Recognition: unknown
Precision measurement of the muon charge asymmetry from W-boson decays in pp collisions at sqrt{s} = 13 TeV in the forward region
Pith reviewed 2026-05-10 14:29 UTC · model grok-4.3
The pith
Muon charge asymmetry from W decays is measured with highest precision yet in the LHC forward region and matches NNLO QCD predictions.
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
Core claim
The measured muon charge asymmetry in the specified kinematic region constitutes the most precise determination in the forward region to date and exhibits excellent agreement with next-to-next-to-leading-order predictions in perturbative quantum chromodynamics.
What carries the argument
The muon charge asymmetry A_μ = (N(μ⁺) − N(μ⁻)) / (N(μ⁺) + N(μ⁻)), obtained after event selection of W → μν candidates, background subtraction, efficiency and acceptance corrections, and unfolding to particle level.
If this is right
- The result tightens constraints on proton parton distribution functions at low momentum fraction and high energy scales.
- Agreement with NNLO calculations supports the reliability of these predictions for other electroweak production processes at the LHC.
- The measurement provides a benchmark for refining theoretical uncertainties in forward-region observables.
- Higher-luminosity data sets can extend the same analysis to smaller uncertainties or wider kinematic coverage.
Where Pith is reading between the lines
- This forward measurement can be combined with central-rapidity results from ATLAS and CMS to improve global fits of parton distributions across the full LHC acceptance.
- Future tensions with theory in similar forward measurements would require careful separation of possible new-physics effects from residual modeling uncertainties in the detector response.
Load-bearing premise
Detector efficiencies, acceptances, backgrounds, and unfolding corrections are accurately modeled for muons in the chosen transverse momentum and pseudorapidity range.
What would settle it
A statistically significant mismatch between the measured asymmetry values and the NNLO pQCD predictions in the same kinematic bins, outside the combined experimental and theoretical uncertainties.
Figures
read the original abstract
A precision measurement of the muon charge asymmetry from $W$-boson decays in proton-proton collisions at $\sqrt{s}$ = 13 TeV is presented. The analysis utilizes data corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 5.1 $fb^{-1}$, recorded by the LHCb detector during 2016, 2017 and 2018. The asymmetry is measured for muons with transverse momentum between 25 and 55 GeV and pseudorapidity between 2.0 and 4.5. This result represents the most precise determination of the muon charge asymmetry in the forward region to date, exhibiting excellent agreement with next-to-next-to-leading-order predictions in perturbative quantum chromodynamics.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The manuscript presents a precision measurement of the muon charge asymmetry from W-boson decays in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV. Using 5.1 fb^{-1} of LHCb data recorded in 2016-2018, the asymmetry is extracted for muons with 25 < p_T < 55 GeV and 2.0 < η < 4.5. The result is presented as the most precise determination of this observable in the forward region to date and is reported to exhibit excellent agreement with next-to-next-to-leading-order perturbative QCD predictions.
Significance. If the analysis holds, the measurement supplies the highest-precision forward-region muon charge asymmetry available, serving as a valuable benchmark for NNLO calculations of electroweak boson production at the LHC. It can tighten constraints on parton distribution functions, particularly valence and strange quark distributions at moderate-to-high x in the forward kinematics, and provides an independent cross-check of Standard Model predictions in a region where PDF uncertainties remain sizable.
major comments (1)
- The central claim of precision and agreement with NNLO rests on the accurate modeling and correction of detector efficiencies, acceptances, backgrounds, and unfolding for muons in the 25-55 GeV p_T and 2.0-4.5 η range. A detailed breakdown of the systematic uncertainty contributions (including correlations) together with data-driven validation plots and checks is required to confirm that no unaccounted bias affects the extracted asymmetry value.
minor comments (2)
- The abstract asserts 'excellent agreement' with NNLO predictions without quoting a quantitative measure (e.g., χ²/dof or pull values). Adding the measured asymmetry value with its total uncertainty would allow readers to assess the claimed precision immediately.
- All comparisons to external NNLO calculations should explicitly state the PDF sets employed and the precise kinematic binning used for the theory predictions.
Simulated Author's Rebuttal
We thank the referee for the positive assessment of our work and the recommendation for minor revision. We address the single major comment below and outline the changes we will make to strengthen the manuscript.
read point-by-point responses
-
Referee: The central claim of precision and agreement with NNLO rests on the accurate modeling and correction of detector efficiencies, acceptances, backgrounds, and unfolding for muons in the 25-55 GeV p_T and 2.0-4.5 η range. A detailed breakdown of the systematic uncertainty contributions (including correlations) together with data-driven validation plots and checks is required to confirm that no unaccounted bias affects the extracted asymmetry value.
