Same Quality Metrics, Different Graph Drawings

Alexandru C. Telea; Simon van Wageningen; Tamara Mchedlidze

REVIEW 3 major objections 2 minor 86 references

Same Quality Metrics, Different Graph Drawings

T0 review · 3 major / 2 minor · reviewed 2026-08-05 · deepseek-v4-flash

Challenge this review Re-run · record.json Download PDF Read on arXiv ↗ Review JSON

Pith's one-line read Quality metrics for graph drawings can stay flat while drawings change shape

desk verdict Potentially useful constructive counterexample to graph-drawing quality metrics, but the submitted packet makes it impossible to check: the full text is an unrelated CP2K chemistry review. read the letter →

arxiv 2508.15557 v1 pith:G33XY23S submitted 2025-08-21 cs.CG

Simon van Wageningen , Tamara Mchedlidze , Alexandru C. Telea This is my paper · ORCID

classification cs.CG

keywords graphdrawingqualitymetricsmetricinvariancedeformationreadabilityvisualizationevaluation

verification ladder T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal

The pith

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The reading

This paper tries to show that standard graph-drawing quality metrics are too weak to certify drawing quality. The authors claim to deform existing drawings into arbitrary target shapes while one or more quality metrics remain almost identical. If true, a drawing that looks very different—and plausibly much worse—can receive nearly the same quality score as the original. They conclude that single-metric or few-metric evaluations cannot be trusted and that more advanced quality metrics are needed.

What carries the argument

The operative mechanism is a deformation procedure that morphs a drawing toward a target shape under a constraint on the reported quality metric(s). The target shape is arbitrary, and the 'almost identical' tolerance on the metric is what carries the argument: by decoupling shape from score, the procedure turns metric blindness from anecdote into a demonstrated property.

What would settle it

Take one commonly used quality metric and one graph from a standard layout benchmark; run the paper's deformation to a visibly cluttered target shape and recompute the metric. If the metric moves by a non-negligible amount, or if human readers rate the deformed drawing as readable as the original, the central demonstration fails.

Watch

Extended reading notes

Core claim

The central claim is constructive: starting from an existing graph drawing, one can reshape it into arbitrary target shapes while keeping one or more quality metrics almost unchanged. This makes explicit a suspicion that has been tacit in the graph drawing community: quality metrics can rate poor drawings as very good. The paper's argument is that reaching arbitrary shapes under a near-constant score is not a rare failure, but evidence that the scores are not tracking the properties that make a drawing good.

Load-bearing premise

The claim collapses if the target shapes are not actually bad drawings by some independent standard—perceptual clarity or human task performance—because then preserving the metric would document flexibility, not blindness.

Editorial extensions

If this is right

A high value of a single graph-drawing quality metric should not be read as evidence that the drawing is good.
Graph-drawing evaluations that rely on one or a few metrics will misclassify some poor drawings as acceptable or good.
Benchmarking new layout algorithms needs adversarial test cases that include deformed drawings with preserved metric scores.
The graph drawing community needs quality measures tied to perceptual clarity or task performance, not just geometric quantities.

Reading between the lines

Editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

Inference: The strength of the conclusion depends on the deformed target shapes being independently poor; metric invariance alone shows insensitivity, not mis-rating. A human-subject study comparing readability of original versus deformed drawings would settle that step.
Inference: The same deformation procedure could be repurposed as a stress test for proposed new metrics: a metric that changes on the deformed drawings would be more sensitive than ones that stay flat.
Inference: The construction may also produce matched pairs of drawings that differ in shape but not score, giving controlled stimuli for user studies on what visual features drive perceived quality.

Share X Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit HN

Signed reviews

No signed human review yet.

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, and a circularity audit.

Desk Editor's Note

read the letter

You should know one thing up front: the abstract of arXiv:2508.15557 makes a point I think is actually worth taking seriously, but the attached full text is not that paper. It's the CP2K software review. So for the purposes of review, the graph drawing paper is essentially an abstract plus metadata.

What the abstract promises is valuable if it holds: turn tacit community skepticism about quality metrics into a concrete demonstration that drawings can be deformed into arbitrary shapes while the metric values barely move. That is exactly the kind of constructive counterexample the graph drawing field needs, because a lot of layout evaluation leans on a single metric, and the community has long suspected such metrics can be gamed. The claim is crisply stated and testable, which is to the authors' credit.

But the soft spots are real, and I want to be precise about them. First, the abstract defines neither "arbitrary target shapes" nor the tolerance under which metrics stay "almost identical." Those are load-bearing. If the reachable shapes are heavily constrained, or if the tolerance is loose enough that any two layouts score the same, the demonstration is weaker than it sounds. Second, the abstract asserts that the deformed drawings are "poor quality" without specifying the independent standard. Metric invariance alone only shows score insensitivity. To conclude that the metrics mis-rate bad drawings, you need some external handle on perceptual or task-based quality. The abstract gestures at it but doesn't supply it.

The bigger issue is that the submitted full text contains none of this. No deformation algorithm, no metric definitions, no experiments, no figures. So the central claim can't be checked at all from what we were given. That is a missing-support finding, not a refutation; the real manuscript may well be solid. But as reviewers, we only have the abstract.

If the actual paper matches the abstract, I'd want to see it. The idea is plausible and the constructive approach is the right way to make the critique rigorous. The editor should ask the authors for the correct PDF rather than desk-reject on the packet alone. On the evidence in front of us, though, I can't verify the claim, and I wouldn't cite it yet.

Net: worth a serious referee if the real text shows up. Based on this submission alone, it's unverifiable.

Referee Report

3 major / 2 minor

Summary. The manuscript, as submitted, consists of an abstract (arXiv:2508.15557, cs.CG) claiming that existing graph drawings can be modified into 'arbitrary target shapes' while keeping one or more quality metrics 'almost identical,' and a full text that is an unrelated CP2K computational-chemistry software review (arXiv:2508.15559). Apart from the abstract, no graph-drawing content appears anywhere in the supplied text: there is no deformation algorithm, no definition or listing of the quality metrics used, no experimental setup or results, and no figures or tables relevant to the claim. The abstract's central assertion and its corollary (that single- or few-metric evaluations cannot reliably certify drawing quality) are therefore entirely unsupported by the body of the manuscript as submitted.

