Competitive effects of transmission constraints in the German electricity market
Pith reviewed 2026-07-02 02:51 UTC · model grok-4.3
The pith
Reducing scarce import headroom by 1 GW raises the odds of suspected capacity withholding by German power plants by 15%.
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
Core claim
Transmission constraints significantly elevate the likelihood of suspected market power abuse. When headroom for further imports is already scarce, reducing import headroom by one Gigawatt increases the odds of suspected capacity withholding by 15%. Reducing export headroom by one GW when scarce increases the odds of suspected capacity push-in by 16%.
What carries the argument
2SRI instrumental variables estimation that relates bounds on zonal net position to upward or downward deviations of observed plant dispatch from a modeled competitive benchmark.
Load-bearing premise
The modeled competitive benchmark gives the dispatch that would occur if all plants behaved as price-takers with no market power.
What would settle it
Finding that the deviations from the benchmark are explained by forecast errors or operational constraints unrelated to transmission would undermine the interpretation as suspected abuse.
Figures
read the original abstract
This paper estimates the effect of cross-border transmission constraints on suspected market power abuse in the German wholesale electricity market. Using a 2SRI instrumental variables approach, we study suspected strategic behavior by German gas- and coal-fired power plants in 2022-2024. Cross-border transmission constraints are measured using the maximum and minimum bounds of zonal net position, while suspected market power abuse is measured as the upward or downward deviation of observed dispatch from a modeled competitive benchmark. We find that transmission constraints significantly elevate the likelihood of suspected market power abuse. When headroom for further imports is already scarce, reducing import headroom by one Gigawatt (GW) increases the odds of suspected capacity withholding by 15%. Similarly, reducing export headroom by one GW when it is scarce increases the odds of suspected capacity push-in, a strategy to depress prices, by 16%. These results provide empirical support for interconnection expansion as an instrument to mitigate market power.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The paper estimates the effect of cross-border transmission constraints on suspected market power abuse by German gas- and coal-fired plants in 2022-2024. Using a 2SRI instrumental-variables strategy, it measures constraints via bounds on zonal net position and suspected abuse via upward/downward deviations of observed dispatch from a modeled competitive benchmark. It reports that scarce import headroom raises the odds of withholding by 15% per GW reduction and scarce export headroom raises the odds of push-in by 16% per GW reduction, concluding that interconnection expansion can mitigate market power.
Significance. If the competitive benchmark is shown to be a reliable counterfactual, the results would supply empirical evidence that transmission constraints amplify strategic behavior and that interconnection policy can serve as a market-power remedy. The application of 2SRI to address endogeneity between constraints and dispatch outcomes is a methodological strength relative to OLS approaches common in the literature.
major comments (3)
- [Methods / competitive benchmark construction] The competitive benchmark is the load-bearing assumption for interpreting dispatch deviations as suspected withholding or push-in rather than model misspecification. No validation against periods of low market-power incentive, no comparison to realized dispatch under known competitive conditions, and no sensitivity to omitted technical constraints (ramping, minimum up/down times, start-up costs, reserves) is described; without this the 15-16% odds ratios cannot be distinguished from benchmark error.
- [Results / IV specification] The abstract and reported results provide no first-stage diagnostics, instrument strength statistics (e.g., F-statistic, partial R²), or robustness checks for the 2SRI procedure. Because the central claim rests on the IV estimates, absence of these diagnostics prevents assessment of whether the reported effects are identified.
- [Results / main estimates] Table or figure reporting the main odds ratios should include the exact definition of 'headroom' (maximum vs. minimum zonal net position) and the precise functional form used to interact scarcity with the continuous headroom variable; without this the 15% and 16% marginal effects cannot be reproduced or compared to alternative specifications.
minor comments (2)
- [Data] Clarify the exact sample period, number of plants, and frequency of the dispatch and constraint data in the data section.
- [Methods] Add a reference to the source or construction method for the competitive benchmark model (e.g., any optimization software or published algorithm).
