REVIEW 4 major objections 7 minor 53 references
Tightly-confined and long Z-cut lithium niobate waveguide with ultralow-loss
T0 review · 4 major / 7 minor · reviewed 2026-08-09 · deepseek-v4-flash
Pith's one-line read Z-cut lithium niobate waveguides hit 5.8 dB/m loss and host the first octave-spanning all-normal-dispersion supercontinuum in an integrated LN waveguide.
desk verdict Genuine fabrication advance with a record loss figure and the first ANDi octave-spanning supercontinuum in integrated LN, but the loss is not mode-selective and the coherence is inferred rather than measured. read the letter →
The pith
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
The reading
What carries the argument
The load-bearing object is a fully etched strip waveguide in a 600 nm Z-cut lithium-niobate-on-insulator film, operated in the quasi-TE mode so that bent sections do not convert TE into TM energy. The fabrication combines a thin adhesion layer, negative-tone electron-beam lithography with multipass exposure for smooth sidewalls, and argon ion-beam etching with thermal management to reach a sidewall angle around 70 degrees. Long spirals are built from Archimedean units each contained in a single writing field, joined by S-bends whose curvature is a cubic polynomial of arc length, $\kappa(s)=a_0+a_1s+a_2s^2+a_3s^3$, which keeps mode coupling low. Loss is read out with optical frequency-domain reflectometry, and dispersion is engineered through the 2.7 $\mu$m by 0.6 $\mu$m cross-section so that the waveguide is all-normal-dispersion, which preserves coherence during supercontinuum generation.
What would settle it
Measure the output mode profile and polarization extinction of the 15 cm and 30 cm spirals: if a measurable TM component or a second transverse mode appears after propagation, the claim that Z-cut TE avoids birefringence-induced intermode coupling would be contradicted.
Extended reading notes
Core claim
The central claim is that choosing the Z-cut crystal orientation and operating in the quasi-TE mode eliminates the material-birefringence penalty that distorts modes in bent X-cut LN waveguides, so a fully etched strip waveguide can be both tightly confining and ultralow loss. On this platform, optical frequency-domain reflectometry yields 5.8 dB/m over a 15 cm spiral, and 207 pJ pulses produce a spectrum spanning more than an octave in a 30 cm all-normal-dispersion waveguide. The authors argue this makes the waveguide a practical building block for on-chip delay lines, narrow-linewidth lasers, parametric amplifiers, and $\chi^3$ nonlinear devices.
Load-bearing premise
The platform relies on the assumption that the quasi-TE mode stays single-mode and polarization-pure throughout the 15-30 cm spiral, yet the paper tests this only in a simulation of one bend rather than on a real long waveguide.
Editorial extensions
If this is right
- Decimeter-long ultralow-loss LN spirals become practical for on-chip delay lines and laser cavities, since a 15 cm path adds under 1 dB of propagation loss.
- Z-cut TE geometry removes the single-direction layout restriction caused by birefringence, so dispersion-engineered and phase-sensitive components can be arranged freely on a chip.
- An octave-spanning all-normal-dispersion supercontinuum in an integrated LN waveguide offers a path toward chip-scale self-referenced frequency combs without the coherence degradation seen in anomalous-dispersion supercontinuum.
- The same fabrication flow is expected to carry over to X-cut LN, preserving access to the largest electro-optic and second-order nonlinear coefficients.
Reading between the lines
- If the 5.8 dB/m loss persists at multi-decimeter lengths, Z-cut LN could compete with silicon nitride in delay-line and narrow-linewidth applications while adding strong quadratic and cubic nonlinearity; the paper does not quantify those trade-offs.
- A direct measurement of output mode purity and polarization extinction along the 30 cm waveguide would convert the single-bend simulation argument into an experimental guarantee that birefringence is fully avoided.
- The coherence of the octave-spanning spectrum is assumed from the all-normal-dispersion regime rather than measured; a pulse-to-pulse interferometric measurement would test that assumption directly.
