Pith. sign in

REVIEW 2 major objections 5 minor 1 cited by

Universal temperature-dependent power law excitation gaps in frustrated quantum spin systems harboring order-by-disorder

T0 review · 2 major / 5 minor · reviewed 2026-08-07 · deepseek-v4-flash

Challenge this review Re-run · record.json Download PDF Read on arXiv ↗

Pith's one-line read This paper predicts universal power-law temperature growth of the pseudo-Goldstone spin gap in frustrated quantum magnets, with exponents set by the soft-mode dispersion and dimensionality, and derives a linear-spin-wave curvature formula…

desk verdict The curvature formula is solid and useful; the 'universal' scaling law is over-sold and contradicted by one of their own examples. read the letter →

arxiv 2505.18253 v1 pith:BXTGJEBT submitted 2025-05-23 cond-mat.str-el

Alexander Hickey , Jeffrey G. Rau , Subhankar Khatua , Michel J. P. Gingras This is my paper · ORCID
classification cond-mat.str-el
keywords order-by-disorderpseudo-Goldstonegapspinwavetheoryfrustratedmagnetism1/Sexpansionpyrochloremagnetsthermalfluctuationsuniversalpowerlaw
verification ladder T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal

The pith

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The reading

The paper aims to establish that the pseudo-Goldstone magnon gap generated by order-by-disorder in frustrated quantum spin systems has a universal power-law temperature dependence in the low-temperature limit, and that it can be computed from linear spin-wave theory alone, without full many-body self-energy calculations. For a classically gapless mode with linear dispersion (type I) the thermal gap correction is predicted to scale as $\Delta(T)-\Delta_0 \propto S^{1/2}(T/S)^{d+1}$, while for a quadratically dispersing mode (type II) it scales as $\Delta(T)-\Delta_0 \propto S^0(T/S)^{d/2+1}$, where $d$ is the spatial dimension. The paper proves a finite-temperature curvature formula that reproduces the $O(S^0)$ self-energy result using only linear spin-wave data, and applies it to Er2Ti2O7, predicting $\Delta_0 \approx 31.1\ \mu$eV and a $T^4$ thermal correction. If correct, this gives a direct experimental signature of order-by-disorder that is independent of the microscopic spin Hamiltonian.

What carries the argument

The central object is the curvature formula $\Delta(T)=\sqrt{g_{\phi\phi}g_{\theta\theta}-g_{\phi\theta}^2}$ (type II) and $\Delta(T)=S^{1/2}\sqrt{(\partial^2\epsilon_{\rm cl}/\partial\theta^2)_0\,g_{\phi\phi}}$ (type I), with $g_{\mu\nu}(T)\equiv (1/S)[(\partial^2 f/\partial\lambda_\mu\partial\lambda_\nu)_0 + K_{\mu\nu}]$, where $f$ is the $O(S)$ linear spin-wave free energy and $K_{\mu\nu}$ is a momentum sum over products of derivatives of the spin-wave energies weighted by $\operatorname{csch}^2(S\epsilon_{\boldsymbol{k},\alpha}/2k_BT)$. A spectral-function sum rule links these free-energy curvatures to the magnon self-energy, proving the formula reproduces the gap to $O(S^0)$. The value of the object is that it lets one compute the thermal gap entirely from linear spin-wave eigenvectors and energies, bypassing three- and four-magnon self-energy diagrams and remaining well-defined in $d<3$ where the self-energy is infrared divergent.

What would settle it

A clean low-temperature measurement of $\Delta(T)-\Delta_0$ in a suspected order-by-disorder material that finds an exponent distinct from $d+1$ (type I) or $d/2+1$ (type II), after carefully subtracting the zero-temperature gap and checking that no higher-order anisotropy is responsible, would contradict the universal scaling claim.

Watch

Extended reading notes

Core claim

At leading order in the $1/S$ expansion and for $0<T\ll T_c$, the temperature-dependent part of the pseudo-Goldstone gap is controlled by the curvature of the linear spin-wave free energy along the soft directions. For type I modes with $\epsilon_{\boldsymbol{k}}\propto |\boldsymbol{k}|$, the thermal correction obeys $\Delta(T)-\Delta_0 \propto S^{1/2}(T/S)^{d+1}$; for type II modes with $\epsilon_{\boldsymbol{k}}\propto|\boldsymbol{k}|^2$, it obeys $\Delta(T)-\Delta_0 \propto S^0(T/S)^{d/2+1}$. The paper establishes a curvature formula (Eq. (11)) that expresses the gap to $O(S^0)$ through second derivatives of the $O(S)$ linear spin-wave free energy plus a thermal curvature term $K_{\mu\nu}$, and demonstrates numerically for the Heisenberg-compass model that this formula agrees with an independent non-linear spin-wave self-energy calculation with no free parameters. Applying the formula to the pyrochlore antiferromagnet Er2Ti2O7 yields $\Delta_0 = 31.1\ \mu$eV and a $T^4$ thermal correction, consistent with its type I order-by-disorder character.

Load-bearing premise

The universal power laws assume that the leading low-temperature term in the curvature of the linear spin-wave free energy along the soft directions is anisotropic and thereby controls the gap; if, as in Lu2V2O7, the leading term is orientation-independent and only higher-order anisotropies enter, the exponent changes from $T^{d/2+1}$ to a higher power (there $T^{7/2}$).

