium term, and develop a high-resolution sub-mm/mm interferometer plus second-generation instruments for large international telescopes in the long term. If the plan is followed, Indian groups would move from archival-data science to leadership of large survey programs.

What carries the argument

The load-bearing mechanism is the phased facility-access plan: a three-horizon roadmap (short/mid/long term) that treats guaranteed access to state-of-the-art telescopes as the necessary input for training, large programs, and impact. The linchpin facility is a 10-20-m class single-dish sub-mm/mm observatory with wide-field mapping and polarimetric capability, which the paper argues would let Indian astronomers trace Galactic molecular clouds in dust continuum and dense-gas tracers and complement interferometric data from ALMA and similar arrays. Around this core are arrayed upgrades to 2-3-m optical telescopes, wide-field imaging polarimeters for B-field mapping, a 10-m class optical telescope with adaptive optics and multi-object spectroscopy, a national consortium for ALMA/JWST-style facilities, and high-performance computing resources.

What would settle it

A quantitative bibliometric study comparing Indian-led papers built on archival ALMA/Herschel/JWST data with PI-led large-program papers, controlling for topic and team size, would settle the point: if archival-based papers already match the citation impact of PI-led programs, then guaranteed facility access is not the decisive factor the paper claims.

Watch

Extended reading notes

Core claim

The paper's central claim is that the Indian ISM and star-formation community's competitiveness is gated by infrastructure: the science it can do with archival and guest-observer data has reached its ceiling, while the global frontier has moved to high-resolution, high-sensitivity sub-mm/mm observations of filaments, cores, disks, and jets that require guaranteed observing time on facilities like ALMA and JWST. It reviews nine science areas—from diffuse atomic gas to giant molecular clouds, filaments and cores, magnetic fields and turbulence, accretion and outflows, the low-mass IMF, massive-star feedback, binary formation, protoplanetary disks, and astrochemistry—and for each documents Indian contributions, mostly based on archival data, and the open questions that need dedicated facilities. The authors conclude that the community should prioritize, in the short term, instrument upgrades and national consortia for international facilities; in the medium term, a 10-20-m single-dish sub-mm/mm observatory with wide-field mapping and polarimetric capability and a 10-m class optical telescope; and in the long term, a high-resolution sub-mm/mm interferometer and participation in major international projects.

Load-bearing premise

The entire recommendation rests on the premise that lack of domestic sub-millimetre and millimetre observing facilities—not limited access to archival data or to collaborators—is what is holding Indian star-formation research back.

Editorial extensions

If this is right

  • With a 10-20-m single-dish sub-mm/mm observatory, Indian teams could run coherent large-scale surveys of molecular clouds in dust continuum and dense-gas tracers like NH3, HCN, and N2H+, data that interferometers like ALMA need as complementary large-scale context.
  • Membership in international consortia such as ALMA/JWST and the East Asian Observatory would give Indian researchers hands-on training with high-resolution data and a pipeline for future facilities like ngVLA.
  • A 10-m class optical telescope with adaptive optics, integral-field and multi-object spectroscopy would bridge the existing 3.6-m telescope and the upcoming TMT, enabling accretion and outflow studies at the faint end of the stellar mass spectrum.
  • Wide-field optical/near-infrared polarimeters on 2-3-m telescopes would let Indian groups build two-dimensional magnetic-field maps of molecular clouds and test grain-alignment theories.
  • A long-term sub-mm/mm interferometer with roughly 0.01-arcsecond resolution and about ten times current sensitivity would directly detect close protostellar companions and small disk structures, putting Indian science at the frontier of multiplicity and disk-formation studies.

Reading between the lines

Editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

  • A testable benchmark follows from the paper's diagnosis: if missing domestic sub-mm/mm access is the main bottleneck, the share of Indian first-author publications that come from PI-led large programs should rise once the recommended facilities or consortia memberships are in place; tracking this share would provide a quantitative check on the plan.
  • The same capability-gap logic may apply to other Indian astronomy subfields that currently rely on archival data, such as time-domain surveys; the paper's reasoning suggests that guaranteed access matters most where the frontier is defined by high-resolution, high-sensitivity imaging.
  • The plan implicitly assumes international partners will accept India into consortia on reasonable terms; if that assumption fails, the domestic single-dish and interferometer paths become not just desirable but necessary, strengthening the paper's case for them.
  • The paper's own account of Indian modelling and astrochemistry strength suggests that facility investment should be paired deliberately with simulation and laboratory infrastructure, since the new telescopes would generate data that those communities are positioned to interpret.
Share X Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit HN

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, and a circularity audit.

Referee Report

3 major / 4 minor

Summary. This white paper, invited by the Astronomical Society of India, reviews Indian contributions to interstellar medium and star formation research across nine themes (neutral ISM, filaments/cores, magnetic fields and turbulence, accretion/jets/outflows, IMF, massive-star feedback, multiplicity, protoplanetary disks, and astrochemistry). For each theme it summarizes the global state of the art, describes Indian work with extensive citations, and closes with a set of prioritized facility and infrastructure recommendations grouped into short-, mid-, and long-term actions. The central recommendation is that the Indian community needs guaranteed access to state-of-the-art sub-millimetre/millimetre facilities, culminating in a domestic 10–20 m single-dish telescope and a high-resolution interferometer, along with instrument upgrades, an NLOT-class optical telescope, wide-field polarimeters, computational infrastructure, and international consortium membership.

Significance. As a community vision document, this paper is genuinely useful: it compiles a broad and largely accurate picture of Indian ISM/star-formation research, connects it to global open questions, and proposes concrete, time-ordered actions. Its strength is its comprehensive literature coverage and the breadth of community input it represents. The recommendations, if adopted, could significantly shape Indian astronomy investment. However, the paper's central policy claim—that lack of domestic sub-mm/mm access is the primary bottleneck to competitive research—rests on repeated assertions rather than quantitative evidence. Since the paper is a review, not a derivation, there is no circularity, but the evidentiary standard for a load-bearing recommendation should still be explicit. The paper would be materially strengthened by a systematic gap analysis or bibliometric assessment of Indian publications' data sources and impact.

major comments (3)
  1. [Sections 3.2, 5.2, 8, and 11] The paper's priority ordering is built on the causal claim that the lack of domestic sub-mm/mm facilities is the primary bottleneck for competitive Indian research. This claim is asserted in §3.2 ('Due to the lack of sub- and millimeter band facilities in the country...'), §5.2 ('largely due to the lack of access to high resolution (sub-arcsec resolution) imaging telescopes, particularly at sub-millimetre wavelengths'), §8, and §11, but no systematic evidence is presented to show that this constraint outweighs others (e.g., limited guaranteed time on international facilities, computational capacity, or workforce). The paper itself lists many high-impact results obtained from archival and collaborative data (e.g., Dewangan et al. 2024a; Rawat et al. 2024a; Sahu et al. 2018; Pandian et al. 2024), which suggests archival routes can support competitive science. A bibliometric or community-survey analysis quantifying the data sources of Indian papers, their citation impact by data-access mode, and a comparison with similarly sized communities without domestic sub-mm facilities would directly test this premise and would make the recommendation load-bearing rather than asserted.
  2. [Section 11] The two quantitative claims in §11—that the community has 'about 100–150 active researchers' and that 'a significant fraction' of its science is based on archival data—are unquantified. These numbers are used to justify the call for 'large observational programs needing guaranteed access to state-of-the-art telescopes.' The authors should document the source of these estimates, for example through an ASI community census, a publication-author count, or a survey of the community, and should define 'significant fraction' with a concrete percentage where possible.
  3. [Section 11 and Figure 8] The recommendations are presented as a prioritized list, but the paper does not discuss trade-offs or opportunity costs among them. In particular, the long-term recommendation for a domestic sub-mm/mm interferometer and the mid-term 10–20 m single-dish telescope are very expensive, and the paper does not compare these investments against alternatives such as guaranteed ALMA/JWST membership, further expansion of the EAO partnership, or increased investment in theory and computation. A simple cost-benefit or feasibility framing would strengthen the justification for the proposed ordering.
minor comments (4)
  1. [Figure 8] Figure 8 is referenced in §11 as a summary of the recommendations, but the text does not describe its content; if the figure is a flowchart or table, consider adding a brief textual description so the recommendations are accessible to readers.
  2. [General presentation] Several references have garbled diacritics and spacing (e.g., 'Grudi´c et al . 2021', '¨Oberg'), and some arXiv identifiers are listed without publication status; a careful proofreading pass and consistent reference formatting would improve the manuscript.
  3. [Section 1] The introduction lists the nine selected topics but does not explain why these topics were chosen or how the selection was made; a sentence describing the consultation process or inclusion criteria would make the scope of the white paper more transparent.
  4. [Sections 3.2 and 5.2] The point about the lack of sub-mm/mm access is made three times in nearly identical terms (§3.2, §5.2, §8); consider consolidating these statements into a single, evidence-based discussion to avoid repetition.