Simulated Author's Rebuttal
We thank the referee for the constructive comments. We address each major point below and indicate planned revisions to strengthen the manuscript.
read point-by-point responses
-
Referee: [Methods / competitive benchmark construction] The competitive benchmark is the load-bearing assumption for interpreting dispatch deviations as suspected withholding or push-in rather than model misspecification. No validation against periods of low market-power incentive, no comparison to realized dispatch under known competitive conditions, and no sensitivity to omitted technical constraints (ramping, minimum up/down times, start-up costs, reserves) is described; without this the 15-16% odds ratios cannot be distinguished from benchmark error.
Authors: We agree the benchmark is central and will expand the methods section with additional robustness checks. We will report sensitivity to ramping and minimum up/down times using available unit-level data, and compare deviation patterns in low-incentive periods (e.g., weekends or low-demand hours). Direct validation against 'known competitive conditions' is limited by the absence of exogenous competitive episodes in 2022-2024, but we will discuss this limitation explicitly and note that the 2SRI design helps isolate constraint effects from benchmark error. revision: partial
-
Referee: [Results / IV specification] The abstract and reported results provide no first-stage diagnostics, instrument strength statistics (e.g., F-statistic, partial R²), or robustness checks for the 2SRI procedure. Because the central claim rests on the IV estimates, absence of these diagnostics prevents assessment of whether the reported effects are identified.
Authors: We will add a dedicated appendix table with first-stage results, including F-statistics, partial R², and Sanderson-Windmeijer statistics for the 2SRI instruments. We will also include robustness checks varying instrument sets and reporting second-stage sensitivity to first-stage specification. revision: yes
-
Referee: [Results / main estimates] Table or figure reporting the main odds ratios should include the exact definition of 'headroom' (maximum vs. minimum zonal net position) and the precise functional form used to interact scarcity with the continuous headroom variable; without this the 15% and 16% marginal effects cannot be reproduced or compared to alternative specifications.
Authors: We will revise the relevant table, figure, and text to state explicitly that headroom is defined as the distance to the maximum (import) or minimum (export) zonal net position bound, and that the specification interacts a scarcity dummy (headroom below median) with the continuous headroom measure using a linear interaction term. Updated captions and an equation box will enable exact reproduction. revision: yes
Circularity Check
No circularity; empirical estimation on external data with independent benchmark model
full rationale
The paper performs a 2SRI instrumental-variables estimation relating transmission headroom (measured from zonal net-position bounds) to dispatch deviations from a separately modeled competitive benchmark. No derivation chain reduces any claimed result to its own fitted parameters or self-citations by construction. The benchmark is presented as an external counterfactual constructed from optimization given realized prices, demand, and limits; deviations are then regressed on constraint variables using market data external to the model. This structure is self-contained against observable data and does not exhibit self-definitional, fitted-input, or self-citation load-bearing patterns.
Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger
axioms (2)
- domain assumption The 2SRI instrumental variables approach identifies the causal effect of transmission constraints on dispatch deviations under standard IV assumptions (relevance, exclusion, monotonicity).
- domain assumption Deviations of observed dispatch from the modeled competitive benchmark represent suspected strategic behavior rather than model misspecification or operational factors.
