Pith. sign in

REVIEW 2 major objections 2 minor 41 references

Full-Field Mode Sorter for Optical Knots

T0 review · 2 major / 2 minor · reviewed 2026-06-26 · grok-4.3

Challenge this review Re-run · record.json Download PDF Read on arXiv ↗

Pith's one-line read Optimized phase-only elements sort optical knots by mapping each to a distinct output region with reduced crosstalk.

desk verdict The paper numerically optimizes one or two phase plates to sort three specific optical knots in simulation but offers no experimental data or optimization details. read the letter →

arxiv 2606.23438 v1 pith:PNOSYHET submitted 2026-06-22 physics.optics quant-ph

Tareq Jaouni , Roohollah Ghobadi , Ebrahim Karimi This is my paper
classification physics.opticsquant-ph
keywords opticalknotsmodesorterphase-onlyelementstopologicallightHopflinktrefoilknotcinquefoilcommunication
verification ladder T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal

The pith

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The reading

Optical knots are topologically structured light fields that could serve as high-dimensional carriers for optical communication and quantum information. The paper establishes that a sorter made from one or two phase-only plates can distinguish knots in an alphabet by directing each knot to its own output area. The plates are designed by optimizing directly on the output intensity patterns to improve assignment accuracy and cut crosstalk. For the specific knots consisting of the Hopf link, trefoil, and cinquefoil, using two planes yields better separation than one. The design is also checked against typical experimental issues such as beam imperfections.

What carries the argument

The full-field sorter based on one or two optimized phase-only elements that assign knots according to their output intensity distributions.

What would settle it

Fabricating the optimized phase plates and experimentally measuring the crosstalk when generating and sorting the three optical knots in a laboratory setup.

Watch

Extended reading notes

Core claim

We demonstrate a proof-of-principle full-field sorter for optical knots using one or two optimized phase-only elements. The sorter maps each input knot to a predefined output region and is optimized directly from the output intensity distributions to enhance correct assignment, suppress crosstalk, and avoid degenerate mappings between distinct knots. We apply the method to an alphabet composed of the Hopf link, trefoil, and cinquefoil optical knots. Two optimized phase planes improve the sorting performance relative to a single plane and enable high distinguishability for the three-knot alphabet. We further benchmark the sorter under common experimental imperfections.

Load-bearing premise

The numerical optimization performed on simulated intensity distributions will translate to low crosstalk when the same phase plates are fabricated and the knots are generated in a real laboratory beam.

Editorial extensions

If this is right

  • Two optimized phase planes improve the sorting performance relative to a single plane.
  • The sorter enables high distinguishability for the Hopf link, trefoil, and cinquefoil knots.
  • The optimization suppresses crosstalk and avoids degenerate mappings between distinct knots.
  • The sorter maintains performance when benchmarked under common experimental imperfections.

Reading between the lines

Editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

  • The method could provide a practical readout for using optical knots in high-dimensional communication protocols.
  • Similar optimization might extend the sorter to larger alphabets of knots.
  • The approach could be adapted to sort other forms of topologically structured light beyond knots.
Share X Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit HN

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, simulated authors' rebuttal, and a circularity audit.

Referee Report

2 major / 2 minor

Summary. The manuscript claims a proof-of-principle numerical demonstration of a full-field sorter for optical knots (Hopf link, trefoil, cinquefoil) realized with one or two optimized phase-only elements. The elements are obtained by direct numerical optimization on simulated output intensity distributions to map each knot to a distinct spatial region while suppressing crosstalk and avoiding degenerate mappings; performance is reported to improve with two planes and is benchmarked under simulated imperfections.