Significance. If the claim in the abstract is correct, it would be a useful cautionary contribution to the graph-drawing community: it would empirically demonstrate that common quality metrics can be insensitive to large, perceptually significant changes in layout, thereby motivating the development of richer quality measures or task-based evaluation. However, the significance cannot be assessed from this submission. The supplied full text provides no method, no data, no code, no machine-checked proofs, and no falsifiable predictions. The only evidence for the central claim is the abstract's own assertion. The manuscript also leaves two load-bearing notions undefined: what 'arbitrary target shapes' means and what independent standard establishes that the deformed drawings are 'poor quality' rather than merely visually different. These are not internal contradictions, but the absence of any supporting material prevents verification of the claim.

major comments (3)

[Full text (arXiv:2508.15559)] The full text of the submission is the CP2K software review, not the graph-drawing paper described in the abstract. It contains no deformation procedure, no quality metrics, no experiments, and no discussion of graph drawings. Consequently, every component of the abstract's central claim — the existence of a method that reaches 'arbitrary target shapes,' the near-invariance of one or more metrics, and the poor quality of the resulting drawings — is unverified. This is a load-bearing missing-support problem: the reader cannot check the method, the metrics, or the results.
[Abstract, 'arbitrary target shapes' and 'very poor quality'] The abstract's argument requires not only that the metrics remain almost identical but also that the deformed drawings are independently bad (e.g., by perceptual or task-performance criteria). The abstract asserts this without defining the external quality notion. If the preserved metric happens to measure features that the deformation preserves, the result would be true but would not establish that quality metrics 'rate drawings with very poor quality as very good.' The manuscript does not supply any independent ground truth for drawing quality, so this premise is unsupported.
[Abstract, 'arbitrary target shapes'] The phrase 'arbitrary target shapes' is an over-generalization relative to the abstract's own description. No evidence is provided that the deformation procedure reaches arbitrary shapes; it could be a curated set where invariance happens to hold. Because the full text offers no algorithm or reachable-set characterization, the generality of the claim is unsubstantiated.

minor comments (2)

[Header] The arXiv identifier in the header (2508.15557) and the full-text identifier (2508.15559) do not match; this appears to be a submission or compilation error that needs to be corrected before any further review.
[Full text] The full text (CP2K review) has no overlap in topic with the abstract. Even as a bibliography or related-work source, it is irrelevant to graph drawing, so its inclusion is misleading.

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged · score 0.0 of 10

No circularity detected in the abstract; full body unavailable due to document mismatch.

full rationale

The supplied full text is arXiv:2508.15559, a CP2K review, not arXiv:2508.15557, so only the abstract of the graph-drawing paper can be inspected. The abstract's argument is an empirical falsification claim: existing drawings are modified into arbitrary target shapes while one or more quality metrics remain almost identical, showing that the metrics cannot reliably discriminate drawing quality. This is not a derivation that assumes its conclusion. The judgment that the target shapes have poor quality is an external perceptual or task-performance premise, not an input to the metric computation; metric invariance alone would only establish score insensitivity, and the question of whether the deformed drawings are independently bad is a benchmark-selection issue rather than circularity. No fitted parameter is relabeled as a prediction, no self-citation carries the argument, and no quantity is defined in terms of the conclusion. The missing body means the construction of arbitrary target shapes and the metric-invariance results cannot be verified here, but absence of evidence is not circularity.

Assumptions & free parameters 2 free parameters · 3 assumptions · 0 invented entities

The ledger is necessarily small because only the abstract is available for review. The key unspecified quantities are the 'almost identical' tolerance and the reachable target shape family; the key undefined notion is the independent standard of poor quality used to conclude that the metrics are failing. No new physical or mathematical entities are introduced.

free parameters (2)

metric invariance tolerance (epsilon)
The claim that metrics stay 'almost identical' requires a threshold for how much metric change counts as acceptable. From the abstract alone this threshold is undefined, and it directly sets the strength of the claim.
deformation and target shape parameters
Modifying drawings into 'arbitrary target shapes' requires a parametrization of the deformation and a family of target templates. Neither is specified in the abstract, and reachability of all target shapes is asserted rather than demonstrated.

assumptions (3)

domain assumption The quality metrics studied are representative of the metrics used by the graph drawing community to judge drawing quality
The conclusion that 'we cannot confidently rely on the value of a single or several certain quality metrics' generalizes from the tested metrics to the community's metric set, but the abstract does not enumerate which metrics were attacked.
domain assumption The deformed drawings are genuinely poor-quality drawings on some independent perceptual or task-based standard
Metric invariance only shows that the score fails to distinguish original from deformed drawing. Calling the deformed drawings 'very poor quality' and concluding the metric is inadequate requires an external quality notion that the abstract does not define.
domain assumption The deformation preserves the graph itself, namely vertex and edge sets, so the deformed image is a valid drawing of the same graph
Comparing metric values across drawings only makes sense for drawings of the same graph. The abstract presupposes this, since otherwise the demonstration would trivially 'fool' metrics by changing the input.

how reviews work

0 comments

Cite this review

Pith. "Pith review of Same Quality Metrics, Different Graph Drawings." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/G33XY23S

@misc{pith2026250815557,
  author       = {Pith},
  title        = {Pith review of: Same Quality Metrics, Different Graph Drawings},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/G33XY23S}},
  note         = {Machine review of arXiv:2508.15557}
}

read the original abstract

Graph drawings are commonly used to visualize relational data. User understanding and performance are linked to the quality of such drawings, which is measured by quality metrics. The tacit knowledge in the graph drawing community about these quality metrics is that they are not always able to accurately capture the quality of graph drawings. In particular, such metrics may rate drawings with very poor quality as very good. In this work we make this tacit knowledge explicit by showing that we can modify existing graph drawings into arbitrary target shapes while keeping one or more quality metrics almost identical. This supports the claim that more advanced quality metrics are needed to capture the 'goodness' of a graph drawing and that we cannot confidently rely on the value of a single (or several) certain quality metrics.

Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

86 extracted references · 80 canonical work pages

[1]

(1) Dirac, P. A. M. Quantum mechanics of many-electron systems.Math. Proc. Camb. Philos. Soc.1929,123, 714–733. (2) Billeter, S. R.; Curioni, A.; Andreoni, W. Efficient linear scaling geometry op- timization and transition-state search for direct wavefunction optimization schemes in density functional theory us- ing a plane-wave basis.Comp. Mat. Sci. 2003...

1929
[24]

(210) Castro, A.; Marques, M. A. L.; Rubio, A. Propagators for the time-dependent Kohn-Sham equations.J. Chem. Phys. 2004,121, 3425–3433. (211) Moler, C.; Loan, C. V. Nineteen Dubious Ways to Compute the Exponential of a Matrix, Twenty-Five Years Later.SIAM Review2003,45, 3–49. (212) Andermatt, S.; Bani-Hashemian, M. H.; Brück, S.; VandeVondele, J.; Luisi...

work page 2004
[25]

M.; Alder, B

(117) Ceperley, D. M.; Alder, B. J. Ground state of the electron gas by a stochastic method.Phys. Rev. Lett.1980,45,

work page 1980
[30]

and Identification of Spec- tral Contributions from Different H- Bond Conformations in Gaseous and Liq- uid Water.J. Phys. Chem. A2006,110, 13388–13393. (264) Ojha, D.; Karhan, K.; Kühne, T. D. On the hydrogen bond strength and vibra- tional spectroscopy of liquid water.Sci. Rep.2018,8, 16888. (265) Elgabarty, H.; Kaliannan, N. K.; Kühne, T. D. Enhancemen...

work page 2018
[40]

J.; Pack, J

(70) Monkhorst, H. J.; Pack, J. D. Special points for Brillouin–zone integrations. Phys. Rev. B1976,13, 5188–5192. (71) Guidon, M.; Hutter, J.; VandeVondele, J. Robust Periodic Hartree-Fock Exchange for Large-Scale Simulations Using Gaus- sian Basis Sets.J. Chem. Theory Com- put.2009,5, 3010–3021. (72) Becke, A. D. Density-functional exchange-energy appro...

work page 2009
[51]

QUICKSTEP: Fast and accu- rate density functional calculations using a mixed Gaussian and plane waves ap- proach.Comput

(23) VandeVondele, J.; Krack, M.; Mo- hamed, F.; Parrinello, M.; Chassaing, T.; Hutter, J. QUICKSTEP: Fast and accu- rate density functional calculations using a mixed Gaussian and plane waves ap- proach.Comput. Phys. Commun.2005, 167, 103–128. (24) Lippert, G.; Hutter, J.; Parrinello, M. A hybrid Gaussian and plane wave density functional scheme.Mol. Phy...

2005
[63]

D.; Shiga, M.; For- bert, H.; Marx, D

(371) Witt, A.; Ivanov, S. D.; Shiga, M.; For- bert, H.; Marx, D. On the applicability of centroid and ring polymer path inte- gral molecular dynamics for vibrational spectroscopy.J. Chem. Phys.2009,130, 194510. (372) Rossi, M.; Ceriotti, M.; Manolopou- los, D. E. How to remove the spurious resonances from ring polymer molecular dynamics.J. Chem. Phys.201...

work page 2009
[79]

Sparse matrix multiplication: The distributed block- compressed sparse row library.Parallel Comput.2014,40, 47–58

(495) Borštnik, U.; VandeVondele, J.; We- ber, V.; Hutter, J. Sparse matrix multiplication: The distributed block- compressed sparse row library.Parallel Comput.2014,40, 47–58. (496) Frigo, M.; Johnson, S. G. FFTW: an adaptive software architecture for the FFT. Proceedings of the 1998 IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech and Signal Processin...

work page 2014

Show all 86 references

[80]

DLA-Future: A Task-Based Linear Algebra Library Which Pro- vides a GPU-Enabled Distributed Eigen- solver

(504) Solcà, R.; Simberg, M.; Meli, R.; In- vernizzi, A.; Reverdell, A.; Biddis- combe, J. DLA-Future: A Task-Based Linear Algebra Library Which Pro- vides a GPU-Enabled Distributed Eigen- solver. Asynchronous Many-Task Sys- tems and Applications. Cham, 2024; pp 135–141, see h...

2024
[86]

(547) Hynes, J. T. Physical chemistry - The protean proton in water.Nature1999, 397, 565–567. (548) Marx, D. Addendum to: Proton Trans- fer 200 Years after von Grotthuss: Insights from Ab Initio Simulations. ChemPhysChem2007,8, 209–210, Orig- inal article:��. (549) Marx, D. I...

2006
[109]

116 (350) Callaway, D. J. E.; Rahman, A. Micro- canonical ensemble formulation of lattice gauge-theory.Phys. Rev. Lett.1982,49, 613–616. (351) Parrinello, M.; Rahman, A. Study of an F–center in molten KCl.J. Chem. Phys. 1984,80, 860–867. (352) Coalson, R. D. On the connection ...

1982
[116]

(253) Ojha, D.; Kühne, T. D. Hydrogen bond dynamics of interfacial water molecules revealed from two-dimensional vibra- tional sum-frequency generation spec- troscopy.Sci. Rep.2021,11,

2021
[145]

Why are insulators insulating and metals conducting?J

(174) Resta, R. Why are insulators insulating and metals conducting?J. Phys. Con- dens. Matter2002,14, R625–R656. (175) Mauri, F.; Louie, S. Magnetic Suscepti- bility of Insulators from First Principles. Phys. Rev. Lett.1996,76, 4246–4249. (176) Keith, T. A.; Bader, R. F. W. C...

1996
[155]

Structures of liq- uid and aqueous water isotopologues at ambient temperature from ab initio path integral simulations.Phys

(541) Thomsen, B.; Shiga, M. Structures of liq- uid and aqueous water isotopologues at ambient temperature from ab initio path integral simulations.Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys.2022,24, 10851–10859. (542) Togo, A.; Chaput, L.; Tadano, T.; Tanaka, I. Implementation strategies in phon...