Editorial extensions

If this is right

  • A measured exponent $d+1$ or $d/2+1$ for $\Delta(T)-\Delta_0$ in the ordered phase would be a direct experimental signature of order-by-disorder that does not rely on fitting an exchange model.
  • The curvature formula gives a practical path to compute finite-temperature pseudo-Goldstone gaps for a wide class of frustrated magnets using only linear spin-wave theory.
  • For Er2Ti2O7, the predicted correction $\Delta(700\ \mathrm{mK})-\Delta_0 \approx 2.9\ \mu$eV provides a concrete target for high-resolution neutron backscattering experiments.
  • The exponent distinguishes the mean-field dispersion of the soft mode, thereby identifying whether the system hosts a type I or type II pseudo-Goldstone mode.
  • The same method is directly applicable to other candidate order-by-disorder materials such as Yb2Ge2O7, CoTiO3, Sr2Cu3O4Cl2, and Fe2Ca3(GeO4)3.

Reading between the lines

Editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

  • The $T^{7/2}$ result reported for Lu2V2O7 in the Supplemental Material shows that the universal exponent is conditioned on the leading free-energy term being anisotropic; experiments claiming universality should first establish that the anisotropic curvature does not vanish.
  • In two dimensions, where long-range order is forbidden but the curvature formula remains well-defined, the formalism could be used to track how the pseudo-Goldstone gap evolves as self-energy approaches are infrared divergent.
  • A systematic analysis of $\Delta(T)-\Delta_0$ across the four candidate materials, with care to identify crossover temperatures, would let one test whether the observed gaps have the order-by-disorder origin or arise from additional exchange anisotropies.
Share X Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit HN

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, and a circularity audit.

Referee Report

2 major / 5 minor

Summary. The manuscript studies the pseudo-Goldstone (PG) gap in frustrated quantum magnets with order-by-disorder at finite temperature. It extends the zero-temperature curvature formula of Ref. [43] to finite temperature, relating the O(S^0) PG gap to the curvature of the linear spin-wave free energy plus a correction term K_mu_nu, and tests the formula against direct self-energy calculations for the Heisenberg-compass model, Er2Ti2O7, Yb2Ge2O7, and Lu2V2O7. The central quantitative claim is Eq. (16): at leading order for 0<T<<T_c, the thermal correction to the gap scales as S^{1/2}(T/S)^{d+1} for type I (linearly dispersing) modes and S^0(T/S)^{d/2+1} for type II (quadratically dispersing) modes. The Supplemental Material, however, reports a type II example, Lu2V2O7, for which the gap scales as T^{7/2} rather than the T^{5/2} predicted by Eq. (16).

Significance. The finite-temperature curvature formula, Eq. (11), is a valuable practical tool: it allows the PG gap to be computed to O(S^0) using only linear spin-wave theory, avoiding explicit self-energy calculations. The parameter-free agreement between Eq. (11) and the self-energy formulas Eqs. (5)-(6) in Figs. 2, 3, and S1 is persuasive, and the explicit supplemental formulas make the calculation reproducible. If the scaling law Eq. (16) can be stated with correct conditions, it offers a falsifiable experimental signature of order-by-disorder that is independent of the microscopic Hamiltonian. However, the universality of Eq. (16) is overstated, because the paper's own Lu2V2O7 results contradict it without a stated additional condition.

major comments (2)
  1. [Discussion, Eq. (16); Supplemental Material, Sec. III.B, Eq. (S81) and Fig. S2] The unqualified universal scaling in Eq. (16) is internally inconsistent with the paper's own Lu2V2O7 results. The Supplemental Material shows that for this type II system with |D|/J << 1, the low-temperature gap scales as T^{7/2}, not T^{5/2}; Eq. (S81) gives f = a T^{5/2} + b(phi,theta) T^{7/2} + O(T^{9/2}) with a orientation-independent, so the leading T^{5/2} term has zero curvature along the soft directions and the gap is controlled by the next order. The main text must either restrict Eq. (16) to systems where the leading low-temperature free-energy curvature is angle-dependent, or discuss this exception explicitly and adjust the 'universal' wording in the title and abstract.
  2. [Discussion, Eqs. (11)-(13) and the derivation of Eq. (16)] The passage from the curvature formula Eq. (11) to the power law Eq. (16) is a dimensional analysis that implicitly assumes the leading low-temperature term in g_mu_nu depends on the soft angles. Since Eq. (11) involves the determinant g_phi_phi g_theta_theta - g_phi_theta^2, an isotropic leading term cancels and the gap is controlled by the next anisotropy term, as in the Lu2V2O7 example. This condition is not stated in the main text, and no proof or general criterion is given for when the leading term is anisotropic. The paper should state this assumption as an explicit condition and provide a testable criterion, or prove the scaling under a well-defined hypothesis.
minor comments (5)
  1. [References] References [54] and [62] are the same paper (Khatua, Gingras, and Rau, Phys. Rev. Lett. 130, 266702 (2023)) and should be merged to avoid duplicate bibliography entries.
  2. [Discussion, paragraph beginning 'The ability to calculate'] There is a typo in the sentence 'tedious calculation of of the magnon self-energy'; the duplicated 'of' should be removed.
  3. [Fig. 2 caption] The caption of Fig. 2 does not define the parameter xi, which appears in the panels; the definition should be included in the caption for readability.
  4. [Discussion, paragraph before Eq. (16)] The sentence introducing Eq. (16) says the scaling is 'generically' satisfied, while the preceding text and the title claim 'universal'; these wordings should be reconciled after the conditions for Eq. (16) are clarified.
  5. [Supplemental Material, Eq. (S81)] The counterexample in Eq. (S81) is only presented in the Supplemental Material; the main text should point the reader to this caveat where Eq. (16) is introduced.

