Pith. sign in

REVIEW 3 major objections 6 minor 122 references

A Spectral Analysis of the Centimeter Regime of Nearby Galaxies: RRLs, Excited OH, and NH$_3$

T0 review · 3 major / 6 minor · reviewed 2026-08-14 · deepseek-v4-flash

Challenge this review Re-run · record.json Download PDF Read on arXiv ↗ Review JSON

Pith's one-line read This paper reports the third and fourth extragalactic detections of OH $J=9/2$ absorption (in NGC 4945 and Circinus) and argues that the excited OH in Circinus is not in Boltzmann equilibrium.

desk verdict Solid cm-wave survey with genuine first detections; the Circinus non-Boltzmann OH claim is heavier than its archival underpinnings can bear. read the letter →

arxiv 1908.08839 v1 pith:HLDLRIBX submitted 2019-08-23 astro-ph.GA

Brian A. Eisner , Juergen Ott , David S. Meier , John M. Cannon This is my paper · ORCID
classification astro-ph.GA
keywords radiorecombinationlinesexcitedOHammoniainversionnearbygalaxiesstarburstnon-LTEexcitationmolecularabsorptioncentimeter-wavespectroscopy
verification ladder T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal

The pith

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The reading

The paper presents a centimeter-wave spectral-line survey of nine nearby galaxies, aiming to show that this weak but underused frequency regime reveals gas excitation that millimeter surveys miss. Its headline results are 18 radio recombination lines in NGC 253, the most ever detected in an external galaxy; the third and fourth extragalactic detections of OH $^{2}\Pi_{3/2}$ $J=9/2$ absorption, in NGC 4945 and Circinus; and a pattern of anomalous NH$_3$ absorption in NGC 4945 that matches Arp 220. The Circinus OH lines imply a rotation temperature above 2000 K, which the authors read as evidence that the OH rotational levels are not populated according to a Boltzmann distribution. If correct, the centimeter regime is a productive window onto nonthermal excitation, nuclear infall, and molecular physics in starburst and AGN nuclei.

What carries the argument

The load-bearing machinery is the Boltzmann-ratio analysis of rotation temperatures, applied to column densities of OH and NH$_3$ levels. For OH, the total column density of a rotational state is built from the two hyperfine components, $N_J = 2N_{l,F=J-1/2} + 2N_{l,F=J+1/2}$, and the rotation temperature is $T_{\rm rot} = (E_u-E_l)/[k\,\ln((2J_u+1)N_{J_l}/((2J_l+1)N_{J_u}))]$. For NH$_3$, equivalent Boltzmann-diagram plots of $\log_{10}[N(J,K)/(g_{op}(2J+1))]$ versus $E/k$ turn temperature into a slope. For the radio recombination lines, the line-to-continuum electron temperature formula $T_e^*$ provides the observed trend that the paper interprets through non-LTE departure coefficients. Comparing hyperfine line ratios (such as F=5 to F=4, expected to be 11/9 under LTE) is the check that keeps the OH analysis anchored.

What would settle it

Re-observe the ground-state OH doublet in Circinus with the same large beam and publish noise-based optical depths and widths; if the $J=3/2$ optical depth is several times larger than the visual estimate, the derived rotation temperature drops far below 2000 K and the non-Boltzmann conclusion is unsupported.

Watch

Extended reading notes

Core claim

On its own terms, the paper claims that centimeter-wave transitions are not just weak echoes of millimeter lines but carry information about departures from local thermodynamic equilibrium. In NGC 253 all 18 $\mathrm{H}(n)\alpha$ recombination lines within the spectral windows are detected, and the LTE electron temperatures derived from their line-to-free-free ratios rise with frequency; the authors attribute that trend to stimulated emission in the nuclear region rather than a real temperature gradient. In NGC 4945 and Circinus, optically thin OH $^{2}\Pi_{3/2}$ $J=9/2$ absorption is detected with line widths of roughly 50–120 km s$^{-1}$, redshifted by about 100 km s$^{-1}$ in NGC 4945 and blueshifted by about 35 km s$^{-1}$ in Circinus. Comparing the Circinus $J=9/2$ column densities with archival $J=3/2$ data yields a rotation temperature above 2000 K, which the authors call unphysically high and use to argue that the OH populations are not Boltzmann-distributed. The NH$_3$ (1,1) through (6,6) lines in NGC 4945 show a superposition of emission and absorption, with depressed (1,1) and enhanced (5,5) absorption similar to Arp 220, and strong (3,3) emission that may be spatially extended maser activity.

Load-bearing premise

The Circinus rotation temperature rests on older ground-state OH line strengths whose optical depths and widths were estimated visually from published plots and carry no quoted uncertainties, so the 2000 K result depends on numbers the paper did not measure itself.

