REVIEW 4 major objections 5 minor 34 references
Angular dependence of large negative magnetoresistance in a field-induced Weyl semimetal candidate HoAuSn
T0 review · 4 major / 5 minor · reviewed 2026-08-12 · deepseek-v4-flash
Pith's one-line read In the antiferromagnetic half-Heusler HoAuSn, a 9 T magnetic field reconstructs the band structure from a trivial semimetal into a Weyl semimetal, creating Weyl points near the Fermi level and raising the carrier concentration, which…
desk verdict New angular-dependent transport data on HoAuSn, but the field-induced Weyl mechanism is asserted, not demonstrated. read the letter →
The pith
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
The reading
What carries the argument
The central object is the field-induced Weyl point: in the ferromagnetic band structure calculated with GGA+SOC+U ($U_{\mathrm{eff}}=8$ eV), Weyl points appear in the $\Gamma$–$L$ path near the Fermi level, and Wilson-loop calculations confirm their existence for magnetization along $[111]$, $[110]$, and $[001]$. This object carries the argument because it connects the applied magnetic field to transport: spin polarization from the field splits bands, closes the gap, enlarges the Fermi surface, raises the density of states at the Fermi level, and thereby increases carrier concentration and suppresses spin scattering. The angular-dependence measurements, in which the field is rotated between $[111]$, $[1\bar{1}0]$, and $[11\bar{2}]$ with current fixed along $[1\bar{1}0]$, together with the two-fold and four-fold AMR symmetry fits, are the experimental counterpart that ties the Weyl-point scenario to the observed negative MR.
What would settle it
Measure the Hall coefficient across the metamagnetic transition near 4 T: the field-induced Weyl scenario predicts a sharp increase in carrier concentration, visible as a jump in the Hall signal at the same field where the resistivity begins its two-order-of-magnitude drop; if the carrier density stays flat while the resistivity collapses, the band-reconstruction mechanism would be falsified.
Extended reading notes
Core claim
The paper's central claim is that in HoAuSn a sufficiently strong magnetic field (on the order of 9 T) reconstructs the electronic band structure, taking the material from a trivial semimetal to a Weyl semimetal and producing a negative magnetoresistance as large as 99%. In the non-magnetic calculation HoAuSn is a trivial semimetal with a small hole pocket near $\Gamma$ and an electron pocket near $X$; in the ferromagnetic calculation, with magnetization along $[111]$ (and also for $[110]$ and $[001]$), Weyl points appear on the $\Gamma$–$L$ path, the Fermi-surface area grows, and the density of states at the Fermi level increases. The paper interprets the enlarged Fermi surface and increased carrier concentration as the reason the resistivity drops sharply under field, and it connects the angular dependence of the magnetoresistance, including the two-fold and four-fold components of the anisotropic magnetoresistance, to the same field-induced band change.
Load-bearing premise
The argument rests on assuming that a 9 T applied field puts HoAuSn into the collinear ferromagnetic state used in the calculation, with moments along $[111]$, $[110]$, or $[001]$, even though the measured zero-field ground state is antiferromagnetic below 1.9 K with a metamagnetic transition near 4 T, and no measurement or calculation shows that 9 T actually produces that ferromagnetic configuration.
Editorial extensions
If this is right
- HoAuSn becomes a transport-based example of a magnetic-field-driven topological transition in an antiferromagnetic half-Heusler, with the 99% negative magnetoresistance serving as a bulk probe of the Weyl-point formation.
- Because the negative MR persists to 20 K, well above the 1.9 K Néel temperature, the field-induced band reconstruction is robust against loss of long-range magnetic order, and the effect should also be observable in the paramagnetic regime.
- The angular dependence of the high-field MR, with two-fold and four-fold components, provides a symmetry-based fingerprint that can be used to identify field-induced Weyl points in other antiferromagnetic half-Heuslers.
- Since the effect appears for all measured angles between field and current, its origin is distinct from the conventional longitudinal chiral-anomaly negative MR and points to a more general band-structure-driven mechanism.
- Replacing Ho with other lanthanide rare earths should tune the field scale and temperature window of the negative magnetoresistance, offering a materials-design route to even larger effects.