Signed reviews
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The paper reports a fabrication process for fully etched Z-cut lithium niobate (LN) waveguides and claims a record-low propagation loss of 5.8 dB/m measured by optical frequency-domain reflectometry (OFDR) in a 15 cm spiral waveguide. It also demonstrates supercontinuum generation in a 30 cm, 2.7 µm-wide all-normal-dispersion (ANDi) waveguide, reaching an octave-spanning spectrum at ~207 pJ on-chip pump energy, and labels the supercontinuum as coherent. The central design idea is that Z-cut LN with TE polarization avoids the direction-dependent birefringence that causes intermode coupling in X-cut bent waveguides, supported by a finite-element simulation of a single bend (Fig. 1(b)). The paper includes detailed fabrication steps, loss measurements versus width and wavelength, and a dispersion simulation.
Significance. If the claims hold, this would be a notable advance for LN photonics: a decimeter-long, tightly confined waveguide with dB/m-level loss would benefit delay lines, narrow-linewidth lasers, and parametric devices, and an ANDi octave-spanning supercontinuum in an integrated LN waveguide would be a first. The fabrication methodology (multipass EBL, thermal management, single-writing-field spiral design) and the direct OFDR loss extraction are useful contributions. However, the current evidence is incomplete in a load-bearing way: the waveguides used for both headline results are explicitly multimode, yet no experimental characterization of mode or polarization purity along the long spirals is provided, and the supercontinuum coherence is inferred rather than measured. The significance is therefore conditional on additional verification.
major comments (4)
- [Section 3, Fig. 1(b), Fig. 3(a)]
- [Section 3, Fig. 3(a)–(d)]
- [Section 4, Fig. 4(c)]
- [Section 4, experimental setup]
minor comments (7)
- [Abstract/Introduction]
- [Section 4]
- [Funding]
- [Section 3, Fig. 3(c),(d)]
- [Section 3, Fig. 3(a)]
- [References]
- [Section 2]
Circularity Check
No circular reduction: loss and supercontinuum are direct measurements, not fitted predictions.
full rationale
The paper's central quantitative results are obtained by direct measurement rather than by deriving a prediction from an input that already contains the answer. The 5.8 dB/m propagation loss is extracted by optical frequency-domain reflectometry as a linear fit to backscattered power versus length along a 15-cm spiral waveguide; this is a measurement of Rayleigh backscattering, not a prediction from a fitted model whose parameters are equivalent to the loss. The octave-spanning supercontinuum is a measured output spectrum at increasing pump energies, and the all-normal-dispersion interpretation is supported by an independent finite-element simulation of the waveguide dispersion and by published ANDi coherence theory. The coherence references include prior work by some of the same authors in Si3N4 waveguides, but that cited work is a separate published experimental result, not an unverified premise or a theorem that already asserts the present conclusion; it is used as external support for the expected coherence properties of ANDi supercontinuum. The paper also explicitly acknowledges that its low-loss waveguides are multimode at large widths, and the assumption of maintained TE00 polarization purity along the long spirals is not experimentally verified. That is a validity or robustness limitation, not a circularity: no equation in the paper defines the reported loss or bandwidth in terms of the claimed result, and no fitted parameter is renamed as a prediction. The derivation chain is therefore self-contained with respect to the stated measurements, and the remaining concerns are experimental verification gaps rather than circular reasoning.
Assumptions & free parameters
free parameters (1)
- Input coupling loss =
~10 dB (estimated)
assumptions (4)
- domain assumption OFDR based on Rayleigh scattering provides an accurate measure of distributed propagation loss.
- domain assumption All-normal-dispersion (ANDi) supercontinuum maintains coherence over long propagation lengths and high pulse energies.
- domain assumption The Z-cut TE mode does not suffer from intermode crosstalk or polarization rotation in bent waveguides.
- domain assumption The design parameters (width, height, bending radius) used in FEM simulation model the fabricated device accurately.