Editorial extensions

If this is right

  • If Circinus's OH populations are genuinely non-Boltzmann, then infrared pumping or another nonthermal process must be acting in its nucleus, and OH column densities derived from any single temperature will be biased.
  • If the NH$_3$ absorption anomaly seen in NGC 4945 is the same effect as in Arp 220, then a systematic level-population mechanism rather than calibration shapes ammonia absorption in luminous nuclei.
  • If the NGC 253 electron-temperature trend is a non-LTE effect, then single-line cm-wave RRL measurements cannot yield true electron temperatures without knowing the departure coefficients.
  • If $J=9/2$ OH appears in two of the nine galaxies surveyed, then this highly excited absorption is likely common in unstudied nearby starbursts.
  • If the (3,3) NH$_3$ emission in NGC 4945 is a maser, it would be only the third or fourth extragalactic NH$_3$ (3,3) maser known.

Reading between the lines

Editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

  • A testable extension of the paper's two-galaxy coincidence between $J=9/2$ OH absorption and luminous H$_2$O megamasers is to search for excited OH in other known H$_2$O megamaser hosts; a positive correlation would tie OH excitation to maser activity rather than to starburst properties alone.
  • The shared NH$_3$ anomaly in Arp 220 and NGC 4945 could be probed by radiative-transfer models that pump ammonia inversion levels with a strong infrared field; the paper's own nondetections of nonmetastable lines make overpopulation of nonmetastable states less likely, leaving the pump mechanism open.
  • The unidentified 5.737 GHz line in NGC 253 deserves a high-resolution follow-up: if it survives, it adds a new centimeter-wave tracer of the nucleus, and if it does not, the antenna ringing noted in the paper is the likely culprit.
  • A systematic multi-line RRL study of NGC 253 with dense frequency coverage could turn the reported temperature trend into a quantitative diagnostic of the clumpiness and radiation field of its nuclear H II regions; the paper provides the anchor data but does not model the departure coefficients.
Share X Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit HN

Signed reviews

No signed human review yet.

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, and a circularity audit.

Referee Report

3 major / 6 minor

Summary. This paper reports ATCA 4cm- and 15mm-band spectral line observations of nine nearby star-forming galaxies. The authors detect 18 H(n)α radio recombination lines in NGC 253, excited OH 2Π3/2 absorption toward NGC 253 (J=5/2), NGC 4945 (J=9/2), and Circinus (J=9/2), NH3 (1,1) through (6,6) in NGC 4945 plus NH3 in three other galaxies, and several other molecular lines. Key interpretive claims are an electron-temperature trend with RRL frequency in NGC 253 attributed to non-LTE effects, a rotation temperature in excess of 2000 K for OH in Circinus interpreted as evidence for non-Boltzmann OH level populations, and an NH3 absorption anomaly in NGC 4945 similar to that previously seen in Arp 220.

Significance. If substantiated, these results are valuable: the two J=9/2 OH detections are only the third and fourth extragalactic detections, the 18 RRLs appear to be the largest extragalactic set to date, and the NGC 4945 NH3 anomaly would show that the Arp 220 pattern is not unique. The observational analysis is generally careful, with RMS thresholds, Gaussian fits, and tabulated parameters that support reproducibility. The paper also makes good use of archival data for comparison, though the archival comparison underpinning the Circinus rotation-temperature claim is not accompanied by propagated uncertainties.

major comments (3)
  1. [6.1.3, Table 10] The >2000 K rotation temperature for Circinus rests on the J=3/2 optical depths and FWHMs from Harnett et al. (1990), which are not published with uncertainties and, as the Table 10 note states, were estimated visually from plots. The note's assertion that the logarithmic dependence in Equation (6) makes these estimates accurate is not a substitute for an uncertainty analysis: for the stated column-density ratio, a factor-of-two change in the archival J=3/2 column density changes Trot by several hundred kelvin and can push it below 2000 K. The authors should re-derive Trot from the original spectra with propagated errors, obtain a new J=3/2 measurement, or explicitly demote this result to a tentative suggestion rather than presenting it as a key finding.
  2. [6.1, Eqs. (5)-(6)] Equations (5) and (6) assume that a single excitation temperature applies to both Λ-doublet components and, more importantly, that a single rotation temperature connects the J=3/2 and J=9/2 states. If Tex varies with J, the quantity labelled Trot is a weighted mean that is not a physical temperature, and the inference that the OH populations are non-Boltzmann does not follow. The text acknowledges this assumption, but the abstract and conclusions present the >2000 K value without that caveat. The assumption-dependence should be stated in the abstract and in Section 10.
  3. [7.1, Figure 9] The NH3 absorption optical depths in NGC 4945 are computed under the assumption that the underlying emission is zero, yet the spectra are explicitly described as a 'superposition of emission and absorption' and the (3,3) line has strong emission. If the zero-emission baseline is violated, the relative optical depths entering the Boltzmann diagrams of Figure 9 can be systematically biased, weakening the claimed similarity to Arp 220. A joint emission-plus-absorption fit or an explicit sensitivity test to the baseline assumption is needed before this anomaly is presented as a firm result.
minor comments (6)
  1. [Title] The draft title contains a spurious space in 'Galax ies'; the final version should read 'Galaxies'.
  2. [Table 11] The 1σ RMS for the NGC 1808 H(105)α RRL is listed as 15.5 mJy beam^-1, an order of magnitude larger than all neighboring entries; this is likely a typo and should be corrected.
  3. [Figures 2, 4-6] Several figure axis labels are truncated in the draft (e.g., 'Intensit', 'k s^-1'); the final figures should be regenerated with complete labels.
  4. [5.1, Eq. (2)] The scaling factor 1.73/1.37 in Equation (2) is introduced without a derivation; a brief statement of how this factor is obtained from the Williams & Bower (2010) data and its uncertainty would improve reproducibility.
  5. [Table 4] The NGC 4945 NH3 (3,3) row has no fitted parameters; a note explaining why (e.g., the complex profile) would aid the reader.
  6. [Figure 7 caption] The M83 Boltzmann diagram shows (3,3) and (6,6) points even though they are excluded from the fits; adding a sentence in the caption explaining their exclusion would avoid confusion.