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged · score 0.0 of 10

No significant circularity: Eq. (11) is derived from a spectral sum rule and benchmarked against direct self-energy calculations without fitted parameters; the Lu2V2O7 T^{7/2} result is a generality caveat, not a circular step.

full rationale

The paper's central derivation of the finite-temperature curvature formula, Eq. (11), is self-contained: the Supplemental Material establishes the spectral sum rule (Eq. S59), relates the first moment of the magnon spectral function to the effective Hamiltonian (Eqs. S66-S69), and obtains the type I and type II gap formulas without importing the desired temperature dependence. The gap exponents in Eq. (16) are obtained by dimensional analysis of Eq. (12) for linear and quadratic dispersions; they are not imposed by assuming the answer, and the paper explicitly checks the curvature formula against direct self-energy calculations in Figs. 2 and 3 and Figs. S1-S2, stating that 'these two calculations are carried out independently of one another, and there are no free parameters introduced to make them agree.' Self-citations to Refs. [43], [54], and [13] are used as prior anchors, but the finite-temperature generalization is re-derived in the supplement, so the citations are not the sole load-bearing support. The flagged Lu2V2O7 passage in the Supplemental Material (Eq. S81, Fig. S2) explicitly states that the gap scales as T^{7/2}, 'distinct from the expected T^{5/2} scaling for a type II mode,' because the leading free-energy term is orientation-independent with the anisotropy entering at O(k^4). This is an internal caveat to the universality of Eq. (16) and a correctness risk, but it is not circularity: the derivation does not reduce to its inputs, and the main text's omission of the angular-curvature condition is an overstatement rather than a self-referential loop. No step in the claimed derivation chain is equivalent, by construction or by fit, to the result it purports to derive.

Assumptions & free parameters 3 free parameters · 5 assumptions · 0 invented entities

The core scaling law has no fitted constants beyond the model inputs. The material-specific predictions use exchange couplings fitted by prior neutron-scattering analyses, which are external inputs, not parameters tuned to reproduce the gap. The main ad hoc element is the generic assumption that the leading free-energy curvature is anisotropic, which is not guaranteed, as the Lu2V2O7 case shows.

free parameters (3)
  • Er2Ti2O7 exchange couplings J_zz, J±, J±±, J_z± = from Savary et al. 2012, values not listed in text
    Used in Eq. (15) to compute the Er2Ti2O7 gap (Fig. 3). These were fitted to inelastic neutron scattering data in Ref. [39], not fit in this paper.
  • Yb2Ge2O7 exchange couplings J_zz, J±, J±±, J_z± = 0.128, 0.138, 0.044, -0.188 meV
    Used in Supplemental Material Sec. III.A for Yb2Ge2O7; fitted to neutron data in the cited prior work.
  • Lu2V2O7 couplings J and |D| = J=8.22 meV, |D|=1.5 meV
    Used in Supplemental Material Sec. III.B for Lu2V2O7; fitted to neutron data in the cited prior work.
assumptions (5)
  • domain assumption Holstein-Primakoff boson mapping and the 1/S expansion truncated at leading order are valid for the ordered state.
    Invoked at the start of the spin-wave section, Eq. (1) and Supplemental Material Sec. I.A. The paper applies the result even at S=1/2, where 1/S corrections are not obviously small a priori.
  • domain assumption The pseudo-Goldstone mode sits at the Brillouin zone center, k=0.
    Main text states 'throughout this paper, we assume that this mode is located at the Brillouin zone center (k=0), although this assumption can be relaxed in general.' The gap formulas project onto the k=0 zero mode.
  • standard math The first-moment spectral sum rule Eq. (10) holds with the thermal expectation value at fixed temperature, and the self-energy can be expanded at (0,0) to O(S^0).
    The sum-rule derivation in Supplemental Material Sec. II.A uses the standard Lehmann representation and analytic continuation; the gap formulas rely on evaluating the retarded self-energy at zero frequency.
  • ad hoc to paper The leading low-temperature free-energy curvature along the soft directions is anisotropic, so the power law in Eq. (16) is generic.
    This is the load-bearing premise behind the universal exponents. The Lu2V2O7 case in Supplemental Material Sec. III.B violates it: the leading T^{5/2} free-energy term is orientation-independent, so the gap appears only at T^{7/2}.
  • domain assumption The low-temperature limit is taken with T/S held fixed, so thermal and quantum corrections enter at the same order in the 1/S expansion.
    Stated in the main text: 'in order to incorporate thermal effects into the self-energy, we must take the limit 1/S -> 0 while keeping T/S fixed.' This controls the Bose function arguments and the form of Eq. (16).

how reviews work

0 comments
Cite this review

Pith. "Pith review of Universal temperature-dependent power law excitation gaps in frustrated quantum spin systems harboring order-by-disorder." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/BXTGJEBT

