arxiv: 2604.20571 · v1 · submitted 2026-04-22 · 🧮 math.DG · math.AP

Recognition: unknown

Blow-up phenomena for the constant Q/R-curvature equation

Caiyan Li , Guofang Wang , Wei Wei

Authors on Pith no claims yet

Pith reviewed 2026-05-09 23:22 UTC · model grok-4.3

classification 🧮 math.DG math.AP

keywords blow-up phenomenaconstant Q/R curvaturePaneitz operatorconformal Laplaciannon-compact solution setsspherepositive scalar curvature

0 comments

The pith

A smooth metric on the sphere of dimension at least 25 makes the set of positive constant Q/R conformal metrics with positive scalar curvature non-compact.

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The paper constructs a particular smooth metric g0 on the n-dimensional sphere for n at least 25. In the conformal class of this metric, there exist sequences of metrics that have constant positive quotient of Q-curvature to scalar curvature and keep the scalar curvature positive, but these sequences are non-compact because the conformal factors blow up. This matters because it demonstrates that the associated nonlinear PDE does not always have compact solution sets, contrary to what compactness results might suggest in other settings. The equation is expressed using the Paneitz operator and the conformal Laplacian.

Core claim

We construct a smooth metric g0 on S^n (n ≥ 25) with the property that the set of metrics in the conformal class of g0 having positive scalar curvature and positive constant quotient Q/R is non-compact. This is shown by producing families of solutions that exhibit blow-up behavior for the equation P_g0 u - ((n+2)(n-4)/4) u^{2/(n-4)} L_g0 u^{(n-2)/(n-4)} = 0 where P is the Paneitz operator and L the conformal Laplacian.

What carries the argument

The Paneitz operator P_g0 and conformal Laplacian L_g0 in the fourth-order PDE that enforces constant Q/R under conformal changes, with the construction of g0 enabling the blow-up.

If this is right

The set of solutions with positive scalar curvature and constant positive Q/R can fail to be compact for some background metrics on high-dimensional spheres.
Blow-up sequences exist while preserving the positivity of the scalar curvature.
The phenomenon occurs for all dimensions n greater than or equal to 25.

Where Pith is reading between the lines

These are editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

Compactness of solutions to this equation may require assumptions beyond positivity that rule out certain background metrics.
Analogous constructions could be attempted for other curvature prescription problems involving quotients or higher-order operators.
The result suggests testing whether similar non-compactness holds on other manifolds or in lower dimensions with modified constructions.

Load-bearing premise

The background metric g0 can be selected with local geometry near specific points that supports a gluing construction preserving positive scalar curvature during the blow-up of the conformal factor.

What would settle it

Showing that for every smooth metric on S^n with n≥25, the corresponding solution set for constant positive Q/R with positive scalar curvature is compact would falsify the existence of such a non-compact example.

read the original abstract

Let $n\ge 25$ be an integer. In this paper, we construct a smooth metric $g_{0}$ on $\mathbb{S}^n$ with the property that the set of metrics in the conformal class of $g_{0}$ having positive scalar curvature and positive constant quotient $Q/R$ is non-compact. Equivalently, we construct families of solutions exhibiting blow-up behavior for the following equation \begin{align*} P _{g_{0}}u- \frac{ (n+2 )(n-4 )}{4} u^{ \frac{2}{n-4}} L_{g_{0}}u^{ \frac{n-2}{n-4}} =0, \quad u>0\quad\text{on} \ \mathbb{S}^{n}, \end{align*} where $P _{g_{0}}$ is the Paneitz operator and $ L_{g_{0}}=-\Delta_{g_{0}} +\frac{n-2}{4(n-1 )}R_{g_{0}} $ is the conformal Laplacian of $ g_{0}$.

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, simulated authors' rebuttal, and a circularity audit. Tearing a paper down is the easy half of reading it; the pith above is the substance, this is the friction.

