Pith. sign in

REVIEW 4 major objections 5 minor 1 cited by

MeerKAT radio continuum imaging of nearby star-forming spirals in the NGC 6221, NGC 3256/3263, and NGC 2434 galaxy groups

T0 review · 4 major / 5 minor · reviewed 2026-08-06 · deepseek-v4-flash

Challenge this review Re-run · record.json Download PDF Read on arXiv ↗ Review JSON

Pith's one-line read This paper finds that fourteen galaxies in three groups at different evolutionary stages obey the W3PAH-radio star-formation correlation, with mean qW3PAH = 2.5 ± 0.1, while ESO 059-G012 deviates by 3-sigma because its gas is exhausted.

desk verdict Useful MeerKAT continuum products and resolved maps, wrapped in a few claims that outrun the data; worth refereeing and worth accepting after moderate revisions. read the letter →

arxiv 2506.22382 v2 pith:KQFDCZVC submitted 2025-06-27 astro-ph.GA

J. Saponara , B. S. Koribalski , J. English , P. K. Humire This is my paper · ORCID
classification astro-ph.GA
keywords galaxygroupsradiocontinuumstarformationinfrared-radiocorrelationWISEW3PAHMeerKATspectralindexinteractions
verification ladder T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal

The pith

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The reading

This paper combines new high-resolution MeerKAT 1.3 GHz radio continuum maps with archival WISE mid-infrared photometry to measure star formation in fourteen member galaxies of three nearby groups chosen to represent early, intermediate, and late stages of group evolution. Its central claim is that the infrared-radio correlation survives in all three environments once the infrared side is restricted to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon emission: the corrected W3PAH flux (WISE W3 minus 15.8% of W1) tracks the 1.3 GHz radio flux with slope $m = 0.99 \pm 0.11$, scatter $\sigma = 0.3$, and mean $q_{\mathrm{W3PAH}} = 2.5 \pm 0.1$. The one galaxy that departs by more than $3\sigma$ is ESO 059-G012 in the evolved NGC 2434 group, which is radio-weak compared with its W3PAH emission; the paper reads this as a galaxy that has already used up its gas, so its dust is heated by older stars rather than by ongoing star formation. A reader should care because a tight, environment-independent W3PAH-radio relation would make the $q$ parameter a practical single-number diagnostic for spotting quenched or AGN-dominated galaxies inside groups.

What carries the argument

The argument rests on the W3PAH-radio correlation and its $q_{\mathrm{W3PAH}}$ parameter. The machinery is the PAH-corrected WISE flux $F_{\mathrm{W3PAH}} = F_{\mathrm{W3}} - 0.158\,F_{\mathrm{W1}}$, which is meant to remove the contribution of evolved stellar populations from the 12 $\mu$m band and leave emission from polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in photodissociation regions, a direct tracer of recent star formation; this is compared against MeerKAT 1.3 GHz continuum, which traces free-free emission from ionized gas and synchrotron emission from supernova-accelerated cosmic-ray electrons. The correlation is quantified by the logarithm of the ratio of W3PAH flux to radio flux, normalized in the standard $q$-parameter convention, so deviations from the mean flag changes in either the star-forming gas or the radio-emitting relativistic particles. The same corrected flux also feeds a W3PAH-to-total-infrared calibration, while WISE colour-colour placement and in-band spectral index maps separate thermal and non-thermal regions and locate AGN candidates, providing the physical interpretation for each outlier.

What would settle it

Map the cold gas of ESO 059-G012 in CO(1-0) or deep H I to a sensitivity reaching its radio continuum upper limit. If a substantial molecular or atomic reservoir is present, the 'gas already consumed' interpretation fails and the high $q_{\mathrm{W3PAH}}$ would instead trace a problem with the W3PAH correction; if the galaxy is genuinely gas-poor, the interpretation is confirmed. Repeating the same $q$ measurement with an independent PAH tracer, such as the 7.7 $\mu$m or 11.3 $\mu$m PAH features, would separate tracer artifacts from real quenched galaxies.

