List-Coloring and Chromatic-Choosability -- A Dynamic Survey
Pith reviewed 2026-07-01 04:30 UTC · model grok-4.3
The pith
This survey reviews where list chromatic number equals chromatic number and where gaps remain across major graph classes.
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
Core claim
The survey updates knowledge on list-coloring, where each vertex receives its own list of admissible colors, and chromatic-choosability as the property that this list chromatic number equals the ordinary chromatic number. It organizes results by graph classes with known equality, classes exhibiting nontrivial gaps, and the main methods used to establish them, spanning embedded graphs, perfect graphs, complete bipartite and multipartite graphs, claw-free graphs, line graphs, powers of graphs, graph products, and selected variants.
What carries the argument
Chromatic-choosability, the equality between a graph's list chromatic number and its chromatic number, used to classify families of graphs.
If this is right
- Equality between list chromatic number and chromatic number holds for some embedded graphs.
- A nontrivial gap between the two numbers persists for certain complete bipartite and multipartite graphs.
- Chromatic-choosability is known for perfect graphs and for claw-free graphs under the reviewed conditions.
- Principal methods developed for line graphs and graph powers extend to related coloring problems.
- Selected variants of list-coloring build directly on the equality and gap classifications.
Where Pith is reading between the lines
- The survey's organization of proof methods could guide attempts to close gaps in unclassified graph families.
- Results on graph products might suggest patterns for choosability in larger composite structures.
- The covered techniques for embedded graphs could be tested on surfaces or embeddings not yet examined in detail.
Load-bearing premise
That the authors have selected and summarized the key results and methods from the literature in a representative and accurate manner without significant omissions or interpretive errors relative to the body of work since the 2001 survey.
What would settle it
A major published result on chromatic-choosability or list-coloring for one of the covered graph classes that is omitted from the survey or presented with a clear factual error.
read the original abstract
List-coloring, introduced independently by Vizing and by Erd\H{o}s, Rubin, and Taylor in the 1970s, generalizes ordinary vertex coloring by assigning to each vertex its own set of admissible colors. A graph is chromatic-choosable if its list chromatic number equals its chromatic number. The previous survey on list-coloring by D R Woodall (2001), emphasized defective choosability, the list-coloring conjectures, and different methods used for list-coloring. This survey reviews major developments on list-coloring and chromatic-choosability, with emphasis on graph classes for which equality is known, graph classes exhibiting a nontrivial gap, and the principal methods used to prove such results. The survey covers embedded graphs, perfect graphs, complete bipartite and multipartite graphs, claw-free graphs, line graphs, powers of graphs, graph products, and selected variants of list-coloring.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. This is a survey paper that updates the 2001 survey by D.R. Woodall on list-coloring. It reviews major developments on list-coloring and chromatic-choosability, emphasizing graph classes where the list chromatic number equals the chromatic number, classes with nontrivial gaps between them, and the principal methods used to prove such results. The coverage includes embedded graphs, perfect graphs, complete bipartite and multipartite graphs, claw-free graphs, line graphs, powers of graphs, graph products, and selected variants of list-coloring.
Significance. If the summaries of results and methods are accurate and representative of the literature since 2001, the survey would serve as a useful reference for researchers working on choosability questions, consolidating progress across multiple graph classes in one place. The focus on equality cases versus gaps and on proof techniques aligns with the needs of the field.
minor comments (1)
- The abstract refers to this as a 'dynamic survey' but does not specify in the provided text how updates will be handled or whether a version history or companion website is planned; this could be clarified in the introduction.
Simulated Author's Rebuttal
We thank the referee for their positive assessment of the survey and for recommending acceptance. We are pleased that the focus on equality cases, gaps, and proof techniques is viewed as aligning with the needs of the field.
Circularity Check
Survey with no derivations, predictions, or self-referential claims
full rationale
This is a literature survey summarizing results on list-coloring and chromatic-choosability from external sources since the 2001 Woodall survey. It advances no new theorems, equations, fitted parameters, or predictions of its own. The central claim is a representative overview of known equalities, gaps, and proof methods across graph classes, with all substantive content drawn from cited prior work. No step reduces by construction to the paper's own inputs, and no uniqueness theorems or ansatzes are imported from the authors' prior publications. The manuscript is therefore self-contained against external benchmarks with no detectable circularity.
Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
proved that every planar graph of girth at least 5 is 3-choosable. This can be seen as a list- coloring analogue, with a slightly stronger girth requirement, of Grötzsch’s theorem, which states that every planar graph of girth at least 4 is 3-colorable. Li [82] extended Thomassen’s result for planar graphs of girth at least 4 that has noC4 that shares a v...
-
[2]
For a planar graph of girth 4, 3-choosability is also guaranteed when it is either{C5, C6}-free [58] or{C7, C8}-free [78]
and Gutner [26] constructed planar graphs of girth 4 that are not 3-choosable, with 166 vertices and 164 vertices, respectively. For a planar graph of girth 4, 3-choosability is also guaranteed when it is either{C5, C6}-free [58] or{C7, C8}-free [78]. When there are no girth constraints, the results depend on forbidden cycles and often on the distance bet...
-
[3]
Wang et al
proved that a{C5, C6}-free planar graph is 3-choosable if either it isC7-free withd(T, T ′)≥3 for anyT, T ′ orC 8-free withd(T, T ′)≥2for anyT, T ′. Wang et al. [73] summarized the results in [57, 60, 65] and generalized it by stating that any planar graph withoutC4, Ci, Cj andC 9 where 4 i < jandi, j∈ {5,6,7,8}is 3-choosable. Apart from these, Grytczuk a...
-
[4]
Along with it, he also estab- lished thatχ ℓ(K3∗k1,1∗k2) = max{k1 +k 2,⌈ 4k1+2k2−1 3 ⌉}
in his paper generalized this result for all possible combinations of partite sets of size 3, 2 and 1 and hence proved the chromatic-choosability ofK3∗k1,2∗(n−k1−k2),1∗k2. Along with it, he also estab- lished thatχ ℓ(K3∗k1,1∗k2) = max{k1 +k 2,⌈ 4k1+2k2−1 3 ⌉}. Through close observation, it can be easily seen that the terms whose maximum is to be compared ...
1996
-
[5]
JinandMiao[124]workedonplanargraphswithgirthatleast5andshowedthatχ ℓ(G2 g≥5,∆≥40)≤ ∆(G) + 4
established that ifGis a{C4, C5}-free planar graph with∆(G)≥32, thenχ ℓ(G2)≤∆(G)+3. JinandMiao[124]workedonplanargraphswithgirthatleast5andshowedthatχ ℓ(G2 g≥5,∆≥40)≤ ∆(G) + 4. Bu and Yan [97] proved thatχℓ(G2 g≥5,∆≤5)≤13. They also added that planar graphsG with∆(G)≥12and without 3, 5-cycles and intersecting 4-cycles haveχℓ(G2)≤∆(G)+6; . Bu and Shang [10...
-
[6]
Balázs and Xuding [110] gave a bound for the lexicographic product of two graphs of the same order
proved thatχ(G[H])≤χ(G)χ(H). Balázs and Xuding [110] gave a bound for the lexicographic product of two graphs of the same order. LetGandHbe graphs withnvertices. Thenχ ℓ(G[H])≤(4∆(G) + 2)(χ ℓ(H) + logn). They also posed a question on a slightly different bound for lexicographic product of two graphs of the same order. 15 Open problem [99] :Does there exis...
