On phase transitions in Pb/Ge(111) and Sn/Ge(111)

The present communication is a critical examination of two points relevant to the surface phase transitions of Pb and Sn overlayers on Ge(111). One is connected with the reading of the reported structural data, which lead to some consequences of paramount importance but overlooked up to now. The other point is the seeming contradiction in what concerns to the transition temperatures obtained from different experimental methods. The importance of this contradiction, in contrast to the previous point, has been overestimated.