2022
[181]

A.; Plasser, F.; Krylov, A.; Dreuw, A

(204) Mewes, S. A.; Plasser, F.; Krylov, A.; Dreuw, A. Benchmarking Excited-State Calculations Using Exciton Properties. J. Chem. Theory Comput.2018,14, 710–725. (205) Bruneval, F.; Rangel, T.; Hamed, S. M.; Shao, M.; Yang, C.; Neaton, J. B. Molgw 1: Many-body Perturbation The...

2018
[189]

D.; Delle Site, L

(132) Panahian Jand, S.; Kühne, T. D.; Delle Site, L. On the physical consistency of an open quantum region with a classi- cal reservoir in molecular simulation.Ad- vanced Theory and Simulations2024,7, 2400833. (133) Tomasi, J.; Mennucci, B.; Cammi, R. Quantum Mechanical Conti...

2005
[197]

P.; Altarawy, D.; Di- dier, B.; Gibsom, T

(44) Pritchard, B. P.; Altarawy, D.; Di- dier, B.; Gibsom, T. D.; Windus, T. L. A New Basis Set Exchange: An Open, Up- to-date Resource for the Molecular Sci- ences Community.J. Chem. Inf. Model. 2019,59, 4814–4820. (45) Zijlstra, E. S.; Huntemann, N.; Kalitsov, A.; Garcia, M....

2019
[198]

(452) Medvedev, N. N. The Algorithm for Three-Dimensional Voronoi Polyhedra. J. Comput. Phys.1986,67, 223–229. (453) Pollak, M.; Rein, R. Molecular-Orbital Studies of Intermolecular Interaction En- ergies. II. Approximations Concerned with Coulomb Interactions and Compar- ison...

1986
[206]

Time-dependent density func- tional calculations of ligand K-edge X-ray absorption spectra.IInorg

109 (235) DeBeer George, S.; Petrenko, T.; Neese, F. Time-dependent density func- tional calculations of ligand K-edge X-ray absorption spectra.IInorg. Chim. Acta2008,361, 965–972. (236) Müller, P.; Karhan, K.; Krack, M.; Gerstmann, U.; Schmidt, W. G.; Bauer, M.; Kühne, T. D. ...

2019
[237]

25; pp 29–

(22) Krack, M.; Parrinello, M.High Perfor- mance Computing in Chemistry; NIC Se- ries; NIC-Directors, 2004; Vol. 25; pp 29–

2004
[241]

S.; Miceli, G.; Rai- teri, P.; Krack, M.; Kühne, T

(282) Cucinotta, C. S.; Miceli, G.; Rai- teri, P.; Krack, M.; Kühne, T. D.; Bernasconi, M.; Parrinello, M. Supe- rionic Conduction in Substoichiometric LiAl Alloy: An Ab Initio Study.Phys. Rev. Lett.2009,103, 125901. (283) Caravati, S.; Bernasconi, M.; Kühne, T. D.; Krack, M.;...

2009
[249]

(143) Stewart, J. J. P. Optimization of pa- rameters for semiempirical methods V: Modification of NDDO approximations and application to 70 elements.J. Mol. Model.2007,13, 1173–1213. (144) Elstner, M.; Porezag, D.; Jungnickel, G.; Elsner, J.; Haugk, M.; Frauenheim, T.; Suhai, ...

2007
[291]

Excited state nuclear forces from the Tamm–Dancoff approximation to time–dependent density functional theory within the plane wave basis set framework.J

(190) Hutter, J. Excited state nuclear forces from the Tamm–Dancoff approximation to time–dependent density functional theory within the plane wave basis set framework.J. Chem. Phys.2003,118, 3928–3934. (191) Grimme, S. A simplified Tamm-Dancoff density functional approach for...

2003
[297]

A.; Bu, S.; Mundy, C

(545) Johnson, B. A.; Bu, S.; Mundy, C. J.; Ananth, N. MixPI: Mixed-Time Slicing Path Integral Software for Quantized Molecular Dynamics Simulations.arXiv 2024,2411.11988. (546) CP2K Benchmark Suite.�� ,

2024 arXiv
[299]

(433) Pipek, J.; Mezey, P. G. A fast intrinsic localization procedure applicable forab initioand semiempirical linear combina- tion of atomic orbital wave functions.J. Chem. Phys.1989,90, 4916–4926. (434) Wannier, G. H. The Structure of Elec- tronic Excitation Levels in Insula...

1989
[364]

Gaussian basis sets for accurate calculations on molecular systems in gas and condensed phases.J

97 (30) VandeVondele, J.; Hutter, J. Gaussian basis sets for accurate calculations on molecular systems in gas and condensed phases.J. Chem. Phys.2007,127, 114105. (31) Goedecker, S.; Teter, M.; Hutter, J. Sep- arable dual–space Gaussian pseudopo- tentials.Phys. Rev. B1996,54, 1703–

2007
[377]

A bird’s-eye view of density- functional theory.Braz

(119) Capelle, K. A bird’s-eye view of density- functional theory.Braz. J. Phys.2006, 36, 1318–1343. 102 (120) Caravati, S.; Bernasconi, M.; Kühne, T.; Krack, M.; Parrinello, M. First- principles study of crystalline and amorphousGe2Sb2Te5 and the effects of stoichiometric def...

2006
[385]

(27) Møller, C.; Plesset, M. S. Note on an ap- proximation treatment for many-electron systems.Phys. Rev.1934,46,

1934
[398]

D.; Luke, D

99 (65) Marks, L. D.; Luke, D. Robust mixing for ab initio quantum mechanical calcu- lations.Phys. Rev. B2008,78, 075114. (66) Broyden, C. G. A Class of Meth- ods for Solving Nonlinear Simultaneous Equations.Mathematics of Computation 1965,19, 557–593. (67) Mermin, N. D. Therm...

1965
[399]

Efficient and low- scaling linear-response time-dependent density functional theory implementa- tion for core-level spectroscopy of large and periodic systems.Phys

(196) Bussy, A.; Hutter, J. Efficient and low- scaling linear-response time-dependent density functional theory implementa- tion for core-level spectroscopy of large and periodic systems.Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys.2021,23, 4736–4746. (197) Ljungberg, M. P.; Koval, P.; Ferrari, F.;...