Significance. If the numerical results hold under real conditions, the work would extend full-field mode sorting to topologically structured light and supply a concrete readout route for knot-based high-dimensional optical communication. The direct optimization from intensity distributions and the two-plane improvement are methodologically interesting; however, the purely simulated nature of all reported figures limits immediate significance.

major comments (2)
  1. [Abstract] Abstract and results: all performance metrics (crosstalk reduction from one to two planes, distinguishability for the three-knot alphabet, and robustness under imperfections) are obtained exclusively from forward simulations of ideal and perturbed fields. The central claim that the sorter 'demonstrates' a practical readout therefore rests on the untested assumption that the modeled imperfections capture the dominant laboratory error sources; no experimental realization or measured crosstalk data are provided.
  2. [Methods] The optimization is performed directly on output intensity distributions; the manuscript should specify the precise figure of merit (e.g., assignment probability, crosstalk matrix norm) and the optimization algorithm, as these choices directly determine whether the reported crosstalk suppression is robust or an artifact of the chosen cost function.
minor comments (2)
  1. Clarify the exact spatial definition of the 'predefined output regions' and how overlap or partial illumination is handled in the assignment metric.
  2. Add a brief comparison to existing knot detection methods (e.g., interferometric or machine-learning approaches) to situate the novelty of the phase-plate sorter.

Simulated Author's Rebuttal

2 responses · 0 unresolved

We thank the referee for the detailed and constructive comments. We address each major comment point by point below.

read point-by-point responses

  1. Referee: [Abstract] Abstract and results: all performance metrics (crosstalk reduction from one to two planes, distinguishability for the three-knot alphabet, and robustness under imperfections) are obtained exclusively from forward simulations of ideal and perturbed fields. The central claim that the sorter 'demonstrates' a practical readout therefore rests on the untested assumption that the modeled imperfections capture the dominant laboratory error sources; no experimental realization or measured crosstalk data are provided.

    Authors: We agree that the work is a numerical proof-of-principle and all metrics are from simulations. The abstract describes a 'proof-of-principle full-field sorter' and benchmarks under simulated imperfections, without claiming experimental realization. To address the concern, we have revised the manuscript to explicitly note in the abstract that this is a numerical demonstration and added discussion on the modeled imperfections and future experimental validation. This clarifies the scope without overstating the results. revision: yes

  2. Referee: [Methods] The optimization is performed directly on output intensity distributions; the manuscript should specify the precise figure of merit (e.g., assignment probability, crosstalk matrix norm) and the optimization algorithm, as these choices directly determine whether the reported crosstalk suppression is robust or an artifact of the chosen cost function.

    Authors: We concur that the specific figure of merit and algorithm should be detailed for clarity and reproducibility. In the revised version, we have expanded the Methods section to include the exact figure of merit (a combination of correct assignment probability and crosstalk suppression) and the optimization procedure (iterative phase retrieval with direct numerical optimization). This addition ensures the results can be properly evaluated. revision: yes

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged · score 0.0 of 10

No significant circularity; optimization-based design is self-contained.

full rationale

The paper describes a numerical optimization of one or two phase-only elements to map input optical knots (Hopf link, trefoil, cinquefoil) onto distinct output regions while minimizing crosstalk, with performance evaluated on the resulting simulated intensity distributions. No equations, fitted parameters presented as independent predictions, or self-citations appear in the provided text that would reduce any central claim to its inputs by construction. The approach is an engineering design method whose outputs are the direct result of the stated optimization objective; no load-bearing self-citation chains or ansatzes imported from prior author work are invoked. This is the expected non-finding for a simulation-driven design paper.

Assumptions & free parameters 0 free parameters · 0 assumptions · 0 invented entities

Abstract-only review yields no explicit free parameters, axioms or invented entities; the optimization procedure itself is not described.

how reviews work

0 comments
Cite this review

Pith. "Pith review of Full-Field Mode Sorter for Optical Knots." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/PNOSYHET

@misc{pith2026260623438,
  author       = {Pith},
  title        = {Pith review of: Full-Field Mode Sorter for Optical Knots},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/PNOSYHET}},
  note         = {Machine review of arXiv:2606.23438}
}
read the original abstract

Optical knots are topologically structured light fields whose phase or polarization singularities trace linked or knotted trajectories during propagation, making them promising candidates for high-dimensional optical information carriers. Their use in communication or quantum-information protocols, however, requires a practical readout method that can distinguish a chosen knot alphabet with low crosstalk. Here, we demonstrate a proof-of-principle full-field sorter for optical knots using one or two optimized phase-only elements. The sorter maps each input knot to a predefined output region and is optimized directly from the output intensity distributions to enhance correct assignment, suppress crosstalk, and avoid degenerate mappings between distinct knots. We apply the method to an alphabet composed of the Hopf link, trefoil, and cinquefoil optical knots. Two optimized phase planes improve the sorting performance relative to a single plane and enable high distinguishability for the three-knot alphabet. We further benchmark the sorter under common experimental imperfections. These results extend full-field optical mode sorting to topologically structured light and provide a readout route for knot-based high-dimensional optical communication.