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged · score 0.0 of 10

No circularity: the paper is a community white paper whose recommendations are narrative policy judgments, not quantities derived from fitted inputs or self-citation chains.

full rationale

This paper contains no derivation chain in the sense of the circularity audit. It is an invited vision document that reviews published results, summarizes open questions, and formulates facility and policy recommendations. There is no fitted parameter that is later renamed as a prediction, no equation whose output equals its input by construction, and no uniqueness theorem invoked from the authors' prior work to force a choice. The authors do cite their own prior papers extensively, but these citations document the community's actual research outputs (e.g., archival-data studies, ALMA observations, polarimetry) and are not used to justify the central recommendation. The central recommendation that India needs guaranteed access to state-of-the-art sub-mm/mm facilities and construction of domestic facilities is an argued policy position, not a consequence of a calculation. The skeptic's concern that the bottleneck claim is unquantified and would benefit from bibliometric testing is a correctness or evidence-quality criticism, not circularity: the recommendation does not reduce to its own premise by construction. Accordingly, the honest finding is no significant circularity, score 0.

Assumptions & free parameters 0 free parameters · 1 assumptions · 0 invented entities

The paper is a review, so it introduces no free parameters or invented entities. Its only axiom is the standard domain assumption of ISM and star formation physics taken from the cited literature.

assumptions (1)
  • domain assumption Standard physics of the multi-phase ISM and star formation as summarized in the cited literature (gravity, turbulence, B-fields, feedback, IMF, disks, astrochemistry) is correct and complete enough to define research priorities.
    The review frames all recommendations within the consensus picture of star formation (e.g., filaments to cores, B-field and turbulence roles, triggered star formation) without considering alternative paradigms. This is reasonable but assumed, not derived.

how reviews work

0 comments
Cite this review

Pith. "Pith review of Research on the Interstellar Medium and Star Formation in the Galaxy: An Indian Perspective." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/4F5ZAHTQ

@misc{pith2026250104290,
  author       = {Pith},
  title        = {Pith review of: Research on the Interstellar Medium and Star Formation in the Galaxy: An Indian Perspective},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/4F5ZAHTQ}},
  note         = {Machine review of arXiv:2501.04290}
}
read the original abstract

Although the star formation process has been studied for decades, many important aspects of the physics involved remain unsolved. Recent advancement of instrumentation in the infrared, far-infrared and sub-millimetre wavelength regimes have contributed to a significantly improved understanding of processes in the interstellar medium (ISM) leading to star formation. The future of research on the ISM and star formation looks exciting with instruments like the JWST, ALMA, etc., already contributing to the topic by gathering high-resolution high-sensitivity data and with several larger ground- and space-bound facilities either being planned or constructed. India has a sizable number of astronomers engaged in research on topics related to the ISM and star formation. In this white paper invited by the Astronomical Society of India to prepare a vision document for Indian astronomy, we review the Indian contributions to the global understanding of the star formation process and suggest areas that require focused efforts both in creating observing facilities and in theoretical front in India, in order to improve the impact of our research in the coming decades.

Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

300 extracted references · 73 canonical work pages

  1. [1]

    , " * write output.state after.block = add.period write newline

    ENTRY address archivePrefix author booktitle chapter doi edition editor eprint howpublished institution journal key month note number organization pages publisher school series title type volume year label extra.label sort.label short.list INTEGERS output.state before.all mid.sentence after.sentence after.block FUNCTION init.state.consts #0 'before.all :=...

  2. [2]

    write newline

    " write newline "" before.all 'output.state := FUNCTION format.doi doi empty "" "doi:" doi * if FUNCTION format.eprint eprint empty "" archivePrefix empty "" archivePrefix ":" * if eprint field.or.null * if FUNCTION format.pid eprint empty format.doi format.eprint if FUNCTION n.dashify 't := "" t empty not t #1 #1 substring "-" = t #1 #2 substring "--" = ...

  3. [3]

    Aarthy , E., Rai , A., Ganesh , S., & Vadawale , S. V. 2019, Journal of Astronomical Telescopes, Instruments, and Systems, 5, 035006

    2019

  4. [4]

    2014, , 443, 1301

    Acharyya , K. 2014, , 443, 1301

    2014

  5. [5]

    2022, , 39, e009

    ---. 2022, , 39, e009

    2022

  6. [6]

    W., & Herbst , E

    Acharyya , K., Schulte , S. W., & Herbst , E. 2020, , 247, 4

    2020

  7. [7]

    C., & Fatuzzo , M

    Adams , F. C., & Fatuzzo , M. 1996, , 464, 256

    1996

  8. [8]

    C., Ruden , S

    Adams , F. C., Ruden , S. P., & Shu , F. H. 1989, , 347, 959

    1989

Show all 300 references
  1. [9]

    2013, Chemical Reviews, 113, 8710

    Ag \'u ndez , M., & Wakelam , V. 2013, Chemical Reviews, 113, 8710

    2013

  2. [10]

    2020, Research in Astronomy and Astrophysics, 20, 014

    Ahmad , A., Shivani , Misra , A., & Tandon , P. 2020, Research in Astronomy and Astrophysics, 20, 014

    2020

  3. [11]

    G., Raman , V

    Anandarao , B. G., Raman , V. V., Ghosh , S. K., Ojha , D. K., & Kumar , M. S. N. 2008, , 390, 1185

    2008

  4. [12]

    2017, Comptes Rendus Geoscience, 349, 187

    Andr \'e , P. 2017, Comptes Rendus Geoscience, 349, 187

    2017

  5. [13]

    2010, , 518, L102

    Andr \'e , P., Men'shchikov , A., Bontemps , S., et al . 2010, , 518, L102

    2010

  6. [14]

    G., & Sargent , A

    Arce , H. G., & Sargent , A. I. 2004, , 612, 342

    2004

  7. [15]

    2021, , 501, 1243

    Arun , R., Mathew , B., Rengaswamy , S., et al . 2021, , 501, 1243

    2021

  8. [16]

    M., et al

    Audard , M., \'A brah \'a m , P., Dunham , M. M., et al . 2014, in Protostars and Planets VI, ed. H. Beuther , R. S. Klessen , C. P. Dullemond , & T. Henning , 387