2021
[558]

Ab initio molecular-dynamics simulation of the liquid-metal–amorphous-semiconductor transition in germanium.Phys

(278) Kresse, G.; Hafner, J. Ab initio molecular-dynamics simulation of the liquid-metal–amorphous-semiconductor transition in germanium.Phys. Rev. B 1994,49, 14251. (279) Car, R.; Parrinello, M. Unified Ap- proach for Molecular Dynamics and Density-Functional Theory.Phys. Rev...

1994
[566]

The GW compendium: A practical guide to theoretical photoemission spectroscopy

(118) Golze, D.; Dvorak, M.; Rinke, P. The GW compendium: A practical guide to theoretical photoemission spectroscopy. Front. Chem.2019,7,

2019
[579]

Committee neural network potentials control generalization errors and enable active learning.J

(321) Schran, C.; Brezina, K.; Marsalek, O. Committee neural network potentials control generalization errors and enable active learning.J. Chem. Phys.2020, 153, 104105. (322) Imbalzano, G.; Zhuang, Y.; Kapil, V.; Rossi, K.; Engel, E. A.; Grasselli, F.; Ceriotti, M. Uncertaint...

2020 arXiv
[609]

(29) Gell-Mann, M.; Brueckner, K. A. Corre- lation energy of an electron gas at high density.Phys. Rev.1957,106,

1957
[618]

A collective de- scription of electron interactions: III

(28) Bohm, D.; Pines, D. A collective de- scription of electron interactions: III. Coulomb interactions in a degenerate electron gas.Phys. Rev.1953,92,

1953
[749]

J.; Lestrange, P

(479) Goings, J. J.; Lestrange, P. J.; Li, X. Real-Time Time-Dependent Electronic Structure Theory.WIREs Comput. Mol. Sci.2018,8, e1341. (480) Chen, H.; Mcmahon, J. M.; Rat- ner, M. A.; Schatz, G. C. Classical Elec- trodynamics Coupled to Quantum Me- chanics for Calculation of...

2018
[809]

W.; Rosenbluth, M

(4) Metropolis, N.; Rosenbluth, A. W.; Rosenbluth, M. N.; Teller, A. H.; Teller, E. Equation of State Calculations by Fast Computing Machines.J. Chem. Phys.1953,21, 1087–1092. (5) Laio, A.; Parrinello, M. Escaping free- energy minima.Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 2002,99, 12562–12566...

1953
[822]

Nuclear Quantum Effects in Liquid Water Are Marginal for Its Average Structure but Significant for Dynamics.J

(376) Stolte, N.; Daru, J.; Forbert, H.; Behler, J.; Marx, D. Nuclear Quantum Effects in Liquid Water Are Marginal for Its Average Structure but Significant for Dynamics.J. Phys. Chem. Lett.2024, 15, 12144–12150. (377) Malik, R.; Stolte, N.; Forbert, H.; Chan- dra, A.; Marx, D...

2024
[846]

Auxiliary Density Matrix Methods for Hartree-Fock Exchange Calculations.J

(50) Guidon, M.; Hutter, J.; VandeVondele, J. Auxiliary Density Matrix Methods for Hartree-Fock Exchange Calculations.J. Chem. Theory Comput.2010,6, 2348–

2010
[918]

First-Principles Theory of the EPR G Tensor in Solids: Defectsin Quartz.Phys

(182) Pickard, C.; Mauri, F. First-Principles Theory of the EPR G Tensor in Solids: Defectsin Quartz.Phys. Rev. Lett.2002, 88, 4–7. (183) Van Yperen-De Deyne, A.; Pauwels, E.; Van Speybroeck, V.; Waroquier, M. Ac- curate Spin–orbit and Spin–other-orbit Contributions to the G-t...

2002
[1072]

BSSE-corrected consistent Gaussian basis sets of triple- zeta valence with polarization quality of the fifth period for solid-state calcula- tions.J

(49) Laun, J.; Bredow, T. BSSE-corrected consistent Gaussian basis sets of triple- zeta valence with polarization quality of the fifth period for solid-state calcula- tions.J. Comput. Chem.2022,43, 839–

2022
[1085]

M.; Reine, S.; Kjærgaard, T

(76) Kumar, C.; Fliegl, H.; Jensen, F.; Teale, A. M.; Reine, S.; Kjærgaard, T. AcceleratingKohn-Shamresponsetheory using density fitting and the auxiliary- density-matrix method.Int. J. Quantum Chem.2018,118, e25639. (77) Gavini, V.; Baroni, S.; Blum, V.; Bowler, D. R.; Bucche...

2018
[1157]

(354) Ceriotti, M.; Parrinello, M.; Mark- land,T.E.; Manolopoulos,D.E.Efficient stochastic thermostatting of path inte- gral molecular dynamics.J. Chem. Phys. 2010,133, 124104. (355) Martyna, G. J.; Klein, M. L.; Tuck- erman, M. Nosé-Hoover chains - The canonical ensemble via ...

2010
[1184]

An Efficient Linear-Scaling Electrostatic Coupling for treating pe- riodic boundary conditions in QM/MM Simulations.J

(153) Laino, T.; Mohamed, F.; Laio, A.; Par- rinello, M. An Efficient Linear-Scaling Electrostatic Coupling for treating pe- riodic boundary conditions in QM/MM Simulations.J. Chem. Theory Comp. 2005,2, 1370–1378. (154) Golze, D.; Iannuzzi, M.; Nguyen, M.- T.; Passerone, D.; H...

2005
[1212]

On-the-Fly

(447) Partovi-Azar, P.; Kühne, T. D. Efficient “On-the-Fly” calculation of Raman Spec- tra from Ab-Initio molecular dynamics: Application to hydrophobic/hydrophilic solutes in bulk water.J. Comp. Chem. 2015,36, 2188–2192. (448) Partovi-Azar, P.; Kühne, T. D.; Kag- hazchi, P. E...

2015
[1315]

An efficient real space multi- grid QM/MM electrostatic coupling.J

104 (152) Laino, T.; Mohamed, F.; Laio, A.; Par- rinello, M. An efficient real space multi- grid QM/MM electrostatic coupling.J. Chem. Theory Comp.2005,1, 1176–

2005
[1359]

Acceler- ated path integral methods for atomistic simulations at ultra-low temperatures.J

(364) Uhl, F.; Marx, D.; Ceriotti, M. Acceler- ated path integral methods for atomistic simulations at ultra-low temperatures.J. Chem. Phys.2016,145, 054101. (365) Cao, J. S.; Voth, G. A. A new perspective on quantum time-correlation functions. J. Chem. Phys.1993,99, 10070–100...