Figures

Figures reproduced from arXiv: 2606.23438 by the authors.

Figure 1
Figure 1. FIG. 1 [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p002_1.png] view at source ↗
Figure 2
Figure 2. FIG. 2 [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p003_2.png] view at source ↗
Figure 3
Figure 3. FIG. 3 [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p004_3.png] view at source ↗
Figures from the paper (4 more)
Figure 4
Figure 4. Figure 4: FIG. 4 [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p005_4.png]
Figure 5
Figure 5. Figure 5: FIG. 5 [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p005_5.png]
Figure 6
Figure 6. Figure 6: illustrates how the sorter’s performance changes under the influence of the trefoil (Z 3 3 ) aberration on a cin￾quefoil input. As the wavefront distortions lie about the cir￾cumference of the aberration mask, the knotted input remains largely invariant under the trans…
Figure 7
Figure 7. Figure 7: FIG. 7 [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p010_7.png]

Discussion (0). Sign in to comment.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

41 extracted references · 3 canonical work pages

  1. [1]

    Thus,V p penalizes the collapse of the alphabet into fewer distinguishable output patterns

    If two inputs produce identical conditional output distri- butions, two columns ofpbecome linearly dependent and Vp =0. Thus,V p penalizes the collapse of the alphabet into fewer distinguishable output patterns. The optimization ob- jective is then taken as, F=C b(α)Rd(eb)V γ P,(6) where 0≤α≤1 controls the emphasis on the worst- performing channel, and 0≤...

  2. [2]

    The corresponding insets in (a) and (b) show the applied aberration withγ=1.0 and at different aperture sizes

    aberration. The corresponding insets in (a) and (b) show the applied aberration withγ=1.0 and at different aperture sizes. Halving the aperture radius results in an enhanced perturbation, as the phase modulations more strongly affect the knotted singularities. remembrance of [28], we investigate the effect of individ- ual Zernike modes, into whichδ(ρ, ϕ) ...

  3. [3]

    aberration on a cin- quefoil input. As the wavefront distortions lie about the cir- cumference of the aberration mask, the knotted input remains largely invariant under the transformation with too large an aperture size,A=8.0w o. Decreasing the aperture size by half causes both efficiency and sorting ability to drop dramat- ically. Similar trends in perfo...

  4. [4]

    Bechmann-Pasquinucci and W

    H. Bechmann-Pasquinucci and W. Tittel, Quantum cryptog- raphy using larger alphabets, Physical Review A61, 062308 (2000)

    2000

  5. [5]

    K. Y . Bliokh, E. Karimi, M. J. Padgett, M. A. Alonso, M. R. Dennis, A. Dudley, A. Forbes, S. Zahedpour, S. W. Hancock, H. M. Milchberg,et al., Roadmap on structured waves, Journal of Optics25, 103001 (2023)

    2023

  6. [6]

    A. Sit, F. Bouchard, R. Fickler, J. Gagnon-Bischoff, H. Larocque, K. Heshami, D. Elser, C. Peuntinger, K. G¨unthner, B. Heim, C. Marquardt, G. Leuchs, R. W. Boyd, and E. Karimi, High-dimensional intracity quantum cryptography with struc- tured photons, Optica4, 1006 (2017)

    2017

  7. [7]

    Bouchard, A

    F. Bouchard, A. Sit, F. Hufnagel, A. Abbas, Y . Zhang, K. He- shami, R. Fickler, C. Marquardt, G. Leuchs, R. w. Boyd, and E. Karimi, Quantum cryptography with twisted photons through an outdoor underwater channel, Optics Express26, 22563 (2018)

    2018

  8. [8]

    Bouchard, K

    F. Bouchard, K. Heshami, D. England, R. Fickler, R. W. Boyd, B.-G. Englert, L. L. S ´anchez-Soto, and E. Karimi, Experimen- tal investigation of high-dimensional quantum key distribution protocols with twisted photons, Quantum2, 111 (2018)