Reading between the lines
- A testable extension not performed in the paper is to look for the enlarged Fermi surface directly via quantum oscillations: the ferromagnetic band calculation predicts additional or shifted Shubnikov–de Haas frequencies above the metamagnetic transition, which could be checked by high-field torque or resistivity measurements.
- The paper assumes a particular collinear ferromagnetic moment direction; an implication left implicit is that the angular dependence of the negative MR could be inverted to infer the actual moment direction at 9 T, effectively using transport as a magnetic-structure probe.
- If the Weyl points really sit near the Fermi level, HoAuSn should also show other topological signatures, such as an anomalous Hall effect or a chiral-anomaly contribution in longitudinal fields; measuring these would provide independent cross-checks of the scenario.
- The framework suggests a correlation across antiferromagnetic half-Heuslers between the rare-earth metamagnetic transition field and the onset field of the large negative MR; a systematic series of compounds could test this prediction.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The paper reports single-crystal growth, magnetization, resistivity, and angular-dependent magnetoresistance measurements on the antiferromagnetic half-Heusler HoAuSn. A negative MR of up to 99% at 9 T is observed, robust up to 20 K, and present for multiple field-current geometries. GGA+U+SOC band-structure calculations of a ferromagnetic state with magnetization along [111], [110], and [001] show Weyl points near the Fermi level, which the authors interpret as evidence that the applied field induces a transition from a trivial semimetal to a Weyl semimetal and thereby suppresses spin scattering and produces the large negative MR.
Significance. The transport data are carefully measured, and the observation of a 99% negative MR at 9 T, with clear angular dependence and persistence far above TN, is of empirical interest for antiferromagnetic half-Heuslers. The paper's value lies mainly in the magnetotransport dataset and the identification of HoAuSn as a candidate field-induced Weyl semimetal; the calculated Fermi surfaces and density of states provide qualitative support for band reconstruction. However, the central mechanism is not demonstrated: the assumed zero-field FM state is used as a proxy for the 9 T state, and no transport signature (Hall effect, longitudinal-only negative MR, quantum oscillations) directly links the negative MR to Weyl nodes. If the mechanism were established, the result would be significant for field-induced topological transitions in magnetic half-Heuslers; as it stands, it is a candidate mechanism with suggestive but incomplete evidence.
major comments (4)
- [Sec. 3, Fig. 4c; Sec. 2, Fig. 1f] The identification of the 9 T field-induced state with the zero-field collinear FM band structure of Fig. 4c is not justified: HoAuSn is antiferromagnetic below TN=1.9 K, and Fig. 1f shows a metamagnetic transition near 4 T with magnetization only gradually approaching saturation at 9 T. No field-dependent calculation or high-field magnetization comparison (e.g., the calculated FM moment vs. M(9 T)) is provided. If the 9 T state is only partially polarized or canted, the Weyl points in the Γ-L path may not exist near the Fermi level, and the central claim that the magnetic field induces the Weyl point collapses.
- [Sec. 2, Sec. 3 Fig. 4 caption] The GGA+U+SOC calculations use a hand-set Ueff = 8 eV for Ho 4f electrons with no sensitivity analysis or validation against the measured magnetic moment, band gap, or photoemission. The presence and energy position of Weyl points in the FM state are sensitive to Ueff and to the treatment of the 4f electrons; without such validation, the calculation cannot establish that Weyl points appear near EF specifically in the high-field state.
- [Sec. 3, Figs. 2b-2d; Conclusion] The transport evidence does not demonstrate Weyl nodes: the paper reports 99% negative MR for B||J and about 90% for B⊥J, yet the chiral-anomaly scenario predicts a pronounced longitudinal-transverse distinction, and the observed negative MR in transverse geometry is attributed to an unquantified increase in carrier concentration from the reconstructed band structure. No Hall measurement, carrier-density analysis, or quantitative magnetotransport model is provided, so the data cannot discriminate between the proposed Weyl mechanism and a generic field-driven insulator-to-metal transition in a canted or partially polarized state.
