Pith. sign in

REVIEW 4 major objections 4 minor 14 references

Revisiting the bimodality of galactic habitability in IllustrisTNG

T0 review · 4 major / 4 minor · reviewed 2026-08-15 · deepseek-v4-flash

Challenge this review Re-run · record.json Download PDF Read on arXiv ↗ Review JSON

Pith's one-line read The Cloudlet bimodality of galactic habitability dissolves under IllustrisTNG filtering.

desk verdict A genuinely new filter set applied to a contested astrobiology claim, but the 'bimodality does not persist' conclusion is only as strong as the unvalidated first-appearance-as-formation-time assumption. read the letter →

arxiv 2505.11048 v1 pith:Z3S3F3NK submitted 2025-05-16 astro-ph.GA astro-ph.EP

Ana Mitrašinović , Branislav Vukotić , Teodora Žižak , Miroslav Micic , Milan M. Ćirković This is my paper · ORCID
classification astro-ph.GAastro-ph.EP
keywords galactichabitabilitymass-metallicityrelationmetal-richdwarfgalaxiesCloudletbimodalitytidalstrippingIllustrisTNGastrobiology
topics Dark Matter
open problems Dark Matter
verification ladder T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal

The pith

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The reading

This paper re-tests the claim that small, metal-rich, star-forming dwarf galaxies—the 'Cloudlet'—form a second peak in the galactic habitability distribution. Working with IllustrisTNG, the authors add the simulation's SubhaloFlag classifier and trace each candidate's formation history. The apparent second branch of the mass–metallicity relation mostly disappears: 461 of 616 candidates first appear only at $z=0$ and are treated as non-galaxy structures, leaving 97 genuine early-forming dwarfs. Because those 97 are compact, tidally stripped remnants with dense stellar environments, their high metallicity does not translate into a statistically significant habitable class. The earlier bimodality of galactic habitability therefore does not persist under more physical filtering.

What carries the argument

The load-bearing machinery is the SubhaloFlag classifier of IllustrisTNG together with a formation-history cut. SubhaloFlag marks as False any subhalo that formed as a satellite inside a host's virial radius with dark-matter fraction below 0.8, i.e. a non-cosmological object; the paper then records the snapshot in which each candidate first appears and keeps only subhaloes that formed early (redshift $z \geq 7.6$). DBSCAN clustering in the $\log(M_\star/M_\odot)$ versus $12+\log Z_\star$ plane isolates the metal-rich dwarf candidates, and the flag plus history filter transforms the apparent second branch into 461 late-appearing non-galaxy structures, 58 late or ambiguous systems, and 97 genuine dwarfs. This machinery is what converts the earlier bimodality claim into a statement about a rare population of compact, tidally stripped remnants.

What would settle it

Trace every one of the 616 Cloudlet candidates through the IllustrisTNG merger-tree or progenitor links across all snapshots, and count how many of the 461 'first appear at $z=0$' objects have continuous progenitor lines back to $z>0.1$; if most do, the claim that only 97 are genuine dwarfs collapses, while if they appear only by numerical fragmentation at the final snapshot, the claim is confirmed.

Watch

Extended reading notes

Core claim

The paper's central claim is that the bimodality of galactic habitability reported in earlier work on the original Illustris simulation does not hold up in IllustrisTNG. In the stellar mass–metallicity plane the Cloudlet is visible as a sparse branch above the main sequence, but the branch is dominated by subhaloes that first appear at $z=0$ and are flagged as non-cosmological by SubhaloFlag; the paper reads these as false negatives of the flag rather than genuine galaxies. After tracing formation histories, only 97 early-forming metal-rich dwarfs remain, and these are mostly compact, dark-matter-poor systems created by tidal stripping of more massive progenitors, with high close-encounter rates. The conclusion is that the Cloudlet is not a distinct secondary peak in the galactic habitability landscape but a sparse tail shaped by extreme evolutionary pathways, and that there is no robust evidence for a second habitability mode associated with metal-rich dwarf galaxies.

Load-bearing premise

The conclusion rests on treating the snapshot where a subhalo first appears as its true formation time, so that the 461 candidates first appearing at $z=0$ are dismissed as non-galaxies rather than as genuinely late-forming or re-identified systems.