2016
[1450]

Z.; Kühne, T

(255) Elgabarty, H.; Khaliullin, R. Z.; Kühne, T. D. Covalency of hydro- gen bonds in liquid water can be probed by proton nuclear magnetic resonance experiments.Nat. Commun.2015,6,

2015
[1549]

(277) Kresse,G.; Hafner,J.Abinitiomolecular dynamics for liquid metals.Phys. Rev. B 1993,47,

1993
[1710]

Relativistic separable dual-space Gaus- sian pseudopotentials from H to Rn

(32) Hartwigsen, C.; Goedecker, S.; Hutter, J. Relativistic separable dual-space Gaus- sian pseudopotentials from H to Rn. Phys. Rev. B1998,58, 3641–3662. (33) Krack, M. Pseudopotentials for H to Kr optimized for gradient-corrected exchange-correlation functionals.Theor. Chem....

2005
[1875]

Nouvelles Applications Des Paramètres Continus à La Théorie Des Formes Quadratiques

(451) Voronoi, G. Nouvelles Applications Des Paramètres Continus à La Théorie Des Formes Quadratiques. Deuxième Mé- moire. Recherches Sur Les Parallélloè- dres Primitifs.J. Reine Angew. Math. 1908,134,

1908
[1879]

E.; Berne, B

(374) Tuckerman, M. E.; Berne, B. J.; Mar- tyna, G. J.; Klein, M. L. Efficient molecular-dynamics and hybrid Monte- Carlo algorithms for path-integrals.J. Chem. Phys.1993,99, 2796–2808. (375) Spura, T.; John, C.; Habershon, S.; Kühne, T. D. Nuclear quantum effects in liquid wa...

1993
[1972]

(346) Barker, J. A. A quantum–statistical Monte Carlo method; path integrals with boundary conditions.J. Chem. Phys. 1979,70, 2914–2918. (347) Chandler, D.; Wolynes, P. G. Exploit- ing the isomorphism between quantum- theory and classical statistical-mechanics of polyatomic fl...

1979
[1977]

interaction induced local- ization

(392) Sindzingre, P.; Klein, M. L.; Ceper- ley, D. M. Path-integral Monte Carlo study of low-temperature �Heclusters. Phys. Rev. Lett.1989,63, 1601–1604. (393) Zeng, T.; Guillon, G.; Cantin, J. T.; Roy, P.-N. Probing the Superfluid Re- sponse of para-Hydrogen with a Sulfur Dio...

1989
[1991]

(424) Spaldin, N. A. A beginner’s guide to the moderntheoryofpolarization.Journal of Solid State Chemistry2012,195, 2–10. (425) King-Smith, R. D.; Vanderbilt, D. The- ory of Polarization of Crystalline Solids. Phys. Rev. B1993,47, 1651–1654. (426) Resta, R. Macroscopic Electri...

1993
[2009]

Car-Parrinello molecular dy- namics.WIREs Comput

(10) Hutter, J. Car-Parrinello molecular dy- namics.WIREs Comput. Mol. Sci.2011, 2, 604–612. (11) Kühne, T. D.; Krack, M.; Mo- hamed, F. R.; Parrinello, M. Efficient and accurate Car-Parrinello-like ap- proach to Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics.Phys. Rev. Lett.2007,98, 066...

2011
[2010]

D.; Macaya, L.; Meng, F.; Richer, M.; Hernández- Esparza, R.; Yang, X

(534) Verstraelen, T.; Adams, W.; Pujal, L.; Tehrani, A.; Kelly, B. D.; Macaya, L.; Meng, F.; Richer, M.; Hernández- Esparza, R.; Yang, X. D. et al. IOData: A python library for reading, writing, and converting computational chemistry file formats and generating input files.J....

2021
[2012]

Elec- tronic excitations: density-functional versus many-body Green’s-function ap- proaches.Rev

(217) Onida, G.; Reining, L.; Rubio, A. Elec- tronic excitations: density-functional versus many-body Green’s-function ap- proaches.Rev. Mod. Phys.2002,74, 601–659. (218) Marek, S.; Wilhelm, J. Linear and Non- linear Optical Properties of Molecules from Real-Time Propagation B...

2002
[2015]

(162) Campañá, C.; Mussard, B.; Woo, T. K. Electrostatic Potential Derived Atomic Charges for Periodic Systems Using a Modified Error Functional.J. Chem. Theory Comput.2009,5, 2866–2878. (163) Huang, C.; Pavone, M.; Carter, E. A. Quantum mechanical embedding theory based on a ...

2009
[2017]

(521) Riccardi, E.; Lervik, A.; Roet, S.; Aarøen, O.; van Erp, T. S. PyRETIS 2: an improbability drive for rare events.J. Comput. Chem.2020,41, 370–377. (522) Vervust, W.; Zhang, D. T.; Ghysels, A.; Roet, S.; van Erp, T. S.; Riccardi, E. PyRETIS 3: Conquering rare and slow eve...

2020
[2018]

methodology discovery

(511) Rocha, A. R.; Garcia-Suarez, V. M.; Bailey, S. W.; Lambert, C. J.; Ferrer, J.; Sanvito, S. Towards molecular spintron- ics.Nat. Mater.2005,4, 335–339, see https://github.com/StefanoSanvitoGroup/libsmeagol. (512) Posenitskiy, E.; Chilkuri, V. G.; Am- mar, A.; Hapka, M.; P...

2005
[2024]

I.; Zaanen, J.; Ander- sen, O

(105) Anisimov, V. I.; Zaanen, J.; Ander- sen, O. K. Band theory and Mott insu- lators: Hubbard U instead of Stoner I. Phys. Rev. B1991,44, 943–954. (106) Dudarev, S. L.; Manh, D. N.; Sut- ton, A. P. Effect of Mott-Hubbard cor- relations on the electronic structure and structu...