- [Sec. 3, Fig. 3] The attribution of the two-fold AMR symmetry to 'chiral anomalies' is speculative: no symmetry analysis or model calculation connects the chiral anomaly to the observed two-fold angular dependence, and the four-fold terms are fitted phenomenologically. At minimum, the angular-dependent data should be compared with expectations for a field-induced Weyl semimetal with the relevant magnetic point group, or the symmetry statement should be withdrawn.
minor comments (5)
- [Sec. 3, paragraph on negative-MR materials] Reference numbering errors: the Cd3As2 negative-MR work is cited as [29] but reference [29] is the MnFeGe paper (Tang et al.); the Cd3As2 nanowire paper is reference [30]. Similarly, BaMn2Bi2 is cited as [30] but appears as reference [31], and EuMnSb2 is cited as [31] but is reference [32]. The 'half-heusler alloy TbPbBi[25]' citation should be [26] (and the compound name should read TbPdBi).
- [Fig. 1c] Typo: 'extractd' should be 'extracted'.
- [Abstract and Sec. 2] The phrase 'magnetics fields' should be 'magnetic fields'.
- [Fig. 4 caption and Sec. 3] The calculation for the zero-moment state is referred to both as 'non-magnetic (NM)' (text) and 'paramagnetic' (Fig. 4 caption); please use one term consistently.
- [Sec. 3, angular dependence discussion] The current direction for the (001)-plane measurements shown in Fig. S4 is not specified in the main text; please state the crystallographic direction of the current in those measurements.
Circularity Check
No circular derivation chains found: the negative-MR data and DFT band structures are independent, and the main claim reduces to an unvalidated modeling assumption rather than to a fitted or self-referential input.
full rationale
The paper's derivation chain is not circular in the sense of the rubric. The large negative MR is measured transport data; the Weyl-point claim comes from separate GGA+U+SOC band-structure and Wilson-loop calculations. No equation in the paper fits a parameter to the MR curves and then re-predicts them, and the transport data are not used as inputs to the DFT. The weakest load-bearing move, treating the 9 T state as the collinear FM state with M along [111] (Section 3, Fig. 4c), is an unvalidated assumption about the field-polarized magnetic configuration, not a reduction of the conclusion to its own premises: the measured zero-field AFM state and the metamagnetic transition near 4 T do not logically force the DFT input. The hand-set Ueff = 8 eV is likewise a modeling choice, not a fit to the target observable. The only same-group citation, ref [19] (Chen et al. 2020) on chiral-anomaly negative MR in RPtBi, is used as background in a list with external refs [20,23,24] and is not load-bearing for the HoAuSn conclusion, which also rests on the external field-induced-Weyl framework of refs [25,26]. Accordingly the score is 2: a minor, non-load-bearing self-citation, with the central claim having independent experimental and computational content.
Assumptions & free parameters
free parameters (1)
- Ueff for Ho 4f electrons =
8 eV
assumptions (3)
- domain assumption PBE-GGA+SOC+U DFT provides a qualitatively correct electronic structure for HoAuSn.
- ad hoc to paper The zero-field collinear ferromagnetic state with magnetization along [111], [110], or [001] represents the electronic structure under an applied field of 9 T.
- domain assumption The large negative MR is caused by Weyl points acting through the chiral anomaly, despite being present in all field-current orientations.
Cite this review
Pith. "Pith review of Angular dependence of large negative magnetoresistance in a field-induced Weyl semimetal candidate HoAuSn." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/QVINPYQI
@misc{pith2026241114140,
author = {Pith},
title = {Pith review of: Angular dependence of large negative magnetoresistance in a field-induced Weyl semimetal candidate HoAuSn},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/QVINPYQI}},
note = {Machine review of arXiv:2411.14140}
}
read the original abstract
The angular dependence of magnetoresistance (MR) in antiferromagnetic half-Heusler HoAuSn single crystals have been systematically studied. Negative MR, as large as 99%, is observed at 9 T, is not restricted to the specific configuration of applied magnetics fields and current, and can persist up to 20 K, much higher than the Neel temperature (TN 1.9 K). Experiments and first-principles calculations suggest that the observed large negative MR is derived from a magnetic field that reconstructs the band structure and induces a Weyl point, which changes the carrier concentration. Taking into consideration that large negative MR has so far been rarely reported, especially in antiferromagnetic materials, it is anticipated that the present work not only offers a guideline for searching materials with large negative MR but also helps to further realize other exotic topological electronic states in a large class of antiferromagnetic half-Heusler compounds.