Editorial extensions

If this is right

  • If the central claim is right, metal-rich dwarf galaxies contribute negligibly to cosmic habitability: only 97 early-forming candidates survive out of tens of thousands of subhaloes, so even optimistic planet-formation assumptions cannot make them a statistically important class.
  • The Cloudlet population is not simply noise; the 519 excluded structures are a mix of numerical artefacts and physical but non-galaxy systems such as tidal debris and kinematically distinct substructures, and they deserve their own habitability assessment.
  • The 97 genuine dwarfs are compact outliers on the mass–size relation with median dark-matter fraction $\sim 0.5$, consistent with tidal stripping, and their dense stellar environments imply high encounter rates that may destabilise planetary orbits, offsetting any metallicity advantage.
  • The apparent Cloudlet signal in the original Illustris simulation was mostly produced by objects that are not true galaxies, so future simulation-based habitability searches should apply galaxy classification filters before interpreting scaling-relation outliers.

Reading between the lines

Editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

  • A natural extension would be to trace the 461 candidates that first appear at $z=0$ back through merger trees at fine time resolution; if many have continuous progenitors before the final snapshot, the paper's dismissal would be weakened, whereas if they emerge only from numerical fragmentation the conclusion would be strengthened.
  • The paper's tidal-stripping interpretation predicts that genuine metal-rich dwarfs should be observable as ultra-compact, dark-matter-poor galaxies near massive hosts; comparing the simulated population with observed compact ellipticals and ultra-compact dwarfs would test whether such remnants are as rare as the simulation suggests.
  • If non-traditional structures such as tidal debris and dark-matter-deficient galaxies can be habitable, then the total 'life-bearing' volume of the universe may be dominated by these transient structures rather than by stable galaxies, reversing the usual prioritisation of massive spiral and elliptical hosts.
Share X Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit HN

Signed reviews

No signed human review yet.

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, and a circularity audit.

Referee Report

4 major / 4 minor

Summary. This paper revisits the 'Cloudlet' population of metal-rich dwarf galaxies identified in Illustris by Stojković et al. (2019), using the IllustrisTNG TNG100 simulation. The authors apply similar sample cuts, use the SubhaloFlag classification, perform DBSCAN clustering in the stellar mass–stellar metallicity plane to isolate 616 metal-rich dwarfs, and then use the earliest snapshot of each subhalo's appearance as a formation-time filter, leaving 97 'genuine' dwarfs and 519 structures of uncertain origin. They analyse basic properties of the 97 (compactness, mass histories, dark matter fraction, morphology, SFR) and argue that these systems are rare, tidally stripped, dynamically challenging remnants, concluding that the bimodality of galactic habitability reported earlier does not persist and that the Cloudlet is a sparse tail rather than a distinct peak.

Significance. If the conclusions are robust, the paper provides a useful cautionary re-evaluation of an earlier claimed population with astrobiological significance, showing that the apparent bimodality in galactic habitability depends on the inclusion of objects that are not conventional galaxies. The study makes appropriate use of the newer TNG simulation, uses public data, and is transparent about the limitations and uncertain nature of many of the selected objects. However, the central claim hinges on the treatment of first-appearance redshift as formation time, a step that is not validated in the manuscript, and on a hand-tuned clustering procedure. The paper is honest in listing possible physical interpretations for the excluded objects, which makes the strength of the final conclusion somewhat disproportionate to the evidence.