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged · score 1.0 of 10

No circular derivation: the reported detections, line ratios, and derived temperatures are based on new measurements compared with archival values; self-citations serve as context, not as inputs that force the results.

full rationale

The central results are measured quantities: OH J=9/2 optical depths in NGC 4945 and Circinus, NH3 line parameters in NGC 4945, and 18 RRLs in NGC 253. The Circinus rotation temperature is obtained from Equation 6 using new J=9/2 column densities and J=3/2 values from Harnett et al. (1990); the archival values are estimated visually without quoted uncertainties, as acknowledged in the Table 10 note and Section 6.1.3. This is an accuracy and robustness limitation, not a circular step: the temperature is not defined by the new data alone, and no fitted parameter is renamed as a prediction. The NH3 absorption anomaly in NGC 4945 is compared with Arp 220 using Ott et al. (2011) and Zschaechner et al. (2016a), which include a coauthor, but the NGC 4945 measurements are independent, and the comparison is not used to derive those measurements. Similarly, the J=9/2 'third and fourth detection' claim simply counts prior detections and does not use them as a load-bearing uniqueness argument. RRL electron temperatures use an external free-free decomposition from Williams & Bower (2010) scaled to the observed continuum; the line-to-continuum ratio is not forced by that model. No uniqueness theorem, ansatz, or defining relation is imported from prior work in a way that makes the conclusions equivalent to their inputs. Therefore no specific circular reduction can be exhibited, and the appropriate finding is no significant circularity.

Assumptions & free parameters 0 free parameters · 5 assumptions · 0 invented entities

The paper's derived physical quantities rest on standard LTE and optically thin assumptions, on a literature free-free SED, and on archival OH line parameters, all acknowledged in the text. No new particles, forces, or dimensions are introduced.

assumptions (5)
  • domain assumption LTE formula for electron temperature (Eq. 1) applies, with |τL - τC| << 1, τC << 1, and N_He/N_H = 0.08.
    Used in Section 5.1 to convert RRL line-to-continuum ratios into T_e values.
  • domain assumption The Williams and Bower (2010) free-free SED, scaled by the observed 5 GHz flux ratio 1.73/1.37, describes the thermal continuum of NGC253 and extrapolates validly to 10 GHz.
    Used in Section 5.1 to separate free-free from synchrotron continuum; if incorrect, derived Te values and the frequency trend change.
  • domain assumption The OH doublet lines are optically thin and share a common excitation temperature, allowing column densities to be summed via Eq. 5.
    Used in Section 6.1 to compute N_J/T_ex and rotation temperatures.
  • domain assumption A single rotation temperature describes the population distribution between OH rotational states with very different energies (Eq. 6), and the archival J=3/2 line parameters used are reliable.
    Underlies the Circinus 2000 K result in Section 6.1.3; the paper acknowledges the single-temperature approximation is poor.
  • domain assumption NH3 absorption is optically thin, and ortho (K=3n) and para states cannot be compared directly in Boltzmann diagrams, so (3,3) and (6,6) are excluded from the fits.
    Used in Section 7 for column densities and Boltzmann plots.

how reviews work

0 comments
Cite this review

Pith. "Pith review of A Spectral Analysis of the Centimeter Regime of Nearby Galaxies: RRLs, Excited OH, and NH$_3$." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/HLDLRIBX

@misc{pith2026190808839,
  author       = {Pith},
  title        = {Pith review of: A Spectral Analysis of the Centimeter Regime of Nearby Galaxies: RRLs, Excited OH, and NH$_3$},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/HLDLRIBX}},
  note         = {Machine review of arXiv:1908.08839}
}
abstract