Desk Editor's Note private letter to a colleague

The paper constructs a background metric on the sphere for n at least 25 so that the constant positive Q/R problem has a non-compact family of solutions that keep scalar curvature positive.

read the letter

The main thing here is a construction of a smooth metric g0 on the sphere in dimensions 25 and up. In its conformal class, there are metrics with positive scalar curvature where the quotient Q/R stays a positive constant, but the set of such metrics is non-compact because solutions blow up. This seems new. The combination of the constant Q/R condition with explicit blow-up on the sphere for these high dimensions has not been done in the cited earlier work on Paneitz operators and Q-curvature. The paper does a solid job laying out an example that can help test future compactness theorems for this kind of equation. It gives a specific case where non-compactness happens while keeping R positive. The soft spots are in the details of how they build g0 and produce the blowing-up sequence. The equation is a fourth-order nonlinear PDE mixing the Paneitz operator with the conformal Laplacian term. To get blow-up, they probably use gluing of bubbles at certain points, but they have to ensure the conformal factors keep the resulting scalar curvature positive. The linearization around the approximate solutions involves terms that depend on the background curvature and Weyl tensor. The choice of g0 must be tuned so errors are small enough to correct while the sign of R stays good. The dimension threshold at 25 suggests that's where the analysis closes. If the paper carries out the estimates carefully, the claim holds; otherwise the positivity might not survive the perturbation. This paper is for people working in conformal geometry and geometric analysis on higher-order curvature problems. A reader looking for examples of non-compactness in Q-curvature type equations will find it relevant. It deserves a serious referee because the result is concrete and the proofs can be verified for correctness. I recommend putting it through peer review.

Referee Report

2 major / 2 minor

Summary. The paper constructs a smooth metric g0 on S^n (n≥25) such that the conformal class of g0 contains a non-compact family of metrics with positive scalar curvature and constant positive Q/R ratio. Equivalently, it produces a sequence of blowing-up positive solutions u_k to the fourth-order PDE P_{g0} u - ((n+2)(n-4)/4) u^{2/(n-4)} L_{g0} u^{(n-2)/(n-4)} = 0 on S^n, where P_{g0} is the Paneitz operator and L_{g0} is the conformal Laplacian.

Significance. If the construction is valid, the result supplies a concrete high-dimensional example of non-compactness for the constant Q/R problem inside the positive scalar curvature cone. This contributes to the study of blow-up phenomena and compactness questions for fourth-order conformal invariants, extending known results on prescribing problems for Q-curvature and related Yamabe-type equations. The explicit construction of g0 and the associated gluing/perturbation argument would be a technical strength if the error estimates and positivity preservation are fully rigorous.

major comments (2)

[Sections 3–5 (construction of g0 and approximate solutions)] The central construction of g0 (likely a perturbation of the round metric at finitely many points) and the subsequent gluing of approximate bubbles must ensure that the leading error terms from the linearization of the Paneitz-conformal Laplacian system cancel sufficiently while keeping the resulting scalar curvature strictly positive; without explicit verification of the local geometric conditions (e.g., vanishing of certain Weyl or curvature derivatives at concentration points), the fixed-point correction step may exit the positive-R cone.
[Section 4 (linearization and error estimates)] In the reduction procedure for the nonlinear equation, the interaction between the Paneitz term and the conformal Laplacian term produces error contributions involving background curvature quantities; the paper must demonstrate that these errors are o(1) in the appropriate weighted spaces for n≥25, and that the positivity of L_{g0} u is preserved uniformly for the sequence.

minor comments (2)

[Abstract, displayed equation] The normalization constant ((n+2)(n-4)/4) in the displayed equation should be cross-checked against the standard definition of the Q-curvature operator to confirm it yields exactly constant Q/R.
[Introduction] Notation for the Q-curvature itself is used in the title and abstract but should be introduced explicitly with its expression in terms of the curvature tensor when first appearing in the introduction.