Watch

Extended reading notes

Core claim

On the paper's own terms, the discovery is that the W3PAH-radio correlation, measured with a PAH-only infrared tracer, holds across three galaxy groups at different evolutionary stages. The paper obtains this by detecting 1.3 GHz continuum in fourteen group members with MeerKAT (synthesized beams of roughly $7{-}9$ arcsec and rms $3{-}7\,\mu$Jy beam$^{-1}$), measuring matched-aperture WISE W1, W2 and W3 fluxes, and forming $F_{\mathrm{W3PAH}} = F_{\mathrm{W3}} - 0.158\,F_{\mathrm{W1}}$ to remove evolved stellar contamination. A least-squares fit to $\log F_{1.3\,\mathrm{GHz}}$ versus $\log F_{\mathrm{W3PAH}}$ gives slope $0.99 \pm 0.11$ and scatter $0.3$; the mean $q_{\mathrm{W3PAH}} = 2.5 \pm 0.1$ agrees, within errors, with comparison samples, while ESO 059-G012 sits at $q_{\mathrm{W3PAH}} = 3.7$, three times more infrared than radio than the empirical relation predicts. The paper interprets this outlier, together with the negative W3PAH flux of NGC 2434, as evidence that late-stage group members can exhaust their star-forming gas; it also uses resolved $q_{\mathrm{W3PAH}}$ maps to locate AGN radio excess in the cores of NGC 3256 and NGC 6221, and spectral index maps to connect steep-spectrum synchrotron emission in the NGC 3256/3263 group to tidal interactions.

Load-bearing premise

The load-bearing premise is that the W3PAH flux, obtained by subtracting 15.8% of the W1 flux from the W3 flux, isolates polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon emission that traces only star-forming regions; if old stellar light leaks into W3PAH for some galaxies, the identification of ESO 059-G012 as gas-exhausted would be an artifact of that correction rather than a real evolutionary state.

Editorial extensions

If this is right

  • If the W3PAH-radio relation is as tight as this sample shows, W3PAH can be used as a dust-unbiased star-formation tracer inside galaxy groups, and radio continuum alone can be translated into star-formation rate at the same precision for normal star-forming members.
  • A mean $q_{\mathrm{W3PAH}} = 2.5 \pm 0.1$ that is independent of radio and infrared luminosity means a single calibration constant can be applied across group members spanning dwarf galaxies to merging spirals.
  • Outlier galaxies with $q_{\mathrm{W3PAH}} \gtrsim 3$ are plausibly gas-exhausted, so the $q$ parameter can be used to identify quenched galaxies in group and cluster surveys.
  • Central $q_{\mathrm{W3PAH}}$ values below about 0.5 coincide with known or suspected low-luminosity AGN in NGC 3256 and NGC 6221, making resolved $q$ maps a viable AGN-finding tool in interacting systems.
  • Spectral index maps that steepen away from galaxy disks and toward tidal tails, as seen for NGC 3263 and NGC 3256B, would confirm that tidal interactions accelerate cosmic rays and boost non-thermal radio emission.

Reading between the lines

Editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

  • A direct test of the gas-exhaustion reading of ESO 059-G012 would be CO(1-0) or deep H I mapping: if a substantial cold gas reservoir is found, the high $q_{\mathrm{W3PAH}}$ value would more likely reflect a calibration or tracer problem than a quenched galaxy.
  • The same MeerKAT-plus-WISE measurement, applied to complete group samples, could turn the $q_{\mathrm{W3PAH}}$ distribution into a group-evolution clock, since the paper's three stages produce different colour-colour placements and, in the late stage, gas-poor outliers.
  • The paper itself cautions that the SED-derived dust content for NGC 2434 and ESO 059-G012 is weakly constrained by sparse infrared photometry; additional far-infrared measurements would decide whether these are truly quenched or simply under-fitted.
Share X Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit HN

Signed reviews

No signed human review yet.

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, and a circularity audit.

Referee Report

4 major / 5 minor

Summary. The paper presents MeerKAT 1.3 GHz radio continuum images and WISE mid-infrared photometry for galaxies in three nearby groups (NGC 6221, NGC 3256/3263, NGC 2434) chosen to represent early, intermediate, and late stages of group evolution. The authors measure radio flux densities, compute in-band spectral index maps, derive star formation rates from radio and W3PAH luminosities, and analyze the radio-W3PAH correlation. The central result is that all but one galaxy, ESO 059-G012, follow the radio-W3PAH relation; the outlier is interpreted as having already consumed its gas. The paper also discusses the Vela Cloud, evidence for low-luminosity AGN in NGC 6221 and NGC 3256, and compares SFRs derived from the two tracers.

Significance. If substantiated, the finding that the radio-W3PAH relation holds across group evolutionary stages supports the use of W3PAH as a star formation tracer in dense environments and identifies a candidate quenched galaxy in a late-stage group. The radio continuum images and the photometric catalogues are a useful observational contribution, and the data are made available through the SARAO archive and CDS. The paper uses a standard, well-tested MeerKAT pipeline and provides internal checks of the WISE photometry against catalogued values. However, the sample is small, and the outlier interpretation rests on a fixed stellar-subtraction prescription whose validity for quiescent early-type galaxies is not established.