Centimeter-wave transitions are important counterparts to the rotational mm-wave transitions usually observed to study gas in star-forming regions. However, given their relative weakness, these transitions have historically been neglected. We present Australia Telescope Compact Array 4cm- and 15mm-band spectral line observations of nine nearby star-forming galaxies in the H75 array configuration. Thirteen different molecular lines are detected across the sample from OH, NH$_3$, H$_2$O, H$_2$CO, and c-C$_3$H$_2$, as well as 18 radio recombination lines (RRLs) in NGC 253. Excited OH $^2\Pi_{3/2}$ absorption is detected towards NGC 253 (J=5/2), NGC 4945 (J=9/2), and Circinus (J=9/2); the latter two represent only the third and fourth extragalactic J=9/2 detections. These lines in Circinus suggest rotation temperatures in excess of 2000 K, and thus it is likely that the populations of OH rotational states are not governed by a Boltzmann distribution. Circinus's OH lines are blueshifted from the systemic velocity by ~35 km s$^{-1}$, while NGC 4945's are redshifted by ~100 km s$^{-1}$. NGC 4945's OH absorption likely indicates infall onto the nucleus. The NH$_3$ (1,1) through (6,6) lines in NGC 4945 display a superposition of emission and absorption similar to that seen in other dense gas tracers. Strong (3,3) emission points towards maser activity. The relative NH$_3$ absorption strengths in NGC 4945 show similar anomalies as in previous studies of Arp 220 (weak (1,1) and strong (5,5) absorption). A trend towards higher LTE electron temperatures with increasing RRL frequency is present in NGC 253, likely indicative of stimulated emission within the nuclear region.

Figures

Figures reproduced from arXiv: 1908.08839 by the authors.

Figure 1
Figure 1. European Southern Observatory Digitized Sky Survey (DSS) images of all galaxies, overlain with our ATCA synthesized beams at the pointing location. Blue circles represent synthesized 4cm beams, and green circles 15mm beams. configuration yields angular resolution comparable to large￾diameter single-dish measurements but maintains an inher￾ently better baseline stability that significantly improves the ability to det… view at source ↗
Figure 2
Figure 2. Profiles of three detected RRLs within NGC 253; other H(n)α RRLs not shown have similar morphologies. The blue verti￾cal lines show the systemic velocity (Koribalski et al. 2004), while the shaded region represents the approximate extent of the line. where TL/Tc is the line-to-thermal-continuum peak bright￾ness temperature ratio, and ∆υ is the FWHM of the line. In addition to LTE conditions, this formula assumes tha… view at source ↗
Figure 3
Figure 3. LTE Electron temperatures in NGC 253, calculated from RRL line-to-continuum ratios. On the bottom is only our data, while the top includes archival data from [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p011_3.png] view at source ↗
Figures from the paper (9 more)
Figure 4
Figure 4. Figure 4: Profiles of detected OH lines within NGC 253, NGC 4945, and Circinus. The blue vertical lines show the systemic velocities from [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p013_4.png]
Figure 5
Figure 5. Figure 5: Profiles of detected NH3 and OH lines within NGC 1365, M83, and NGC 1266. The blue vertical lines show the systemic velocities from [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p017_5.png]
Figure 6
Figure 6. Figure 6: Profiles of detected NH3 and OH lines within NGC 4945. The blue vertical lines show the systemic velocity from [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p018_6.png]
Figure 7
Figure 7. Figure 7: Boltzmann diagram of NH3 in M83 slightly redshifted absorption centered on the nucleus. Al￾though we lack the resolving power to see this, our profiles fit this model. We spectrally resolve two distinct absorption components, separated by roughly 75 km s−1 . One of the…
Figure 8
Figure 8. Figure 8: Boltzmann diagrams of blueshifted (left) and redshifted (right) NH3 emission in NGC 4945. The (5,5) point in the redshifted￾component diagram is not corrected for RRL contamination since both lines’ true strengths are unknown 5  5  5  5  $Δ 5  …
Figure 9
Figure 9. Figure 9: Boltzmann diagrams of systemic (left) and redshifted (right) NH3 absorption in NGC 4945 While these are unexpected and unexplained effects, simi￾lar patterns in NH3 absorption have been noted before. In Arp 220, Ott et al. (2011) and Zschaechner et al. (2016a) found a …
Figure 10
Figure 10. Figure 10: Profiles of detected H2O lines within the sample. The blue vertical lines show the systemic velocities from [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p022_10.png]
Figure 12
Figure 12. Figure 12: Profile of unidentified line within NGC 253. The shaded region represents the approximate extent of the line. ten different transitions are detected in NGC 4945. Primary conclusions include: 1) Within NGC 253, we detect all 18 H(n)α recombina￾tion lines within our spe…
Figure 11
Figure 11. Figure 11: Profiles of other detected lines within the sample. The blue vertical lines show the systemic velocities from [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p023_11.png]

Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

122 extracted references · 79 canonical work pages

  1. [1]

    602C `\.=

    thebibliography [1] 20pt to REFERENCES 6pt =0pt 10pt plus 3pt =0pt =0pt =1pt plus 1pt =0pt =0pt -12pt =13pt plus 1pt =20pt =13pt plus 1pt \@M =10000 =-1.0em =0pt =0pt 0pt =0pt =1.0em @enumiv\@empty 10000 10000 `\.\@m \@noitemerr \@latex@warning Empty `thebibliography' environment \@ifnextchar \@reference \@latexerr Missing key on reference command Each re...