    2014

  9. [17]

    2016, , 54, 491

    Bally , J. 2016, , 54, 491

    2016

  10. [18]

    2022, , 517, 5063

    Basu , A., Roy , N., Beuther , H., et al . 2022, , 517, 5063

    2022

  11. [19]

    R., Bonnell , I

    Bate , M. R., Bonnell , I. A., & Bromm , V. 2002, , 336, 705

    2002

  12. [20]

    K., et al

    Baug , T., de Grijs , R., Dewangan , L. K., et al . 2019, , 885, 68

    2019

  13. [21]

    K., Dewangan , L

    Baug , T., Ojha , D. K., Dewangan , L. K., et al . 2015, , 454, 4335

    2015

  14. [22]

    K., Ojha , D

    Baug , T., Dewangan , L. K., Ojha , D. K., et al . 2018, , 852, 119

    2018

  15. [23]

    2020, , 890, 44

    Baug , T., Wang , K., Liu , T., et al . 2020, , 890, 44

    2020

  16. [24]

    2021, , 507, 4316

    ---. 2021, , 507, 4316

    2021

  17. [25]

    T., Rivilla , V

    Beltr \'a n , M. T., Rivilla , V. M., Cesaroni , R., et al . 2022, , 659, A81

    2022

  18. [26]

    2016, , 595, A32

    Beuther , H., Bihr , S., Rugel , M., et al . 2016, , 595, A32

    2016

  19. [27]

    2022, , 659, A77

    Beuther , H., Schneider , N., Simon , R., et al . 2022, , 659, A77

    2022

  20. [28]

    B., & Sharma , P

    Bhadra , S., Gupta , S., Nath , B. B., & Sharma , P. 2022, , 510, 5579

    2022

  21. [29]

    G., Sivaraman , B., Lo , J.-I., et al

    Bhuin , R. G., Sivaraman , B., Lo , J.-I., et al . 2014, , 141, 231101

    2014

  22. [30]

    2023, , 526, 1308

    Bijas , N., Eswaraiah , C., Wang , J.-W., et al . 2023, , 526, 1308

    2023

  23. [31]

    G., W \"u nsch , R., Whitworth , A

    Bisbas , T. G., W \"u nsch , R., Whitworth , A. P., Hubber , D. A., & Walch , S. 2011, , 736, 142

    2011

  24. [32]

    2022, , 935, 171

    Bonne , L., Schneider , N., Garc \' a , P., et al . 2022, , 935, 171

    2022

  25. [33]

    S., Lopez-Rodriguez , E., Beck , R., et al

    Borlaff , A. S., Lopez-Rodriguez , E., Beck , R., et al . 2021, , 921, 128

    2021

  26. [34]

    2020, , 644, L3

    Bracco , A., Jeli \'c , V., Marchal , A., et al . 2020, , 644, L3

    2020

  27. [35]

    2011, , 527, A62

    Brand , J., Massi , F., Zavagno , A., Deharveng , L., & Lefloch , B. 2011, , 527, A62

    2011

  28. [36]

    2020, , 896, L34

    Brucy , N., Hennebelle , P., Bournaud , F., & Colling , C. 2020, , 896, L34

    2020

  29. [37]

    2020, , 892, 11

    Buragohain , M., Pathak , A., Sakon , I., & Onaka , T. 2020, , 892, 11

    2020

  30. [38]

    R., et al

    Campbell , H., Khilfeh , E., Covey , K. R., et al . 2022, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2211.06454

    2022 arXiv

  31. [39]

    E., Sipil \"a , O., et al

    Caselli , P., Pineda , J. E., Sipil \"a , O., et al . 2022, , 929, 13

    2022

  32. [40]

    Chakrabarti , S., & Chakrabarti , S. K. 2000, , 354, L6

    2000

  33. [41]

    2019, Science Advances, 5, eaau7555

    Chakraborty , P., Nag , A., Natarajan , G., et al . 2019, Science Advances, 5, eaau7555

    2019

  34. [42]

    K., Ogura , K., et al

    Chauhan , N., Pandey , A. K., Ogura , K., et al . 2009, , 396, 964

    2009

  35. [43]

    2019, , 483, 3437

    Choudhuri , S., & Roy , N. 2019, , 483, 3437

    2019

  36. [44]

    S., Allen , D., et al

    Churchwell , E., Povich , M. S., Allen , D., et al . 2006, , 649, 759

    2006

  37. [45]

    F., Povich , M

    Churchwell , E., Watson , D. F., Povich , M. S., et al . 2007, , 670, 428

    2007

  38. [46]

    P., Sarcia , D., Grabau , A., et al

    Clemens , D. P., Sarcia , D., Grabau , A., et al . 2007, , 119, 1385

    2007

  39. [47]

    P., Anderson , M

    Collings , M. P., Anderson , M. A., Chen , R., et al . 2004, , 354, 1133

    2004

  40. [48]

    P., Dever , J

    Collings , M. P., Dever , J. W., Fraser , H. J., McCoustra , M. R. S., & Williams , D. A. 2003, , 583, 1058

    2003

  41. [49]

    J., Ashraf , M., et al

    Contreras Pe \ n a , C., Herczeg , G. J., Ashraf , M., et al . 2023, , 521, 5669

    2023

  42. [50]

    C., Girart , J

    Cortes , P. C., Girart , J. M., Hull , C. L. H., et al . 2016, , 825, L15

    2016

  43. [51]

    2018, , 617, A89

    Csengeri , T., Bontemps , S., Wyrowski , F., et al . 2018, , 617, A89

    2018

  44. [52]

    E., Ngoumou , J., Ercolano , B., & Bonnell , I

    Dale , J. E., Ngoumou , J., Ercolano , B., & Bonnell , I. A. 2013, , 436, 3430

    2013

  45. [53]

    R., et al

    Damian , B., Jose , J., Samal , M. R., et al . 2021, , 504, 2557

    2021

  46. [54]

    2023, , 951, 139

    Damian , B., Jose , J., Biller , B., et al . 2023, , 951, 139

    2023

  47. [55]

    Das , A., Acharyya , K., Chakrabarti , S., & Chakrabarti , S. K. 2008, , 486, 209

    2008

  48. [56]

    Das , A., Sahu , D., Majumdar , L., & Chakrabarti , S. K. 2016, , 455, 540

    2016

  49. [57]

    2020, , 902, 131

    Das , A., Sil , M., Bhat , B., et al . 2020, , 902, 131

    2020

  50. [58]

    R., Tej , A., Vig , S., et al

    Das , S. R., Tej , A., Vig , S., et al . 2018, , 612, A36

    2018

  51. [59]

    D., et al

    Deharveng , L., Schuller , F., Anderson , L. D., et al . 2010, , 523, A6

    2010

  52. [60]

    A., Dwarakanath , K

    Deshpande , A. A., Dwarakanath , K. S., & Goss , W. M. 2000, , 543, 227

    2000

  53. [61]

    Dewangan , L. K. 2021, , 504, 1152

    2021

  54. [62]

    K., Baug , T., Ojha , D

    Dewangan , L. K., Baug , T., Ojha , D. K., et al . 2016, , 826, 27

    2016

  55. [63]

    K., Bhadari , N

    Dewangan , L. K., Bhadari , N. K., Maity , A. K., et al . 2024 a , , 527, 5895

    2024

  56. [64]

    K., Dhanya , J

    Dewangan , L. K., Dhanya , J. S., Bhadari , N. K., Ojha , D. K., & Baug , T. 2021, , 506, 6081

    2021

  57. [65]

