On the Role of Defects in the Electronic Structure of MnBi$_{2-x}$Sb$_x$Te$_4$

Elemental substitution is a proven method of Fermi level tuning in topological insulators, which is needed for device applications. Through static and time resolved photoemission, we show that in MnBi$_2$Te$_4$, elemental substitution of Bi with Sb indeed tunes the Fermi level towards the bulk band gap, making the material charge neutral at 35\% Sb concentration. For the first time, we are able to directly probe the excited state band structure at this doping level, and their dynamics, which show that the decay channels at the Fermi level are severely restricted. However, elemental substitution widens the surface state gap, which we attribute to the increase in antisite defects resulting from Sb substitution. This hypothesis is supported by DFT calculations that include defects, which show a sensitivity of the topological surface state to their inclusion. Our results emphasize the need for defect control if MnBi$_{2-x}$Sb$_x$Te$_4$ is to be used for device applications.