Figures
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[25]
Ueda K., Yu T., Hirayama M., Kurokawa R., Nakajima T., Saito H., Kriener M., Hoshino M., Hashizume D., Arima T.-h., Arita R. and Tokura Y ., Colossal negative magnetoresistance in field-induced Weyl semimetal of magnetic half-Heusler compound, Nature Communications, 2023, 14(1): 6339
work page 2023
-
[26]
H., Singleton J., Min L., Palmstrom J
Zhu Y ., Huang C.-Y ., Wang Y ., Graf D., Lin H., Lee S. H., Singleton J., Min L., Palmstrom J. C., Bansil A., Singh B. and Mao Z., Large anomalous Hall effect and negative magnetoresistance in half -topological semimetals, Communications Physics, 2023, 6(1): 346
work page 2023
-
[1]
Baibich M. N., Broto J. M., Fert A., Van Dau F. N., Petroff F., Etienne P., Creuzet G., Friederich A. and Chazelas J., Giant Magnetoresistance of (001)Fe/(001)Cr Magnetic Superlattices, Physical Review Letters, 1988, 61(21): 2472
work page 1988
-
[29]
-X., Wang P.-H., You Y .-R., Wang Y .-D., Xu Z., Hou Z
Tang J. -X., Wang P.-H., You Y .-R., Wang Y .-D., Xu Z., Hou Z. -P., Zhang H. -G., Xu G. -Z. and Xu F., Abnormal low -field M -type magnetoresistance in hexagonal noncollinear ferromagnetic MnFeGe alloy, Rare Metals, 2022, 41(8): 2680
work page 2022
-
[2]
Fert A., Nobel Lecture: Origin, development, and future of spintronics, Reviews of Modern Physics, 2008, 80(4): 1517
work page 2008
-
[3]
Chappert C., Fert A. and Van Dau F. N., The emergence of spin electronics in data storage, Nature Materials, 2007, 6(11): 813
work page 2007
-
[4]
Dai Y ., Zhao Y . W., Ma L., Tang M., Qiu X. P., Liu Y ., Yuan Z. and Zhou S. M., Fourfold Anisotropic Magnetoresistance of L10 FePt Due to Relaxation Time Anisotropy, Physical Review Letters, 2022, 128(24) : 247202
work page 2022
-
[5]
Oogane M., McFadden A. P., Kota Y ., Brown-Heft T. L., Tsunoda M., Ando Y . and Palmstrøm C. J., Fourfold symmetric anisotropic magnetoresistance in half -metallic Co 2MnSi Heusler alloy thin films, Japanese Journal of Applied Physics, 2018, 57(6): 063001
work page 2018
Show all 34 references
-
[6]
and Yu G.-H., Tunable perpendicular anisotropic magnetoresistance in CoO/Co/Pt heterostructures, Rare Metals, 2017, 42(2): 579
Liu Q.-Q., Yang G., Zhang J.-Y ., Feng G.-N., Feng C., Zhan Q., Li M.- H. and Yu G.-H., Tunable perpendicular anisotropic magnetoresistance in CoO/Co/Pt heterostructures, Rare Metals, 2017, 42(2): 579
2017
-
[7]
and Jiang Y ., Robust interface-induced unusual anomalous Hall effect in Mn 3Sn/Pt 12 bilayers, Rare Metals, 2022, 41(9): 3012
Liu J.-J., Meng K.-K., Chen J.-K., Wu Y ., Miao J., Xu X.-G. and Jiang Y ., Robust interface-induced unusual anomalous Hall effect in Mn 3Sn/Pt 12 bilayers, Rare Metals, 2022, 41(9): 3012
2022
-
[8]
Vlietstra N., Shan J., Castel V ., van Wees B. J. and Ben Youssef J., Spin- Hall magnetoresistance in platinum on yttrium iron garnet: Dependence on platinum thickness and in -plane/out-of-plane magnetization, Physical Review B, 2013, 87(18): 184421
2013
-
[9]
C., Cai X
Song T. C., Cai X. H., Tu M. W. Y ., Zhang X. O., Huang B. V ., Wilson N. P., Seyler K. L., Zhu L., Taniguchi T., Watanabe K., McGuire M. A., Cobden D. H., Xiao D., Yao W. and Xu X. D., Giant tunneling magnetoresistance in spin -filter van der Waals heteros tructures, Science,...