Cite this review
Pith. "Pith review of Tightly-confined and long Z-cut lithium niobate waveguide with ultralow-loss." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/OKIRXULH
@misc{pith2026250118341,
author = {Pith},
title = {Pith review of: Tightly-confined and long Z-cut lithium niobate waveguide with ultralow-loss},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/OKIRXULH}},
note = {Machine review of arXiv:2501.18341}
}
abstract
Lithium niobate (LN) is a promising material for future complex photonic-electronic circuits, with wide applications in fields like data communications, sensing, optical computation, and quantum optics. There was a great step toward LN photonic integrated circuits (PICs) with the development of dry etching for low-loss LN on insulator (LNOI) waveguides. However, the versatility of the LN waveguide platform for applications like $\chi^3$ nonlinear devices and passive phase sensitive components, has not been fully utilized. The main challenges are the difficulty of making highly confined ultralow-loss waveguides and overcoming the strong material birefringence. Here, we developed a fabrication technology for an ultralow-loss, tightly-confined, dispersion-engineered LN waveguide. We demonstrated an ultra-low propagation loss of 5.8 dB/m in a decimeter-long LN spiral waveguide. We focused on Z-cut LN waveguides with TE mode to avoid the material birefringence. Aiming for $\chi^3$ nonlinear applications, we demonstrated the first all normal-dispersion (ANDi) based coherent octave-spanning supercontinuum frequency comb in integrated LN waveguide. Our ultralow-loss Z-cut LN long waveguide might be useful in on-chip narrow linewidth lasers, optical delay lines, and parametric amplifiers.
Figures
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
Introduction Photonic integrated circuits [1] (PICs) enable on-chip light generation, manipulation, and detection. Via in- tegration and miniturization, PICs shows great potential for realizing low-cost and scalable optical systems in fields like data communication, bio-chemical sensing, and op- tical computation. In recent decades, different material pla...
-
[2]
Tightly-confined and long Z-cut lithium niobate waveguide with ultralow-loss
Z-cut LN long waveguide platform LN is a well-known anisotropic material, in which the nonlinear and EO coefficients vary largely in different di- rections. To take advantage of the largest EO (r 33 ) or second order nonlinear coefficient (d 33 ), most work has focused on the TE polarization in X-cut LN waveguides. However, the strong birefringence limits...
work page Pith review arXiv 2025
-
[3]
Losses characterization We fabricated long spiral waveguides to characterize the propagation losses. Fig. 2(c) shows a microscope image for a fabricated spiral waveguide. The spiral shape reduces the footprint for the entire de- vice. We minimize stiching errors (and thus extra losses), by intentionally fitting each spiral unit into a single writ- ing fil...
work page 2000
-
[4]
The device used for the experiment includes 6 cascaded spiral units with around 5 cm length for each
Nonlinear applications based onχ3 We study supercontinuum generation in an all-normal dispersion LN waveguide with geometry of 2.7 × 0.6 µm2 and length of 30 cm. The device used for the experiment includes 6 cascaded spiral units with around 5 cm length for each. The measurement setup is shown in Fig 4. (a). A 50 femtosecond mode lock laser (MLL) with a c...
-
[5]
Conclusion In conclusion, a LN waveguide fabrication technology has been developed to realize a fully-etched strip LN waveguide with advantages for simultaneously achiev- ing ultra-low propagation losses, strong light confinement and dispersion engineering. We focused on Z-cut LN to avoid the material anisotropy, but the fabrication tech- nology is not li...