@misc{pith2026250518253,
  author       = {Pith},
  title        = {Pith review of: Universal temperature-dependent power law excitation gaps in frustrated quantum spin systems harboring order-by-disorder},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/BXTGJEBT}},
  note         = {Machine review of arXiv:2505.18253}
}
abstract

When magnetic moments are subject to competing or frustrated interactions, continuous degeneracies that are not protected by any symmetry of the parent Hamiltonian can emerge at the classical (mean-field) level. Such "accidental" degeneracies are often lifted by both thermal and quantum fluctuations via a mechanism known as order-by-disorder (ObD). The leading proposal to detect and characterize ObD in real materials, in a way that quantitatively distinguishes it from standard energetic selection, is to measure a small fluctuation-induced pseudo-Goldstone gap in the excitation spectrum. While the properties of this gap are known to leading order in the spin wave interactions, in both the zero-temperature and classical limits, the pseudo-Goldstone (PG) gap in quantum magnets at finite temperature has yet to be characterized. Using non-linear spin wave theory, we compute the PG gap to leading order in a $1/S$ expansion at low temperature for a variety of frustrated quantum spin systems. We also develop a formalism to calculate the PG gap in a way that solely uses linear spin-wave theory, circumventing the need to carry out tedious quantum many-body calculations. We argue that, at leading order, the PG gap acquires a distinct power-law temperature dependence, proportional to either $T^{d+1}$ or $T^{d/2+1}$ depending on the gapless dispersion of the PG mode predicted at the mean-field level. Finally, we examine the implications of these results for the pyrochlore oxide compound Er$_2$Ti$_2$O$_7$, for which there is compelling evidence of ObD giving rise to the experimentally observed long-range order.

Figures

Figures reproduced from arXiv: 2505.18253 by the authors.

Figure 1
Figure 1. FIG. 1. Schematic picture depicting the spectrum of a PG modes for [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p001_1.png] view at source ↗
Figure 2
Figure 2. FIG. 2. PG gap for the Heisenberg-compass model Eq. [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p004_2.png] view at source ↗
Figure 3
Figure 3. FIG. 3. PG gap for the pyrochlore antiferromagnet [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p005_3.png] view at source ↗

Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.

Forward citations

Cited by 1 Pith paper

Reviewed papers in the Pith corpus that reference this work. Sorted by Pith novelty score. Full citation record

  1. Anharmonic Collective Oscillations in Isotropic Spin Systems and their Spectroscopic Signatures

    cond-mat.str-el 2025-08 conditional novelty 7.0 of 10

    Quartic spin oscillations in spiral magnets generate a thermally induced spin-wave gap that scales as √T in the thermodynamic limit, with a finite-size T^{1/4} regime that vanishes as system size grows.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

91 extracted references · 67 canonical work pages · cited by 1 Pith paper

  1. [1]

    London, The𝜆-Phenomenon of Liquid Helium and the Bose- Einstein Degeneracy, Nature141, 643 (1938)

    F. London, The𝜆-Phenomenon of Liquid Helium and the Bose- Einstein Degeneracy, Nature141, 643 (1938)

    1938

  2. [2]

    Balents, Spin liquids in frustrated magnets, Nature464, 199 (2010)

    L. Balents, Spin liquids in frustrated magnets, Nature464, 199 (2010)

    2010

  3. [3]

    M.J.P.GingrasandP.A.McClarty,Quantumspinice: Asearch for gapless quantum spin liquids in pyrochlore magnets, Rep. Prog. Phys.77, 056501 (2014)

    2014

  4. [4]

    Imai and Y

    T. Imai and Y. S. Lee, Do quantum spin liquids exist?, Phys. Today69, 30 (2016). 6

    2016

  5. [5]

    Savary and L

    L. Savary and L. Balents, Quantum spin liquids: A review, Reports on Progress in Physics80, 016502 (2017)

    2017

  6. [6]

    Knolle and R

    J. Knolle and R. Moessner, A field guide to spin liquids, Annu. Rev. Condens. Matter Phys.10, 451 (2019)

    2019

  7. [7]

    Villain, Insulating spin-glasses, Zeitschrift für Physik B- Condensed Matter33, 31 (1979)

    J. Villain, Insulating spin-glasses, Zeitschrift für Physik B- Condensed Matter33, 31 (1979)

    1979

  8. [8]

    Moessner and J

    R. Moessner and J. T. Chalker, Low-temperature properties of classical geometrically frustrated antiferromagnets, Phys. Rev. B 58, 12049 (1998)

    1998

Show all 91 references
  1. [9]

    Lozano-Gómez, V

    D. Lozano-Gómez, V. Noculak, J. Oitmaa, R. R. P. Singh, Y. Iqbal, J. Reuther, and M. J. P. Gingras, Competing gauge fields and entropically driven spin liquid to spin liquid transition in non-Kramers pyrochlores, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.121, e2403487121 (2024)

    2024

  2. [10]

    Lozano-Gómez, O

    D. Lozano-Gómez, O. Benton, M. J. P. Gingras, and H. Yan, An atlas of classical pyrochlore spin liquids, arXiv:2411.03547 [cond-mat.str-el] 10.48550/arXiv.2411.03547 (2024)

    2024 doi arXiv

  3. [11]

    Note that the existence of an accidental degeneracy by no means implies this intermediate scenario

  4. [12]

    Villain, R

    J. Villain, R. Bidaux, J.-P. Carton, and R. Conte, Order as an effect of disorder, J. Phys.41, 1263 (1980)

    1980

  5. [13]