    2017

  2. [2]

    Aladro, R., Mart \' n, S., Riquelme, D., et al.\ 2015, , 579, A101

    2015

  3. [3]

    M., et al.\ 2011, , 735, 88

    Alatalo, K., Blitz, L., Young, L. M., et al.\ 2011, , 735, 88

    2011

  4. [4]

    Alatalo, K., Lacy, M., Lanz, L., et al.\ 2015, , 798, 31

    2015

  5. [5]

    L., P \'e rez, L

    ALMA Partnership, Brogan, C. L., P \'e rez, L. M., et al.\ 2015, , 808, L3

    2015

  6. [6]

    R., Zhao, J.-H., Goss, W

    Anantharamaiah, K. R., Zhao, J.-H., Goss, W. M., & Viallefond, F.\ 1993, , 419, 585

    1993

  7. [7]

    Ando, R., Nakanishi, K., Kohno, K., et al.\ 2017, , 849, 81

    2017

  8. [8]

    A., et al.\ 2011, , 529, A154

    Ao, Y., Henkel, C., Braatz, J. A., et al.\ 2011, , 529, A154

    2011

Show all 122 references
  1. [9]

    M., Sip o cz, B

    Astropy Collaboration, Price-Whelan, A. M., Sip o cz, B. M., et al.\ 2018, , 156, 123

    2018

  2. [10]

    A., Haschick, A., & Henkel, C.\ 1992, , 103, 728

    Baan, W. A., Haschick, A., & Henkel, C.\ 1992, , 103, 728

    1992

  3. [11]

    S., Wenger, T

    Balser, D. S., Wenger, T. V., Goss, W. M., Johnson, K. E., & Kepley, A. A.\ 2017, , 844, 73

    2017

  4. [12]

    A., Jauncey, D

    Batchelor, R. A., Jauncey, D. L., & Whiteoak, J. B.\ 1982, , 200, 19p

    1982

  5. [13]

    M., Winnberg, A., & Wilson, T

    Baudry, A., Walmsley, C. M., Winnberg, A., & Wilson, T. L.\ 1981, , 102, 287

    1981

  6. [14]

    M.\ 1995, , 298, 905

    Baudry, A., & Menten, K. M.\ 1995, , 298, 905

    1995

  7. [15]

    Belloche, A., M \"u ller, H. S. P., Menten, K. M., Schilke, P., & Comito, C.\ 2013, , 559, A47

    2013

  8. [16]

    J., Beswick, R

    Bendo, G. J., Beswick, R. J., D'Cruze, M. J., et al.\ 2015, , 450, L80

    2015

  9. [17]

    J., Henkel, C., D'Cruze, M

    Bendo, G. J., Henkel, C., D'Cruze, M. J., et al.\ 2016, , 463, 252

    2016

  10. [18]

    D., Warren, S

    Bolatto, A. D., Warren, S. R., Leroy, A. K., et al.\ 2013, , 499, 450

    2013

  11. [19]

    D., Wolfire, M., & Leroy, A

    Bolatto, A. D., Wolfire, M., & Leroy, A. K.\ 2013, , 51, 207

    2013

  12. [20]

    R., & Staveley-Smith, L.\ 1996, , 463, 60

    Bureau, M., Mould, J. R., & Staveley-Smith, L.\ 1996, , 463, 60

    1996

  13. [21]

    Busch, G., Eckart, A., Valencia-S., M., et al.\ 2017, , 598, A55

    2017

  14. [22]

    Cappellari, M., Emsellem, E., Krajnovi \'c , D., et al.\ 2011, , 413, 813

    2011

  15. [23]

    M., Hartmann, D., & Thaddeus, P.\ 2001, , 547, 792

    Dame, T. M., Hartmann, D., & Thaddeus, P.\ 2001, , 547, 792

    2001

  16. [24]

    R., Valiron, P., Schilke, P., & Walmsley, C

    Danby, G., Flower, D. R., Valiron, P., Schilke, P., & Walmsley, C. M.\ 1988, , 235, 229

    1988

  17. [25]

    G., Jr., et al.\ 1991, Third Reference Catalogue of Bright Galaxies (New York: Springer)

    de Vaucouleurs, G., de Vaucouleurs, A., Corwin, H. G., Jr., et al.\ 1991, Third Reference Catalogue of Bright Galaxies (New York: Springer)

    1991

  18. [26]

    Esquej, P., Alonso-Herrero, A., Gonz \'a lez-Mart \' n, O., et al.\ 2014, , 780, 86

    2014

  19. [27]

    S., & Jarrett, T

    For, B.-Q., Koribalski, B. S., & Jarrett, T. H.\ 2012, , 425, 1934

    2012

  20. [28]

    T., Seaquist, E

    Frayer, D. T., Seaquist, E. R., & Frail, D. A.\ 1998, , 115, 559

    1998

  21. [29]

    F., Baum, S

    Gallimore, J. F., Baum, S. A., O'Dea, C. P., Brinks, E., & Pedlar, A.\ 1996, , 462, 740

    1996

  22. [30]

    F., Henkel, C., Baum, S

    Gallimore, J. F., Henkel, C., Baum, S. A., et al.\ 2001, , 556, 694

    2001

  23. [31]

