Estimation of Time-Varying Treatment Effects in a Joint Model for Longitudinal and Recurrent Event Outcomes in Mobile Health Data
Pith reviewed 2026-05-08 10:47 UTC · model grok-4.3
The pith
An extension of joint longitudinal-survival models estimates time-varying effects of repeated treatments delivered in mobile health trials.
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
Core claim
We present a model-based approach for estimating the effect of repeatedly delivered treatments in a micro-randomized trial via an extension of a joint longitudinal-survival model. Different model specifications correspond to different mechanisms by which treatment is assumed to impact the longitudinal and event processes. Taking a Bayesian approach to inference, we model the association between repeated treatments, multiple longitudinally measured outcomes, and recurrent events, and we show how to calculate information criteria for model selection together with goodness-of-fit plots for the survival submodel.
What carries the argument
Extension of the joint longitudinal-survival model that incorporates repeated treatment effects through alternative specifications, each corresponding to a distinct assumed mechanism of action on the longitudinal and recurrent-event processes.
Load-bearing premise
The chosen specification must correctly represent the actual mechanisms by which the repeated treatments affect the longitudinal outcomes and the recurrent events.
What would settle it
In a controlled micro-randomized trial with known treatment delivery times and known true effect mechanisms, the estimated time-varying effects would recover the known values only when the model uses the matching specification and would show clear bias or poor calibration otherwise.
Figures
read the original abstract
Not only does mobile health technology enable researchers to track changes in multiple longitudinal outcomes of interest and to record the occurrence of health-related events over time, but it also allows for the delivery of repeated low-cost treatments directly to individuals in real time. We present a model-based approach for estimating the effect of repeatedly delivered treatments in a micro-randomized trial (MRT) via an extension of a joint longitudinal-survival model. We discuss different ways that these repeated treatment effects can be incorporated into the joint model; these different model specifications correspond to different mechanisms by which treatment is assumed to impact the longitudinal and event processes. Taking a Bayesian approach to inference, we model the association between repeated treatments, multiple longitudinally measured outcomes, and recurrent events. We also demonstrate how to calculate information criteria for model selection and present goodness-of-fit plots for assessing survival submodel calibration. We then illustrate the performance of our method via simulations and analysis of data collected in an MRT of substance use.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The manuscript presents a model-based approach for estimating time-varying effects of repeatedly delivered treatments in micro-randomized trials (MRTs) by extending joint longitudinal-survival models to accommodate multiple longitudinal outcomes and recurrent events in mobile health data. It explores alternative specifications for how treatments affect the processes (corresponding to different assumed mechanisms), employs Bayesian inference, demonstrates information criteria for model selection and goodness-of-fit plots for survival calibration, and validates via simulations plus a real-data analysis from a substance-use MRT.
Significance. If the derivations hold and the mechanism-specific models are correctly specified, the work provides a flexible, unified framework for causal estimation in MRTs that jointly handles longitudinal trajectories, recurrent events, and time-varying treatments. The explicit discussion of multiple treatment-effect mechanisms, combined with Bayesian tools, information criteria, and calibration checks, addresses a practical need in digital health research and could improve the reliability of analyses involving complex, repeatedly measured mHealth data.
minor comments (2)
- Abstract: The high-level description does not include any model equations, parameter definitions, or quantitative summaries of the simulation or real-data results; adding one or two key equations (e.g., the form of the treatment-effect term in the longitudinal or hazard submodel) would improve accessibility without lengthening the abstract excessively.
- The manuscript would benefit from a dedicated subsection or table that explicitly contrasts the different treatment-mechanism specifications (e.g., direct effect on longitudinal mean vs. effect on event intensity) with their implied identifiability conditions and expected bias under misspecification.
Simulated Author's Rebuttal
We thank the referee for their positive assessment of our manuscript, accurate summary of its contributions, and recommendation for minor revision. We appreciate the recognition that our extension of joint longitudinal-survival models provides a flexible framework for causal estimation in micro-randomized trials.
Circularity Check
No significant circularity in derivation chain
full rationale
The paper extends existing joint longitudinal-survival models to accommodate repeated treatments in MRTs by enumerating multiple explicit mechanisms for how treatments affect the processes, then applies standard Bayesian inference, information criteria for selection, and calibration diagnostics. Simulations and real-data analysis serve as independent validation steps separate from any fitted quantities. No equations or claims reduce by construction to inputs, self-citations, or renamed empirical patterns; the central contribution is the availability of this flexible modeling framework under stated assumptions.
Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger
free parameters (1)
- Treatment effect parameters
axioms (1)
- domain assumption Joint distribution of longitudinal outcomes and recurrent events can be modeled via shared random effects or equivalent linking structures.