    K., Maity , A

    Dewangan , L. K., Maity , A. K., Mayya , Y. D., et al . 2023, , 958, 51

    2023

  58. [66]

    K., Mayya , Y

    Dewangan , L. K., Mayya , Y. D., Luna , A., & Ojha , D. K. 2015, , 803, 100

    2015

  59. [67]

    K., Ojha , D

    Dewangan , L. K., Ojha , D. K., Anandarao , B. G., Ghosh , S. K., & Chakraborti , S. 2012, , 756, 151

    2012

  60. [68]

    K., Ojha , D

    Dewangan , L. K., Ojha , D. K., Zinchenko , I., & Baug , T. 2018, , 861, 19

    2018

  61. [69]

    K., Pirogov , L

    Dewangan , L. K., Pirogov , L. E., Ryabukhina , O. L., Ojha , D. K., & Zinchenko , I. 2019, , 877, 1

    2019

  62. [70]

    K., Sharma , S., Pandey , R., et al

    Dewangan , L. K., Sharma , S., Pandey , R., et al . 2020, , 898, 172

    2020

  63. [71]

    K., Zinchenko , I

    Dewangan , L. K., Zinchenko , I. I., Zemlyanukha , P. M., et al . 2022 a , , 925, 41

    2022

  64. [72]

    2022 b , , 925, 41

    ---. 2022 b , , 925, 41

    2022

  65. [73]

    K., Jadhav , O

    Dewangan , L. K., Jadhav , O. R., Maity , A. K., et al . 2024 b , , 528, 3909

    2024

  66. [74]

    D., & Lal , D

    Dey , J., Pandian , J. D., & Lal , D. V. 2022, , 925, 60

    2022

  67. [75]

    M., McClure-Griffiths , N

    Dickey , J. M., McClure-Griffiths , N. M., Stanimirovi \'c , S., Gaensler , B. M., & Green , A. J. 2001, , 561, 264

    2001

  68. [76]

    2013, , 51, 269

    Duch \^e ne , G., & Kraus , A. 2013, , 51, 269

    2013

  69. [77]

    N., Roy , N., et al

    Dutta , P., Chengalur , J. N., Roy , N., et al . 2014, , 442, 647

    2014

  70. [78]

    2015, , 454, 3597

    Dutta , S., Mondal , S., Jose , J., et al . 2015, , 454, 3597

    2015

  71. [79]

    R., & Jose , J

    Dutta , S., Mondal , S., Samal , M. R., & Jose , J. 2018, , 864, 154

    2018

  72. [80]

    Elmegreen , B. G. 2011, in EAS Publications Series, Vol. 51, EAS Publications Series, ed. C. Charbonnel & T. Montmerle , 45--58

    2011

  73. [81]

    G., & Lada , C

    Elmegreen , B. G., & Lada , C. J. 1977, , 214, 725

    1977

  74. [82]

    G., & Scalo , J

    Elmegreen , B. G., & Scalo , J. 2004, , 42, 211

    2004

  75. [83]

    J., Looney , L

    Encalada , F. J., Looney , L. W., Tobin , J. J., et al . 2021, , 913, 149

    2021

  76. [84]

    2019, , 875, 64

    Eswaraiah , C., Lai , S.-P., Ma , Y., et al . 2019, , 875, 64

    2019

  77. [85]

    R., et al

    Eswaraiah , C., Li , D., Samal , M. R., et al . 2020 a , , 897, 90

    2020

  78. [86]

    2020 b , , 897, 90

    ---. 2020 b , , 897, 90

    2020

  79. [87]

    S., et al

    Eswaraiah , C., Li , D., Furuya , R. S., et al . 2021, , 912, L27

    2021

  80. [88]

    S., Iapichino , L., & Beattie , J

    Federrath , C., Klessen , R. S., Iapichino , L., & Beattie , J. R. 2021, Nature Astronomy, 5, 365

    2021

  81. [89]

    Fedriani , R., Caratti o Garatti , A., Purser , S. J. D., et al . 2019, Nature Communications, 10, 3630

    2019

  82. [90]

    2020, Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion, 62, 014014

    Ferri \`e re , K. 2020, Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion, 62, 014014

    2020

  83. [91]

    B., Goldsmith , D

    Field , G. B., Goldsmith , D. W., & Habing , H. J. 1969, , 155, L149

    1969

  84. [92]

    2022, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2211.07653

    Fiorellino , E., Tychoniec , L., Cruz-Saenz de Miera , F., et al . 2022, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2211.07653

    2022 arXiv

  85. [93]

    J., Hillenbrand , L

    Fischer , W. J., Hillenbrand , L. A., Herczeg , G. J., et al . 2023, in Astronomical Society of the Pacific Conference Series, Vol. 534, Protostars and Planets VII, ed. S. Inutsuka , Y. Aikawa , T. Muto , K. Tomida , & M. Tamura , 355

    2023

  86. [94]

    Fisher , R. T. 2004, , 600, 769

    2004

  87. [95]

    2016, in Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers (SPIE) Conference Series, Vol

    Friberg , P., Bastien , P., Berry , D., et al . 2016, in Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers (SPIE) Conference Series, Vol. 9914, Millimeter, Submillimeter, and Far-Infrared Detectors and Instrumentation for Astronomy VIII, ed. W. S. Holland & J. Zmuidzinas , 991403

    2016

  88. [96]

    Galitzki , N., Ade , P. A. R., Angil \`e , F. E., et al . 2014, Journal of Astronomical Instrumentation, 3, 1440001

    2014

  89. [97]

    2020, in Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers (SPIE) Conference Series, Vol

    Ganesh , S., Rai , A., Aravind , K., et al . 2020, in Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers (SPIE) Conference Series, Vol. 11447, Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers (SPIE) Conference Series, 114479E

    2020

  90. [98]

    P., Mather , J

    Gardner , J. P., Mather , J. C., Clampin , M., et al . 2006, , 123, 485

    2006

  91. [99]

    T., & Widicus Weaver , S

    Garrod , R. T., & Widicus Weaver , S. L. 2013, Chemical Reviews, 113, 8939

    2013

  92. [100]

    T., Widicus Weaver , S

    Garrod , R. T., Widicus Weaver , S. L., & Herbst , E. 2008, , 682, 283

    2008

  93. [101]

    2017, , 466, 1903

    Gatto , A., Walch , S., Naab , T., et al . 2017, , 466, 1903

    2017

  94. [102]

    A., Mac Low , M.-M., Korpi-Lagg , M

    Gent , F. A., Mac Low , M.-M., Korpi-Lagg , M. J., & Singh , N. K. 2023, , 943, 176

    2023

  95. [103]

    A., Schutte , W

    Gerakines , P. A., Schutte , W. A., & Ehrenfreund , P. 1996, , 312, 289

    1996

  96. [104]

    P., et al

    Ghosh , A., Sharma , S., Ninan , J. P., et al . 2022, , 926, 68

    2022

  97. [105]

    2023, , 954, 82

    ---. 2023, , 954, 82

    2023

  98. [106]

    Ghosh , J., Methikkalam , R. R. J., Bhuin , R. G., et al . 2019, Proceedings of the National Academy of Science, 116, 1526

    2019

  99. [107]

    F., Mookerjea , B., Fuchs , G

    Giesen , T. F., Mookerjea , B., Fuchs , G. W., et al . 2020, , 633, A120

    2020

  100. [108]

    J., Krumholz , M

    Goldbaum , N. J., Krumholz , M. R., Matzner , C. D., & McKee , C. F. 2011, , 738, 101

    2011

  101. [109]

    F., Langer , W

    Goldsmith , P. F., Langer , W. D., Seo , Y., et al . 2021, , 916, 6

    2021

  102. [110]