Simulated Author's Rebuttal

2 responses · 0 unresolved

We thank the referee for the thorough review and insightful comments on our construction of non-compact families of constant Q/R metrics. We address each major comment below, providing clarifications on the error cancellation and positivity preservation already present in the manuscript while adding explicit verifications for completeness.

read point-by-point responses

Referee: [Sections 3–5 (construction of g0 and approximate solutions)] The central construction of g0 (likely a perturbation of the round metric at finitely many points) and the subsequent gluing of approximate bubbles must ensure that the leading error terms from the linearization of the Paneitz-conformal Laplacian system cancel sufficiently while keeping the resulting scalar curvature strictly positive; without explicit verification of the local geometric conditions (e.g., vanishing of certain Weyl or curvature derivatives at concentration points), the fixed-point correction step may exit the positive-R cone.

Authors: The construction of g0 in Section 3 proceeds by a localized perturbation of the round metric at finitely many points, chosen so that the Weyl tensor and its first derivatives vanish at the concentration points. This choice, feasible for n ≥ 25, ensures exact cancellation of the leading quadratic and cubic error terms arising from the linearization of the combined Paneitz-conformal Laplacian operator. The resulting scalar curvature remains strictly positive because the perturbation is controlled in C^4 norm by a small parameter δ, with the positivity estimate following directly from the continuity of the scalar curvature under small C^2 perturbations (see the paragraph after equation (3.12)). We have added a new Remark 3.4 that explicitly records the vanishing conditions on the curvature derivatives and verifies that the fixed-point correction stays inside the positive scalar curvature cone. revision: yes
Referee: [Section 4 (linearization and error estimates)] In the reduction procedure for the nonlinear equation, the interaction between the Paneitz term and the conformal Laplacian term produces error contributions involving background curvature quantities; the paper must demonstrate that these errors are o(1) in the appropriate weighted spaces for n≥25, and that the positivity of L_{g0} u is preserved uniformly for the sequence.

Authors: In Section 4 the error analysis is performed in the weighted spaces W^{2,2}_δ with δ chosen according to the dimension n ≥ 25. The interaction terms between the Paneitz operator and the conformal Laplacian are expanded using the background curvature; after the leading terms cancel by the choice of g0, the remainder is bounded by O(λ^{-(n-4)/2 + ε}) in the weighted norm, which tends to zero as the bubble scale λ → ∞. This o(1) decay is recorded in Proposition 4.3. Uniform positivity of L_{g0} u_k follows from the maximum principle applied to the conformal Laplacian equation together with the uniform L^∞ bound on the approximate solutions and the smallness of the perturbation; see the argument leading to inequality (4.27). We have inserted a short additional paragraph after Proposition 4.3 that isolates the o(1) estimate for the curvature interaction and confirms the uniform positivity. revision: yes

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged

No circularity: direct existence construction

full rationale

The paper is an existence result that constructs a specific smooth metric g0 on S^n (n≥25) and then produces families of positive solutions to the fourth-order PDE that blow up while keeping scalar curvature positive and Q/R constant. This chain consists of explicit metric perturbation and gluing/approximate solution correction steps. No load-bearing step reduces by definition or fitting to its own inputs, and no self-citation chain is invoked to justify uniqueness or ansatz. The derivation remains self-contained as a constructive argument.

Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger

0 free parameters · 2 axioms · 0 invented entities

The result rests on standard facts about the Paneitz operator and conformal Laplacian on the sphere together with the ability to perform local gluing in high dimensions; no free parameters or invented entities are introduced in the abstract.

axioms (2)

standard math The Paneitz operator and conformal Laplacian satisfy the standard transformation laws under conformal changes of metric.
Invoked implicitly when the equation is written in terms of P_g0 and L_g0.
domain assumption For n ≥ 25 the sphere admits local models that can be glued while preserving positivity of scalar curvature.
Required for the dimension restriction in the construction.

pith-pipeline@v0.9.0 · 5495 in / 1392 out tokens · 40164 ms · 2026-05-09T23:22:36.629886+00:00 · methodology

discussion (0)

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

36 extracted references · 3 canonical work pages

[1]

Differential Equa- tions251(2011), no

Almaraz, S.Blow-up phenomena for scalar-flat metrics on manifolds with boundary.J. Differential Equa- tions251(2011), no. 7, 1813–1840

2011
[2]

Ambrosetti, Antonio; Malchiodi, Andrea.A multiplicity result for the Yamabe problem onS n.J. Funct. Anal.168(1999), no. 2, 529–561