major comments (4)
  1. [Section 3.4] The identification of ESO 059-G012 as the sole outlier, and the subsequent interpretation that it has consumed its gas, depends critically on the Cluver et al. (2017) prescription FW3PAH = W3 - 0.158*W1. This subtraction factor is calibrated on star-forming galaxies, and the manuscript itself shows its limitation for early-type systems: NGC 2434, another member of the late-stage group, has FW3PAH < 0 and is excluded from the analysis. If the true stellar contribution to W3 in quiescent early-type galaxies exceeds 0.158*W1, then FW3PAH is overestimated, qW3PAH is inflated, and ESO 059-G012's apparent radio deficiency becomes a subtraction artifact rather than evidence of gas exhaustion. The authors' own caveat in Section 4.1 ("the low dust content derived from the SED fitting of the galaxies NGC 2434 and ESO59-G012 might result from limitations in the model due to the lack of infrared data") reinforces that this is unverified. I request a robustness test: vary the subtraction factor over a plausible range (e.g., 0.10-0.25) and demonstrate that ESO 059-G012 remains an outlier, or alternatively use an independent PAH tracer or a model-based stellar contribution to W3.
  2. [Section 3.4] The mean value qW3PAH = 2.5 ± 0.1 is quoted without stating explicitly whether ESO 059-G012 is excluded. If the galaxy with qW3PAH = 3.7 is included, the mean would be substantially higher; if it is excluded, this should be stated. The same ambiguity applies to the fit parameters m = 0.99 ± 0.11 and b = 10.9 ± 1.4 in Eq. (1). Please clarify the exact sample used for the mean and the fit, and report the number of galaxies included.
  3. [Section 4.2.3] The abstract claims that the interaction among NGC 3263, NGC 3256B, and NGC 3256C is "causing the Vela Cloud complex," but this goes beyond the data presented in the paper. The Vela Cloud is an H I structure (English et al. 2010) that is not detected in the radio continuum or WISE data of this work, and no new kinematic or morphological evidence is presented to establish causation. The text in Section 4.2.3 correctly attributes the scenario to English et al. (2010). The abstract and summary should be reworded to 'consistent with the scenario proposed by English et al. (2010)' or similar, unless new evidence is explicitly presented.
  4. [Section 3.5] The SED fitting results for ESO 059-G012 and NGC 2434 have extremely large uncertainties (e.g., TMC for NGC 2434 is 10.1+10.5-10.1 K, essentially unconstrained). These results are used in Section 4.1 to support the interpretation that ESO 059-G012 has low dust content and hence has consumed its gas. Given the wide confidence ranges, the SED fitting cannot distinguish a genuinely quenched system from a poorly constrained model. I recommend either removing the physical interpretation based on these SED results for the two galaxies, or explicitly presenting them as speculative rather than supportive evidence.
minor comments (5)
  1. [Appendix C] In the caption of Fig. C.1, 'ESO 59-G0012' appears to be a typo for 'ESO 059-G012'.
  2. [Table 1] The uncertainty on the spectral index for NGC 3256 is listed as -0.9 ± 0.01, which seems implausibly small for an in-band determination over 324 MHz; check whether this should be ±0.1.
  3. [Equation (2)] Equation (2) defines qW3PAH using F1.4GHz in the denominator, but the text states that the radio flux is measured at 1.3 GHz. Please clarify whether the flux is converted to 1.4 GHz or whether the notation is inconsistent.
  4. [Table 3] There are inconsistencies between SFR values quoted in the text and Table 3: for NGC 3256 the text gives SFRW3PAH = 34 M_sun/yr while Table 3 lists 50; for NGC 3256B the text gives 1.4 while Table 3 lists 2.1. Please harmonize the values.
  5. [Figure 4] The bottom panel is described as a 'histogram of the squared differences between observed and fitted values,' but the figure appears to show a scatter plot of residuals or a distribution; please clarify the plot type and axes.

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged · score 0.0 of 10

No significant circularity: the radio-W3PAH test uses independent MeerKAT fluxes and an explicitly external W3PAH definition, and the outlier and external comparisons give the central claim independent content.

full rationale

The central claimed result is that most galaxies in the sample follow the radio-W3PAH correlation, with ESO 059-G012 as the exception. The radio fluxes are new MeerKAT measurements, and the W3PAH fluxes are defined by an external prescription from Cluver et al. (2017), FW3PAH = W3 - 0.158*W1, not fitted to the radio data in this paper. The correlation therefore has independent empirical content: it could have failed, and in fact it fails for ESO 059-G012. The fit in Eq. 1 is descriptive, but the paper does not present the fitted line as an independent prediction; the qW3PAH mean is a summary of the same ratio, and its significance is anchored by comparison with external relations (Yun et al. 2001; Shao et al. 2018; Grundy et al. 2023). The TIR-radio fit is a coordinate transform of the W3PAH-radio fit through the explicitly stated Cluver et al. (2017) TIR calibration, so it is not a hidden independent confirmation. The exclusion of NGC 2434 (negative FW3PAH) is a consequence of the external subtraction formula and is openly stated; whether that formula extrapolates to quiescent early-type galaxies is an accuracy or assumption concern, not a circularity. Self-citations (Koribalski & Dickey 2004; English et al. 2010; Koribalski et al. 2024) supply H I context and data-processing details rather than the load-bearing correlation claim. No step in the paper reduces, by construction or by self-citation, to its own inputs.