1998
[2364]

New Method for Calculating the One-Particle Green’s Function with Application to the Electron-Gas Prob- lem.Phys

(51) Hedin, L. New Method for Calculating the One-Particle Green’s Function with Application to the Electron-Gas Prob- lem.Phys. Rev.1965,139, A796–A823. (52) Aryasetiawan, F.; Gunnarsson, O. The GW method.Reports on Progress in Physics1998,61, 237–312. (53) Whitten, J. L. Cou...

1965
[2421]

Generalized variational den- sity functional perturbation theory.J

(166) Putrino, A.; Sebastiani, D.; Par- rinello, M. Generalized variational den- sity functional perturbation theory.J. Chem. Phys.2000,113, 7102–7109. (167) Sebastiani, D.; Parrinello, M. A New ab-Initio Approach for NMR Chemi- cal Shifts in Periodic Systems.J. Phys. Chem. A2...

2000
[2453]

J.; Ko- rnbluth, M.; Kozinsky, B

(320) Musaelian, A.; Batzner, S.; Johans- son, A.; Sun, L.; Owen, C. J.; Ko- rnbluth, M.; Kozinsky, B. Learning lo- cal equivariant representations for large- scale atomistic dynamics.Nat. Commun. 2023,14,

2023
[2456]

D.; Khaliullin, R

(254) Kühne, T. D.; Khaliullin, R. Z. Elec- tronic signature of the instantaneous asymmetry in the first coordination shell of liquid water.Nat. Commun.2013,4,

2013
[2465]

Quantum nature of the hydrogen bond from ambient con- ditions down to ultra-low temperatures

(339) Schran, C.; Marx, D. Quantum nature of the hydrogen bond from ambient con- ditions down to ultra-low temperatures. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys.2019,21, 24967–24975. (340) Ohto, T.; Dodia, M.; Xu, J.; Imoto, S.; Tang, F.; Zysk, F.; Kühne, T. D.; Shigeta, Y.; Bonn, M.; Wu, X. e...

2019
[2471]

(411) Simko, I.; Schran, C.; Brieuc, F.; Fabri,C.; Schlemmer,O.A.S.; Marx,D.; Csasza, A. G. Quantum Nuclear Delo- calization and its Rovibrational Finger- prints.Angew. Chem. Int. Ed.2023,62, e202306744. (412) Davies, J. A.; Schran, C.; Brieuc, F.; Marx, D.; Ellis, A. M. Onset...

2023
[2643]

Umbrella integration

(356) Tuckerman, M. E.; Marx, D.; Klein, M. L.; Parrinello, M. Efficient and general algorithms for path integral Car–Parrinello molecular dynamics.J Chem Phys 104, 5579–5588. (357) Kästner, J.; Thiel, W. Bridging the gap between thermodynamic integration and umbrella sampling...

2005
[2832]

TRAVIS - A free Analyzer and Visualizer for Monte Carlo and Molecular Dynamics Trajec- tories.J

(463) Brehm, M.; Kirchner, B. TRAVIS - A free Analyzer and Visualizer for Monte Carlo and Molecular Dynamics Trajec- tories.J. Chem. Inf. Model.2011,51, 2007–2023. (464) Ewald, P. P. Die Berechnung optis- cher und elektrostatischer Gitterpoten- tiale.Ann. Phys.1921,369, 253–28...

2011
[3082]

Convergence acceleration of it- erative sequences

(64) Pulay, P. Convergence acceleration of it- erative sequences. the case of scf itera- tion.Chem. Phys. Lett.1980,73, 393–

1980
[3083]

The GW method.Rep

(21) Aryasetiawan, F.; Gunnarsson, O. The GW method.Rep. Prog. Phys.1998,61,

1998
[3227]

R.; Isborn, C

(478) Provorse, M. R.; Isborn, C. M. Elec- tron Dynamics with Real-Time Time- Dependent Density Functional Theory. Int. J. Quantum Chem.2016,116, 739–

2016
[3234]

An efficient orbital transformation method for elec- tronic structure calculations.J

(62) VandeVondele, J.; Hutter, J. An efficient orbital transformation method for elec- tronic structure calculations.J. Chem. Phys.2003,118, 4365–4369. (63) Kerker, G. Efficient iteration scheme for self-consistent pseudopotential calcula- tions.Phys. Rev. B1981,23,

2003
[3809]

Insights into lithiummanganeseoxide-waterinterfaces using machine learning potentials.J

(305) Eckhoff, M.; Behler, J. Insights into lithiummanganeseoxide-waterinterfaces using machine learning potentials.J. Chem. Phys.2021,155. (306) Khaliullin, R. Z.; Eshet, H.; Kühne, T. D.; Behler, J.; Parrinello, M. Graphite-diamond phase coexistence study employing a neural-...

2021
[3865]

Precon- ditioned conjugate gradient method for the sparse generalized eigenvalue prob- lem in electronic structure calculations

(69) Gan, C.; Haynes, P.; Payne, M. Precon- ditioned conjugate gradient method for the sparse generalized eigenvalue prob- lem in electronic structure calculations. Comput. Phys. Commun.2001,134, 33–

2001
[3981]

M.; Neaton, J

(199) Bruneval, F.; Hamed, S. M.; Neaton, J. B. A systematic bench- mark of the ab initio Bethe-Salpeter equation approach for low-lying optical excitations of small organic molecules. J. Chem. Phys.2015,142, 244101. (200) Sander, T.; Maggio, E.; Kresse, G. Be- yond the Tamm-D...

2015
[4130]

Ra- man spectra from ab initio molecular dynamics and its application to liquid S-methyloxirane.J

(468) Luber, S.; Iannuzzi, M.; Hutter, J. Ra- man spectra from ab initio molecular dynamics and its application to liquid S-methyloxirane.J. Chem. Phys.2014, 141, 094503. (469) Albrecht, A. C. On the Theory of Ra- man Intensities.J. Chem. Phys.1961, 34, 1476–1484. (470) Tang, ...