    Garc \' a-Burillo, S., Combes, F., Ramos Almeida, C., et al.\ 2016, , 823, L12

    2016

  24. [32]

    Garc \' a-Burillo, S., Combes, F., Usero, A., et al.\ 2014, , 567, A125

    2014

  25. [33]

    Ginsburg, A., & Mirocha, J.\ 2011, ascl, ascl:1109.001

    2011

  26. [34]

    Gooch, R.\ 1996, adass V, 101, 80

    1996

  27. [35]

    A., & Walmsley, C

    Gordon, M. A., & Walmsley, C. M.\ 1990, , 365, 606

    1990

  28. [36]

    Gorski, M., Ott, J., Rand, R., et al.\ 2017, , 842, 124

    2017

  29. [37]

    Gorski, M., Ott, J., Rand, R., et al.\ 2018, , 856, 134

    2018

  30. [38]

    D., & Alexander, D

    Goulding, A. D., & Alexander, D. M.\ 2009, , 398, 1165

    2009

  31. [39]

    A., Caswell, J

    Green, J. A., Caswell, J. L., Fuller, G. A., et al.\ 2008, , 385, 948

    2008

  32. [40]

    J., Booth, R

    Greenhill, L. J., Booth, R. S., Ellingsen, S. P., et al.\ 2003, , 590, 162

    2003

  33. [41]

    J., Moran, J

    Greenhill, L. J., Moran, J. M., & Herrnstein, J. R.\ 1997, , 481, L23

    1997

  34. [42]

    J., Jiang, D

    Greenhill, L. J., Jiang, D. R., Moran, J. M., et al.\ 1995, , 440, 619

    1995

  35. [43]

    Harada, N., Sakamoto, K., Mart \' n, S., et al.\ 2018, , 855, 49

    2018

  36. [44]

    I., Whiteoak, J

    Harnett, J. I., Whiteoak, J. B., Reynolds, J. E., Gardnere, F. F., & Tzioumis, A.\ 1990, , 244, 130

    1990

  37. [45]

    Henkel, C., Mauersberger, R., & Schilke, P.\ 1988, , 201, L23

    1988

  38. [46]

    Henkel, C., M \"u hle, S., Bendo, G., et al.\ 2018, , 615, A155

    2018

  39. [47]

    Henkel, C., Wouterloot, J. G. A., & Bally, J.\ 1986, , 155, 193

    1986

  40. [48]

    Ho, P. T. P., & Townes, C. H.\ 1983, , 21, 239

    1983

  41. [49]

    P., Vogeley, M

    Huchra, J. P., Vogeley, M. S., & Geller, M. J.\ 1999, , 121, 287

    1999

  42. [50]

    L., Mauersberger, R., et al.\ 1995, , 294, 667

    Huettemeister, S., Wilson, T. L., Mauersberger, R., et al.\ 1995, , 294, 667

    1995

  43. [51]

    Hunter, J.D.\ 2007, CSE, 9, 90

    2007

  44. [52]

    Iwasawa, K., Koyama, K., Awaki, H., et al.\ 1993, , 409, 155

    1993

  45. [53]

    Izumi, T., Nakanishi, K., Imanishi, M., & Kohno, K.\ 2016, , 459, 3629

    2016

  46. [54]

    Jiang, X.-J., Wang, J.-Z., Gao, Y., & Gu, Q.-S.\ 2017, , 600, A15

    2017

  47. [55]

    Jim \'e nez-Bail \'o n, E., Santos-Lle \'o , M., Dahlem, M., et al.\ 2005, , 442, 861

    2005

  48. [56]

    D., & Kaisina, E

    Karachentsev, I. D., & Kaisina, E. I.\ 2013, , 146, 46

    2013

  49. [57]

    C., & Evans, N

    Kennicutt, R. C., & Evans, N. J.\ 2012, , 50, 531

    2012

  50. [58]

    A., Chomiuk, L., Johnson, K

    Kepley, A. A., Chomiuk, L., Johnson, K. E., et al.\ 2011, , 739, L24

    2011

  51. [59]

    S., Staveley-Smith, L., Kilborn, V

    Koribalski, B. S., Staveley-Smith, L., Kilborn, V. A., et al.\ 2004, , 128, 16

    2004

  52. [60]

    C., Goss, W

    Lang, C. C., Goss, W. M., & Morris, M.\ 2001, , 121, 2681

    2001

  53. [61]

    K., Bolatto, A

    Leroy, A. K., Bolatto, A. D., Ostriker, E. C., et al.\ 2015, , 801, 25

    2015

  54. [62]

    K., Bolatto, A

    Leroy, A. K., Bolatto, A. D., Ostriker, E. C., et al.\ 2018, , 869, 126

    2018

  55. [63]

    Lira, P., Gonzalez-Corvalan, V., Ward, M., & Hoyer, S.\ 2008, , 384, 316

    2008

  56. [64]

    Malizia, A., Bassani, L., Bazzano, A., et al.\ 2012, , 426, 1750

    2012

  57. [65]