    A., Alves , J., Beaumont , C

    Goodman , A. A., Alves , J., Beaumont , C. N., et al . 2014, , 797, 53

    2014

  103. [111]

    2020, , 895, 86

    Gorai , P., Bhat , B., Sil , M., et al . 2020, , 895, 86

    2020

  104. [112]

    J., & Salpeter , E

    Gould , R. J., & Salpeter , E. E. 1963, , 138, 393

    1963

  105. [113]

    Y., Guszejnov , D., Hopkins , P

    Grudi \'c , M. Y., Guszejnov , D., Hopkins , P. F., Offner , S. S. R., & Faucher-Gigu \`e re , C.-A. 2021, , 506, 2199

    2021

  106. [114]

    Y., Guszejnov , D., Offner , S

    Grudi \'c , M. Y., Guszejnov , D., Offner , S. S. R., et al . 2022, , 512, 216

    2022

  107. [115]

    2020, , 636, A16

    Guevara , C., Stutzki , J., Ossenkopf-Okada , V., et al . 2020, , 636, A16

    2020

  108. [116]

    2018, , 610, A77

    Hacar , A., Tafalla , M., Forbrich , J., et al . 2018, , 610, A77

    2018

  109. [117]

    2013, Chemical Reviews, 113, 8783

    Hama , T., & Watanabe , N. 2013, Chemical Reviews, 113, 8783

    2013

  110. [118]

    A., Runyan , M

    Harper , D. A., Runyan , M. C., Dowell , C. D., et al . 2018, Journal of Astronomical Instrumentation, 7, 1840008

    2018

  111. [119]

    2016, , 54, 135

    Hartmann , L., Herczeg , G., & Calvet , N. 2016, , 54, 135

    2016

  112. [120]

    I., Herbst , E., & Leung , C

    Hasegawa , T. I., Herbst , E., & Leung , C. M. 1992, , 82, 167

    1992

  113. [121]

    Heiles , C., & Troland , T. H. 2003, , 586, 1067

    2003

  114. [122]

    2007, , 465, 431

    Hennebelle , P., & Audit , E. 2007, , 465, 431

    2007

  115. [123]

    2008, , 684, 395

    Hennebelle , P., & Chabrier , G. 2008, , 684, 395

    2008

  116. [124]

    2024, , 136, 054302

    Henning , T., Kamp , I., Samland , M., et al . 2024, , 136, 054302

    2024

  117. [125]

    1973, , 185, 505

    Herbst , E., & Klemperer , W. 1973, , 185, 505

    1973

  118. [126]

    Herbst , E., & van Dishoeck , E. F. 2009, , 47, 427

    2009

  119. [127]

    F., Simon , R., Aladro , R., & Ricken , O

    Heyer , M., Goldsmith , P. F., Simon , R., Aladro , R., & Ricken , O. 2022, , 941, 62

    2022

  120. [128]

    S., Bintley , D., Chapin , E

    Holland , W. S., Bintley , D., Chapin , E. L., et al . 2013, , 430, 2513

    2013

  121. [129]

    J., & Tielens , A

    Hollenbach , D. J., & Tielens , A. G. G. M. 1999, Reviews of Modern Physics, 71, 173

    1999

  122. [130]

    Hopkins , A. M. 2018, , 35, e039

    2018

  123. [131]

    F., Kere s , D., O \ n orbe , J., et al

    Hopkins , P. F., Kere s , D., O \ n orbe , J., et al . 2014, , 445, 581

    2014

  124. [132]

    R., Andersen , M., et al

    Hosek , M., Lu , J. R., Andersen , M., et al . 2019, , 51, 439

    2019

  125. [133]

    2012, , 759, 35

    Inoue , T., & Inutsuka , S.-i. 2012, , 759, 35

    2012

  126. [134]

    2015, , 580, A49

    Inutsuka , S.-i., Inoue , T., Iwasaki , K., & Hosokawa , T. 2015, , 580, A49

    2015

  127. [135]

    J., et al

    Ioppolo , S., Fedoseev , G., Chuang , K. J., et al . 2021, Nature Astronomy, 5, 197

    2021

  128. [136]

    2018, , 615, A20

    Iqbal , W., & Wakelam , V. 2018, , 615, A20

    2018

  129. [137]

    2019, , 485, 1775

    Issac , N., Tej , A., Liu , T., et al . 2019, , 485, 1775

    2019

  130. [138]

    2020, , 499, 3620

    Issac , N., Tej , A., Liu , T., & Wu , Y. 2020, , 499, 3620

    2020

  131. [139]

    M., Finn , S

    Jackson , J. M., Finn , S. C., Chambers , E. T., Rathborne , J. M., & Simon , R. 2010, , 719, L185

    2010

  132. [140]

    M., Rathborne , J

    Jackson , J. M., Rathborne , J. M., Shah , R. Y., et al . 2006, , 163, 145

    2006

  133. [141]

    K., Belloche , A., & Garrod , R

    J rgensen , J. K., Belloche , A., & Garrod , R. T. 2020, , 58, 727

    2020

  134. [142]

    J., Samal , M

    Jose , J., Herczeg , G. J., Samal , M. R., Fang , Q., & Panwar , N. 2017, , 836, 98

    2017

  135. [143]

    K., Ojha , D

    Jose , J., Pandey , A. K., Ojha , D. K., et al . 2008, , 384, 1675

    2008

  136. [144]

    K., Ogura , K., et al

    Jose , J., Pandey , A. K., Ogura , K., et al . 2012, , 424, 2486

    2012

  137. [145]

    Kalberla , P. M. W., Kerp , J., & Haud , U. 2020, , 639, A26

    2020

  138. [146]

    2021, , 654, A91

    ---. 2021, , 654, A91

    2021

  139. [147]

    2006, in Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers (SPIE) Conference Series, Vol

    Kandori , R., Kusakabe , N., Tamura , M., et al . 2006, in Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers (SPIE) Conference Series, Vol. 6269, Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers (SPIE) Conference Series, ed. I. S. McLean & M. Iye , 626951

    2006

  140. [148]

    2011, , 737, L33

    Kanekar , N., Braun , R., & Roy , N. 2011, , 737, L33

    2011

  141. [149]

    K., et al

    Kaur , H., Sharma , S., Dewangan , L. K., et al . 2020, , 896, 29

    2020

  142. [150]

    1999, , 37, 190

    Kennicutt , Robert C., J. 1999, , 37, 190

    1999

  143. [151]

    2003, , 338, 545

    Kessel-Deynet , O., & Burkert , A. 2003, , 338, 545

    2003

  144. [152]

    Kim , J.-G., Kim , W.-T., & Ostriker , E. C. 2018, , 859, 68

    2018

  145. [153]

    2019, , 483, 593

    Koley , A., & Roy , N. 2019, , 483, 593

    2019

  146. [154]

    M., et al

    Koley , A., Roy , N., Menten , K. M., et al . 2021, , 501, 4825

    2021

  147. [155]

    P., & Datta , A

    Koley , A., Roy , N., Momjian , E., Sarma , A. P., & Datta , A. 2022, , 516, L48

    2022

  148. [156]

    2015, , 584, A91

    K \"o nyves , V., Andr \'e , P., Men'shchikov , A., et al . 2015, , 584, A91

    2015

  149. [157]

    R., Burkhart , B., Forbes , J

    Krumholz , M. R., Burkhart , B., Forbes , J. C., & Crocker , R. M. 2018, , 477, 2716

    2018

  150. [158]