    2018

Show all 41 references
  1. [9]

    Mirhosseini, O

    M. Mirhosseini, O. S. Maga ˜na-Loaiza, M. N. O’Sullivan, B. Rodenburg, M. Malik, M. P. Lavery, M. J. Padgett, D. J. Gauthier, and R. W. Boyd, High-dimensional quantum cryptog- raphy with twisted light, New Journal of Physics17, 033033 (2015)

    2015

  2. [10]

    Jaouni, L

    T. Jaouni, L. Scarfe, F. Bouchard, M. Krenn, K. Heshami, F. D. Colandrea, and E. Karimi, Predicting atmospheric turbulence for secure quantum communications in free space, Optics Ex- press33, 10759 (2025)

    2025

  3. [11]

    A. E. Willner, H. Huang, Y . Yan, Y . Ren, N. Ahmed, G. Xie, C. Bao, L. Li, Y . Cao, Z. Zhao,et al., Optical communications using orbital angular momentum beams, Advances in optics and photonics7, 66 (2015)

    2015

  4. [12]

    X. Gu, M. Krenn, M. Erhard, and A. Zeilinger, Gouy Phase Ra- dial Mode Sorter for Light: Concepts and Experiments, Physi- cal Review Letters120, 103601 (2018)

    2018

  5. [13]

    Leach, M

    J. Leach, M. J. Padgett, S. M. Barnett, S. Franke-Arnold, and J. Courtial, Measuring the Orbital Angular Momentum of a Sin- gle Photon, Physical Review Letters88, 257901 (2002)

    2002

  6. [14]

    Fickler, M

    R. Fickler, M. Ginoya, and R. W. Boyd, Custom-tailored spatial mode sorting by controlled random scattering, Physical Review B95, 161108 (2017)

    2017

  7. [15]

    Fickler, F

    R. Fickler, F. Bouchard, E. Giese, V . Grillo, G. Leuchs, and E. Karimi, Full-field mode sorter using two optimized phase transformations for high-dimensional quantum cryptography, Journal of Optics22, 024001 (2020)

    2020

  8. [16]

    N. K. Fontaine, R. Ryf, H. Chen, D. T. Neilson, K. Kim, and J. Carpenter, Laguerre-Gaussian mode sorter, Nature Commu- nications10, 1865 (2019)

    2019

  9. [17]

    J. C. A. Rocha, U. G. B ¯utait˙e, J. Carpenter, and D. B. Phillips, Self-configuring high-speed multi-plane light conversion, Na- ture Communications 10.1038/s41467-025-66798-2 (2025)

    2025 doi

  10. [18]

    Kupianskyi, S

    H. Kupianskyi, S. A. R. Horsley, and D. B. Phillips, High- dimensional spatial mode sorting and optical circuit design using multi-plane light conversion, APL Photonics8, 026101 (2023)

    2023

  11. [19]

    O. Lib, K. Sulimany, M. Ara ´ujo, M. Ben-Or, and Y . Bromberg, High-dimensional quantum key distribution using a multi-plane light converter, Optica Quantum3, 182 (2025)

    2025

  12. [20]

    Bauer, P

    T. Bauer, P. Banzer, E. Karimi, S. Orlov, A. Rubano, L. Mar- rucci, E. Santamato, R. W. Boyd, and G. Leuchs, Observation of optical polarization m¨obius strips, Science347, 964 (2015)

    2015

  13. [21]

    Bauer, P

    T. Bauer, P. Banzer, F. Bouchard, S. Orlov, L. Marrucci, E. San- tamato, R. W. Boyd, E. Karimi, and G. Leuchs, Multi-twist polarization ribbon topologies in highly-confined optical fields, New Journal of Physics21, 053020 (2019)

    2019

  14. [22]

    Leach, M

    J. Leach, M. R. Dennis, J. Courtial, and M. J. Padgett, V ortex knots in light, New Journal of Physics7, 55 (2005)

    2005

  15. [23]

    Larocque, D

    H. Larocque, D. Sugic, D. Mortimer, A. J. Taylor, R. Fickler, R. W. Boyd, M. R. Dennis, and E. Karimi, Reconstructing the 8 topology of optical polarization knots, Nature Physics14, 1079 (2018)

    2018

  16. [24]