    E. F. Shender, Antiferromagnetic garnets with fluctuationally interacting sublattices, Sov. Phys. JETP56, 178 (1982)

    1982

  6. [14]

    C. L. Henley, Ordering due to disorder in a frustrated vector antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. Lett.62, 2056 (1989)

    1989

  7. [15]

    C. L. Henley, Ordering by disorder: Ground-state selection in fcc vector antiferromagnets, J. Appl. Phys.61, 3962 (1987)

    1987

  8. [16]

    Prakash and C

    S. Prakash and C. L. Henley, Ordering due to disorder in dipolar magnets on two-dimensional lattices, Phys. Rev. B42, 6574 (1990)

    1990

  9. [17]

    J. N. Reimers and A. J. Berlinsky, Order by disorder in the classical Heisenberg kagomé Antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B48, 9539 (1993)

    1993

  10. [18]

    Noculak, D

    V. Noculak, D. Lozano-Gómez, J. Oitmaa, R. R. P. Singh, Y. Iqbal, M. J. P. Gingras, and J. Reuther, Classical and quantum phases of the pyrochlore𝑆= 1 2 magnet with Heisenberg and Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interactions, Phys. Rev. B107, 214414 (2023)

    2023

  11. [19]

    Hickey, D

    A. Hickey, D. Lozano-Gómez, and M. J. P. Gingras, Order- by-disorder without quantum zero-point fluctuations in the py- rochlore Heisenberg ferromagnet with Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interactions, Phys. Rev. B111, 184434 (2025)

    2025

  12. [20]

    Bergman, J

    D. Bergman, J. Alicea, E. Gull, S. Trebst, and L. Balents, Order- by-disorder and spiral spin-liquid in frustrated diamond-lattice antiferromagnets, Nat. Phys.3, 487 (2007)

    2007

  13. [21]

    Chern, Pyrochlore antiferromagnet with antisymmetric exchange interactions: critical behavior and order from disorder, arXiv:1008.3038 [cond-mat.str-el] (2010)

    G.-W. Chern, Pyrochlore antiferromagnet with antisymmetric exchange interactions: critical behavior and order from disorder, arXiv:1008.3038 [cond-mat.str-el] (2010)

    2010 arXiv

  14. [22]

    M. V. Gvozdikova, P.-E. Melchy, and M. E. Zhitomirsky, Mag- netic phase diagrams of classical triangular and kagome antifer- romagnets, J. Phys. Condens. Matter23, 164209 (2011)

    2011

  15. [23]

    P.A.McClarty,P.Stasiak,andM.J.P.Gingras,Order-by-disorder in the𝑋𝑌 pyrochlore antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B89, 024425 (2014)

    2014

  16. [24]

    N.Francini,L.Janssen,andD.Lozano-Gómez,Higher-rankspin liquids and spin nematics from competing orders in pyrochlore magnets, Phys. Rev. B111, 085140 (2025)

    2025

  17. [25]

    J. R. Tessman, Magnetic Anisotropy at0◦K, Phys. Rev.96, 1192 (1954)

    1954

  18. [26]

    Belorizky, R

    E. Belorizky, R. Casalegno, and J. J. Niez, Calculation of the SpinWaveEnergyGapat 𝒌=0 foraSimpleCubicFerromagnet with Anisotropic Exchange Interactions, Phys. Status Solidi B 102, 365 (1980)

    1980

  19. [27]

    Chandra and B

    P. Chandra and B. Doucot, Possible spin-liquid state at large 𝑆 for the frustrated square Heisenberg lattice, Phys. Rev. B38, 9335 (1988)

    1988

  20. [28]

    Kubo and T

    K. Kubo and T. Kishi, Ordering Due to Quantum Fluctuations in the Frustrated Heisenberg Model, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn.60, 567 (1991)

    1991

  21. [29]

    Sachdev, Kagomé and triangular-lattice Heisenberg antifer- romagnets: Ordering from quantum fluctuations and quantum- disordered ground states with unconfined bosonic spinons, Phys

    S. Sachdev, Kagomé and triangular-lattice Heisenberg antifer- romagnets: Ordering from quantum fluctuations and quantum- disordered ground states with unconfined bosonic spinons, Phys. Rev. B45, 12377 (1992)

    1992

  22. [30]

    A. V. Chubukov and D. I. Golosov, Quantum theory of an antiferromagnetonatriangularlatticeinamagneticfield,J.Phys. Condens. Matter3, 69 (1991)

    1991

  23. [31]

    A.Chubukov,OrderfromDisorderinaKagoméAntiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. Lett.69, 832 (1992)

    1992

  24. [32]

    C. L. Henley, Selection by Quantum Fluctuations of Dipolar Order in a Diamond Lattice, Phys. Rev. Lett.73, 2788 (1994)

    1994

  25. [33]

    Lecheminant, B

    P. Lecheminant, B. Bernu, C. Lhuillier, and L. Pierre,𝐽1−𝐽 2 quantum Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the triangular lattice: A group-symmetry analysis of order by disorder, Phys. Rev. B52, 6647 (1995)

    1995

  26. [34]

    R. R. Sobral and C. Lacroix, Order by disorder in the pyrochlore antiferromagnets, Solid State Communications103, 407 (1997)

    1997

  27. [35]

    Balakrishnan, S

    J.D.M.Champion,M.J.Harris,P.C.W.Holdsworth,A.S.Wills, G. Balakrishnan, S. T. Bramwell, E. Čižmár, T. Fennell, J. S. Gardner, J. Lago, D. F. McMorrow, M. Orendáč, A. Orendáčová, D. M. Paul, R. I. Smith, M. T. F. Telling, and A. Wildes, Er2Ti2O7: Evidenceofquantumorderbydisorder...