    R., Klein , R

    Krumholz , M. R., Klein , R. I., & McKee , C. F. 2005, in Protostars and Planets V Posters, 8271

    2005

  151. [159]

    R., McKee , C

    Krumholz , M. R., McKee , C. F., & Bland-Hawthorn , J. 2019, , 57, 227

    2019

  152. [160]

    2023, , 524, 1219

    Kumar , S., Soam , A., & Roy , N. 2023, , 524, 1219

    2023

  153. [161]

    Larson , R. B. 1981, , 194, 809

    1981

  154. [162]

    P., Pandey , J

    Lata , S., Chen , W. P., Pandey , J. C., et al . 2023, , 520, 1092

    2023

  155. [163]

    T., & Meyer , D

    Lauroesch , J. T., & Meyer , D. M. 1999, , 519, L181

    1999

  156. [164]

    2018, Nature Communications, 9, 4636

    Lee , C.-F., Hwang , H.-C., Ching , T.-C., et al . 2018, Nature Communications, 9, 4636

    2018

  157. [165]

    2022, , 927, L27

    Lee , C.-F., Li , Z.-Y., Shang , H., & Hirano , N. 2022, , 927, L27

    2022

  158. [166]

    B., Goodman , A., Sridharan , T

    Li , H. B., Goodman , A., Sridharan , T. K., et al . 2014, in Protostars and Planets VI, ed. H. Beuther , R. S. Klessen , C. P. Dullemond , & T. Henning , 101

    2014

  159. [167]

    C., & Newman , J

    Licquia , T. C., & Newman , J. A. 2015, , 806, 96

    2015

  160. [168]

    A., \"O berg , K

    Loomis , R. A., \"O berg , K. I., Andrews , S. M., et al . 2020, , 893, 101

    2020

  161. [169]

    Mac Low , M.-M., & Klessen , R. S. 2004, Reviews of Modern Physics, 76, 125

    2004

  162. [170]

    Maheswar , G., Manoj , P., & Bhatt , H. C. 2002, , 387, 1003

    2002

  163. [171]

    2016, , 458, 1859

    Majumdar , L., Gratier , P., Vidal , T., et al . 2016, , 458, 1859

    2016

  164. [172]

    2018, , 477, 525

    Majumdar , L., Gratier , P., Wakelam , V., et al . 2018, , 477, 525

    2018

  165. [173]

    K., Ojha , D

    Mallick , K. K., Ojha , D. K., Tamura , M., et al . 2015, , 447, 2307

    2015

  166. [174]

    2014, , 443, 3218

    ---. 2014, , 443, 3218

    2014

  167. [175]

    F., Ansdell , M., Rosotti , G

    Manara , C. F., Ansdell , M., Rosotti , G. P., et al . 2023, in Astronomical Society of the Pacific Conference Series, Vol. 534, Protostars and Planets VII, ed. S. Inutsuka , Y. Aikawa , T. Muto , K. Tomida , & M. Tamura , 539

    2023

  168. [176]

    D., Megeath , S

    Manoj , P., Green , J. D., Megeath , S. T., et al . 2016, , 831, 69

    2016

  169. [177]

    2003, , 41, 15

    Massey , P. 2003, , 41, 15

    2003

  170. [178]

    S., & Federrath , C

    Mathew , S. S., & Federrath , C. 2021, , 507, 2448

    2021

  171. [179]

    S., Federrath , C., & Seta , A

    Mathew , S. S., Federrath , C., & Seta , A. 2022, , arXiv:2208.08802

    2022 arXiv

  172. [180]

    2021, , 916, 23

    Matsushita , Y., Takahashi , S., Ishii , S., et al . 2021, , 916, 23

    2021

  173. [181]

    2015, Spectrochimica Acta Part A: Molecular and Biomolecular Spectroscopy, 151, 1

    Maurya , A., & Rastogi , S. 2015, Spectrochimica Acta Part A: Molecular and Biomolecular Spectroscopy, 151, 1

    2015

  174. [182]

    McGuire , B. A. 2022, , 259, 30

    2022

  175. [183]

    A., Loomis , R

    McGuire , B. A., Loomis , R. A., Burkhardt , A. M., et al . 2021, Science, 371, 1265

    2021

  176. [184]

    F., & Ostriker , J

    McKee , C. F., & Ostriker , J. P. 1977, , 218, 148

    1977

  177. [185]

    1940, , 52, 187

    McKellar , A. 1940, , 52, 187

    1940

  178. [186]

    1966, , 133, 265

    Mestel , L. 1966, , 133, 265

    1966

  179. [187]

    Methikkalam , R. R. J., Pavithraa , S., Murali Babu , S. P., et al . 2016, Advances in Space Research, 58, 438

    2016

  180. [188]

    J., & Williams , D

    Millar , T. J., & Williams , D. A. 1975, , 173, 527

    1975

  181. [189]

    C., & Kataoka , A

    Miotello , A., Kamp , I., Birnstiel , T., Cleeves , L. C., & Kataoka , A. 2023, in Astronomical Society of the Pacific Conference Series, Vol. 534, Protostars and Planets VII, ed. S. Inutsuka , Y. Aikawa , T. Muto , K. Tomida , & M. Tamura , 501

    2023

  182. [190]

    M., Papamastorakis , J., Boumis , P., & Goudis , C

    Misiriotis , A., Xilouris , E. M., Papamastorakis , J., Boumis , P., & Goudis , C. D. 2006, , 459, 113

    2006

  183. [191]

    S., & Srinivasan , G

    Mohan , R., Dwarakanath , K. S., & Srinivasan , G. 2004, Journal of Astrophysics and Astronomy, 25, 143

    2004

  184. [192]

    2022, , 514, 3709

    Mohan , S., Vig , S., & Mandal , S. 2022, , 514, 3709

    2022

  185. [193]

    P., & Tej , A

    Mohan , S., Vig , S., Varricatt , W. P., & Tej , A. 2023, , 942, 76

    2023

  186. [194]

    2010, , 122, 314

    Molinari , S., Swinyard , B., Bally , J., et al . 2010, , 122, 314

    2010

  187. [195]

    2021, , 366, 23

    Mondal , A., Chattopadhyay , T., & Sen , A. 2021, , 366, 23

    2021

  188. [196]

    K., Iqbal , W., Gorai , P., et al

    Mondal , S. K., Iqbal , W., Gorai , P., et al . 2022, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2211.03066

    2022 arXiv

  189. [197]

    2022, , 926, 4

    Mookerjea , B. 2022, , 926, 4

    2022

  190. [198]

    K., Rengarajan , T

    Mookerjea , B., Ghosh , S. K., Rengarajan , T. N., Tandon , S. N., & Verma , R. P. 2000, , 539, 775

    2000

  191. [199]

    2019, , 626, A131

    Mookerjea , B., Sandell , G., G \"u sten , R., et al . 2019, , 626, A131

    2019

  192. [200]

    2023, , 525, 5468

    ---. 2023, , 525, 5468

    2023

  193. [201]

    S., et al

    Mookerjea , B., Sandell , G., Veena , V. S., et al . 2021, , 648, A40

    2021

  194. [202]

    2010, , 521, L13

    Mookerjea , B., Giesen , T., Stutzki , J., et al . 2010, , 521, L13

    2010

  195. [203]

    E., Gerin , M., et al

    Mookerjea , B., Hassel , G. E., Gerin , M., et al . 2012, , 546, A75

    2012

  196. [204]

    2018, , 56, 41

    Motte , F., Bontemps , S., & Louvet , F. 2018, , 56, 41

    2018

  197. [205]