2009
-
[7]
Graphs with given group and given graph-theoretical properties
Gert Sabidussi. “Graphs with given group and given graph-theoretical properties”. In:Cana- dian journal of mathematics9 (1957), pp. 515–525
1957
-
[8]
On the chromatic numbers of a graph and its complement
HJ Finck. “On the chromatic numbers of a graph and its complement”. In:Theory of graphs (1968), pp. 99–113
1968
-
[9]
A (< 5)-colour theorem for planar graphs
AJW Hilton, Richard Rado, and SH Scott. “A (< 5)-colour theorem for planar graphs”. In: Bulletin of the London Mathematical Society5.3 (1973), pp. 302–306
1973
-
[10]
Vertex colorings with given colors
Vadim G Vizing. “Vertex colorings with given colors”. In:Diskret. Analiz29.3-10 (1976), p. 2
1976
-
[11]
On an upper bound of a graph’s chromatic number, depending on the graph’s degree and density
Oleg V Borodin and Alexandr V Kostochka. “On an upper bound of a graph’s chromatic number, depending on the graph’s degree and density”. In:Journal of Combinatorial Theory, Series B23.2-3 (1977), pp. 247–250
1977
-
[12]
Graphs with given diameter and a coloring problem
Gerd Wegner. “Graphs with given diameter and a coloring problem”. In: (1977)
1977
-
[13]
Choosability in graphs
Paul Erdös, Arthur L Rubin, and Herbert Taylor. “Choosability in graphs”. In:Congr. Numer 26.4 (1979), pp. 125–157
1979
-
[14]
Problems and conjectures in extremal graph theory
AJ Harris. “Problems and conjectures in extremal graph theory”. PhD thesis. University of Cambridge, 1985
1985
-
[15]
Recognizing claw-free perfect graphs
Vasek Chvátal and Najiba Sbihi. “Recognizing claw-free perfect graphs”. In:Journal of Com- binatorial Theory, Series B44.2 (1988), pp. 154–176
1988
-
[16]
A note on list-colorings
Amanda Chetwynd and Roland Häggkvist. “A note on list-colorings”. In:Journal of Graph Theory13.1 (1989), pp. 87–95
1989
-
[17]
DIMACS, Center for Discrete Mathematics and Theoretical Computer Science, 1991
Nadimpalli VR Mahadev, Fred S Roberts, and Prakash Santhanakrishnan.3-choosable com- plete bipartite graphs. DIMACS, Center for Discrete Mathematics and Theoretical Computer Science, 1991
1991
-
[18]
Choice numbers of graphs: a probabilistic approach
Noga Alon. “Choice numbers of graphs: a probabilistic approach”. In:Combinatorics, Proba- bility and Computing1.2 (1992), pp. 107–114. 18
1992
-
[19]
Colorings and orientations of graphs
Noga Alon and Michael Tarsi. “Colorings and orientations of graphs”. In:Combinatorica12 (1992), pp. 125–134
1992
-
[20]
A solution to a colouring problem of P. Erdös
Herbert Fleischner and Michael Stiebitz. “A solution to a colouring problem of P. Erdös”. In: Discrete Mathematics101.1-3 (1992), pp. 39–48
1992
-
[21]
Some upper bounds on the total and list chro- matic numbers of multigraphs
Roland Häggkvist and Amanda Chetwynd. “Some upper bounds on the total and list chro- matic numbers of multigraphs”. In:Journal of graph theory16.5 (1992), pp. 503–516
1992
-
[22]
Restricted colorings of graphs
Noga Alon. “Restricted colorings of graphs”. In:Surveys in combinatorics187 (1993), pp. 1– 33
1993
-
[23]
On the choice number ofKm,n
DG Hoffman and PD Johnson. “On the choice number ofKm,n”. In:Congressus Numerantium (1993), pp. 105–105
1993
-
[24]
List colourings of planar graphs
Margit Voigt. “List colourings of planar graphs”. In:Discrete Mathematics120.1-3 (1993), pp. 215–219
1993
-
[25]
Restricted choice numbers
DG Hoffman, PD Johnson, and EB Wantland. “Restricted choice numbers”. In:Congressus Numerantium(1994), pp. 65–79
1994
-
[26]
Everyplanargraphis5-choosable
CarstenThomassen.“Everyplanargraphis5-choosable”.In:Journal of Combinatorial Theory Series B62.1 (1994), pp. 180–181
1994
-
[27]