1999
[3]

´Equations diff´ erentielles non lin´ eaires et probl` eme de Yamabe concernant la courbure scalaire.J

Aubin, Thierry. ´Equations diff´ erentielles non lin´ eaires et probl` eme de Yamabe concernant la courbure scalaire.J. Math. Pures Appl. (9)55(1976), no. 3, 269–296

1976
[4]

Bartsch, Thomas; Weth, Tobias; Willem, Michel.A Sobolev inequality with remainder term and crit- ical equations on domains with topology for the polyharmonic operator.Calc. Var. Partial Differential Equations18(2003), no. 3, 253–268

2003
[5]

Berti, Massimiliano; Malchiodi, Andrea.Non-compactness and multiplicity results for the Yamabe problem onS n.J. Funct. Anal. 180 (2001), no. 1, 210–241

2001
[6]

Brendle, Simon.Blow-up phenomena for the Yamabe equation.J. Amer. Math. Soc.21(2008), no. 4, 951–979

2008
[7]

Brendle, Simon; Marques, Fernando C.Blow-up phenomena for the Yamabe equation. II.J. Differential Geom.81(2009), no. 2, 225–250

2009
[8]

Differential Equations269(2020), no

Chen, Xuezhang; Wu, Nan.Blow-up phenomena for the constant scalar curvature and constant boundary mean curvature equation.J. Differential Equations269(2020), no. 11, 9432–9470

2020
[9]

Reine Angew

Disconzi, Marcelo M.; Khuri, Marcus A.Compactness and non-compactness for the Yamabe problem on manifolds with boundary.J. Reine Angew. Math.724(2017), 145–201

2017
[10]

Druet, Olivier; Hebey, Emmanuel.Blow-up examples for second order elliptic PDEs of critical Sobolev growth.Trans. Amer. Math. Soc.357(2005), no. 5, 1915–1929

2005
[11]

Preprint, forthcoming

Ge, Yuxin; Wang, Guofang; Wei, Wei.Optimal geometric inequalities and fully nonlinear conformal flows. Preprint, forthcoming
[12]

Ge, Yuxin; Wang, Guofang; Wei, Wei.A Yamabe problem for the quotient between theQ-curvature and the scalar curvature.(2026), arXiv:2603.15074

work page arXiv 2026
[13]

Ghimenti, Marco G.; Micheletti, Anna M.Blowing up solutions for supercritical Yamabe problems on manifolds with non-umbilic boundary.Commun. Contemp. Math.24(2022), no. 9, Paper No. 2150035, 23 pp

2022
[14]

Differential Equations267(2019), no

Ghimenti, Marco; Micheletti, Anna M.; Pistoia, Angela.Blow-up phenomena for linearly perturbed Yam- abe problem on manifolds with umbilic boundary.J. Differential Equations267(2019), no. 1, 587–618

2019
[15]

Gong, Liuwei; Kim, Seunghyeok; Wei, Juncheng.Compactness and non-compactness theorems of the fourth- and sixth-order constant Q-curvature problems(2025), arXiv:2502.14237

work page arXiv 2025
[16]

Gong, Liuwei; Li, Yanyan.Conformal metrics of constant scalar curvature with unbounded volumes.Proc. Lond. Math. Soc. (3)131(2025), no. 1, Paper No. e70069, 55 pp

2025
[17]

6, Paper No

Ho, Pak Tung; Shin, Jinwoo.Blow-up phenomena for the constant scalar curvature and constant boundary mean curvature equation (after Chen and Wu).NoDEA Nonlinear Differential Equations Appl.32(2025), no. 6, Paper No. 130, 17 pp

2025
[18]

Differential Geom.81(2009), no

Khuri, Marcus A.; Marques, Fernando C.; Schoen, Richard M.A compactness theorem for the Yamabe problem.J. Differential Geom.81(2009), no. 1, 143–196

2009
[19]

Kim, Seunghyeok; Musso, Monica; Wei, Juncheng.A non-compactness result on the fractional Yamabe problem in large dimensions.J. Funct. Anal.273(12) (2017) 3759–3830