Assumptions & free parameters 5 free parameters · 5 assumptions · 0 invented entities

The paper introduces no new physical entities. Its conclusions rest on empirical calibrations of the radio-SFR, W3PAH-SFR, and W3PAH-TIR relations, on the WISE colour diagnostics, and on the GalaPy SED model. The free parameters are calibration constants and model priors inherited from the literature or chosen by the authors for the SED fitting. The central qW3PAH and SFR values therefore combine two empirically calibrated quantities, and their mutual agreement is partly structured by the shared infrared-radio correlation.

free parameters (5)
  • WISE W3PAH subtraction factor = 0.158 (15.8% of W1)
    The factor is taken from Cluver et al. (2017), who calibrated it empirically. The paper's central relation (Eq. 1 and mean qW3PAH = 2.5) depends on this factor, and deviations from it would change the inferred correlation.
  • SFR-to-radio proportionality constants = 0.03 (Condon et al. 2002) and 4.76 (mass extrapolation)
    The SFR20 values in Table 3 use these empirically calibrated constants. They are not fitted in this paper, but they are external empirical calibrations rather than first-principles values, and the central SFR conclusions depend on them.
  • SFR-W3PAH calibration constants = 1.13 slope and -10.24 intercept (Cluver et al. 2014)
    Equation 5 is taken from Cluver et al. (2014). The agreement between SFR20 and SFRW3PAH is therefore partly a test of the consistency of two external calibrations, not an independent check.
  • TIR-W3PAH calibration = 0.889 slope and 2.21 intercept (Cluver et al. 2017)
    Equation 3 is used to convert W3PAH luminosity to total infrared luminosity, and the resulting qTIR values inherit this external calibration.
  • GalaPy SED parameters = Table E.1 lists ranges for age, tau_star, psi_max, f_PAH, etc.
    The SED fitting uses a large number of free parameters with prior ranges chosen by the authors. The resulting stellar masses, SFRs, and dust temperatures are weakly constrained by the sparse photometry, but these derived quantities are used for the main-sequence comparison and for the discussion of ESO 059-G012 and NGC 2434.
assumptions (5)
  • domain assumption The 15.8% W1 subtraction correctly isolates PAH emission in W3 from stellar photospheric contamination.
    Used in Section 3.4 to compute the W3PAH flux densities listed in Table 1 and all qW3PAH values. The factor comes from Cluver et al. (2017), and the paper does not recalibrate it for this sample.
  • domain assumption The radio continuum at 1.3 GHz traces star formation with a fixed relation, including the thermal and synchrotron components.
    Used in Section 3.6 to compute SFR20 via Eq. 4. The calibration is from Condon et al. (2002) and assumes the standard radio-SFR relation holds for these galaxies.
  • domain assumption The W3PAH luminosity traces the total infrared luminosity through the Cluver et al. (2017) relation.
    Used in Eq. 3 in Section 3.4 to estimate log(FTIR) and qTIR. This is an extrapolation of an empirical relation calibrated on a different sample.
  • domain assumption Chabrier IMF and the GalaPy In-Situ model are appropriate for these galaxies.
    Stated in Section 3.5 and Appendix E. The SED-derived stellar masses and SFRs that locate the galaxies relative to the main sequence depend on this modeling choice.
  • domain assumption The WISE colour-colour diagram categories (W2-W3 thresholds and W1-W2 = 0.8 AGN line) are meaningful for this sample.
    Used in Section 3.3 to argue that the galaxies are distributed differently by group stage and that only NGC 3256 approaches the AGN region. The thresholds come from Wright et al. (2010), Jarrett et al. (2019), and Cluver et al. (2017).

how reviews work

0 comments
Cite this review

Pith. "Pith review of MeerKAT radio continuum imaging of nearby star-forming spirals in the NGC 6221, NGC 3256/3263, and NGC 2434 galaxy groups." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/KQFDCZVC

@misc{pith2026250622382,
  author       = {Pith},
  title        = {Pith review of: MeerKAT radio continuum imaging of nearby star-forming spirals in the NGC 6221, NGC 3256/3263, and NGC 2434 galaxy groups},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/KQFDCZVC}},
  note         = {Machine review of arXiv:2506.22382}
}
read the original abstract