Authors: We agree that a transparent and detailed presentation of the systematic treatment is essential to support the precision claim. The current manuscript already contains a full description of the efficiency corrections, acceptance factors, background subtraction, and unfolding procedure in Sections 4 and 5, together with a source-by-source breakdown of the systematic uncertainties in Table 3 and the associated covariance matrix that incorporates all correlations. Data-driven validation is performed using control samples and is shown in Figures 5–8. Nevertheless, to address the referee’s request explicitly, we will add an expanded appendix containing additional data-driven cross-checks (including efficiency ratios in finer bins and closure tests of the unfolding) and a more granular table of systematic contributions with their pairwise correlation coefficients. These additions will be included in the revised version. revision: partial
Circularity Check
No significant circularity: experimental measurement extracted from data and compared to independent theory
full rationale
The paper reports a direct experimental extraction of the muon charge asymmetry from 5.1 fb^{-1} of LHCb pp collision data at 13 TeV, using standard selection, efficiency, acceptance, background, and unfolding corrections for muons in the stated pT and eta range. The central result is the measured asymmetry value itself, which is then compared to separate NNLO pQCD calculations; no equation or step reduces the reported asymmetry to a fitted parameter, self-defined quantity, or prior self-citation by construction. The derivation chain is self-contained against external data and independent theory benchmarks, with no load-bearing self-citation or ansatz smuggling visible in the provided text.
Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger
free parameters (1)
- detector efficiency and background correction factors
axioms (2)
- domain assumption Standard Model and perturbative QCD calculations at NNLO are valid and correctly implemented
- domain assumption LHCb detector response, calibration, and acceptance are accurately modeled in simulation
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
LHCb collaboration, R. Aaijet al.,Inclusive W and Z production in the forward region at √s=7 TeV, JHEP06(2012) 058,arXiv:1204.1620
-
[2]
LHCb collaboration, R. Aaijet al.,Measurement of the cross-section for Z→e +e− production inppcollisions at √s=7 TeV, JHEP02(2013) 106,arXiv:1212.4620
-
[3]
Aaijet al., JHEP12, 079 (2014), arXiv:1408.4354 [hep-ex]
LHCb collaboration, R. Aaijet al.,Measurement of the forward W boson production cross-section in pp collisions at √s=7 TeV , JHEP12(2014) 079, arXiv:1408.4354
-
[4]
Aaijet al.,Measurement of forward Z→e +e− production at√s=8 TeV, JHEP05(2015) 109,arXiv:1503.00963
LHCb collaboration, R. Aaijet al.,Measurement of forward Z→e +e− production at√s=8 TeV, JHEP05(2015) 109,arXiv:1503.00963
-
[5]
LHCb collaboration, R. Aaijet al.,Measurement of the forward Z boson cross-section inppcollisions at √s=7 TeV, JHEP08(2015) 039,arXiv:1505.07024
-
[6]
LHCb collaboration, R. Aaijet al.,Measurement of forward W and Z boson production inppcollisions at √s=8 TeV, JHEP01(2016) 155,arXiv:1511.08039
-
[7]
LHCb collaboration, R. Aaijet al.,Measurement of the forward Z boson pro- duction cross-section in pp collisions at √s=13 TeV , JHEP09(2016) 136, arXiv:1607.06495
-
[8]
LHCb collaboration, R. Aaijet al.,Measurement of forward W→eν production in ppcollisions at √s=8 TeV, JHEP10(2016) 030,arXiv:1608.01484
-
[9]
LHCb collaboration, R. Aaijet al.,Precision measurement of forward Z boson production in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV, JHEP07(2022) 026, arXiv:2112.07458
-
[10]
LHCb collaboration, R. Aaijet al.,Measurement of the Z boson production cross- section at 5.02 TeV, JHEP02(2024) 070,arXiv:2308.12940
-
[11]
S. Dulatet al.,New parton distribution functions from a global analysis of quantum chromodynamics, Phys. Rev.D93(2016) 033006,arXiv:1506.07443