2014
[5142]

L.; Parrinello, M

(430) Silvestrelli, P. L.; Parrinello, M. Water Molecule Dipole in the Gas and in the Liquid Phase — Erratum.Phys. Rev. Lett.1999,82,

1999
[5174]

Developing the random phase approximation into a practical post- Kohn–Sham correlation model.J

(95) Furche, F. Developing the random phase approximation into a practical post- Kohn–Sham correlation model.J. Chem. Phys.2008,129, 114105. (96) Boyd, J. P. Exponentially convergent Fourier-Chebshevquadratureschemeson bounded and infinite intervals.J. Sci. Comput.1987,2, 99–1...

2008
[5415]

L.; Parrinello, M

(431) Silvestrelli, P. L.; Parrinello, M. Struc- tural, electronic, and bonding properties of liquid water from first principles.J. Chem. Phys.1999,111, 3572–3580. (432) Boys, S. F. Construction of Some Molec- ularOrbitalstobeApproximatelyInvari- ant for Changes from One Molec...

1999
[6373]

On-the-fly

115 (332) Singh, R.; Azadi, S.; Kühne, T. D. An- harmonicity and finite-temperature ef- fects on the structure, stability, and vi- brational spectrum of phase III of solid molecular hydrogen.Phys. Rev. B2014, 90, 014110. (333) Spura, T.; Elgabarty, H.; Kühne, T. D. “On-the-fly...

2015
[7382]

(203) Bechstedt, F.Many-Body Approach to Electronic Excitations: Concepts and Applications; Springer Series in Solid- State Sciences; Springer Berlin Heidel- berg: Berlin, Heidelberg, 2015; Vol

2015
[7859]

O.; Granucci, G.; Kossoski, F.; Lischka, H.; Mennucci, B.; Mukherjee, S

(231) Barbatti, M.; Bondanza, M.; Crespo- Otero, R.; Demoulin, B.; Dral, P. O.; Granucci, G.; Kossoski, F.; Lischka, H.; Mennucci, B.; Mukherjee, S. et al. Newton-X Platform: New Software De- velopments for Surface Hopping and Nu- clear Ensembles.J. Chem. Theory Com- put.2022,...

2022
[7895]

(116) Slater, J. C. Wave functions in a periodic potential.Phys. Rev.1937,51,

1937
[8318]

(256) Elgabarty, H.; Kühne, T. D. Tumbling with a limp: local asymmetry in wa- ter’s hydrogen bond network and its consequences.Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2020,22, 10397–10411. (257) Kühne, T. D.; Khaliullin, R. Z. Nature of the Asymmetry in the Hydrogen-Bond Networks of Hexagona...

2020

Pith tools

Reviewed August 5, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.

[1] [1]

(1) Dirac, P. A. M. Quantum mechanics of many-electron systems.Math. Proc. Camb. Philos. Soc.1929,123, 714–733. (2) Billeter, S. R.; Curioni, A.; Andreoni, W. Efficient linear scaling geometry op- timization and transition-state search for direct wavefunction optimization schemes in density functional theory us- ing a plane-wave basis.Comp. Mat. Sci. 2003...

1929

[2] [24]

(210) Castro, A.; Marques, M. A. L.; Rubio, A. Propagators for the time-dependent Kohn-Sham equations.J. Chem. Phys. 2004,121, 3425–3433. (211) Moler, C.; Loan, C. V. Nineteen Dubious Ways to Compute the Exponential of a Matrix, Twenty-Five Years Later.SIAM Review2003,45, 3–49. (212) Andermatt, S.; Bani-Hashemian, M. H.; Brück, S.; VandeVondele, J.; Luisi...

work page 2004

[3] [25]

M.; Alder, B

(117) Ceperley, D. M.; Alder, B. J. Ground state of the electron gas by a stochastic method.Phys. Rev. Lett.1980,45,

work page 1980

[4] [30]

and Identification of Spec- tral Contributions from Different H- Bond Conformations in Gaseous and Liq- uid Water.J. Phys. Chem. A2006,110, 13388–13393. (264) Ojha, D.; Karhan, K.; Kühne, T. D. On the hydrogen bond strength and vibra- tional spectroscopy of liquid water.Sci. Rep.2018,8, 16888. (265) Elgabarty, H.; Kaliannan, N. K.; Kühne, T. D. Enhancemen...

work page 2018

[5] [40]

J.; Pack, J

(70) Monkhorst, H. J.; Pack, J. D. Special points for Brillouin–zone integrations. Phys. Rev. B1976,13, 5188–5192. (71) Guidon, M.; Hutter, J.; VandeVondele, J. Robust Periodic Hartree-Fock Exchange for Large-Scale Simulations Using Gaus- sian Basis Sets.J. Chem. Theory Com- put.2009,5, 3010–3021. (72) Becke, A. D. Density-functional exchange-energy appro...

work page 2009

[6] [51]

QUICKSTEP: Fast and accu- rate density functional calculations using a mixed Gaussian and plane waves ap- proach.Comput

(23) VandeVondele, J.; Krack, M.; Mo- hamed, F.; Parrinello, M.; Chassaing, T.; Hutter, J. QUICKSTEP: Fast and accu- rate density functional calculations using a mixed Gaussian and plane waves ap- proach.Comput. Phys. Commun.2005, 167, 103–128. (24) Lippert, G.; Hutter, J.; Parrinello, M. A hybrid Gaussian and plane wave density functional scheme.Mol. Phy...

2005

[7] [63]

D.; Shiga, M.; For- bert, H.; Marx, D

(371) Witt, A.; Ivanov, S. D.; Shiga, M.; For- bert, H.; Marx, D. On the applicability of centroid and ring polymer path inte- gral molecular dynamics for vibrational spectroscopy.J. Chem. Phys.2009,130, 194510. (372) Rossi, M.; Ceriotti, M.; Manolopou- los, D. E. How to remove the spurious resonances from ring polymer molecular dynamics.J. Chem. Phys.201...

work page 2009

[8] [79]

Sparse matrix multiplication: The distributed block- compressed sparse row library.Parallel Comput.2014,40, 47–58

(495) Borštnik, U.; VandeVondele, J.; We- ber, V.; Hutter, J. Sparse matrix multiplication: The distributed block- compressed sparse row library.Parallel Comput.2014,40, 47–58. (496) Frigo, M.; Johnson, S. G. FFTW: an adaptive software architecture for the FFT. Proceedings of the 1998 IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech and Signal Processin...

work page 2014