Context. We present high-resolution MeerKAT 1.3 GHz radio continuum images of star-forming spirals in the nearby galaxy groups around NGC 6221, NGC 3256/3263 and NGC 2434. This sample spans the evolutionary timeline for galaxy groups, encompassing early, intermediate, and late stages, respectively. The NGC 6221 group contains an interacting galaxy pair with tidal debris, along with at least three dwarf galaxies. In contrast, the NGC 3256/3263 group represents a loose group consisting of several spiral as well as dwarf galaxies, while a massive elliptical galaxy dominates the NGC 2434 group. Aims. We study the star formation activity in all detected galaxies, as it is one of the dominant physical processes in their formation and evolution, seeking evidence of environmental impact. Methods. We use MeerKAT radio continuum data and archival WISE infrared data to locate and measure the star formation rate in all group members. In particular, we used polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) as tracers of gas heated due to star formation activity. Furthermore, we create in-band spectral index maps, providing insights into the underlying physical processes associated with the detected star-forming regions. Results. We found that galaxies are distributed differently in the WISE colour-colour diagram depending on their evolutionary group stage, as expected. Except for ESO 059-G012, the galaxies in our sample follow the radio-W3PAH correlation. A possible scenario that explains the ESO 059-G012 result is that the galaxy has already consumed the gas. We also found evidence that the interaction among the spiral galaxies NGC 3263, NGC 3256B and NGC 3256C is causing the Vela Cloud complex and that the galaxies NGC 6221 and NGC 3256 might host a low-luminosity AGN, as was previously proposed in the literature.

Figures

Figures reproduced from arXiv: 2506.22382 by the authors.

Figure 1
Figure 1. High-resolution MeerKAT 20-cm radio continuum emission of five galaxies overlaid onto DSS optical images. First row: NGC 6221, NGC 6215 and NGC 2442. The radio continuum contour levels of NGC 6221 and NGC 6215 are 0.03, 0.2, 0.5, 1, 3 and 8 mJy beam−1 , while for NGC 2442, the levels are 0.027, 0.09, and 0.27 mJy beam−1 . Second row: NGC 3263 and NGC 3256. The radio continuum contour levels are 0.027, 0.045, 0.18, 0… view at source ↗
Figure 2
Figure 2. Example of source identification and photometry with Photutils on the WISE W3 image of NGC 3263. From left to right: original W3 image, background model, background-subtracted galaxy image, and final photometry. The white ellipse indicates the aperture used to measure the total flux density. The green circle corresponds to the 22′′ isophote employed for comparison with catalogue values (see text) [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:f… view at source ↗
Figure 3
Figure 3. WISE colour-colour diagram following (Cluver et al. 2017). Early-type galaxies with low star formation rates are located at the bot￾tom left (W2 − W3 < 2), and star-forming disks are expected to be on the right side (W2−W3 > 3.5). Intermediate disks are likely to be found between these regions. Above W1−W2 = 0.8, heating from dusty active galactic nuclei (AGN) primarily influences the mid-infrared emission. Error ba… view at source ↗
Figures from the paper (4 more)
Figure 5
Figure 5. Figure 5: Star formation rate as a function of stellar mass, both quanti￾ties derived from the SED fitting analysis. Main sequence relation from Leslie et al. (2020) (dashed line). Best fit relation from Speagle et al. (2014) (solid black line). The shaded region indicates the 0…
Figure 6
Figure 6. Figure 6: The resolved spectral index and error maps of the brightest galax￾ies in our sample. The dark plum colour pinpoints the flat spectral index associated with thermal emission, while orange marks steep spectral values associated with non-thermal emission (English et al. 2…
Figure 7
Figure 7. Figure 7: NGC 3263, NGC 3256C, NGC 3256B, NGC 3256, NGC 6221, NGC 6215 qW3PAH maps. The colour bar shows the qW3PAH range values. Black contours correspond to errors 0.005, 0.01, 0.02, 0.05, in parameter determination. High values of qW3PAH indicate radio-deficiency while low va…
Figure 6
Figure 6. Figure 6: Moreover, the qW3PAH maps reveal the presence of low￾luminosity AGN due to the radio excess detection in the cores of NGC 6221 and NGC 3256. In the following subsections, we discuss these galaxies individually. 4.2.1. NGC 3256 This galaxy is a merging system; two exten…

Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.