-
[12]
NNPDF collaboration, R. D. Ballet al.,Parton distributions for the LHC Run II, JHEP04(2015) 040,arXiv:1410.8849
work page Pith review arXiv 2015
- [13]
-
[14]
S. Alekhin, J. Blumlein, and S. Moch,The ABM parton distributions tuned to LHC data, Phys. Rev.D89(2014) 054028,arXiv:1310.3059
-
[15]
CDF collaboration, F. Abeet al.,Measurement of the lepton charge asymmetry in W -boson decays produced in p¯pcollisions, Phys. Rev. Lett.81(1998) 5754, arXiv:hep-ex/9809001. 7
-
[16]
CDF collaboration, D. Acostaet al.,Measurement of the forward-backward charge asymmetry from W→eν production in p¯pcollisions at √s = 1.96TeV, Phys. Rev. D71(2005) 051104,arXiv:hep-ex/0501023
- [17]
- [18]
- [19]
- [20]
-
[21]
CDF collaboration, T. Aaltonenet al.,Direct measurement of the W production charge asymmetry in p¯pcollisions at √s = 1.96TeV, Phys. Rev. Lett.102(2009) 181801,arXiv:0901.2169
- [22]
-
[23]
ATLAS collaboration, G. Aadet al.,Measurement of the W charge asymmetry in the W→µν decay mode in pp collisions at √s = 7TeV with the ATLAS detector, Phys. Lett.B701(2011) 31,arXiv:1103.2929
-
[24]
ATLAS collaboration, M. Aaboudet al.,Precision measurement and interpretation of inclusive W + , W − and Z/γ ∗ production cross sections with the ATLAS detector, Eur. Phys. J.C77(2017) 367,arXiv:1612.03016
-
[25]
Chatrchyanet al., JHEP04, 050 (2011), arXiv:1103.3470 [hep-ex]
CMS collaboration, S. Chatrchyanet al.,Measurement of the lepton charge asymmetry in inclusive W production in pp collisions at √s = 7TeV, JHEP04(2011) 050, arXiv:1103.3470
-
[26]
CMS collaboration, S. Chatrchyanet al.,Measurement of the electron charge asym- metry in inclusive W production in pp collisions at √s = 7TeV, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109(2012) 111806,arXiv:1206.2598
-
[27]
CMS collaboration, S. Chatrchyanet al.,Measurement of the muon charge asymmetry in inclusive pp→W +X production at √s =7 TeV and an improved determination of light parton distribution functions, Phys. Rev.D90(2014) 032004, arXiv:1312.6283
-
[28]
CMS collaboration, V. Khachatryanet al.,Measurement of the differential cross section and charge asymmetry for inclusivepp → W± + X production at √s = 8 TeV, Eur. Phys. J.C76(2016) 469,arXiv:1603.01803. 8
-
[29]
ATLAS collaboration, G. Aadet al.,Measurement of W ±-boson differential cross- sections in proton-proton collisions with low pile-up data at √s = 5.02TeV and13 TeV with the ATLAS detector, Eur. Phys. J.C85(2025) 729,arXiv:2502.09403
-
[30]
ATLAS collaboration, M. Aaboudet al.,Measurements of W and Z boson production in pp collisions at √s = 5.02TeV with the ATLAS detector, Eur. Phys. J.C79(2019) 128, Erratum ibid.79(2019) 374,arXiv:1810.08424
-
[31]
ATLAS collaboration, G. Aadet al.,Measurement of the cross-section and charge asymmetry of W bosons produced in proton–proton collisions at √s = 8 TeV with the ATLAS detector, Eur. Phys. J.C79(2019) 760,arXiv:1904.05631
-
[32]
Aaijet al.,Measurement of the W boson mass, JHEP01 (2022) 036,arXiv:2109.01113
LHCb collaboration, R. Aaijet al.,Measurement of the W boson mass, JHEP01 (2022) 036,arXiv:2109.01113
-
[33]
LHCb collaboration, R. Aaijet al.,Measurement of the effective leptonic weak mixing angle, JHEP12(2024) 026,arXiv:2410.02502
-
[34]
LHCb collaboration, R. Aaijet al.,First measurement of the Z→µ +µ− angular coefficients in the forward region of pp collisions at √s = 13 TeV, Phys. Rev. Lett. 129(2022) 091801,arXiv:2203.1602
-
[35]
W. Beenakkeret al.,NLO+NLL squark and gluino production cross sections with threshold-improved parton distributions, Eur. Phys. J.C76(2016) 53, arXiv:1510.00375
-
[36]
Denget al.,Impact of LHCb 13 TeV W and Z pseudo-data on the parton distribution functions, Chin
Q. Denget al.,Impact of LHCb 13 TeV W and Z pseudo-data on the Parton Distribution Functions, Chin. Phys.C45(2021) 023110,arXiv:2009.03181
-
[37]
Aaijet al.,Measurement of the W -boson production cross- sections in pp collisions at √s = 13 TeV in the forward region, LHCb-PAPER-2025- 070, CERN-EP-2026-083, Submitted to Phys