The list chromatic index of a bipartite multigraph
Fred Galvin. “The list chromatic index of a bipartite multigraph”. In:Journal of Combinato- rial Theory, Series B63.1 (1995), pp. 153–158
1995
-
[28]
3-ChoosabilityofK 5,q
AnilMShendeandBTessman.“3-ChoosabilityofK 5,q”.In:Congressus Numerantium(1995), pp. 193–221
1995
-
[29]
3-list-coloring planar graphs of girth 5
Carsten Thomassen. “3-list-coloring planar graphs of girth 5”. In:Journal of Combinatorial Theory, Series B64.1 (1995), pp. 101–107
1995
-
[30]
A not 3-choosable planar graph without 3-cycles
Margit Voigt. “A not 3-choosable planar graph without 3-cycles”. In:Discrete Mathematics 146.1-3 (1995), pp. 325–328
1995
-
[31]
List edge colourings of some 1-factorable multigraphs
Mark N Ellingham and Luis Goddyn. “List edge colourings of some 1-factorable multigraphs”. In:Combinatorica16.3 (1996), pp. 343–352
1996
-
[32]
The complexity of planar graph choosability
Shai Gutner. “The complexity of planar graph choosability”. In:Discrete Mathematics159.1-3 (1996), pp. 119–130
1996
-
[33]
Choosability of bipartite graphs
Denis Hanson, Gary MacGillivray, and Bjarne Toft. “Choosability of bipartite graphs”. In: Ars Combinatoria44 (1996), pp. 183–192
1996
-
[34]
Thwart numbers of some bipartite graphs
Dean G Hoffman, Peter D Johnson Jr, and Evan B Wantland. “Thwart numbers of some bipartite graphs”. In:Australasian Journal of Combinatorics13 (1996), pp. 247–258
1996
-
[35]
A small non-4-choosable planar graph
Maryam Mirzakhani. “A small non-4-choosable planar graph”. In:Bull. Inst. Combin. Appl 17.15-18 (1996), p. 3
1996
-
[36]
Every 2-choosable graph is (2m, m)-choosable
Zsolt Tuza and Margit Voigt. “Every 2-choosable graph is (2m, m)-choosable”. In:Journal of Graph Theory22.3 (1996), pp. 245–252
1996
-
[37]
On a conjecture of Erdös, Rubin and Taylor
Zsolt Tuza and Margit Voigt. “On a conjecture of Erdös, Rubin and Taylor”. In:Tatra Moun- tains Mathematical Publications9 (1996), pp. 69–82
1996
-
[38]
List edge and list total colourings of multigraphs
Oleg V Borodin, Alexandr V Kostochka, and Douglas R Woodall. “List edge and list total colourings of multigraphs”. In:Journal of combinatorial theory, Series B71.2 (1997), pp. 184– 204
1997
-
[39]
Choice number of 3-colorable elementary graphs
Sylvain Gravier and Frédéric Maffray. “Choice number of 3-colorable elementary graphs”. In: Discrete Mathematics165 (1997), pp. 353–358
1997
-
[40]
New bounds on the list-chromatic index of the complete graph and other simple graphs
Roland Häggkvist and Jeannette Janssen. “New bounds on the list-chromatic index of the complete graph and other simple graphs”. In:Combinatorics, Probability and Computing6.3 (1997), pp. 295–313
1997
-
[41]
Graphs whose choice number is equal to their chro- matic number
Sylvain Gravier and Frédéric Maffray. “Graphs whose choice number is equal to their chro- matic number”. In:Journal of Graph Theory27.2 (1998), pp. 87–97
1998
-
[42]
Choosability ofK5-minor-free graphs
Riste Škrekovski. “Choosability ofK5-minor-free graphs”. In:Discrete mathematics190.1-3 (1998), pp. 223–226
1998
-
[43]
Dirac’s map-color theorem for choos- ability
Thomas Böhme, Bojan Mohar, and Michael Stiebitz. “Dirac’s map-color theorem for choos- ability”. In:Journal of Graph Theory32.4 (1999), pp. 327–339. 19
1999
-
[44]
Listedge-coloringsofseries-parallelgraphs
MartinJuvan,BojanMohar,andRobinThomas.“Listedge-coloringsofseries-parallelgraphs”. In:the electronic journal of combinatorics6.1 (1999), R42
1999
-
[45]
The 4-choosability of plane graphs without 4-cycles
Peter Che Bor Lam, Baogang Xu, and Jiazhuang Liu. “The 4-choosability of plane graphs without 4-cycles”. In:Journal of Combinatorial Theory, Series B76.1 (1999), pp. 117–126
