A Characterization of the Critical Catenoid

We show that an embedded minimal annulus $\Sigma^2 \subset B^3$ which intersects $\partial B^3$ orthogonally and is invariant under reflection through the coordinate planes is the critical catenoid. The proof uses nodal domain arguments and a characterization, due to Fraser and Schoen, of the critical catenoid as the unique free boundary minimal annulus in $B^n$ with lowest Steklov eigenvalue equal to 1. We also give more general criteria which imply that a free boundary minimal surface in $B^3$ invariant under a group of reflections has lowest Steklov eigenvalue 1.