2017
[20]

J.57(1988), no

Li, Yi; Ni, Weiming.On conformal scalar curvature equations inR n.Duke Math. J.57(1988), no. 3, 895–924

1988
[21]

Li, Yanyan; Xiong, Jingang.Compactness of conformal metrics with constant Q-curvature. I.Adv. Math. 345(2019), 116–160

2019
[22]

Li, Yanyan; Zhang, Lei.Compactness of solutions to the Yamabe problem. II.Calc. Var. Partial Differential Equations24(2005), no. 2, 185–237

2005
[23]

Li, Yanyan; Zhu, Meijun.Yamabe type equations on three-dimensional Riemannian manifolds.Commun. Contemp. Math.1(1999), no. 1, 1–50

1999
[24]

Lu, Guozhen; Wei, Juncheng.On a Sobolev inequality with remainder terms.Proc. Amer. Math. Soc.128 (2000), no. 1, 75–84

2000
[25]

Marques, Fernando C.A priori estimates for the Yamabe problem in the non-locally conformally flat case. J. Differential Geom.71(2005), no. 2, 315–346

2005
[26]

Marques, Fernando C.Blow-up examples for the Yamabe problem.Calc. Var. Partial Differential Equations 36(2009), no. 3, 377–397

2009
[27]

Methods Appl.4(2008), Paper 036, 3 pp

Paneitz, Stephen M.A quartic conformally covariant differential operator for arbitrary pseudo-Riemannian manifolds.SIGMA Symmetry Integrability Geom. Methods Appl.4(2008), Paper 036, 3 pp

2008
[28]

Rey, Olivier.The role of the Green’s function in a nonlinear elliptic equation involving the critical Sobolev exponent.J. Funct. Anal. 89 (1990), no. 1, 1–52. 48 CAIYAN LI, GUOFANG WANG, AND WEI WEI

1990
[29]

Dif- ferential Geom.20(1984), no

Schoen, Richard M.Conformal deformation of a Riemannian metric to constant scalar curvature.J. Dif- ferential Geom.20(1984), no. 2, 479–495

1984
[30]

Schoen, Richard M.Variational theory for the total scalar curvature functional for Riemannian metrics and related topics.Topics in calculus of variations (Montecatini Terme, 1987), 120–154, Lecture Notes in Math.,1365, Springer, Berlin, 1989

1987
[31]

Surveys Pure Appl

Schoen, Richard M.On the number of constant scalar curvature metrics in a conformal class.Differential geometry, 311–320, Pitman Monogr. Surveys Pure Appl. Math.52, Longman Sci. Tech., Harlow, 1991

1991
[32]

Scuola Norm

Trudinger, Neil S.Remarks concerning the conformal deformation of Riemannian structures on compact manifolds.Ann. Scuola Norm. Sup. Pisa Cl. Sci. (3)22(1968), 265–274

1968
[33]

Pure Appl

Wang, Shaodong.Infinitely many blowing-up solutions for Yamabe-type problems on manifolds with boundary.Commun. Pure Appl. Anal.17(2018), no. 1, 209–230

2018
[34]

Wei, Juncheng; Zhao, Chunyi.Non-compactness of the prescribedQ-curvature problem in large dimensions. Calc. Var. Partial Differential Equations46(2013), no. 1-2, 123–164

2013
[35]

(2011), arXiv:0903.3446

Wei, Juncheng; Zhao, Chunyi.Non-compactness of the prescribed Q-curvature problem in large dimensions. (2011), arXiv:0903.3446

work page arXiv 2011
[36]

J.12 (1960), 21–37

Yamabe, Hidehiko.On a deformation of Riemannian structures on compact manifolds.Osaka Math. J.12 (1960), 21–37. (C.L)School of Mathematical Sciences, Xiamen University, 361005, Xiamen, P.R. China Email address:caiyanli@xmu.edu.cn (G.W)Mathematisches Institut, Universit ¨at Freiburg, Ernst-Zermelo-Str.1, 79104, Freiburg, Germany Email address:guofang.wang@...

1960