work page 2017
- [6]
-
[7]
B. Jalali and S. Fathpour, Silicon photonics, J. Light. Technol. 24, 4600 (2006)
work page 2006
-
[8]
M. Smit, K. Williams, and J. Van Der Tol, Past, present, and future of inp-based photonic integration, Apl Pho- tonics 4 (2019)
work page 2019
Show all 53 references
-
[9]
Y. Xuan, Y. Liu, L. T. Varghese, A. J. Metcalf, X. Xue, P.-H. Wang, K. Han, J. A. Jaramillo-Villegas, A. Al No- man, C. Wang, et al., High-q silicon nitride microres- onators exhibiting low-power frequency comb initiation, Optica 3, 1171 (2016)
2016
-
[10]
X. Ji, F. A. Barbosa, S. P. Roberts, A. Dutt, J. Carde- nas, Y. Okawachi, A. Bryant, A. L. Gaeta, and M. Lip- son, Ultra-low-loss on-chip resonators with sub-milliwatt parametric oscillation threshold, Optica 4, 619 (2017)
2017
-
[11]
J. Liu, A. S. Raja, M. Karpov, B. Ghadiani, M. H. Pfeiffer, B. Du, N. J. Engelsen, H. Guo, M. Zervas, and T. J. Kippenberg, Ultralow-power chip-based soliton mi- crocombs for photonic integration, Optica5, 1347 (2018)
2018
-
[12]
Z. Ye, K. Twayana, P. A. Andrekson, and V. Torres- Company, High-q si3n4 microresonators based on a sub- tractive processing for kerr nonlinear optics, Opt. Express 27, 35719 (2019)
2019
-
[13]
M. Pu, L. Ottaviano, E. Semenova, and K. Yvind, Effi- cient frequency comb generation in algaas-on-insulator, Optica 3, 823 (2016)
2016
-
[14]
Chang, W
L. Chang, W. Xie, H. Shu, Q.-F. Yang, B. Shen, A. Boes, J. D. Peters, W. Jin, C. Xiang, S. Liu, et al., Ultra- efficient frequency comb generation in algaas-on-insulator microresonators, Nat. Commun. 11, 1331 (2020)
2020
-
[15]
H. Jung, K. Y. Fong, C. Xiong, and H. X. Tang, Elec- trical tuning and switching of an optical frequency comb generated in aluminum nitride microring resonators, Opt. Lett. 39, 84 (2013)
2013
-
[16]
M. A. Guidry, K. Y. Yang, D. M. Lukin, A. Markosyan, J. Yang, M. M. Fejer, and J. Vuˇ ckovi´ c, Optical paramet- ric oscillation in silicon carbide nanophotonics, Optica 7, 1139 (2020)
2020
-
[17]
Zhang, C
M. Zhang, C. Wang, R. Cheng, A. Shams-Ansari, and M. Lonˇ car, Monolithic ultra-high-Q lithium niobate mi- croring resonator, Optica 4, 1536 (2017)
2017
-
[18]
He, Q.-F
Y. He, Q.-F. Yang, J. Ling, R. Luo, H. Liang, M. Li, B. Shen, H. Wang, K. J. Vahala, and Q. Lin, Self-starting bi-chromatic LiNbO3 soliton microcomb, Optica 6, 1138 (2019)
2019
-
[19]
Z. Gong, X. Liu, Y. Xu, M. Xu, J. B. Surya, J. Lu, A. Bruch, C. Zou, and H. X. Tang, Soliton microcomb generation at 2 µm in z-cut lithium niobate microring resonators, Opt. Lett. 44, 3182 (2019)
2019
-
[20]
Y. Gao, F. Lei, M. Girardi, Z. Ye, R. Van Laer, V. Torres- Company, and J. Schr¨ oder, Compact lithium niobate mi- croring resonators in the ultrahigh q/v regime, Opt. Lett. 6 48, 3949 (2023)
2023
-
[21]
D. Zhu, L. Shao, M. Yu, R. Cheng, B. Desiatov, C. Xin, Y. Hu, J. Holzgrafe, S. Ghosh, A. Shams- Ansari, E. Puma, N. Sinclair, C. Reimer, M. Zhang, and M. Lonˇ car, Integrated photonics on thin-film lithium nio- bate, Adv. Opt. Photonics 13, 242 (2021)
2021
-
[22]
Qi and Y
Y. Qi and Y. Li, Integrated lithium niobate photonics, Nanophotonics 9, 1287 (2020)
2020
-
[23]
Honardoost, K