major comments (4)
  1. [3.2, Table 1] The central conclusion that the bimodality does not persist depends entirely on the classification of 461 of 616 metal-rich dwarfs as non-genuine because they 'first appeared' at z=0. The manuscript equates first appearance with formation time without validating this assumption. In IllustrisTNG, a subhalo can first appear at z=0 because of tidal stripping of a more massive system, because of dark-matter-deficient galaxy formation in high-velocity collisions, or because the object only becomes resolvable as a distinct structure at late times; the paper itself acknowledges these possibilities for the 519 excluded structures (Section 5). Since the quantitative size of the 'genuine' sample is the load-bearing input to the conclusion in Section 4.2, the authors need to provide evidence that the z=0 first-appearance objects are predominantly numerical artefacts (e.g., by comparing their properties with known artefact populations, checking their tidal coherence, or performing a resolution test). Without such validation, the claim that the Cloudlet is a sparse tail rather than a physical population is not established.
  2. [3.2, Figure 4] The DBSCAN parameters are hand-adjusted to the data (eps=0.1/min_samples=50 in the first pass and eps=0.2/min_samples=10 in the second), and no stability or sensitivity analysis is provided. The size and even the existence of the 616-object metal-rich cluster is a direct function of these choices. Please include a robustness check (e.g., a grid of eps/min_samples values or a bootstrap resampling of the data) to show that the isolated cluster and the subsequent conclusions do not critically depend on the specific tuning.
  3. [4.2] The statement that 'the bimodality of galactic habitability ... does not persist' is stronger than what the analysis supports. The paper shows that a subset of 97 objects with early first appearance are compact and rare, but the 519 unclassified structures are explicitly left as potentially physical (Section 5). Since the original Cloudlet claim was about a population in the mass–metallicity plane, many of which may be non-traditional but real structures, the conclusion should be qualified to 'no robust evidence for a second peak among conventional dwarf galaxies' unless the authors either classify the 519 objects or demonstrate that a large fraction of them are numerical artefacts. As written, the central claim conflates 'not galaxies in a traditional sense' with 'not a physical population.'
  4. [4.2 and 3.3] The habitability conclusion is presented as quantitative ('the rate of close encounters is too high', 'global contribution ... is negligible'), but the close-encounter rate Γ is not actually computed for the sample; the discussion in Section 3.3 gives the formula and qualitative reasoning only. Since the paper is explicitly revisiting a habitability claim, the authors should either calculate Γ or present the dynamical arguments as a qualitative plausibility statement. As is, the phrase 'does not persist' conflates statistical rarity with a demonstration of habitability disadvantage.
minor comments (4)
  1. [2.2] The sentence beginning 'However, previous work contains several methodological limitations' is a run-on; consider splitting it for clarity.
  2. [3.3, Figure 7] The colour bar label 'fG' is not defined in the caption; specify that it is the baryonic gas fraction and clarify how it is computed.
  3. [References] Several references (e.g., Vogelsberger et al. 2014, 2020; Nelson et al. 2015) contain an extra space in the name ('V ogelsberger', 'N elson'), likely a compilation artefact; please correct.
  4. [Abstract] Phrases such as 'thrilling area of exploration' and 'fascinating possibility' are not standard scientific register; consider tempering the language.

Circularity Check

1 steps flagged · score 2.0 of 10

Definitional formation-time filter partly drives the sparse-tail verdict; the central re-analysis is otherwise independent of prior self-authored work.

  1. self definitional [Section 3.2, Table 1; Section 4.2, 'Re-evaluating the Habitability of Metal-Rich Dwarfs']
    "Only 97 subhaloes have formed sufficiently early, at redshifts z≥7.6. We consider them genuine metal-rich dwarf galaxies and will explore their relevant basic properties in the following. ... Genuine dwarf galaxies, as they are conventionally understood and examined in the present study, constitute only a small fraction of the Cloudlet population. ... we find that the Cloudlet is not a distinct secondary peak in the galactic habitability landscape, but a sparse tail shaped by extreme evolutionary pathways."

    The analyzed 'genuine' sample is defined by the authors' formation-history criterion: subhaloes first appearing at z≥7.6 are deemed genuine, while the 461 subhaloes first appearing at z=0 are dismissed as false negatives of SubhaloFlag. The conclusion that the Cloudlet is a sparse tail is reached after this definition has removed the bulk of the Cloudlet population. The paper itself concedes that the excluded 519 structures 'could be genuine physical structures' (Section 5) and may include tidal debris or dark-matter-deficient galaxies (Section 4.3). No validation equating first appearance with true galaxy formation is provided, so the small size of the 'genuine' sample, and hence part of the 'no bimodality' verdict, is encoded in the filter rather than independently discovered.

full rationale

The paper's central test is conducted on the publicly available IllustrisTNG simulation, using the SubhaloFlag classifier defined by the TNG team and applied to an independently generated galaxy sample. The comparison with Stojković et al. (2019) is framed as a target to be challenged rather than as supporting evidence, so the self-citation (two of the present authors co-authored the earlier paper) is not load-bearing. The kernel-density comparison, DBSCAN clustering, and measured properties of the retained 97 dwarfs (compactness, dark-matter fractions, encounter rates) are independent of the earlier claim and provide substantive content. The only circular element is definitional: 'genuine dwarf galaxies' are defined by the formation-time criterion (first appearance at z≥7.6), so the statement that genuine dwarfs are rare and the Cloudlet is a sparse tail is partly a consequence of that definition. Because the authors transparently acknowledge that the excluded objects may be physical and that their origin is uncertain, this is a partial, low-severity circularity rather than a collapse of the derivation; the paper also supplies independent analysis that would survive the definitional concern.