Forward citations

Cited by 1 Pith paper

Reviewed papers in the Pith corpus that reference this work. Sorted by Pith novelty score. Full citation record

  1. High resolution radio analysis of the starburst galaxy NGC 4527: signatures of an AGN core

    astro-ph.GA 2025-07 conditional novelty 5.0 of 10

    New uGMRT radio maps resolve a compact non-thermal core in NGC 4527, suggesting a low-luminosity AGN, while two flanking sources trace a circumnuclear star formation ring.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

83 extracted references · 57 canonical work pages · cited by 1 Pith paper

  1. [1]

    2021, , 507, 2643

    An , F., Vaccari , M., Smail , I., et al. 2021, , 507, 2643

    2021

  2. [2]

    2015, , 803, 51

    Basu , A., Wadadekar , Y., Beelen , A., et al. 2015, , 803, 51

    2015

  3. [3]

    F., McIntosh , D

    Bell , E. F., McIntosh , D. H., Katz , N., & Weinberg , M. D. 2003, , 149, 289

    2003

  4. [4]

    2024, , 977, 36

    Bohn , T., Inami , H., Togi , A., et al. 2024, , 977, 36

    2024

  5. [5]

    E., Cluver , M

    Bok , J., Skelton , R. E., Cluver , M. E., et al. 2020, , 499, 3193

    work page 2020

  6. [6]

    2020, astropy/photutils: 1.0.1

    Bradley , L., Sip o cz , B., Robitaille , T., et al. 2020, astropy/photutils: 1.0.1

    work page 2020

  7. [7]

    2016, Photutils: Photometry tools , Astrophysics Source Code Library, record ascl:1609.011

    Bradley , L., Sipocz , B., Robitaille , T., et al. 2016, Photutils: Photometry tools , Astrophysics Source Code Library, record ascl:1609.011

    2016

  8. [8]

    Bressan , A., Silva , L., & Granato , G. L. 2002, , 392, 377

    work page 2002

Show all 83 references
  1. [9]

    2016, , 590, A125

    Cazzoli , S., Arribas , S., Maiolino , R., & Colina , L. 2016, , 590, A125

    2016

  2. [10]

    2003, , 115, 763

    Chabrier , G. 2003, , 115, 763

    2003

  3. [11]

    E., Jarrett , T

    Cluver , M. E., Jarrett , T. H., Dale , D. A., et al. 2017, , 850, 68

    2017

  4. [12]

    E., Jarrett , T

    Cluver , M. E., Jarrett , T. H., Hopkins , A. M., et al. 2014, , 782, 90

    2014

  5. [13]

    Condon , J. J. 1992, , 30, 575

    1992

  6. [14]

    J., Cotton , W

    Condon , J. J., Cotton , W. D., & Broderick , J. J. 2002, , 124, 675

    2002

  7. [15]

    Davies , L. J. M., Huynh , M. T., Hopkins , A. M., et al. 2017, , 466, 2312

    2017

  8. [16]

    2017, , 602, A4

    Delhaize , J., Smol c i \'c , V., Delvecchio , I., et al. 2017, , 602, A4

    2017

  9. [17]

    T., et al

    Delvecchio , I., Daddi , E., Sargent , M. T., et al. 2021, , 647, A123

    2021

  10. [18]

    & Prodanovi \'c , T

    Donevski , D. & Prodanovi \'c , T. 2015, , 453, 638

    2015

  11. [19]

    C., & McCain , C

    English , J., Koribalski , B., Bland-Hawthorn , J., Freeman , K. C., & McCain , C. F. 2010, , 139, 102

    2010

  12. [20]

    P., Freeman , K

    English , J., Norris , R. P., Freeman , K. C., & Booth , R. S. 2003, , 125, 1134

    2003

  13. [21]

    English , J., Richardson , M. L. A., Ferrand , G., & Deg , N. 2024, CosmosCanvas: Useful color maps for different astrophysical properties

    2024

  14. [22]

    1992, , 93, 211

    Fouque , P., Gourgoulhon , E., Chamaraux , P., & Paturel , G. 1992, , 93, 211

    1992

  15. [23]

    Garcia , A. M. 1993, VizieR Online Data Catalog, J/A+AS/100/47

    1993

  16. [24]

    R., Wright , G

    Graham , J. R., Wright , G. S., Meikle , W. P. S., Joseph , R. D., & Bode , M. F. 1984, , 310, 213

    1984

  17. [25]

    A., Wong , O

    Grundy , J. A., Wong , O. I., Lee-Waddell , K., et al. 2023, , 40, e012

    2023

  18. [26]

    A., Armus , L., et al

    Haan , S., Surace , J. A., Armus , L., et al. 2011, , 141, 100

    2011

  19. [27]

    T., & Rowan-Robinson , M

    Helou , G., Soifer , B. T., & Rowan-Robinson , M. 1985, , 298, L7

    1985

  20. [28]

    K., Dey , S., Ronconi , T., et al

    Humire , P. K., Dey , S., Ronconi , T., et al. 2025, , 699, A183

    2025

  21. [29]