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
Forecasting Cross-Border Power Transmission Capacities in. Energy Informatics , volume =. doi:10.1186/s42162-019-0094-y , urldate =
-
[2]
Achieving. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.ch05 , urldate =
-
[3]
Allaz, Blaise and Vila, Jean-Luc , year = 1993, month = feb, journal =. Cournot. doi:10.1006/jeth.1993.1001 , urldate =
-
[4]
Angrist, Joshua D , year = 2001, month = jan, journal =. Estimation of. doi:10.1198/07350010152472571 , urldate =
-
[5]
and Graddy, Kathryn and Imbens, Guido W
Angrist, Joshua D. and Graddy, Kathryn and Imbens, Guido W. , year = 2000, journal =. The
2000
-
[6]
and Graddy, Kathryn and Imbens, Guido W
Angrist, Joshua D. and Graddy, Kathryn and Imbens, Guido W. , year = 2000, month = jul, journal =. The. doi:10.1111/1467-937X.00141 , urldate =
-
[7]
Journal of International Economics , volume =
Cross-Border Trade in Electricity , author =. Journal of International Economics , volume =. doi:10.1016/j.jinteco.2016.03.007 , urldate =
-
[8]
, year = 2017, month = sep, series =
Basu, Anirban and Coe, Norma and Chapman, Cole G. , year = 2017, month = sep, series =. Comparing. doi:10.3386/w23840 , urldate =. National Bureau of Economic Research , file =:23840 , publisher =
-
[9]
Screening Instruments for Monitoring Market Power ---
Bataille, Marc and Bodnar, Olivia and Steinmetz, Alexander and Thorwarth, Susanne , year = 2019, month = jun, journal =. Screening Instruments for Monitoring Market Power ---. doi:10.1016/j.eneco.2019.03.011 , urldate =
-
[10]
Economics of Energy & Environmental Policy , volume =
Energy. Economics of Energy & Environmental Policy , volume =. 26780605 , eprinttype =
-
[11]
Beltrami, Filippo and Grossi, Luigi and Liebensteiner, Mario , year = 2025, month = aug, journal =. Beyond Borders:. doi:10.1016/j.eneco.2025.108588 , urldate =
-
[12]
Strategic Capacity Withholding through Failures in the
Bergler, Julian and Heim, Sven and H. Strategic Capacity Withholding through Failures in the. Energy Policy , volume =. doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2016.12.017 , urldate =
-
[13]
Borenstein, Severin and Bushnell, James and Stoft, Steven , year = 2000, journal =. The. doi:10.2307/2601042 , urldate =. 2601042 , eprinttype =
-
[14]
, year = 1999, month = oct, journal =
Borenstein, Severin and Bushnell, James and Knittel, Christopher R. , year = 1999, month = oct, journal =. Market. doi:10.5547/ISSN0195-6574-EJ-Vol20-No4-3 , urldate =
-
[15]
Borenstein, Severin and Bushnell, James B. and Wolak, Frank A. , year = 2002, month = dec, journal =. Measuring. doi:10.1257/000282802762024557 , urldate =
-
[16]
, year = 2009, month = jun, journal =
Bowden, Nicholas S. , year = 2009, month = jun, journal =. Measuring. doi:10.1016/j.tej.2009.04.006 , urldate =
-
[17]
Improving Flow-Based Market Coupling by Integrating Redispatch potential
Bucksteeg, Michael and Voswinkel, Simon and Blumberg, Gerald , year = 2024, month = may, journal =. Improving Flow-Based Market Coupling by Integrating Redispatch potential. doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2024.114093 , urldate =
-
[18]
Journal of Regulatory Economics , volume =
Inefficient Arbitrage in Inter-Regional Electricity Transmission , author =. Journal of Regulatory Economics , volume =. doi:10.1007/s11149-009-9104-5 , urldate =
-
[19]
Bushnell, James B. and Mansur, Erin T. and Saravia, Celeste , year = 2008, month = mar, journal =. Vertical. doi:10.1257/aer.98.1.237 , urldate =
-
[20]
Water and
Bushnell, James , year = 1998, urldate =. Water and
1998
-
[21]
Electricity. Energies , volume =. doi:10.3390/en10091438 , urldate =
-
[22]
arXiv.org , urldate =
An Empirical Estimate of the Electricity Supply Curve from Market Outcomes , author =. arXiv.org , urldate =
-
[23]
Resource and Energy Economics , volume =
Market Power and Strategic Interaction in Electricity Networks , author =. Resource and Energy Economics , volume =. doi:10.1016/S0928-7655(97)00006-7 , urldate =