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
" write newline "" before.all 'output.state := FUNCTION format.url url empty "" url if FUNCTION article output.bibitem format.authors "author" output.check author format.key output output.year.check new.block format.title "title" output.check new.block crossref missing format.jour.vol output format.article.crossref output.nonnull format.pages output if ne...
-
[2]
barticle [author] Abbott , M R M. R. , Dempsey , W H W. H. , Nahum-Shani , I I. , Potter , L N L. N. , Wetter , D W D. W. , Lam , C Y C. Y. Taylor , J M G J. M. G. ( 2025 a). A B ayesian joint longitudinal-survival model with a latent stochastic process for intensive longitudinal data . Biometrics 81 . barticle
work page 2025
-
[3]
barticle [author] Abbott , M R M. R. , Dempsey , W H W. H. , Nahum-Shani , I I. , Lam , C Y C. Y. , Wetter , D W D. W. Taylor , J M G J. M. G. ( 2025 b). A Continuous-Time Dynamic Factor Model for Intensive Longitudinal Data Arising from Mobile Health Studies . Psychometrika 90 1-22 . barticle
work page 2025
-
[4]
barticle [author] Boruvka , A A. , Almirall , D D. , Witkiewitz , K K. Murphy , S A S. A. ( 2018 ). Assessing Time-Varying Causal Effect Moderation in Mobile Health . Journal of the American Statistical Association 113 1112-1121 . barticle
work page 2018
-
[5]
binbook [author] Brigo , D D. Mercurio , F F. ( 2007 ). Interest Rate Models-Theory and Practice with Smile, Inflation and Credit , second ed. 3 . Springer Finance . binbook
work page 2007
-
[6]
barticle [author] Carpenter , B B. , Gelman , A A. , Hoffman , M D M. D. , Lee , D D. , Goodrich , B B. , Betancourt , M M. , Brubaker , M M. , Guo , J J. , Li , P P. Riddell , A A. ( 2017 ). Stan: A Probabilistic Programming Language . Journal of Statistical Software 76 1--32 . barticle
work page 2017
-
[7]
binbook [author] Gelman , A A. , Carlin , J B J. B. Stern , H S H. S. ( 2014 ). Bayesian Data Analysis , third ed. 7 . Chapman & Hall/CRC texts in statistical science . binbook
work page 2014
-
[8]
barticle [author] Gelman , A A. , Hwang , J J. Vehtari , A A. ( 2014 ). Understanding predictive information criteria for B ayesian models . Statistics and Computing 24 997–1016 . barticle
work page 2014
-
[9]
barticle [author] Ibrahim , J G J. G. , Chu , H H. Chen , L M L. M. ( 2010 ). Basic concepts and methods for joint models of longitudinal and survival data . Journal of Clinical Oncology 26 2796–2801 . barticle
work page 2010
-
[10]
barticle [author] Klasnja , P P. , Hekler , E B E. B. , Shiffman , S S. , Boruvka , A A. , Almirall , D D. , Tewari , A A. Murphy , S A S. A. ( 2015 ). Microrandomized trials: An experimental design for developing just-in-time adaptive interventions . Health Psychology 0 1220-8 . 10.1037/hea0000305 barticle
-
[11]
barticle [author] Klasnja , P P. , Smith , S S. , Seewald , N J N. J. , Lee , A A. , Hall , K K. , Luers , B B. , Hekler , E B E. B. Murphy , S A S. A. ( 2019 ). Efficacy of Contextually Tailored Suggestions for Physical Activity: A Micro-randomized Optimization Trial of HeartSteps . Annals of Behavioral Medicine 53 573-582 . barticle
work page 2019
-
[12]
barticle [author] Liao , P P. , Klasnja , P P. , Tewari , A A. Murphy , S A S. A. ( 2016 ). Sample size calculations for micro-randomized trials in m H ealth . Statistics in Medicine 35 1944-1971 . barticle
work page 2016
-
[13]
barticle [author] Merkle , E C E. C. , Furr , D D. Rabe-Hesketh , S S. ( 2019 ). Bayesian Comparison of Latent Variable Models: Conditional Versus Marginal Likelihoods . Psychometrika 84 802–829 . barticle
work page 2019
-
[14]
barticle [author] Nahum-Shani , I I. , Smith , S N S. N. , Spring , B J B. J. , Collins , L M L. M. , Witkiewitz , K K. , Tewari , A A. Murphy , S A S. A. ( 2018 ). Just-in-Time Adaptive Interventions ( JITAI s) in Mobile Health: Key Components and Design Principles for Ongoing Health Behavior Support . Annals of Behavioral Medicine 52 446–462 . barticle
work page 2018
-
[15]
barticle [author] Nahum-Shani , I I. , Potter , L N L. N. , Lam , C Y C. Y. , Yap , J J. , Moreno , A A. , Stoffel , R R. , Wu , Z Z. , Wan , N N. , Dempsey , W W. , Kumar , S S. , Ertin , E E. , Murphy , S A S. A. , Rehg , J M J. M. Wetter , D W D. W. ( 2021 ). The mobile assistance for regulating smoking ( MARS ) micro-randomized trial design protocol ....