Assumptions & free parameters 3 free parameters · 5 assumptions · 0 invented entities

The paper's conclusions rest on the IllustrisTNG simulation, the SubhaloFlag classifier, and a hand-set formation-time cutoff. The biggest item the reader pays for upstream is the assumption that first-appearance snapshot equals physical formation time; this single assumption discards 461 of 616 metal-rich candidates. DBSCAN parameters are also hand-tuned. No new physical entities are introduced.

free parameters (3)
  • DBSCAN eps and min_samples (first pass) = eps=0.1, min_samples=50
    Hand-selected to isolate the main sequence of the mass-metallicity relation; no theoretical derivation or sensitivity analysis is provided.
  • DBSCAN eps and min_samples (second pass) = eps=0.2, min_samples=10
    Adjusted to the outlier sub-sample to yield a metal-rich dwarf cluster; the choice partly determines which objects are labelled as Cloudlet.
  • Formation-time cutoff for 'genuine' dwarfs = z >= 7.6 (SnapNum 1-9)
    Only subhaloes first appearing at z>=7.6 are counted as genuine; this arbitrary threshold removes 461 of 616 metal-rich candidates and largely determines the final sample size of 97.
assumptions (5)
  • domain assumption SubhaloFlag=True reliably identifies cosmological galaxies
    The paper relies on the IllustrisTNG team's classifier to separate genuine galaxies from artifacts, and uses it to argue the Cloudlet is predominantly spurious (Section 2.1).
  • domain assumption First appearance in a simulation snapshot is a good proxy for physical formation time
    Used to define the 97 genuine dwarfs by requiring formation at z>=7.6; late first appearance is treated as false-negative flagging rather than real late assembly (Section 3.2).
  • domain assumption Stellar metallicity can stand in for gas-phase metallicity
    The paper switches from gas-phase MZR to stellar MZ*R, justified by a Pearson correlation of rho~0.95, and assumes this does not affect conclusions (Section 2).
  • domain assumption IllustrisTNG sub-grid physics and resolution are adequate for the population and history analysis at M*~1e7-1e9 Msun
    The entire analysis is simulation-based; the authors acknowledge limited particle resolution for these dwarfs but proceed with qualitative habitability statements.
  • domain assumption The habitability proxy Np (increases with metallicity, decreases with SFR) is a reasonable starting point for framing the bimodality debate
    The paper adopts the Dayal et al. (2015) indicator to frame the prior claim, even while arguing that such proxies are insufficient (Sections 2.2, 4.1).

how reviews work

0 comments
Cite this review

Pith. "Pith review of Revisiting the bimodality of galactic habitability in IllustrisTNG." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/Z3S3F3NK

@misc{pith2026250511048,
  author       = {Pith},
  title        = {Pith review of: Revisiting the bimodality of galactic habitability in IllustrisTNG},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/Z3S3F3NK}},
  note         = {Machine review of arXiv:2505.11048}
}
read the original abstract

The potential of galaxies to host habitable planets is central to astrobiology, tightly linked to galaxy-scale evolution and cosmological processes. Using IllustrisTNG, we revisit the proposed local peak in the mass-metallicity relation for small, metal-rich, star-forming galaxies (Cloudlet) as an indicator of enhanced galactic habitability. We refine the earlier analysis by applying updated filtering criteria to identify a more refined sample, further selecting objects based on their history. This process resulted in a confirmed sample of 97 dwarf galaxies, alongside 519 additional structures of uncertain origin, potentially comprising both numerical artefacts and unrecognised physical systems. Under these stricter conditions, the proposed bimodality in galactic habitability is strongly diminished. However, the astrobiological potential of metal-rich dwarfs, most of which are compact remnants of more massive galaxies that underwent tidal stripping, is a thrilling area of exploration. Although dense stellar environments are traditionally seen as inhospitable, recent studies highlight the role of dynamic environments in enhancing the distribution of biological material. Furthermore, the potential habitability of tidal structures formed in the aftermath of galactic interactions is a fascinating possibility. Our findings suggest that non-traditional structures support conditions favourable for life, opening up exciting new avenues for astrobiological research. This research underscores the need for a holistic approach to studying habitability that moves beyond planetary and stellar-focused frameworks to incorporate the broader galactic environment. Understanding the interactions between galaxies, their evolution, and the influence of their surroundings is essential to developing a more comprehensive model of how and where life might emerge and persist across the Universe.

Figures

Figures reproduced from arXiv: 2505.11048 by the authors.