    Larocque, A

    H. Larocque, A. D’Errico, M. F. Ferrer-Garcia, A. Carmi, E. Cohen, and E. Karimi, Optical framed knots as information carriers, Nature communications11, 5119 (2020)

    2020

  17. [25]

    M. V . Berry and M. R. Dennis, Knotted and linked phase sin- gularities in monochromatic waves, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A: Mathematical, Physical and Engi- neering Sciences457, 2251 (2001)

    2001

  18. [26]

    Sugic, M

    D. Sugic, M. R. Dennis, F. Nori, and K. Y . Bliokh, Knotted po- larizations and spin in three-dimensional polychromatic waves, Physical Review Research2, 042045 (2020)

    2020

  19. [27]

    M. F. Ferrer-Garcia, A. D’Errico, H. Larocque, A. Sit, and E. Karimi, Polychromatic electric field knots, Physical Review Research3, 033226 (2021)

    2021

  20. [28]

    M. V . Berry and M. R. Dennis, Knotting and unknotting of phase singularities: Helmholtz waves, paraxial waves and waves in 2+1 spacetime, Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and General34, 8877 (2001)

    2001

  21. [29]

    M. F. Ferrer-Garcia, A. Carmi, A. D’Errico, H. Larocque, E. Cohen, and E. Karimi, Secure communication us- ing low dimensional topological elements, arXiv preprint arXiv:2212.04350 (2022)

    2022

  22. [30]

    Freedman, A

    M. Freedman, A. Kitaev, M. Larsen, and Z. Wang, Topological quantum computation, Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society40, 31 (2003)

    2003

  23. [31]

    Dehghan, A

    N. Dehghan, A. D’Errico, T. Jaouni, and E. Karimi, Effects of aberrations on 3D optical topologies, Communications Physics 6, 357 (2023)

    2023

  24. [32]

    D. G. Pires, D. Tsvetkov, H. Barati Sedeh, N. Chandra, and N. M. Litchinitser, Stability of optical knots in atmospheric tur- bulence, Nature Communications16, 3001 (2025)

    2025

  25. [33]

    C. W. Helstrom, Quantum detection and estimation theory, Journal of Statistical Physics1, 231 (1969)

    1969

  26. [34]

    A. Mair, A. Vaziri, G. Weihs, and A. Zeilinger, Entanglement of the orbital angular momentum states of photons, Nature412, 313 (2001)

    2001

  27. [35]

    Qassim, F

    H. Qassim, F. M. Miatto, J. P. Torres, M. J. Padgett, E. Karimi, and R. W. Boyd, Limitations to the determination of a laguerre– gauss spectrum via projective, phase-flattening measurement, Journal of the Optical Society of America B31, A20 (2014)

    2014

  28. [36]

    Trichili, C

    A. Trichili, C. Rosales-Guzm ´an, A. Dudley, B. Ndagano, A. Ben Salem, M. Zghal, and A. Forbes, Optical communi- cation beyond orbital angular momentum, Scientific reports6, 27674 (2016)

    2016

  29. [37]

    Bar-Natan and R

    D. Bar-Natan and R. van der Veen, A fast, strong, topo- logically meaningful and fun knot invariant, arXiv preprint arXiv:2509.18456 (2025)

    2025 arXiv

  30. [38]

    S. Goel, M. Tyler, F. Zhu, S. Leedumrongwatthanakun, M. Ma- lik, and J. Leach, Simultaneously sorting overlapping quantum states of light, Physical Review Letters130, 143602 (2023)

    2023

  31. [39]

    Peters, V

    C. Peters, V . Cocotos, and A. Forbes, Structured light in atmo- spheric turbulence—a guide to its digital implementation: tuto- rial, Advances in Optics and Photonics17, 113 (2025)

    2025

  32. [40]

    Jaouni, R

    T. Jaouni, R. Ghobadi, and E. Karimi, KnotSorter

  33. [41]

    A. F. Gad, Pygad: An intuitive genetic algorithm python library, Multimedia tools and applications83, 58029 (2024). 9 APPENDIX Genetic Algorithm details.We apply the GA in two steps to determine the optimized phase masks. In the first 10 4 it- erations, we optimize the startin...

    2024

Pith tools

Reviewed June 26, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.