A. Honardoost, K. Abdelsalam, and S. Fathpour, Reju- venating a versatile photonic material: thin-film lithium niobate, Laser Photonics Rev. 14, 2000088 (2020)
2020
-
[24]
Weis and T
R. Weis and T. Gaylord, Lithium niobate: Summary of physical properties and crystal structure, Appl. Phys. A 37, 191 (1985)
1985
-
[25]
C. Wang, M. Zhang, X. Chen, M. Bertrand, A. Shams- Ansari, S. Chandrasekhar, P. Winzer, and M. Lonˇ car, Integrated lithium niobate electro-optic modulators op- erating at CMOS-compatible voltages, Nature 562, 101 (2018)
2018
-
[26]
M. He, M. Xu, Y. Ren, J. Jian, Z. Ruan, Y. Xu, S. Gao, S. Sun, X. Wen, L. Zhou, L. Liu, C. Guo, H. Chen, S. Yu, L. Liu, and X. Cai, High-performance hybrid silicon and lithium niobate Mach–Zehnder modulators for 100 gbit s- 1 and beyond, Nat. Photonics 13, 359 (2019)
2019
-
[27]
Zhang, B
M. Zhang, B. Buscaino, C. Wang, A. Shams-Ansari, C. Reimer, R. Zhu, J. M. Kahn, and M. Lonˇ car, Broadband electro-optic frequency comb generation in a lithium niobate microring resonator, Nature 568, 373 (2019)
2019
-
[28]
J. Lu, J. B. Surya, X. Liu, A. W. Bruch, Z. Gong, Y. Xu, and H. X. Tang, Periodically poled thin-film lithium nio- bate microring resonators with a second-harmonic gener- ation efficiency of 250,000%/W, Optica 6, 1455 (2019)
2019
-
[29]
Chen, Z.-H
J.-Y. Chen, Z.-H. Ma, Y. M. Sua, Z. Li, C. Tang, and Y.-P. Huang, Ultra-efficient frequency conversion in quasi-phase-matched lithium niobate microrings, Optica 6, 1244 (2019)
2019
-
[30]
Nehra, R
R. Nehra, R. Sekine, L. Ledezma, Q. Guo, R. M. Gray, A. Roy, and A. Marandi, Few-cycle vacuum squeezing in nanophotonics, arXiv preprint arXiv:2201.06768 (2022)
2022 arXiv
-
[31]
J. Zhao, C. Ma, M. R¨ using, and S. Mookherjea, High quality entangled photon pair generation in periodically poled thin-film lithium niobate waveguides, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 163603 (2020)
2020
-
[32]
J. Lu, A. Al Sayem, Z. Gong, J. B. Surya, C.-L. Zou, and H. X. Tang, Ultralow-threshold thin-film lithium niobate optical parametric oscillator, Optica 8, 539 (2021)
2021
-
[33]
T. P. McKenna, H. S. Stokowski, V. Ansari, J. Mishra, M. Jankowski, C. J. Sarabalis, J. F. Herrmann, C. Lan- grock, M. M. Fejer, and A. H. Safavi-Naeini, Ultra-low- power second-order nonlinear optics on a chip, Nat. Com- mun. 13, 4532 (2022)
2022
-
[34]
Xiang, W
C. Xiang, W. Jin, J. Guo, J. D. Peters, M. Kennedy, J. Selvidge, P. A. Morton, and J. E. Bowers, Narrow- linewidth iii-v/si/si 3 n 4 laser using multilayer hetero- geneous integration, Optica 7, 20 (2020)
2020
-
[35]
H. Lee, T. Chen, J. Li, O. Painter, and K. J. Vahala, Ultra-low-loss optical delay line on a silicon chip, Nat. Commun. 3, 867 (2012)
2012
-
[36]
S. Hong, L. Zhang, Y. Wang, M. Zhang, Y. Xie, and D. Dai, Ultralow-loss compact silicon photonic waveguide spirals and delay lines, Photonics Res. 10, 1 (2021)
2021
-
[37]
X. Ji, X. Yao, Y. Gan, A. Mohanty, M. A. Tadayon, C. P. Hendon, and M. Lipson, On-chip tunable photonic delay line, APL Photonics 4 (2019)
2019
-
[38]
Z. Ye, P. Zhao, K. Twayana, M. Karlsson, V. Torres- Company, and P. A. Andrekson, Overcoming the quan- tum limit of optical amplification in monolithic waveg- uides, Sci. Adv. 7, eabi8150 (2021)
2021
-
[39]
Kazama, T