    2003

  28. [36]

    Baskaran, D

    G. Baskaran, D. Sen, and R. Shankar, Spin-𝑆 Kitaev model: Classicalgroundstates,orderfromdisorder,andexactcorrelation functions, Phys. Rev. B78, 115116 (2008)

    2008

  29. [37]

    Bernier, M

    J.-S. Bernier, M. J. Lawler, and Y. B. Kim, Quantum Order by Disorder in Frustrated Diamond Lattice Antiferromagnets, Phys. Rev. Lett.101, 047201 (2008)

    2008

  30. [38]

    Mulder, R

    A. Mulder, R. Ganesh, L. Capriotti, and A. Paramekanti, Spiral orderbydisorderandlatticenematicorderinafrustratedHeisen- berg antiferromagnet on the honeycomb lattice, Phys. Rev. B81, 214419 (2010)

    2010

  31. [39]

    L.Savary, K.A.Ross, B.D.Gaulin, J.P.C.Ruff,andL.Balents, Order by Quantum Disorder in Er2Ti2O7, Phys. Rev. Lett.109, 167201 (2012)

    2012

  32. [40]

    M. E. Zhitomirsky, M. V. Gvozdikova, P. C. W. Holdsworth, and R. Moessner, Quantum Order by Disorder and Accidental Soft Mode in Er2Ti2O7, Phys. Rev. Lett.109, 077204 (2012)

    2012

  33. [41]

    A. L. Chernyshev and M. E. Zhitomirsky, Quantum Selection of Order in an𝑋𝑋𝑍 Antiferromagnet on a Kagome Lattice, Phys. Rev. Lett.113, 237202 (2014)

    2014

  34. [42]

    Rousochatzakis, J

    I. Rousochatzakis, J. Reuther, R. Thomale, S. Rachel, and N. B. Perkins, Phase Diagram and Quantum Order by Disorder in the Kitaev𝐾1−𝐾 2 Honeycomb Magnet, Phys. Rev. X5, 041035 (2015)

    2015

  35. [44]

    Placke, R

    B. Placke, R. Moessner, and O. Benton, Hierarchy of energy scales and field-tunable order by disorder in dipolar-octupolar pyrochlores, Phys. Rev. B102, 245102 (2020)

    2020

  36. [45]

    Chen and X

    G. Chen and X. Wang, Electron quasi-itinerancy intertwined with quantum order by disorder in pyrochlore iridate magnetism, Phys. Rev. Res.2, 043273 (2020)

    2020

  37. [46]

    C.Liu,C.-J.Huang,andG.Chen,IntrinsicquantumIsingmodel on a triangular lattice magnetTmMgGao4, Phys. Rev. Res.2, 043013 (2020)

    2020

  38. [47]

    Khatua, S

    S. Khatua, S. Srinivasan, and R. Ganesh, State selection in 7 frustrated magnets, Phys. Rev. B103, 174412 (2021)

    2021

  39. [48]

    S.Khatua,G.C.Howson,M.J.P.Gingras,andJ.G.Rau,Ground state properties of the Heisenberg-compass model on the square lattice, Phys. Rev. B110, 104426 (2024)

    2024

  40. [49]

    K. A. Ross, Y. Qiu, J. R. D. Copley, H. A. Dabkowska, and B. D. Gaulin, Order by Disorder Spin Wave Gap in the𝑋𝑌 Pyrochlore Magnet Er2Ti2O7, Phys. Rev. Lett.112, 057201 (2014)

    2014

  41. [50]

    C. L. Sarkis, J. G. Rau, L. D. Sanjeewa, M. Powell, J. Kolis, J. Marbey, S. Hill, J. A. Rodriguez-Rivera, H. S. Nair, D. R. Yahne, S. Säubert, M. J. P. Gingras, and K. A. Ross, Unravel- ling competing microscopic interactions at a phase boundary: A single-crystal study of the ...

    2020

  42. [51]

    Elliot, P

    M. Elliot, P. A. McClarty, D. Prabhakaran, R. D. Johnson, H. C. Walker, P. Manuel, and R. Coldea, Order-by-Disorder from Bond-Dependent Exchange and Intensity Signature of Nodal Quasiparticles in a Honeycomb Cobaltate, Nature Communica- tions12, 3936 (2021)

    2021

  43. [52]

    Y. J. Kim, A. Aharony, R. J. Birgeneau, F. C. Chou, O. Entin- Wohlman, R. W. Erwin, M. Greven, A. B. Harris, M. A. Kastner, I. Y. Korenblit, Y. S. Lee, and G. Shirane, Ordering due to Quantum Fluctuations in Sr2Cu3O4Cl2, Phys. Rev. Lett.83, 852 (1999)

    1999

  44. [53]

    Brueckel, B

    T. Brueckel, B. Dorner, A. G. Gukasov, V. P. Plakhty, W. Prandl, E. F. Shender, and O. P. Smirnow, Dynamical interaction of antiferromagnetic subsystems: a neutron scattering study of the spinwave spectrum of the garnet Fe2Ca3(GeO4)3, Z. Phys. B72, 477 (1988)