    G., Darling, J., Henkel, C., & Menten, K

    Mangum, J. G., Darling, J., Henkel, C., & Menten, K. M.\ 2013, , 766, 108

    2013

  58. [66]

    G., Darling, J., Henkel, C., et al.\ 2013, , 779, 33

    Mangum, J. G., Darling, J., Henkel, C., et al.\ 2013, , 779, 33

    2013

  59. [67]

    G., Darling, J., Menten, K

    Mangum, J. G., Darling, J., Menten, K. M., & Henkel, C.\ 2008, , 673, 832

    2008

  60. [68]

    G., & Shirley, Y

    Mangum, J. G., & Shirley, Y. L.\ 2015, , 127, 266

    2015

  61. [69]

    Mart \' n, S., Mauersberger, R., Mart \' n-Pintado, J., Henkel, C., & Garc \' a-Burillo, S.\ 2006, , 164, 450

    2006

  62. [70]

    B., & Hagiwara, Y.\ 2003, , 403, 561

    Mauersberger, R., Henkel, C., Wei , A., Peck, A. B., & Hagiwara, Y.\ 2003, , 403, 561

    2003

  63. [71]

    P., Waters, B., Schiebel, D., Young, W., & Golap, K.\ 2007, adass XVI, 376, 127

    McMullin, J. P., Waters, B., Schiebel, D., Young, W., & Golap, K.\ 2007, adass XVI, 376, 127

    2007

  64. [72]

    S., & Turner, J

    Meier, D. S., & Turner, J. L.\ 2005, , 618, 259

    2005

  65. [73]

    S., Turner, J

    Meier, D. S., Turner, J. L., & Schinnerer, E.\ 2011, , 142, 32

    2011

  66. [74]

    S., Walter, F., Bolatto, A

    Meier, D. S., Walter, F., Bolatto, A. D., et al.\ 2015, , 801, 63

    2015

  67. [75]

    Miyamoto, Y., Nakai, N., Seta, M., et al.\ 2015, , 67, 5

    2015

  68. [76]

    Moorwood, A. F. M., & Oliva, E.\ 1994, , 429, 602

    1994

  69. [77]

    Nakajima, T., Takano, S., Kohno, K., et al.\ 2015, , 67, 8

    2015

  70. [78]

    Ohyama, Y., Terashima, Y., & Sakamoto, K.\ 2015, , 805, 162

    2015

  71. [79]

    E.\ 2007, A guide to NumPy (Trelgol Publishing)

    Oliphant, T. E.\ 2007, A guide to NumPy (Trelgol Publishing)

    2007

  72. [80]

    A., & Wei , A.\ 2011, , 742, 95

    Ott, J., Henkel, C., Braatz, J. A., & Wei , A.\ 2011, , 742, 95

    2011

  73. [81]

    Ott, J., Weiss, A., Henkel, C., & Walter, F.\ 2005, , 629, 767

    2005

  74. [82]

    E.\ 2007, CSE, 9, 21

    P\'erez, F., & Granger, B. E.\ 2007, CSE, 9, 21

    2007

  75. [83]

    P., G \"u sten, R., Harris, A., et al.\ 2018, , 860, 23

    P \'e rez-Beaupuits, J. P., G \"u sten, R., Harris, A., et al.\ 2018, , 860, 23

    2018

  76. [84]

    J., Markwick-Kemper, A., & ALMA Working Group on Spectral Line Frequencies\ 2007, , 39, 132.11

    Remijan, A. J., Markwick-Kemper, A., & ALMA Working Group on Spectral Line Frequencies\ 2007, , 39, 132.11

    2007

  77. [85]

    Robinson, B. J. & McGee, R. X.\ 1967, , 5, 183

    1967

  78. [86]

    A., Goss, W

    Rodr \' guez-Rico, C. A., Goss, W. M., Zhao, J.-H., G \'o mez, Y., & Anantharamaiah, K. R.\ 2006, , 644, 914

    2006

  79. [87]

    L.\ 2000, Tools of radio astronomy (New York: Springer)

    Rohlfs, K., & Wilson, T. L.\ 2000, Tools of radio astronomy (New York: Springer)

    2000

  80. [88]

    L., Goss, W

    Roy, A. L., Goss, W. M., & Anantharamaiah, K. R.\ 2008, , 483, 79

    2008

  81. [89]

    L., Goss, W

    Roy, A. L., Goss, W. M., Mohan, N. R., & Anantharamaiah, K. R.\ 2005, , 435, 831

    2005

  82. [90]

    L., Oosterloo, T., Goss, W

    Roy, A. L., Oosterloo, T., Goss, W. M., & Anantharamaiah, K. R.\ 2010, , 517, A82

    2010

  83. [91]

    Sakamoto, K., Ho, P. T. P., Iono, D., et al.\ 2006, , 636, 685

    2006

  84. [92]

    Sakamoto, K., Aalto, S., Combes, F., Evans, A., & Peck, A.\ 2014, , 797, 90

    2014

  85. [93]

    Salak, D., Nakai, N., Hatakeyama, T., & Miyamoto, Y.\ 2016, , 823, 68

    2016

  86. [94]