-
[24]
Generation Failures, Strategic Withholding, and Capacity Payments in the
Durmaz, Tun. Generation Failures, Strategic Withholding, and Capacity Payments in the. Energy Policy , volume =. doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2023.113897 , urldate =
-
[25]
Efficient. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.ch07 , urldate =
-
[26]
Efficient. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.part4 , urldate =
-
[27]
Efficient. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.ch09 , urldate =
-
[28]
Efficient. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.ch08 , urldate =
-
[29]
Efficient. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.ch11 , urldate =
-
[30]
Efficient. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.ch04 , urldate =
-
[31]
Electricity. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.ch03 , urldate =
-
[32]
Fabra, Natalia and Imelda , year = 2023, month = nov, journal =. Market. doi:10.1257/pol.20210221 , urldate =
-
[33]
The Flow-Based Market Coupling Domain -
Felten, Bj. The Flow-Based Market Coupling Domain -. Utilities Policy , volume =. doi:10.1016/j.jup.2020.101136 , urldate =
-
[34]
Finck, Rafael , year = 2021, month = jun, journal =. Impact of. doi:10.1007/s00550-021-00520-w , urldate =
-
[35]
Electricity Prices during the Energy Crisis in
Fladung, Till and Saile, Anna , year = 2024, publisher =. Electricity Prices during the Energy Crisis in
2024
-
[36]
Fogelberg, Sara and Lazarczyk, Ewa , year = 2019, month = sep, journal =. Strategic. doi:10.5547/01956574.40.5.sfog , urldate =
-
[37]
Franke, Andreas , year = 2020, journal =
2020
-
[38]
Frequency-. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.ch12 , urldate =
-
[39]
Front. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.fmatter , urldate =
-
[40]
Fusar Bassini, Chiara , year = 2025, publisher =. Time. doi:10.5281/zenodo.15204429 , howpublished =
-
[41]
Gebhardt, Georg and Hffler, Felix , year = 2013, month = jan, journal =. How. doi:10.5547/01956574.34.1.6 , urldate =
-
[42]
Gilbert, Richard and Neuhoff, Karsten and Newbery, David , year = 2004, journal =. Allocating. doi:10.2307/1593768 , urldate =. 1593768 , eprinttype =
-
[43]
Measuring the
Graf, Christoph and Wolak, Frank A , abstract =. Measuring the
-
[44]
, year = 2025, month = sep, series =
Graf, Christoph and Wolak, Frank A. , year = 2025, month = sep, series =. Measuring. doi:10.3386/w34272 , urldate =. National Bureau of Economic Research , file =:34272 , publisher =
-
[45]
Green, Richard , year = 2004, month = mar, abstract =. `
2004
-
[46]
Handling. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.part5 , urldate =
-
[47]
Journal of Econometrics , volume =
Misclassification of the Dependent Variable in a Discrete-Response Setting , author =. Journal of Econometrics , volume =. doi:10.1016/S0304-4076(98)00015-3 , urldate =
-
[48]
Impacts of Transmission Congestion on Market Power in Electricity Market , booktitle =
He, Hui and Xu, Zheng and Cheng, Gaihong , year = 2004, month = oct, pages =. Impacts of Transmission Congestion on Market Power in Electricity Market , booktitle =. doi:10.1109/PSCE.2004.1397553 , urldate =
-
[49]
Market Power Monitoring and Mitigation in the
Helman, Udi , year = 2006, month = may, journal =. Market Power Monitoring and Mitigation in the. doi:10.1016/j.energy.2005.05.011 , urldate =
-
[50]
How Aggregate Electricity Demand Responds to Hourly Wholesale Price Fluctuations , author =. Energy Economics , volume =. doi:10.1016/j.eneco.2024.107652 , urldate =
-
[51]
Understanding Strategic Bidding in Multi-Unit Auctions: A Case Study of the
Horta. Understanding Strategic Bidding in Multi-Unit Auctions: A Case Study of the. The RAND Journal of Economics , volume =. doi:10.1111/j.0741-6261.2008.00005.x , urldate =
-
[52]
Introduction to. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.part1 , urldate =
-
[53]