    2022, , 662, A8

    Motte , F., Bontemps , S., Csengeri , T., et al . 2022, , 662, A8

    2022

  198. [206]

    E., Stanimirovi \'c , S., Goss , W

    Murray , C. E., Stanimirovi \'c , S., Goss , W. M., et al . 2018, , 238, 14

    2018

  199. [207]

    2020, , 496, 1803

    Nandakumar , M., & Dutta , P. 2020, , 496, 1803

    2020

  200. [208]

    2023, , 526, 4690

    ---. 2023, , 526, 4690

    2023

  201. [209]

    2023, , 524, 5166

    Nidhi , S., Mathew , B., Shridharan , B., et al . 2023, , 524, 5166

    2023

  202. [210]

    P., Ojha , D

    Ninan , J. P., Ojha , D. K., Bhatt , B. C., et al . 2013, , 778, 116

    2013

  203. [211]

    P., Ojha , D

    Ninan , J. P., Ojha , D. K., Baug , T., et al . 2015, , 815, 4

    2015

  204. [212]

    Offner , S. S. R., Kratter , K. M., Matzner , C. D., Krumholz , M. R., & Klein , R. I. 2010, , 725, 1485

    2010

  205. [213]

    Offner , S. S. R., Moe , M., Kratter , K. M., et al . 2022, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2203.10066

    2022 arXiv

  206. [214]

    K., Ghosh , S

    Ojha , D. K., Ghosh , S. K., Kulkarni , V. K., et al . 2004 a , , 415, 1039

    2004

  207. [215]

    K., Tamura , M., Nakajima , Y., et al

    Ojha , D. K., Tamura , M., Nakajima , Y., et al . 2009, , 693, 634

    2009

  208. [216]

    2004 b , , 616, 1042

    ---. 2004 b , , 616, 1042

    2004

  209. [217]

    M., Lopez , L

    Olivier , G. M., Lopez , L. A., Rosen , A. L., et al . 2021, , 908, 68

    2021

  210. [218]

    2002, , 576, 870

    Padoan , P., & Nordlund , A . 2002, , 576, 870

    2002

  211. [219]

    Palla , F., & Stahler , S. W. 2000, , 540, 255

    2000

  212. [220]

    K., Sharma , S., Ogura , K., et al

    Pandey , A. K., Sharma , S., Ogura , K., et al . 2008, , 383, 1241

    2008

  213. [221]

    2020, , 891, 81

    Pandey , R., Sharma , S., Panwar , N., et al . 2020, , 891, 81

    2020

  214. [222]

    D., Chatterjee , R., Csengeri , T., et al

    Pandian , J. D., Chatterjee , R., Csengeri , T., et al . 2024, , 966, 54

    2024

  215. [223]

    Panwar , N., Kumar , A., & Pandey , S. B. 2022, Journal of Astrophysics and Astronomy, 43, 7

    2022

  216. [224]

    2024, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2406.08261

    Panwar , N., Rishi , C., Sharma , S., et al . 2024, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2406.08261

    2024 arXiv

  217. [225]

    K., et al

    Panwar , N., Sharma , S., Ojha , D. K., et al . 2020, , 905, 61

    2020

  218. [226]

    Pathak , A., & Sarre , P. J. 2008, , 391, L10

    2008

  219. [227]

    N., Kanekar , N., Chengalur , J

    Patra , N. N., Kanekar , N., Chengalur , J. N., & Roy , N. 2018, , 479, L7

    2018

  220. [228]

    N., & Roy , N

    Patra , N. N., & Roy , N. 2024, , 529, 4037

    2024

  221. [229]

    2022, , 164, 129

    Patra , S., Evans , Neal J., I., Kim , K.-T., et al . 2022, , 164, 129

    2022

  222. [230]

    2024, , 970, 88

    Patra , S., Jose , J., & Evans , Neal J., I. 2024, , 970, 88

    2024

  223. [231]

    2022, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2203.11179

    Pattle , K., Fissel , L., Tahani , M., Liu , T., & Ntormousi , E. 2022, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2203.11179

    2022 arXiv

  224. [232]

    Pavithraa , S., Methikkalam , R. R. J., Gorai , P., et al . 2017, Spectrochimica Acta Part A: Molecular Spectroscopy, 178, 166

    2017

  225. [233]

    A., Andr \'e , P., et al

    Peretto , N., Fuller , G. A., Andr \'e , P., et al . 2014, , 561, A83

    2014

  226. [234]

    E., Arzoumanian , D., Andr \'e , P., et al

    Pineda , J. E., Arzoumanian , D., Andr \'e , P., et al . 2022, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2205.03935

    2022 arXiv

  227. [235]

    1997, , 475, L69

    Pirronello , V., Liu , C., Shen , L., & Vidali , G. 1997, , 475, L69

    1997

  228. [236]

    M., Salyk , C., Banzatti , A., et al

    Pontoppidan , K. M., Salyk , C., Banzatti , A., et al . 2024, , 963, 158

    2024

  229. [237]

    A., Henry , T

    Raghavan , D., McAlister , H. A., Henry , T. J., et al . 2010, , 190, 1

    2010

  230. [238]

    S., Joshi , G

    Rautela , B. S., Joshi , G. C., & Pandey , J. C. 2004, Bulletin of the Astronomical Society of India, 32, 159

    2004

  231. [239]

    R., Walker , D

    Rawat , V., Samal , M. R., Walker , D. L., et al . 2024 a , , 528, 2199

    2024

  232. [240]

    R., Eswaraiah , C., et al

    Rawat , V., Samal , M. R., Eswaraiah , C., et al . 2024 b , , 528, 1460

    2024

  233. [241]

    P., & Ferreira , J

    Ray , T. P., & Ferreira , J. 2021, , 93, 101615

    2021

  234. [242]

    R., Carrasco-Gonz \'a lez , C., Rodr \' guez , L

    Rodr \' guez-Kamenetzky , A. R., Carrasco-Gonz \'a lez , C., Rodr \' guez , L. F., et al . 2022, , 931, L26

    2022

  235. [243]

    Rosen , A. L. 2022, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2204.09700

    2022 arXiv

  236. [244]

    N., & Srianand , R

    Roy , N., Chengalur , J. N., & Srianand , R. 2006, , 365, L1

    2006

  237. [245]

    L., et al

    Roy , N., Frank , S., Carilli , C. L., et al . 2017, , 834, 171

    2017

  238. [246]

    Roy , N., Kanekar , N., & Chengalur , J. N. 2013, , 436, 2366

    2013

  239. [247]

    2022, , 516, 1983

    Saha , A., Tej , A., Liu , H.-L., et al . 2022, , 516, 1983

    2022

  240. [248]

    2021, , 502, 5313

    Saha , P., Bharadwaj , S., Chakravorty , S., et al . 2021, , 502, 5313

    2021

  241. [249]

    2020, , 899, 65

    Sahu , D., Liu , S.-Y., Das , A., Garai , P., & Wakelam , V. 2020, , 899, 65

    2020

  242. [250]

    2021, Frontiers in Astronomy and Space Sciences, 8, 137

    Sahu , D., Liu , S.-Y., & Liu , T. 2021, Frontiers in Astronomy and Space Sciences, 8, 137

    2021

  243. [251]

    C., Lee , C.-F., et al

    Sahu , D., Minh , Y. C., Lee , C.-F., et al . 2018, , 475, 5322

    2018

  244. [252]

    2014, , 791, L38

    Sakai , N., Oya , Y., Sakai , T., et al . 2014, , 791, L38

    2014

  245. [253]

    Salpeter , E. E. 1955, , 121, 161

    1955

  246. [254]