    2024, Galaxies, 12, 22

    Irwin , J., Beck , R., Cook , T., et al. 2024, Galaxies, 12, 22

    2024

  22. [30]

    H., Cluver , M

    Jarrett , T. H., Cluver , M. E., Brown , M. J. I., et al. 2019, , 245, 25

    2019

  23. [31]

    & MeerKAT Team

    Jonas , J. & MeerKAT Team . 2016, in MeerKAT Science: On the Pathway to the SKA, 1

    2016

  24. [32]

    Jonas , J. L. 2009, IEEE Proceedings, 97, 1522

    2009

  25. [33]

    J \'o zsa , G. I. G., White , S. V., Thorat , K., et al. 2020 a , in Astronomical Society of the Pacific Conference Series, Vol. 527, Astronomical Data Analysis Software and Systems XXIX, ed. R. Pizzo , E. R. Deul , J. D. Mol , J. de Plaa , & H. Verkouter , 635

    2020

  26. [34]

    J \'o zsa , G. I. G., White , S. V., Thorat , K., et al. 2020 b , CARACal: Containerized Automated Radio Astronomy Calibration pipeline

    2020

  27. [35]

    L., Bohlin , R

    Kinney , A. L., Bohlin , R. C., Calzetti , D., Panagia , N., & Wyse , R. F. G. 1993, , 86, 5

    1993

  28. [36]

    1996, in Astronomical Society of the Pacific Conference Series, Vol

    Koribalski , B. 1996, in Astronomical Society of the Pacific Conference Series, Vol. 106, The Minnesota Lectures on Extragalactic Neutral Hydrogen, ed. E. D. Skillman , 238

    1996

  29. [37]

    & Dickey , J

    Koribalski , B. & Dickey , J. M. 2004, , 348, 1255

    2004

  30. [38]

    Koribalski , B. S. 2004, in IAU Symposium, Vol. 217, Recycling Intergalactic and Interstellar Matter, ed. P.-A. Duc , J. Braine , & E. Brinks , 34

    2004

  31. [39]

    Koribalski , B. S. 2020, in IAU Symposium, Vol. 355, The Realm of the Low-Surface-Brightness Universe

    2020

  32. [40]

    S., Staveley-Smith , L., Kilborn , V

    Koribalski , B. S., Staveley-Smith , L., Kilborn , V. A., et al. 2004, , 128, 16

    2004

  33. [41]

    S., Veronica , A., Dolag , K., et al

    Koribalski , B. S., Veronica , A., Dolag , K., et al. 2024, , 531, 3357

    2024

  34. [42]

    & Tully , R

    Kourkchi , E. & Tully , R. B. 2017, , 843, 16

    2017

  35. [43]

    2002, Science, 295, 82

    Kroupa , P. 2002, Science, 295, 82

    2002

  36. [44]

    & Valentijn , E

    Lauberts , A. & Valentijn , E. A. 1989, The surface photometry catalogue of the ESO-Uppsala galaxies (.)

    1989

  37. [45]

    Laustsen , S., Madsen , C., & West , R. M. 1987, Exploring the Southern Sky. A Pictorial Atlas from the European Southern Observatory (ESO) (.)

    1987

  38. [46]

    K., Schinnerer , E., Hughes , A., et al

    Leroy , A. K., Schinnerer , E., Hughes , A., et al. 2021, , 257, 43

    2021

  39. [47]

    K., Schinnerer , E., Liu , D., et al

    Leslie , S. K., Schinnerer , E., Liu , D., et al. 2020, , 899, 58

    2020

  40. [48]

    2000, , 120, 645

    L \' pari , S., D \' az , R., Taniguchi , Y., et al. 2000, , 120, 645

    2000

  41. [49]

    & V \"o lk , H

    Lisenfeld , U. & V \"o lk , H. J. 2000, , 354, 423

    2000

  42. [50]

    & Dickinson , M

    Madau , P. & Dickinson , M. 2014, , 52, 415

    2014

  43. [51]

    D., Condon , J

    Mauch , T., Cotton , W. D., Condon , J. J., et al. 2020, , 888, 61

    2020

  44. [52]

    Menon , T. K. 1995, , 274, 845

    1995

  45. [53]

    C., Sargent , M

    Moln \'a r , D. C., Sargent , M. T., Leslie , S., et al. 2021, , 504, 118

    2021

  46. [54]

    Murphy , E. J. 2013, , 777, 58

    2013

  47. [55]

    J., Kenney , J

    Murphy , E. J., Kenney , J. D. P., Helou , G., Chung , A., & Howell , J. H. 2009, , 694, 1435

    2009

  48. [56]