Introduction to. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.part2 , urldate =
-
[54]
Introduction to. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.ch02 , urldate =
-
[55]
Introduction to. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.ch01 , urldate =
-
[56]
Investing.com , urldate =
Coal (. Investing.com , urldate =
-
[57]
Investing.com , urldate =
Dutch. Investing.com , urldate =
-
[58]
Ito, Koichiro and Reguant, Mar , year = 2016, month = jul, journal =. Sequential. doi:10.1257/aer.20141529 , urldate =
-
[59]
and Kahn, Edward , year = 2002, month = oct, journal =
Joskow, Paul L. and Kahn, Edward , year = 2002, month = oct, journal =. A. doi:10.5547/ISSN0195-6574-EJ-Vol23-No4-1 , urldate =
-
[60]
Just, Sebastian and Weber, Christoph , year = 2008, month = nov, journal =. Pricing of Reserves:. doi:10.1016/j.eneco.2008.05.004 , urldate =
-
[61]
Just, Sebastian and Weber, Christoph , year = 2015, month = oct, journal =. Strategic Behavior in the. doi:10.1007/s11149-015-9270-6 , urldate =
-
[62]
Kargus, Tobias and. Multi-. doi:10.2139/ssrn.5250225 , urldate =. Social Science Research Network , langid =:5250225 , publisher =
-
[63]
IET Generation, Transmission & Distribution , volume =
Behavioural Market Power Indices in a Transmission-Constrained Electricity Market , author =. IET Generation, Transmission & Distribution , volume =. doi:10.1049/iet-gtd.2017.0911 , urldate =
-
[64]
Kim, Harim , year = 2022, month = may, journal =. Heterogeneous. doi:10.1257/mic.20190367 , urldate =
-
[65]
Short-Term Electricity Trading for System Balancing:
Koch, Christopher and Hirth, Lion , year = 2019, month = oct, journal =. Short-Term Electricity Trading for System Balancing:. doi:10.1016/j.rser.2019.109275 , urldate =
-
[66]
The Flow Based Market Coupling Arrangement in
Kristiansen, Tarjei , year = 2020, month = jan, journal =. The Flow Based Market Coupling Arrangement in. doi:10.1016/j.esr.2019.100444 , urldate =
-
[67]
K. Does. The Electricity Journal , volume =. doi:10.1016/j.tej.2008.12.006 , urldate =
-
[68]
Kwoka, John and Sabodash, Vladlena , year = 2011, month = may, journal =. Price. doi:10.1007/s11151-011-9294-8 , urldate =
-
[69]
and Hers, Sebastiaan , year = 2008, month = apr, journal =
Lise, Wietze and Hobbs, Benjamin F. and Hers, Sebastiaan , year = 2008, month = apr, journal =. Market Power in the. doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2007.12.012 , urldate =
-
[70]
Managing. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.ch13 , urldate =
-
[71]
Managing. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.part6 , urldate =
-
[72]
Market-. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.ch10 , urldate =
-
[73]
Assessing Wholesale Competition in the
Marshall, Luke and Bruce, Anna and MacGill, Iain , year = 2021, month = feb, journal =. Assessing Wholesale Competition in the. doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2020.112066 , urldate =
-
[74]
Competition Policy: Theory and Practice , author =
-
[75]
Mulder, Machiel , year = 2015, month = apr, journal =. Competition in the. doi:10.5547/01956574.36.2.1 , urldate =
-
[76]
Decomposing Changes in Competition in the
Mulder, Machiel and Schoonbeek, Lambert , year = 2013, month = sep, journal =. Decomposing Changes in Competition in the. doi:10.1016/j.eneco.2013.04.006 , urldate =
-
[77]
Market Power Implication on Congested Power System:
Nappu, Muhammad Bachtiar and Bansal, Ramesh Chand and Saha, Tapan Kumar , year = 2013, month = may, journal =. Market Power Implication on Congested Power System:. doi:10.1016/j.ijepes.2012.09.016 , urldate =
-
[78]
Newbery, David and Strbac, Goran and Viehoff, Ivan , year = 2016, month = jul, journal =. The Benefits of Integrating. doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2016.03.047 , urldate =
-
[79]
Mitigating
Newbery, David , langid =. Mitigating
-
[80]
Optimal. The. doi:10.1002/9781118775745.part3 , urldate =
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.