T. Kazama, T. Umeki, S. Shimizu, T. Kashiwazaki, K. Enbutsu, R. Kasahara, Y. Miyamoto, and K. Watan- abe, Over-30-db gain and 1-db noise figure phase- sensitive amplification using a pump-combiner-integrated fiber i/o ppln module, Opt. Express 29, 28824 (2021)
2021
-
[40]
J. F. Bauters, M. J. Heck, D. John, D. Dai, M.-C. Tien, J. S. Barton, A. Leinse, R. G. Heideman, D. J. Blumen- thal, and J. E. Bowers, Ultra-low-loss high-aspect-ratio si 3 n 4 waveguides, Optics express 19, 3163 (2011)
2011
-
[41]
J. Liu, G. Huang, R. N. Wang, J. He, A. S. Raja, T. Liu, N. J. Engelsen, and T. J. Kippenberg, High-yield, wafer- scale fabrication of ultralow-loss, dispersion-engineered silicon nitride photonic circuits, Nat. Commun. 12, 2236 (2021)
2021
-
[42]
B. Pan, Y. Tan, P. Chen, L. Liu, Y. Shi, and D. Dai, Compact racetrack resonator on linbo 3, J. Light. Tech- nol. 39, 1770 (2020)
2020
-
[43]
J. Yi, C. Guo, Z. Ruan, G. Chen, H. Wei, L. Lu, S. Gong, X. Pan, X. Shen, X. Guan, et al., Anisotropy-free ar- rayed waveguide gratings on x-cut thin film lithium nio- bate platform of in-plane anisotropy, Light Sci. Appl. 13, 147 (2024)
2024
-
[44]
T. Chen, H. Lee, J. Li, and K. J. Vahala, A general design algorithm for low optical loss adiabatic connections in waveguides, Opt. Express 20, 22819 (2012)
2012
-
[45]
Z. Ye, F. Lei, K. Twayana, M. Girardi, P. A. Andrekson, and V. Torres-Company, Integrated, ultra-compact high- q silicon nitride microresonators for low-repetition-rate soliton microcombs, Laser Photonics Rev. 16, 2100147 (2022)
2022
-
[46]
Liang, Q
C. Liang, Q. Bai, M. Yan, Y. Wang, H. Zhang, and B. Jin, A comprehensive study of optical frequency domain re- flectometry, IEEE Access 9, 41647 (2021)
2021
-
[47]
Finot, B
C. Finot, B. Kibler, L. Provost, and S. Wabnitz, Ben- eficial impact of wave-breaking for coherent continuum formation in normally dispersive nonlinear fibers, JOSA B 25, 1938 (2008)
2008
-
[48]
J. M. Dudley and S. Coen, Coherence properties of su- percontinuum spectra generated in photonic crystal and tapered optical fibers, Opt. Lett. 27, 1180 (2002)
2002
-
[49]
Rebolledo-Salgado, Z
I. Rebolledo-Salgado, Z. Ye, S. Christensen, F. Lei, K. Twayana, J. Schr¨ oder, M. Zelan, and V. Torres- Company, Coherent supercontinuum generation in all- normal dispersion si3n4 waveguides, Opt. Express 30, 8641 (2022)
2022
-
[50]
T. J. Seok, K. Kwon, J. Henriksson, J. Luo, and M. C. Wu, Wafer-scale silicon photonic switches beyond die size limit, Optica 6, 490 (2019)
2019
-
[51]
Zhang, K
X. Zhang, K. Kwon, J. Henriksson, J. Luo, and M. C. Wu, A large-scale microelectromechanical-systems-based silicon photonics LiDAR, Nature 603, 253 (2022)
2022
-
[52]
Zhang, M
H. Zhang, M. Gu, X. Jiang, J. Thompson, H. Cai, S. Pae- sani, R. Santagati, A. Laing, Y. Zhang, M. Yung, et al., An optical neural chip for implementing complex-valued neural network, Nat. Commun. 12, 457 (2021)
2021
-
[53]
Y. Gao, Y. Sun, I. Rebolledo-Salgado, R. Van Laer, V. Torres-company, and S. Jochen, Data accompanying ’tightly-confined and long z-cut lithium niobate waveg- uide with ultralow-loss’ (2025)
2025
Reviewed August 9, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.
Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.