Figure 1
Figure 1. Colour-coded number of subhaloes in the stellar metallicity - gas metallicity plane for the whole sample. The dashed black line represents the y = x line, while the red ellipse highlights the non-negligible sub-population that is expected to reside below the observationally constrained MZR. There is a distinct group of subhaloes with higher stellar metallicities and a range of lower, most likely sub-MZR, gas metalli… view at source ↗
Figure 2
Figure 2. for the whole sample (upper panel) and additionally filtered True subhaloes (lower panel). The Cloudlet population is discernible in the upper panel, albeit appearing differently than in the previous work (i.e. there is a distinct second prong above the main sequence, but there is no noticeable, more significant gap between the two at lower masses). The addi￾tional filter clearly shows that this population predomina… view at source ↗
Figure 3
Figure 3. shows the resulting probability density distribu￾tions. The total sample and sub-sample cases show a similar distribution in the bulk of the sample. At the same time, the high-metallicity segment is separated from the rest of the sam￾ple for log(M⋆/M⊙) > 8.5 and 12+log Z⋆ > 10. The separation is visible at the first contour level of 0.01 for the subhalo sub￾sample, while the whole sample indicates the separation eve… view at source ↗
Figures from the paper (4 more)
Figure 4
Figure 4. Figure 4: Results of the DBSCAN algorithm application in the stellar mass￾metallicity plane. Contours represent the main sequence, while the scatter points represent detected clusters, whose labels are indicated in the legend. subhalo counts per snapshot bin, are listed in [PIT…
Figure 5
Figure 5. Figure 5: Mass-size relation in the TNG100 simulation box, determined con￾sidering all the galaxies in the stellar mass range 7 ≤ log(M⋆/M⊙) ≤ 11. The expected boundaries of the relation are represented with black dashed lines, while early-formed metal-rich dwarf galaxies are ma…
Figure 7
Figure 7. Figure 7: Star-forming main sequence (Renzini and Peng 2015, black dashed line, where the dotted lines represent the boundaries ∆ = ±0.5), and the metal-rich dwarf galaxies in the stellar mass – star formation rate plane, colour-coded for the baryonic fraction of gas. The presen…
Figure 6
Figure 6. Figure 6: History of the total mass of metal-rich dwarf galaxies, where the x-axis represents the redshift when the galaxy reached its maximum total mass, and the y-axis represents present-day total mass as a percentage of the maximum total mass. Histogram counts are given for e…

Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

14 extracted references · 6 canonical work pages

  1. [2]

    00007 - 1

    https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/B978- 0- 12- 811940- 2 . 00007 - 1. https : / / www . sciencedirect . com / science / article / pii / B9780128119402000071. Kim, Jeonghwan H., Sebastien Peirani, Sungsoo Kim, Hong Bae Ann, Sung- Ho An, and Suk-Jin Y oon. 2014. Formation of Warped Disks by Galactic Flyby Encounters. I. Stellar Disks. ApJ 789, no. 1 (...

    arXiv

  2. [6]

    Mass Extinction And The Structure Of The Milky Way

    Mass Extinction and the Structure of the Milky Way. Serbian Astronomical Journal 187 (December): 43–52. https://doi.org/10.2298/ SAJ130819005F. arXiv: 1309.4838 [astro-ph.GA]. Fischer, Debra A., and Jeff Valenti. 2005. The Planet-Metallicity Correlation. ApJ 622, no. 2 (April): 1102–1117. https://doi.org/10.1086/428383. Forgan, Duncan, Pratika Dayal, Char...

    work page Pith review arXiv 2005

  3. [7]

    ApJ 804, no

    Galactic Angular Momentum in the Illustris Simulation: Feedback and the Hubble Sequence. ApJ 804, no. 2 (May): L40. https://doi.org/ 10.1088/2041-8205/804/2/L40. arXiv: 1503.01117 [astro-ph.GA]. Genel, Shy, Dylan Nelson, Annalisa Pillepich, V olker Springel, Rüdiger Pak- mor, Rainer Weinberger, Lars Hernquist, et al. 2018. The size evolution of star-formi...

    arXiv

  4. [200]

    Evolution of galaxy habitability

    https : / / doi . org / 10 . 1093 / mnras / stu1654. arXiv: 1405 . 3749 [astro-ph.CO]. Gobat, Raphael, and Sungwook E. Hong. 2016. Evolution of galaxy hab- itability. A&A 592 (August): A96. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004- 6361/201628834. arXiv: 1605.06627 [astro-ph.GA]. Gonzalez, Guillermo, Donald Brownlee, and Peter Ward. 2001. The Galactic Habitable Zone:...