    J., Teuben, P

    Sault, R. J., Teuben, P. J., & Wright, M. C. H.\ 1995, adass IV, 77, 433

    1995

  87. [95]

    J., Hunter, T

    Schilke, P., Benford, D. J., Hunter, T. R., Lis, D. C., & Phillips, T. G.\ 2001, , 132, 281

    2001

  88. [96]

    R., Carlstrom, J

    Seaquist, E. R., Carlstrom, J. E., Bryant, P. M., & Bell, M. B.\ 1996, , 465, 691

    1996

  89. [97]

    A.\ 1980, , 90, 34

    Shaver, P. A.\ 1980, , 90, 34

    1980

  90. [98]

    O., Murray, C

    Sjouwerman, L. O., Murray, C. E., Pihlstr \"o m, Y. M., Fish, V. L., & Araya, E. D.\ 2010, , 724, L158

    2010

  91. [99]

    Stone, M., Veilleux, S., Mel \'e ndez, M., et al.\ 2016, , 826, 111

    2016

  92. [100]

    A., Riffel, R., et al.\ 2012, , 755, 87

    Storchi-Bergmann, T., Riffel, R. A., Riffel, R., et al.\ 2012, , 755, 87

    2012

  93. [101]

    W., Bloemen, J

    Strong, A. W., Bloemen, J. B. G. M., Dame, T. M., et al.\ 1988, , 207, 1

    1988

  94. [102]

    Surcis, G., Tarchi, A., Henkel, C., et al.\ 2009, , 502, 529

    2009

  95. [103]

    M.\ 2011, , 525, A91

    Tarchi, A., Castangia, P., Henkel, C., Surcis, G., & Menten, K. M.\ 2011, , 525, A91

    2011

  96. [104]

    B.\ 1988, Nearby Galaxies Catalog (Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press)

    Tully, R. B.\ 1988, Nearby Galaxies Catalog (Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press)

    1988

  97. [105]

    B., Courtois, H

    Tully, R. B., Courtois, H. M., Dolphin, A. E., et al.\ 2013, , 146, 86

    2013

  98. [106]

    B., Rizzi, L., Shaya, E

    Tully, R. B., Rizzi, L., Shaya, E. J., et al.\ 2009, , 138, 323

    2009

  99. [107]

    E.\ 1985, , 299, 312

    Turner, B. E.\ 1985, , 299, 312

    1985

  100. [108]

    Veilleux, S., & Bland-Hawthorn, J.\ 1997, , 479, L105

    1997

  101. [109]

    Wagner, J.\ 2013, , 560, A12

    2013

  102. [110]

    M., Baudry, A., Guilloteau, S., & Winnberg, A.\ 1986, , 167, 151

    Walmsley, C. M., Baudry, A., Guilloteau, S., & Winnberg, A.\ 1986, , 167, 151

    1986

  103. [111]

    M., & Ungerechts, H.\ 1983, , 122, 164

    Walmsley, C. M., & Ungerechts, H.\ 1983, , 122, 164

    1983

  104. [112]

    D., Leroy, A

    Walter, F., Bolatto, A. D., Leroy, A. K., et al.\ 2017, , 835, 265

    2017

  105. [113]

    Weliachew, L.\ 1971, , 167, L47

    1971

  106. [114]

    B., & Gardner, F

    Whiteoak, J. B., & Gardner, F. F.\ 1974, , 15, 211

    1974

  107. [115]

    B., & Gardner, F

    Whiteoak, J. B., & Gardner, F. F.\ 1975, , 195, L81

    1975

  108. [116]

    B., & Wilson, W

    Whiteoak, J. B., & Wilson, W. E.\ 1990, , 245, 665

    1990

  109. [117]

    K., Migenes, V., & Smidt, J

    Wiggins, B. K., Migenes, V., & Smidt, J. M.\ 2016, , 816, 55

    2016

  110. [118]

    Williams, P. K. G., & Bower, G. C.\ 2010, , 710, 1462

    2010

  111. [119]

    R., Goss, W

    Zhao, J.-H., Anantharamaiah, K. R., Goss, W. M., & Viallefond, F.\ 1996, , 472, 54

    1996

  112. [120]

    K., Ott, J., Walter, F., et al.\ 2016, , 833, 41

    Zschaechner, L. K., Ott, J., Walter, F., et al.\ 2016, , 833, 41

    2016

  113. [121]

    , " * write output.state after.block = add.period write newline

    Zschaechner, L. K., Walter, F., Bolatto, A., et al.\ 2016, , 832, 142 Results.tex0000664000000000000000000002471313527520637011762 0ustar rootroot LINES DETECTED Ch4 We detected at least one molecular spectral line in eight of our nine galaxies. No morphological structure is o...

    2016

  114. [122]

    write newline

    " write newline "" before.all 'output.state := FUNCTION format.archive archivePrefix empty "" archivePrefix ":" * if FUNCTION format.primaryClass primaryClass empty "" " [" primaryClass * "]" * if FUNCTION format.eprint eprint empty pages empty not booktitle empty not or or ""...

Pith tools

Reviewed August 14, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.