1999
-
[46]
Edge-choosability in line-perfect multigraphs
Dale Peterson and Douglas R Woodall. “Edge-choosability in line-perfect multigraphs”. In: Discrete mathematics202.1-3 (1999), pp. 191–199
1999
-
[47]
On the list chromatic index of nearly bipartite multigraphs
Michael J Plantholt and Shailesh K Tipnis. “On the list chromatic index of nearly bipartite multigraphs”. In:Australasian Journal of Combinatorics19 (1999), pp. 157–170
1999
-
[48]
Edge-choosability of multicircuits
Douglas R Woodall. “Edge-choosability of multicircuits”. In:Discrete mathematics202.1-3 (1999), pp. 271–277
1999
-
[49]
On the choosability of complete multipartite graphs with part size three
Henry A Kierstead. “On the choosability of complete multipartite graphs with part size three”. In:Discrete Mathematics211.1-3 (2000), pp. 255–259
2000
-
[50]
Choosability conjectures and multicircuits
Alexandr V Kostochka and Douglas R Woodall. “Choosability conjectures and multicircuits”. In:Discrete Mathematics240.1-3 (2001), pp. 123–143
2001
-
[51]
List colourings of graphs
Douglas R Woodall. “List colourings of graphs”. In:London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series(2001), pp. 269–301
2001
-
[52]
Choice number of some complete multi-partite graphs
Hikoe Enomoto et al. “Choice number of some complete multi-partite graphs”. In:Discrete mathematics244.1-3 (2002), pp. 55–66
2002
-
[53]
Planar graphs without cycles of specific lengths
Gašper Fijavž et al. “Planar graphs without cycles of specific lengths”. In:European Journal of Combinatorics23.4 (2002), pp. 377–388
2002
-
[54]
Total choosability of multicircuits I
Alexandr V Kostochka and Douglas R Woodall. “Total choosability of multicircuits I”. In: Journal of Graph Theory40.1 (2002), pp. 26–43
2002
-
[55]
Total choosability of multicircuits II
Alexandr V Kostochka and Douglas R Woodall. “Total choosability of multicircuits II”. In: Journal of Graph Theory40.1 (2002), pp. 44–67
2002
-
[56]
On chromatic-choosable graphs
Kyoji Ohba. “On chromatic-choosable graphs”. In:Journal of Graph Theory40.2 (2002), pp. 130–135
2002
-
[57]
Choosability and edge choosability of planar graphs without intersecting triangles
Wei-Fan Wang and Ko-Wei Lih. “Choosability and edge choosability of planar graphs without intersecting triangles”. In:SIAM Journal on Discrete Mathematics15.4 (2002), pp. 538–545
2002
-
[58]
Onalist-coloringproblem
SylvainGravier,FrédéricMaffray,andBojanMohar.“Onalist-coloringproblem”.In:Discrete mathematics268.1-3 (2003), pp. 303–308
2003
-
[59]
Choosability of powers of circuits
Anton Prowse and Douglas R Woodall. “Choosability of powers of circuits”. In:Graphs and Combinatorics19 (2003), pp. 137–144
2003
-
[60]
Arizona State University, 2003
Daqing Yang.Extension of the game coloring number and some results on the choosability of complete multipartite graphs. Arizona State University, 2003
2003
-
[61]
On the choice number of claw-free perfect graphs
Sylvain Gravier and Frédéric Maffray. “On the choice number of claw-free perfect graphs”. In:Discrete mathematics276.1-3 (2004), pp. 211–218
2004
-
[62]
Choice number of complete multipartite graphs with part size at most three
Kyoji Ohba. “Choice number of complete multipartite graphs with part size at most three”. In:Ars combinatoria72 (2004), pp. 133–139
2004
-
[63]
Three-coloring planar graphs without certain small cycles
Li Zhang and Baoyindureng Wu. “Three-coloring planar graphs without certain small cycles”. In:Graph Theory Notes of New York46 (2004), pp. 27–30
2004
-
[64]
The 3-choosability of plane graphs of girth 4
Peter CB Lam, Wai Chee Shiu, and Zeng Min Song. “The 3-choosability of plane graphs of girth 4”. In:Discrete mathematics294.3 (2005), pp. 297–301