    1988

  45. [54]

    Khatua, M

    S. Khatua, M. J. P. Gingras, and J. G. Rau, Pseudo-goldstone modes and dynamical gap generation from order by thermal disorder, Phys. Rev. Lett.130, 266702 (2023)

    2023

  46. [55]

    Holstein and H

    T. Holstein and H. Primakoff, Field Dependence of the Intrinsic Domain Magnetization of a Ferromagnet, Phys. Rev.58, 1098 (1940)

    1940

  47. [56]

    Refer to the Supplemental Material for details of spin-wave theory and the proof of the curvature formula

  48. [57]

    Blaizot and G

    J.-P. Blaizot and G. Ripka,Quantum Theory of Finite Systems (MIT Press, 1986)

    1986

  49. [58]

    normal”referstothenumber-conservingblocksofEq. (1) (i.e. terms proportional to𝑎†𝑎 and𝑎𝑎†) and “anomalous

    Here,“normal”referstothenumber-conservingblocksofEq. (1) (i.e. terms proportional to𝑎†𝑎 and𝑎𝑎†) and “anomalous” refers to the number-non-conserving blocks (i.e. terms proportional to 𝑎†𝑎† and𝑎𝑎)

  50. [59]

    Rastelli,Statistical Mechanics of Magnetic Excitations: from Spin Waves to Stripes to Checkerboards(World Scientific, Lon- don, 2013)

    E. Rastelli,Statistical Mechanics of Magnetic Excitations: from Spin Waves to Stripes to Checkerboards(World Scientific, Lon- don, 2013)

    2013

  51. [60]

    J. W. Negele and H. Orland,Quantum Many-particle Systems (Westview Press, 1988)

    1988

  52. [61]

    Watanabe and H

    H. Watanabe and H. Murayama, Unified Description of Nambu- Goldstone Bosons without Lorentz Invariance, Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 251602 (2012)

    2012

  53. [62]

    Khatua, M

    S. Khatua, M. J. P. Gingras, and J. G. Rau, Pseudo-Goldstone Modes and Dynamical Gap Generation from Order by Thermal Disorder, Phys. Rev. Lett.130, 266702 (2023)

    2023

  54. [63]

    R. P. Feynman, Forces in Molecules, Phys. Rev.56, 340 (1939)

    1939

  55. [64]

    Mutka, M

    S.Petit,J.Robert,S.Guitteny,P.Bonville,C.Decorse,J.Ollivier, H. Mutka, M. J. P. Gingras, and I. Mirebeau, Order by disorder or energetic selection of the ground state in the𝑋𝑌 pyrochlore antiferromagnetEr 2Ti2O7: Aninelasticneutronscatteringstudy, Phys. Rev. B90, 060410 (2014)

    2014

  56. [65]

    K. A. Ross, L. Savary, B. D. Gaulin, and L. Balents, Quantum excitations in quantum spin ice, Phys. Rev. X1, 021002 (2011)

    2011

  57. [67]

    H. Yan, O. Benton, L. Jaubert, and N. Shannon, Theory of multiple-phase competition in pyrochlore magnets with anisotropic exchange with application to Yb2Ti2O7, Er2Ti2O7, and Er2Sn2O7, Phys. Rev. B95, 094422 (2017)

    2017

  58. [68]

    Lhotel, J

    E. Lhotel, J. Robert, E. Ressouche, F. Damay, I. Mirebeau, J.Ollivier,H.Mutka,P.DalmasdeRéotier,A.Yaouanc,C.Marin, C. Decorse, and S. Petit, Field-induced phase diagram of the XY pyrochlore antiferromagnet Er2Ti2O7, Phys. Rev. B95, 134426 (2017)

    2017

  59. [69]

    Coleman, There are no Goldstone bosons in two dimensions, Commun

    S. Coleman, There are no Goldstone bosons in two dimensions, Commun. Math. Phys31, 259 (1973)

    1973

  60. [70]

    N. D. Mermin and H. Wagner, Absence of Ferromagnetism or Antiferromagnetism in One- or Two-Dimensional Isotropic Heisenberg Models, Phys. Rev. Lett.17, 1133 (1966)

    1966

  61. [71]

    P. C. Hohenberg, Existence of Long-Range Order in One and Two Dimensions, Phys. Rev.158, 383 (1967)

    1967

  62. [72]

    V. L. Berezinskii, Destruction of Long-range Order in One- dimensional and Two-dimensional Systems having a Continuous Symmetry Group I. Classical Systems, Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz.59, 907 (1970), [Sov. Phys. JETP32, 493 (1971)]

    1970

  63. [73]

    V. L. Berezinskii, Destruction of Long-range Order in One- dimensional and Two-dimensional Systems Possessing a Con- tinuous Symmetry Group II. Quantum Systems, Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz.61, 1144 (1971), [Sov. Phys. JETP34, 610 (1972)]

    1971

  64. [74]

    P. D. Loly, The Heisenberg ferromagnet in the selfconsistently renormalized spin wave approximation, J. Phys. C: Solid State Phys.4, 1365 (1971)

    1971

  65. [75]

