Approximating full conformal prediction: distribution free guarantees via the tournament correction

Conformal prediction is a framework for providing prediction intervals with distribution-free validity, guaranteeing predictive coverage for data drawn from any distribution. Its two main variants are full conformal prediction and split conformal prediction (also called transductive and inductive). Full conformal prediction is widely considered to be statistically more efficient (since split conformal prediction requires data splitting, and therefore can lead to wider prediction intervals due to the resulting loss in sample size), but its implementation is computationally prohibitive, as it requires the underlying model to be refit for every candidate value in the response space. Existing computational shortcuts, such as using a discrete grid of values to approximate the full conformal prediction construction, frequently lack theoretical guarantees on marginal coverage and can fail in practice. To address this limitation, we introduce a novel class of approximations to the full conformal prediction method, based on the idea of \emph{tournaments}, which enables the construction of prediction sets with a rigorous marginal coverage guarantee of $1-2\alpha$. Under stability conditions, the theoretical coverage guarantee tightens to approximately $1-\alpha$. This new framework generalizes the existing method of leave-one-out cross-conformal prediction, while allowing for flexible use of various existing approximation strategies.