2018
-
[10]
Parkin S. S. P., Kaiser C., Panchula A., Rice P. M., Hughes B., Samant M. and Yang S. -H., Giant tunnelling magnetoresistance at room temperature with MgO (100) tunnel barriers, Nature Materials, 2004, 3(12): 862
2004
-
[11]
P., Colossal magnetoresistance, Journal of Physics - Condensed Matter, 1997, 9(39): 8171
Ramirez A. P., Colossal magnetoresistance, Journal of Physics - Condensed Matter, 1997, 9(39): 8171
1997
-
[12]
S., Negative Magnetoresistance in Viscous Flow of Two- Dimensional Electrons, Physical Review Letters, 2016, 117(16): 166601
Alekseev P. S., Negative Magnetoresistance in Viscous Flow of Two- Dimensional Electrons, Physical Review Letters, 2016, 117(16): 166601
2016
-
[13]
Kondo J., RESISTANCE MINIMUM IN DILUTE MAGNETIC ALLOYS, Progress of Theoretical Physics, 1964, 32(1): 37
1964
-
[14]
L., Khmel'nitzkii D., Larkin A
Altshuler B. L., Khmel'nitzkii D., Larkin A. I. and Lee P. A., Magnetoresistance and Hall effect in a disordered two -dimensional 13 electron gas, Physical Review B, 1980, 22(11): 5142
1980
-
[15]
E., Park S., Park J., Skourski Y ., Choi E
Seo J., De C., Ha H., Lee J. E., Park S., Park J., Skourski Y ., Choi E. S., Kim B., Cho G. Y ., Yeom H. W., Cheong S.-W., Kim J. H., Yang B.-J., Kim K. and Kim J. S., Colossal angular magnetoresistance in ferrimagnetic nodal-line semiconductors, Nature, 2021, 599(7886): 576
2021
-
[16]
A., Yao D.- X
Yin J., Wu C., Li L., Yu J., Sun H., Shen B., Frandsen B. A., Yao D.- X. and Wang M., Large negative magnetoresistance in the antiferromagnetic rare -earth dichalcogenide EuTe 2, Physical Review Materials, 2020, 4(1): 013405
2020
-
[17]
Liu E., Sun Y ., Kumar N., Muechler L., Sun A., Jiao L., Yang S.-Y ., Liu D., Liang A., Xu Q., Kroder J., Süß V ., Borrmann H., Shekhar C., Wang Z., Xi C., Wang W., Schnelle W., Wirth S., Chen Y ., Goennenwein S. T. B. and Felser C., Giant anomalous Hall eff ect in a ferromagn...
2018
-
[18]
and Miao F., Gate-tunable negative longitudinal magnetoresistance in the predicted type-II Weyl semimetal WTe2, Nature Communications, 2016, 7(1): 13142
Wang Y ., Liu E., Liu H., Pan Y ., Zhang L., Zeng J., Fu Y ., Wang M., Xu K., Huang Z., Wang Z., Lu H.-Z., Xing D., Wang B., Wan X. and Miao F., Gate-tunable negative longitudinal magnetoresistance in the predicted type-II Weyl semimetal WTe2, Nature Communications, 2016, 7(1): 13142
2016
-
[19]
Chen J., Li H., Ding B., Liu E., Yao Y ., Wu G. and Wang W., Chiral- anomaly induced large negative magnetoresistance and nontrivial π-Berry phase in half -Heusler compounds RPtBi (R=Tb, Ho, and Er), Applied Physics Letters, 2020, 116(22): 222403. 14
2020
-
[20]
A., Cava R
Hirschberger M., Kushwaha S., Wang Z., Gibson Q., Liang S., Belvin Carina A., Bernevig B. A., Cava R. J. and Ong N. P., The chiral anomaly and thermopower of Weyl fermions in the half -Heusler GdPtBi, Nature Materials, 2016, 15(11): 1161
2016
-
[21]
C., Kampert E., Skourski Y ., Wosnitza J., Schnelle W., McCollam A., Zeitler U., Kübler J., Yan B., Klauss H
Shekhar C., Kumar N., Grinenko V ., Singh S., Sarkar R., Luetkens H., Wu S.-C., Zhang Y ., Komarek A. C., Kampert E., Skourski Y ., Wosnitza J., Schnelle W., McCollam A., Zeitler U., Kübler J., Yan B., Klauss H. H., Parkin S. S. P. and Felser C., Anomalous Hall effect in Weyl ...
