The structure of Doppler peaks induced by active perturbations

We investigate how the qualitative structure of Doppler peaks in the angular power spectrum of the cosmic microwave anisotropy is affected by basic assumptions going into theories of structure formation. We define the concepts of ``coherent'' and ``incoherent'' fluctuations, and also of ``active'' and ``passive'' fluctuations. In these terms inflationary fluctuations are passive and coherent while topological defects are active incoherent fluctuations. Causality and scale invariance are shown to have different implementations in theories differing in the above senses. We then extend the formalism of Hu and Sugiyama to treat models with cosmic defects. Using this formalism we show that the existence or absence of secondary Doppler peaks and the rough placing of the primary peak are very sensitive to the fundamental properties defined. We claim therefore that even a rough measurement of the angular power spectrum $C_l$ shape at $100<l<1500$ ought to tell us which are the basic ingredients to be used in the right structure formation theory. We also apply our formalism to cosmic string theories. These are shown to fall into the class of active incoherent theories for which one can robustly predict the absence of secondary Doppler peaks. The placing of the cosmic strings' primary peak is more uncertain, but should fall in $l\approx400-600$.