-
[16]
barticle [author] Qian , T T. , Yoo , H H. , Klasnja , P P. , Almirall , D D. Murphy , S A S. A. ( 2021 ). Estimating time-varying causal excursion effect in mobile health with binary outcomes . Biometrika 108 507-527 . barticle
work page 2021
-
[17]
barticle [author] Rabbi , M M. , Philyaw Kotov , M M. , Cunningham , R R. , Bonar , E E E. E. , Nahum-Shani , I I. , Klasnja , P P. , Walton , M M. Murphy , S S. ( 2018 ). Toward Increasing Engagement in Substance Use Data Collection: Development of the Substance Abuse Research Assistant App and Protocol for a Microrandomized Trial Using Adolescents and E...
work page 2018
- [18]
-
[19]
barticle [author] Rizopoulos , D D. , Taylor , J M G J. M. G. , Papageorgiou , G G. Morgan , T M T. M. ( 2024 ). Using joint models for longitudinal and time-to-event data to investigate the causal effect of salvage therapy after prostatectomy . Statistical Methods in Medical Research 33 894-908 . barticle
work page 2024
-
[20]
barticle [author] Shi , J J. , Wu , Z Z. Dempsey , W W. ( 2023 ). Assessing time-varying causal effect moderation in the presence of cluster-level treatment effect heterogeneity and interference . Biometrika 110 645–662 . barticle
work page 2023
-
[21]
barticle [author] Taylor , J M G J. M. G. , Shen , J J. , Kennedy , E H E. H. , Wang , L L. Schaubel , D E D. E. ( 2014 ). Comparison of methods for estimating the effect of salvage therapy in prostate cancer when treatment is given by indication . Statistics in Medicine 2 257--74 . barticle
work page 2014
-
[22]
barticle [author] Tran , T D T. D. , Lesaffre , E E. , Verbeke , G G. Duyck , J J. ( 2021 ). Latent O rnstein- U hlenbeck models for B ayesian analysis of multivariate longitudinal categorical responses . Biometrics 77 689--701 . 10.1111/biom.13292 barticle
- [23]
-
[24]
barticle [author] Yu , M M. , Law , N J N. J. , Taylor , J M G J. M. G. Sandler , H M H. M. ( 2004 ). Joint longitudinal-survival-cure models and their application to prostate cancer . Statistica Sinica 14 835-862 . barticle
work page 2004
-
[25]
barticle [author] Zhang , D D. , Chen , M H M. H. , Ibrahim , J G J. G. , Boye , M E M. E. Shen , W W. ( 2017 ). Bayesian Model Assessment in Joint Modeling of Longitudinal and Survival Data with Applications to Cancer Clinical Trials . Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics 26 121–133 . barticle
work page 2017
-
[26]
barticle [author] Abbott , M R M. R. , Dempsey , W H W. H. , Nahum-Shani , I I. , Lam , C Y C. Y. , Wetter , D W D. W. Taylor , J M G J. M. G. ( 2025 a). A Continuous-Time Dynamic Factor Model for Intensive Longitudinal Data Arising from Mobile Health Studies . Psychometrika 90 1-22 . barticle
work page 2025
-
[27]
barticle [author] Abbott , M R M. R. , Dempsey , W H W. H. , Nahum-Shani , I I. , Potter , L N L. N. , Wetter , D W D. W. , Lam , C Y C. Y. Taylor , J M G J. M. G. ( 2025 b). A B ayesian joint longitudinal-survival model with a latent stochastic process for intensive longitudinal data . Biometrics 81 . barticle
work page 2025
-
[28]
barticle [author] Prochaska , J J J. J. , Vogel , E A E. A. Benowitz , N N. ( 2022 ). Nicotine delivery and cigarette equivalents from vaping a JUULpod . Tobacco Control 31 e88-e93 . barticle
work page 2022
-
[29]
barticle [author] Vehtari , A A. , Gelman , A A. Gabry , J J. ( 2017 ). Practical B ayesian model evaluation using leave-one-out cross-validation and WAIC . Statistics and Computing 27 1413-1432 . barticle
work page 2017
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.