REVIEW
NOEMA3D: Resolving radial gas flows in disk galaxies at z~1.1-1.6 with high-resolution CO observations
Astrophysics of Galaxies · Submitted 20 Apr 2026 · 107 references
Pith's verdict: New kpc-scale CO kinematics at z~1.1-1.6 show morphology-aligned velocity residuals, but the radial-inflow interpretation depends on an untested thin-disk assumption.
Why Pith says this
Highlight any text to comment on it.
Referee report
The paper
The paper claims
High-resolution CO observations show that spiral arms and bars in z~1-2 disk galaxies drive molecular gas inflows at rates comparable to star formation.
The reading
What carries the argument
Velocity residuals after subtraction of axisymmetric rotation via DysmalPy forward modeling, whose spatial alignment with JWST-detected spiral arms and bars is used to infer in-plane radial gas flows.
Extended reading notes
Core claim
After modeling the axisymmetric rotation with DysmalPy, we reveal spatially coherent velocity residuals in all but one more inclined system. The inferred in-plane non-circular motions reach amplitudes of ~50-100 km/s. Interpreting these non-circular motions as radial flows we find that the velocity residuals spatially coincide with non-axisymmetric structures -- spiral arms and bars -- demonstrating a direct link between galaxy morphology and gas transport at z ~ 1-2. In spiral galaxies, the residual velocity patterns are typically dominated by inflows, while barred systems display an apparent inflow-outflow pattern. We further find that the inferred molecular gas inflow rates are of the the
Load-bearing premise
That the observed velocity residuals represent purely in-plane radial flows driven by the morphological features rather than warps, vertical motions, outflows, or modeling imperfections.
Original abstract
We present NOEMA3D, a unique high-resolution study of purely molecular gas kinematics at $z \sim 1.1$ to 1.6, providing a dedicated view of cold gas dynamics at the late stages of the peak epoch of cosmic star formation. Using deep ($> 20$ hr on source per target) IRAM-NOEMA CO observations of 10 massive ($10.45 < \log(M^*/M_\odot) < 11.43$)) main-sequence galaxies, complemented by high-resolution JWST imaging, we resolve the molecular gas kinematics and morphology on kiloparsec scales. We find that all galaxies exhibit ordered rotation with moderate intrinsic turbulence (median $\sigma_0 \sim 32 \pm 10$ km/s, median $V_c/\sigma_0 \sim 8.6 \pm 2.9$), consistent with dynamically turbulent disks at late cosmic noon. After modeling the axisymmetric rotation with the forward-modeling code DysmalPy, we reveal spatially coherent velocity residuals in all but one more inclined system. The inferred in-plane non circular motions reach amplitudes of $\sim 50$-100 km/s, significantly larger than typically observed in local disk galaxies. Interpreting these non-circular motions as radial flows we find that the velocity residuals spatially coincide with non-axisymmetric structures -- spiral arms and bars -- demonstrating a direct link between galaxy morphology and gas transport at $z \sim 1$-2. In spiral galaxies, the residual velocity patterns are typically dominated by inflows, while barred systems display an apparent inflow-outflow pattern, characteristic of in-plane bar-driven gas motions. We further find that the inferred molecular gas inflow rates are substantial, with a typical net inflow rate of the order of the star formation rate ($\dot M \sim -50 M_\odot$/yr). This implies that spiral arms and bars at cosmic noon are highly efficient at funneling cold gas toward galaxy centers, perhaps driving the buildup of bulges and feeding central star forming regions and supermassive black holes.
Figures
Showing 4 of the paper's 5 figures. See all figures in the PDF ↗ Figures reproduced from arXiv:2604.18503 by the authors.
References
How the literature uses it
3 arXiv papers cite this in 3 sentences
What it cites · 7 sentences without a confident label
Uses the method or tool of 3 papers
-
In addition to the average flow we compute the associated net mass flow rate following [ref] : For each pixel we compute the corresponding molecular gas mass [ref] .
The Evolution of the Star-forming Interstellar Medium across Cosmic Time · Average in-plane radial velocities and mass flow rates · 1.00
-
We use the 1D profiles as inputs to generate galaxy models, using the publicly available forward modeling code [<https://www.mpe.mpg.de/resources/IR/DYSMALPY/>] [ref] . is a package designed to perform forward modeling of galaxy kinematics using multi-component mass models.
The Nuclear Gas Dynamics and Star Formation of NGC 7469 · forward modeling · 0.99
-
We use the 1D profiles as inputs to generate galaxy models, using the publicly available forward modeling code [<https://www.mpe.mpg.de/resources/IR/DYSMALPY/>] [ref] . is a package designed to perform forward modeling of galaxy kinematics using multi-component mass models.
The Nuclear Gas Dynamics and Star Formation of Markarian 231 · forward modeling · 0.99
Uses data or values from 1 paper
-
We extracted integrated photometry from the reduced HST and JWST images, and complemented it with additional mid- and far-IR data from Spitzer/IRAC and MIPS ( [ref] ) and Herschel/PACS ( [ref] ), as well as (sub-)mm continuum measurements from our NOEMA$^3D$ observations (; see Table [ref]).
The Great Observatories Origins Deep Survey · Ancillary photometric data and SED fitting · 0.98
Cites as background 8 papers
-
While it is well established [ref] that non-circular motions at the end of and along galactic bars will typically be the sum of radial motions and deviations from axisymmetric rotation in the azimuthal direction (tangential streaming motions), the analysis performed here focused solely on radial motions.
Gas flow models in the Milky Way embedded bars · Discussion · 0.97
-
While it is well established [ref] that non-circular motions at the end of and along galactic bars will typically be the sum of radial motions and deviations from axisymmetric rotation in the azimuthal direction (tangential streaming motions), the analysis performed here focused solely on radial motions.
Gas accretion on spiral galaxies: bar formation and renewal · Discussion · 0.97
-
In local spiral galaxies, and according to density wave theory, inflows are observed along the arms while outflows are observed in the inter-arm region [ref] .
Nuclear spirals in galaxies: gas response to asymmetric potential. II. Hydrodynamical models · Discussion · 0.85
Discussion
Disagree with the review, or know something it missed? Leave a comment, highlight any passage above to comment on it, or challenge this review formally.