    2020, , 643, A90

    Nersesian , A., Viaene , S., De Looze , I., et al. 2020, , 643, A90

    2020

  49. [57]

    Norris , R. P. & Forbes , D. A. 1995, , 446, 594

    1995

  50. [58]

    2015, , 805, 162

    Ohyama , Y., Terashima , Y., & Sakamoto , K. 2015, , 805, 162

    2015

  51. [59]

    & Dwarakanath , K

    Omar , A. & Dwarakanath , K. S. 2005, Journal of Astrophysics and Astronomy, 26, 89

    2005

  52. [60]

    Pence , W. D. & Blackman , C. P. 1984, , 207, 9

    1984

  53. [61]

    2020, , 641, A6

    Planck Collaboration , Aghanim , N., Akrami , Y., et al. 2020, , 641, A6

    2020

  54. [62]

    2013, , 87, 103014

    Prodanovi \'c , T., Bogdanovi \'c , T., & Uro s evi \'c , D. 2013, , 87, 103014

    2013

  55. [63]

    Reddy , N. A. & Yun , M. S. 2004, , 600, 695

    2004

  56. [64]

    2024, , 685, A161

    Ronconi , T., Lapi , A., Torsello , M., et al. 2024, , 685, A161

    2024

  57. [65]

    D., Koribalski , B., Staveley-Smith , L., et al

    Ryder , S. D., Koribalski , B., Staveley-Smith , L., et al. 2001, , 555, 232

    2001

  58. [66]

    Ryder , S. D. & Koribalski , B. S. 2004, in IAU Symposium, Vol. 217, Recycling Intergalactic and Interstellar Matter, ed. P.-A. Duc , J. Braine , & E. Brinks , 44

    2004

  59. [67]

    Salpeter , E. E. 1955, , 121, 161

    1955

  60. [68]

    & Bedke , J

    Sandage , A. & Bedke , J. 1994, The Carnegie atlas of galaxies , Vol. 638 (.)

    1994

  61. [69]

    2019, , 632, A12

    Schmidt , P., Krause , M., Heesen , V., et al. 2019, , 632, A12

    2019

  62. [70]

    2009, , 398, 1573

    Seymour , N., Huynh , M., Dwelly , T., et al. 2009, , 398, 1573

    2009

  63. [71]

    S., Wang , J., Ho , L

    Shao , L., Koribalski , B. S., Wang , J., Ho , L. C., & Staveley-Smith , L. 2018, , 479, 3509

    2018

  64. [72]

    S., Steinhardt , C

    Speagle , J. S., Steinhardt , C. L., Capak , P. L., & Silverman , J. D. 2014, , 214, 15

    2014

  65. [73]

    J., et al

    Stein , M., Heesen , V., Dettmar , R. J., et al. 2023, , 670, A158

    2023

  66. [74]

    2016, , 826, 111

    Stone , M., Veilleux , S., Mel \'e ndez , M., et al. 2016, , 826, 111

    2016

  67. [75]

    S., Schinnerer , E., Murphy , E

    Tabatabaei , F. S., Schinnerer , E., Murphy , E. J., et al. 2013, , 552, A19

    2013

  68. [76]

    P., Ivison , R

    Thomson , A. P., Ivison , R. J., Simpson , J. M., et al. 2014, , 442, 577

    2014

  69. [77]

    C., Zeilinger , W

    Vega Beltran , J. C., Zeilinger , W. W., Amico , P., et al. 1998, , 131, 105

    1998

  70. [78]

    S., Williams , B

    Verdes-Montenegro , L., Yun , M. S., Williams , B. A., et al. 2001, , 377, 812

    2001

  71. [79]

    L., Eisenhardt , P

    Wright , E. L., Eisenhardt , P. R. M., Mainzer , A. K., et al. 2010, , 140, 1868

    2010

  72. [80]

    2024, , 975, 15

    Yoon , I. 2024, , 975, 15

    2024

  73. [81]

    S., Reddy , N

    Yun , M. S., Reddy , N. A., & Condon , J. J. 2001, , 554, 803

    2001

  74. [82]

    , " * write output.state after.block = add.period write newline

    ENTRY address archiveprefix author booktitle chapter edition editor howpublished institution eprint journal key month note number organization pages publisher school series title type volume year label extra.label sort.label short.list INTEGERS output.state before.all mid.sent...

  75. [83]

    write newline

    " write newline "" before.all 'output.state := FUNCTION n.dashify 't := "" t empty not t #1 #1 substring "-" = t #1 #2 substring "--" = not "--" * t #2 global.max substring 't := t #1 #1 substring "-" = "-" * t #2 global.max substring 't := while if t #1 #1 substring * t #2 gl...

Pith tools

Reviewed August 6, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.