    work page Pith review arXiv 2016

  5. [1209]

    arXiv: 2308.00305 [astro-ph.GA]

    https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stad2313. arXiv: 2308.00305 [astro-ph.GA]. Diemand, Jürg, Michael Kuhlen, and Piero Madau. 2007. Formation and Evolution of Galaxy Dark Matter Halos and Their Substructure. ApJ 667, no. 2 (October): 859–877. https://doi.org/10.1086/520573. arXiv: astro-ph/0703337 [astro-ph]. Djorgovski, S., and Marc Davis. 1987. Fundamental P...

    arXiv 2007

  6. [1547]

    org / 10

    https : / / doi . org / 10 . 1093 / mnras / stu1536. arXiv: 1405 . 2921 [astro-ph.CO]. V ogelsberger, Mark, Federico Marinacci, Paul Torrey, and Ewald Puchwein

    work page

  7. [2001]

    A new formation model for M32: A threshed early-type spiral?

    A New Formation Model for M32: A Threshed Early-Type Spiral Galaxy? ApJ 557, no. 1 (August): L39–L42. https://doi.org/10.1086/ 323075. arXiv: astro-ph/0107117 [astro-ph]. Buchhave, Lars A., and David W. Latham. 2015. The Metallicities of Stars with and without Transiting Planets. ApJ 808, no. 2 (August): 187. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/808/2/187. a...

    work page Pith review arXiv 2015

  8. [2013]

    ApJ 765, no

    CANDELS: The Progenitors of Compact Quiescent Galaxies at z ~2. ApJ 765, no. 2 (March): 104. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004- 637X/765/2/104. arXiv: 1206.5000 [astro-ph.CO]. Bekki, K., W. J. Couch, M. J. Drinkwater, and Y. Shioya. 2003. Galaxy threshing and the origin of ultra-compact dwarf galaxies in the Fornax cluster. MNRAS 344, no. 2 (September): 399–41...

    arXiv

Show all 14 references
  1. [2015]

    The Number Density

    Quiescent Compact Galaxies at Intermediate Redshift in the COS- MOS Field. The Number Density. ApJ 806, no. 2 (June): 158. https: / / doi . org / 10 . 1088 / 0004 - 637X / 806 / 2 / 158. arXiv: 1501 . 04976 [astro-ph.GA]. Dayal, Pratika, Charles Cockell, Ken Rice, and Anupam M...

    2015 arXiv

  2. [2020]

    Nature Reviews Physics 2, no

    Cosmological simulations of galaxy formation. Nature Reviews Physics 2, no. 1 (January): 42–66. https://doi.org/10.1038/s42254-019- 0127-2. arXiv: 1909.07976 [astro-ph.GA]. Vukotic, B., J. Seckbach, and R. Gordon, eds. 2021. Planet formation and panspermia: new prospects for t...

    1909 arXiv

  3. [2022]

    Nature 605, no

    A trail of dark-matter-free galaxies from a bullet-dwarf collision. Nature 605, no. 7910 (May): 435–439. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586- 022-04665-6. arXiv: 2205.08552 [astro-ph.GA]. V ogelsberger, Mark, Shy Genel, V olker Springel, Paul Torrey, Debora Sijacki, Dandan Xu, Greg...

    arXiv

  4. [3524]

    arXiv: 1604.01664 [astro-ph.GA]

    https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stw829. arXiv: 1604.01664 [astro-ph.GA]. Vukotić, Branislav. 2018. N-body simulations and galactic habitability. In Habitability of the universe before earth, edited by Richard Gordon and Alexei A. Sharov, 173–197. Astrobiology Exploring Life on E...

    2018 arXiv

  5. [5279]

    Galactic Habitable Zone

    https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stad2176. arXiv: 2307.08911 [astro-ph.GA]. Lu, Cicero X., Kevin C. Schlaufman, and Sihao Cheng. 2020. An Increase in Small-planet Occurrence with Metallicity for Late-type Dwarf Stars in the Kepler Field and Its Implications for Planet Formation. ...

    2020 arXiv

  6. [9956]

    Ester, Martin, Hans-Peter Kriegel, Jörg Sander, and Xiaowei Xu

    https://doi.org/10.1109/TC.1976.1674577. Ester, Martin, Hans-Peter Kriegel, Jörg Sander, and Xiaowei Xu. 1996. A density-based algorithm for discovering clusters in large spatial databases with noise. In Knowledge discovery and data mining. https://api.semanticsc holar.org/Cor...

    1976

Pith tools

Reviewed August 15, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.