2018
-
[22]
T., Feng W., Xiao D., Lynn J
Suzuki T., Chisnell R., Devarakonda A., Liu Y . T., Feng W., Xiao D., Lynn J. W. and Checkelsky J. G., Large anomalous Hall effect in a half - Heusler antiferromagnet, Nature Physics, 2016, 12(12): 1119
2016
-
[23]
Y ., Wu F., Wu Z
Guo C. Y ., Wu F., Wu Z. Z., Smidman M., Cao C., Bostwick A., Jozwiak C., Rotenberg E., Liu Y ., Steglich F. and Yuan H. Q., Evidence for Weyl fermions in a canonical heavy -fermion semimetal YbPtBi, Nature Communications, 2018, 9(1): 4622
2018
-
[24]
Pavlosiuk O., Kaczorowski D. and Wiśniewski P., Negative longitudinal magnetoresistance as a sign of a possible chiral magnetic anomaly in the half-Heusler antiferromagnet DyPdBi, Physical Review B, 2019, 99(12): 125142. 15
2019
-
[27]
and Furthmuller J., Efficient iterative schemes for ab initio total-energy calculations using a plane-wave basis set, Physical Review B, 1996, 54(16): 11169
Kresse G. and Furthmuller J., Efficient iterative schemes for ab initio total-energy calculations using a plane-wave basis set, Physical Review B, 1996, 54(16): 11169
1996
-
[28]
P., Burke K
Perdew J. P., Burke K. and Ernzerhof M., Generalized gradient approximation made simple, Physical Review Letters, 1997, 78(7): 3865
1997
-
[30]
and Yu D.-P., Giant negative magnetoresistance induced by the chiral anomaly in individual Cd3As2 nanowires, Nature Communications, 2015, 6(1): 10137
Li C.-Z., Wang L.-X., Liu H., Wang J., Liao Z.-M. and Yu D.-P., Giant negative magnetoresistance induced by the chiral anomaly in individual Cd3As2 nanowires, Nature Communications, 2015, 6(1): 10137
2015
-
[31]
Y ., Nagata K
Ogasawara T., Huynh K.-K., Tahara T., Kida T., Hagiwara M., Arčon 16 D., Kimata M., Matsushita S. Y ., Nagata K. and Tanigaki K., Large negative magnetoresistance in the antiferromagnet BaMn 2Bi2, Physical Review B, 2021, 103(12): 125108
2021
-
[32]
and Luo J., Large negative magnetoresistance of a nearly Dirac material: Layered antimonide EuMnSb2, Physical Review B, 2017, 96(20): 205103
Yi C., Yang S., Yang M., Wang L., Matsushita Y ., Miao S., Jiao Y ., Cheng J., Li Y ., Yamaura K., Shi Y . and Luo J., Large negative magnetoresistance of a nearly Dirac material: Layered antimonide EuMnSb2, Physical Review B, 2017, 96(20): 205103
2017
-
[33]
and Yan B., Magnetically induced, Nature Materials, 2016, 15(11): 1149
Felser C. and Yan B., Magnetically induced, Nature Materials, 2016, 15(11): 1149
2016
-
[34]
Cano J., Bradlyn B., Wang Z., Hirschberger M., Ong N. P. and Bernevig B. A., Chiral anomaly factory: Creating Weyl fermions with a magnetic field, Physical Review B, 2017, 95(16): 161306
2017
Reviewed August 12, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.
Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.