    W. T. Fuhrman, M. Mourigal, M. E. Zhitomirsky, and A. L. Chernyshev, Dynamical structure factor of quasi-two- dimensional antiferromagnet in high fields, Phys. Rev. B85, 184405 (2012)

    2012

  66. [76]

    Schick, O

    R. Schick, O. Götze, T. Ziman, R. Zinke, J. Richter, and M. E. Zhitomirsky, Ground-state selection by magnon interactions in a fcc antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B106, 094431 (2022)

    2022

  67. [77]

    C. A. Gallegos and A. L. Chernyshev, Magnon interactions in the quantum paramagnetic phase of CoNb2O6, Phys. Rev. B109, 014424 (2024)

    2024

  68. [78]

    J. S. Gardner, G. Ehlers, A. Faraone, and V. G. Sakai, High- resolutionneutronspectroscopyusingbackscatteringandneutron spin-echo spectrometers in soft and hard condensed matter, Nature Reviews Physics2, 103 (2020)

    2020

  69. [79]

    Universal temperature-dependent power law excitation gaps in frustrated quantum spin systems harboring order-by-disorder

    X. Lin and T. Shi, Pseudo-Goldstone Modes at Finite Tempera- ture, arXiv:2505.07229v1 [cond-mat.str-el] (2025). 8 Supplemental Material for “Universal temperature-dependent power law excitation gaps in frustrated quantum spin systems harboring order-by-disorder” Alexander Hick...

    2025 arXiv

  70. [80]

    indirect

    One can subsequently calculate the appropriate spin-wave theory using Eqs. (S4-S8). Alternatively, these small rotations can be related to the magnon zero-modes 𝑏0≡ 𝑽† 0 𝝈3 /√︁a√︂enleftt√︁/√︁a√︂enleftex /√︁a√︂enleftbt 𝒂0 𝒂† 0 /√︁a√︂en√︂ightt√︁/√︁a√︂en√︂ightex /√︁a√︂en√︂ig...

  71. [81]

    Blaizot and G

    J.-P. Blaizot and G. Ripka,Quantum Theory of Finite Systems(MIT Press, 1986)

    1986

  72. [82]

    Colpa, Diagonalization of the quadratic boson hamiltonian, Phys

    J. Colpa, Diagonalization of the quadratic boson hamiltonian, Phys. A: Stat. Mech. Appl.93, 327 (1978)

    1978

  73. [83]

    Kondo, Y

    H. Kondo, Y. Akagi, and H. Katsura, Non-Hermiticity and topological invariants of magnon Bogoli- ubov–de Gennes systems, Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys2020, 12A104 (2020)

    2020

  74. [84]

    J. G. Rau, P. A. McClarty, and R. Moessner, Pseudo-Goldstone Gaps and Order-by-Quantum Disorder in Frustrated Magnets, Phys. Rev. Lett.121, 237201 (2018)

    2018

  75. [85]

    E.Rastelli, StatisticalMechanicsofMagneticExcitations: fromSpinWavestoStripestoCheckerboards (World Scientific, London, 2013)

    2013

  76. [86]

    G. D. Mahan,Many-Particle Physics, 3rd ed. (Springer New York, 2000)

    2000

  77. [87]

    Altland and B

    A. Altland and B. Simons,Condensed Matter Field Theory, 2nd ed. (Cambridge University Press, 2010)

    2010

  78. [88]

    J. G. Rau and M. J. P. Gingras, Frustrated Quantum Rare-Earth Pyrochlores, Annual Review of Condensed Matter Physics10, 357 (2019)

    2019

  79. [89]

    C. L. Sarkis, J. G. Rau, L. D. Sanjeewa, M. Powell, J. Kolis, J. Marbey, S. Hill, J. A. Rodriguez-Rivera, H.S.Nair,D.R.Yahne,S.Säubert,M.J.P.Gingras,andK.A.Ross,Unravellingcompetingmicroscopic interactions at a phase boundary: A single-crystal study of the metastable antiferro...

    2020

  80. [90]

    H. Yan, O. Benton, L. Jaubert, and N. Shannon, Theory of multiple-phase competition in pyrochlore magnets with anisotropic exchange with application to Yb2Ti2O7, Er2Ti2O7, and Er2Sn2O7, Phys. Rev. B 95, 094422 (2017)

    2017

  81. [91]

    McMorrow, Spin-Wave Spectrum of the Quantum Ferromagnet on the Pyrochlore Lattice Lu2V2O7, Phys

    M.Mena, R.S.Perry, T.G.Perring, M.D.Le, S.Guerrero, M.Storni, D.T.Adroja, C.Rüegg,andD.F. McMorrow, Spin-Wave Spectrum of the Quantum Ferromagnet on the Pyrochlore Lattice Lu2V2O7, Phys. Rev. Lett.113, 047202 (2014)

    2014

  82. [92]

    Elhajal, B

    M. Elhajal, B. Canals, R. Sunyer, and C. Lacroix, Ordering in the pyrochlore antiferromagnet due to Dzyaloshinsky-Moriya interactions, Phys. Rev. B71, 094420 (2005)

    2005

  83. [93]

    Hickey, D

    A. Hickey, D. Lozano-Gómez, and M. J. P. Gingras, Order-by-disorder without quantum zero-point fluctuations in the pyrochlore Heisenberg ferromagnet with Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interactions, Phys. 15 23 Rev. B111, 184434 (2025). 16

    2025

Pith tools

Reviewed August 7, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.