LHCb collaboration, R. Aaijet al.,Measurement of the W -boson production cross- sections in pp collisions at √s = 13 TeV in the forward region, LHCb-PAPER-2025- 070, CERN-EP-2026-083, Submitted to Phys. Rev. D
2025
-
[38]
LHCb collaboration, A. A. Alves Jr.et al.,The LHCb detector at the LHC, JINST3 (2008) S08005
2008
-
[39]
Aaijet al.,LHCb detector performance, Int
LHCb collaboration, R. Aaijet al.,LHCb detector performance, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A30(2015) 1530022,arXiv:1412.6352
-
[40]
A Brief Introduction to PYTHIA 8.1
T. Sj¨ ostrand, S. Mrenna, and P. Skands,A brief introduction to PYTHIA 8.1, Comput. Phys. Commun.178(2008) 852, arXiv:0710.3820; T. Sj¨ ostrand, S. Mrenna, and P. Skands,PYTHIA 6.4 physics and manual, JHEP05(2006) 026, arXiv:hep-ph/0603175
work page internal anchor Pith review arXiv 2008
-
[41]
Belyaevet al.,Handling of the generation of primary events in Gauss, the LHCb simulation framework, J
I. Belyaevet al.,Handling of the generation of primary events in Gauss, the LHCb simulation framework, J. Phys. Conf. Ser.331(2011) 032047
2011
-
[42]
Allisonet al.,Geant4 developments and applications, IEEE Trans
Geant4 collaboration, J. Allisonet al.,Geant4 developments and applications, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci.53(2006) 270; Geant4 collaboration, S. Agostinelliet al.,Geant4: A simulation toolkit, Nucl. Instrum. Meth.A506(2003) 250. 9
2006
-
[43]
Clemencicet al.,The LHCb simulation application, Gauss: Design, evolution and experience, J
M. Clemencicet al.,The LHCb simulation application, Gauss: Design, evolution and experience, J. Phys. Conf. Ser.331(2011) 032023
2011
-
[44]
Camarda, et al., DYTurbo: Fast predictions for Drell-Yan processes, Eur
S. Camardaet al.,DYTurbo: fast predictions for Drell–Yan processes, Eur. Phys. J. C80(2020) 251, Erratum ibid.80(2020) 440,arXiv:1910.07049
-
[45]
R. Gauldet al.,Precise predictions for the angular coefficients in Z-boson production at the LHC, JHEP11(2017) 003,arXiv:1708.00008
-
[46]
Aaijet al.,Performance of the LHCb Vertex Locator, JINST9(2014) P09007, arXiv:1405.7808
R. Aaijet al.,Performance of the LHCb Vertex Locator, JINST9(2014) P09007, arXiv:1405.7808
-
[47]
P. d’Argentet al.,Improved performance of the LHCb Outer Tracker in LHC Run 2, JINST12(2017) P11016,arXiv:1708.00819
-
[48]
N. Davidson, T. Przedzinski, and Z. Was,PHOTOS interface in C++: Technical and physics documentation, Comput. Phys. Commun.199(2016) 86, arXiv:1011.0937
- [49]
-
[50]
LHCb collaboration, R. Aaijet al.,Curvature-bias corrections using a pseudomass method, JINST19(2024) P03010,arXiv:2311.04670
-
[51]
R. J. Barlow and C. Beeston,Fitting using finite Monte Carlo samples, Comput. Phys. Commun.77(1993) 219
1993
-
[52]
LHCb collaboration, R. Aaijet al.,Measurement of the track reconstruction efficiency at LHCb, JINST10(2015) P02007,arXiv:1408.1251
- [53]
-
[54]
NNPDF collaboration, R. D. Ballet al.,Parton distributions from high-precision collider data, Eur. Phys. J.C77(2017) 663,arXiv:1706.00428
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv 2017
-
[55]
T.-J. Houet al.,New CTEQ global analysis of quantum chromodynamics with high- precision data from the LHC, Phys. Rev.D103(2021) 014013,arXiv:1912.10053
-
[56]
Wanget al.,Improved resummation prediction on Higgs production at hadron colliders, Phys
J. Wanget al.,Improved resummation prediction on Higgs production at hadron colliders, Phys. Rev.D86(2012) 094026,arXiv:1205.4311
- [57]
-
[58]
D. Bourilkov, R. C. Group, and M. R. Whalley,LHAPDF: PDF use from the Tevatron to the LHC,arXiv:hep-ph/0605240. 10 LHCb collaboration R. Aaij38 , M. Abdelfatah 69, A.S.W. Abdelmotteleb 57 , C. Abellan Beteta 51 , F. Abudin´ en59 , T. Ackernley61 , A. A. Adefisoye 69 , B. Adeva47 , M. Adinolfi 55 , P. Adlarson87 , C. Agapopoulou 14 , C.A. Aidala 89 , Z. Aj...
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.