2005
-
[65]
List Colouring when the Chromatic Number is Close to the Order of the Graph
Bruce Reed and Benny Sudakov. “List Colouring when the Chromatic Number is Close to the Order of the Graph”. In:Combinatorica25.1 (2005), pp. 117–123.doi:10.1007/s00493- 005-0010-x
-
[66]
A note on 3-choosability of planar graphs without certain cycles
Li Zhang and Baoyindureng Wu. “A note on 3-choosability of planar graphs without certain cycles”. In:Discrete mathematics297.1-3 (2005), pp. 206–209
2005
-
[67]
List coloring of Cartesian products of graphs
Mieczysław Borowiecki and Jozef Miškuf. “List coloring of Cartesian products of graphs”. In: Discrete mathematics306.16 (2006), pp. 1955–1958
2006
-
[68]
On the asymptotic value of the choice number of complete multi-partite graphs
Nurit Gazit and Michael Krivelevich. “On the asymptotic value of the choice number of complete multi-partite graphs”. In:Journal of Graph Theory52.2 (2006), pp. 123–134. 20
2006
-
[69]
Bordeaux 3-color conjecture and 3-choosability
Mickaël Montassier, André Raspaud, and Weifan Wang. “Bordeaux 3-color conjecture and 3-choosability”. In:Discrete mathematics306.6 (2006), pp. 573–579
2006
-
[70]
List colouring squares of planar graphs
Frédéric Havet et al. “List colouring squares of planar graphs”. In:Electronic Notes in Discrete Mathematics29 (2007), pp. 515–519
2007
-
[71]
A sufficient condition for a planar graph to be 3-choosable
Liang Shen and Yingqian Wang. “A sufficient condition for a planar graph to be 3-choosable”. In:Information processing letters104.4 (2007), pp. 146–151
2007
-
[72]
The 4-choosability of toroidal graphs without intersecting triangles
Luo Xiaofang. “The 4-choosability of toroidal graphs without intersecting triangles”. In:In- formation processing letters102.2-3 (2007), pp. 85–91
2007
-
[73]
Planar graphs without triangular 4-cycles are 3-choosable
Oleg Veniaminovich Borodin and Anna Olegovna Ivanova. “Planar graphs without triangular 4-cycles are 3-choosable”. In:Siberian Electronic Mathematical Reports5.0 (2008), pp. 75–79
2008
-
[74]
List 2-distance (∆+1)-coloring of planar graphs with given girth
OV Borodin, AO Ivanova, and TK Neustroeva. “List 2-distance (∆+1)-coloring of planar graphs with given girth”. In:Journal of Applied and Industrial Mathematics2.3 (2008), pp. 317–328
2008
-
[75]
List-coloring the square of a subcubic graph
Daniel W Cranston and Seog-Jin Kim. “List-coloring the square of a subcubic graph”. In: Journal of Graph theory57.1 (2008), pp. 65–87
2008
-
[76]
List-coloring squares of sparse sub- cubic graphs
Zdeněk Dvořák, Riste Škrekovski, and Martin Tancer. “List-coloring squares of sparse sub- cubic graphs”. In:SIAM Journal on Discrete Mathematics22.1 (2008), pp. 139–159
2008
-
[77]
ChoicenumberofcompletemultipartitegraphsK 3∗3,2∗(k−5),1∗2 andK 4,3∗2,2∗(k−6),1∗3
WenjieHeetal.“ChoicenumberofcompletemultipartitegraphsK 3∗3,2∗(k−5),1∗2 andK 4,3∗2,2∗(k−6),1∗3”. In:Discrete mathematics308.23 (2008), pp. 5871–5877
2008
-
[78]
On choosability of some complete multipartite graphs and Ohba’s conjec- ture
Yufa Shen et al. “On choosability of some complete multipartite graphs and Ohba’s conjec- ture”. In:Discrete mathematics308.1 (2008), pp. 136–143
2008
-
[79]
A note on 3-choosability of planar graphs
Yingqian Wang, Huajing Lu, and Ming Chen. “A note on 3-choosability of planar graphs”. In:Information processing letters105.5 (2008), pp. 206–211
2008
-
[80]
On 3-choosability of planar graphs without certain cycles
Haihui Zhang and Zhiren Sun. “On 3-choosability of planar graphs without certain cycles”. In:Information processing letters107.3-4 (2008), pp. 102–106
2008
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.