    R., Deharveng , L., Zavagno , A., et al

    Samal , M. R., Deharveng , L., Zavagno , A., et al . 2018, , 617, A67

    2018

  247. [255]

    R., Pandey , A

    Samal , M. R., Pandey , A. K., Ojha , D. K., et al . 2010, , 714, 1015

    2010

  248. [256]

    R., Ojha , D

    Samal , M. R., Ojha , D. K., Jose , J., et al . 2015, , 581, A5

    2015

  249. [257]

    2016, , 591, A40

    Schneider , N., Bontemps , S., Motte , F., et al . 2016, , 591, A40

    2016

  250. [258]

    2020, , 132, 104301

    Schneider , N., Simon , R., Guevara , C., et al . 2020, , 132, 104301

    2020

  251. [259]

    S., et al

    Schuller , F., Csengeri , T., Urquhart , J. S., et al . 2017, , 601, A124

    2017

  252. [260]

    S., Csengeri , T., et al

    Schuller , F., Urquhart , J. S., Csengeri , T., et al . 2021, , 500, 3064

    2021

  253. [261]

    2022, , 514, 957

    Seta , A., & Federrath , C. 2022, , 514, 957

    2022

  254. [262]

    W., & Seshadri , T

    Sharma , E., Gopinathan , M., Soam , A., Lee , C. W., & Seshadri , T. R. 2022 a , , 517, 1138

    2022

  255. [263]

    2022 b , , 658, A55

    Sharma , E., Maheswar , G., & Dib , S. 2022 b , , 658, A55

    2022

  256. [264]

    2020 a , , 639, A133

    Sharma , E., Gopinathan , M., Soam , A., et al . 2020 a , , 639, A133

    2020

  257. [265]

    K., Ogura , K., et al

    Sharma , S., Pandey , A. K., Ogura , K., et al . 2008, , 135, 1934

    2008

  258. [266]

    K., Ojha , D

    Sharma , S., Pandey , A. K., Ojha , D. K., et al . 2017, , 467, 2943

    2017

  259. [267]

    2007, , 380, 1141

    ---. 2007, , 380, 1141

    2007

  260. [268]

    K., Pandey , J

    Sharma , S., Pandey , A. K., Pandey , J. C., et al . 2012 a , , 64, 107

    2012

  261. [269]

    2012 b , , 64, 107

    ---. 2012 b , , 64, 107

    2012

  262. [270]

    K., et al

    Sharma , S., Ghosh , A., Ojha , D. K., et al . 2020 b , , 498, 2309

    2020

  263. [271]

    K., Tandon , P., Kumar , R., et al

    Singh , K. K., Tandon , P., Kumar , R., et al . 2021, , 506, 2059

    2021

  264. [272]

    P., & Banerjee , S

    Sivaraman , B., Mukherjee , R., Subramanian , K. P., & Banerjee , S. B. 2015, , 798, 72

    2015

  265. [273]

    Smith , I. W. M. 2011, , 49, 29

    2011

  266. [274]

    P., Le Page , V., Keheyan , Y., & Bierbaum , V

    Snow , T. P., Le Page , V., Keheyan , Y., & Bierbaum , V. M. 1998, , 391, 259

    1998

  267. [275]

    2024, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2402.18840

    Soam , A., Eswaraiah , C., Seta , A., Dewangan , L., & G , M. 2024, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2402.18840

    2024 arXiv

  268. [276]

    W., Neha , S., & Andersson , B

    Soam , A., Maheswar , G., Lee , C. W., Neha , S., & Andersson , B. G. 2017, , 465, 559

    2017

  269. [277]

    W., Andersson , B

    Soam , A., Lee , C. W., Andersson , B. G., et al . 2019, , 883, 9

    2019

  270. [278]

    G., Strai z ys , V., et al

    Soam , A., Andersson , B. G., Strai z ys , V., et al . 2021, , 161, 149

    2021

  271. [279]

    2022, , 515, 3524

    Srivastav , S., Sil , M., Gorai , P., et al . 2022, , 515, 3524

    2022

  272. [280]

    M., Pei , Z., Tuttle , K., & Green , J

    Stanimirovi \'c , S., Weisberg , J. M., Pei , Z., Tuttle , K., & Green , J. T. 2010, , 720, 415

    2010

  273. [281]

    1937, , 86, 483

    Swings , P., & Rosenfeld , L. 1937, , 86, 483

    1937

  274. [282]

    Tan , J. C. 2015, in IAU General Assembly, Vol. 29, 2254046

    2015

  275. [283]

    K., Kulkarni , V

    Tej , A., Ghosh , S. K., Kulkarni , V. K., et al . 2007, , 468, 1001

    2007

  276. [284]

    Tielens , A. G. G. M. 2008, , 46, 289

    2008

  277. [285]

    W., et al

    Tiwari , M., Karim , R., Pound , M. W., et al . 2021, , 914, 117

    2021

  278. [286]

    W., et al

    Tiwari , M., Wolfire , M., Pound , M. W., et al . 2022, , 164, 150

    2022

  279. [287]

    J., Looney , L., Li , Z.-Y., et al

    Tobin , J. J., Looney , L., Li , Z.-Y., et al . 2016 a , in American Astronomical Society Meeting Abstracts, Vol. 227, American Astronomical Society Meeting Abstracts \#227, 205.03

    2016

  280. [288]

    J., Looney , L

    Tobin , J. J., Looney , L. W., Li , Z.-Y., et al . 2016 b , , 818, 73

    2016

  281. [289]

    J., Sheehan , P

    Tobin , J. J., Sheehan , P. D., Reynolds , N., et al . 2020, , 905, 162

    2020

  282. [290]

    J., Offner , S

    Tobin , J. J., Offner , S. S. R., Kratter , K. M., et al . 2022, , 925, 39

    2022

  283. [291]

    F., Grant , S., Tabone , B., et al

    van Dishoeck , E. F., Grant , S., Tabone , B., et al . 2023, Faraday Discussions, 245, 52

    2023

  284. [292]

    2022, , 517, 5780

    Vats , A., & Pathak , A. 2022, , 517, 5780

    2022

  285. [293]

    S., Vig , S., Mookerjea , B., et al

    Veena , V. S., Vig , S., Mookerjea , B., et al . 2018, , 852, 93

    2018

  286. [294]

    S., Schilke , P., S \'a nchez-Monge , \'A ., et al

    Veena , V. S., Schilke , P., S \'a nchez-Monge , \'A ., et al . 2021, , 921, L42

    2021

  287. [295]

    K., Ojha , D

    Vig , S., Ghosh , S. K., Ojha , D. K., & Verma , R. P. 2007, , 463, 175

    2007

  288. [296]

    S., Mandal , S., Tej , A., & Ghosh , S

    Vig , S., Veena , V. S., Mandal , S., Tej , A., & Ghosh , S. K. 2018, , 474, 3808

    2018

  289. [297]

    2021, Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics (Incorporating Faraday Transactions), 23, 24052

    Vishwakarma , G., Ghosh , J., & Pradeep , T. 2021, Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics (Incorporating Faraday Transactions), 23, 24052

    2021

  290. [298]

    K., & Dutta , P

    Vishwakarma , P. K., & Dutta , P. 2020, , 491, 2360

    2020

  291. [299]

    D., & Salpeter , E

    Watson , W. D., & Salpeter , E. E. 1972, , 175, 659

    1972

  292. [300]

    J., Lefloch , B., Fridlund , C

    White , G. J., Lefloch , B., Fridlund , C. V. M., et al . 1997, , 323, 931

    1997

Pith tools

Reviewed August 10, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.