Typed states for the displayed outbound observations.
Source: paper_references, paper_reference_links, observed 2026-05-22T09:28:00.343907Z
Paper Citation Record · LEDGER
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms
As of 12 July 2026, this Paper Citation Record lists 28 of 28 outbound references and 0 inbound Pith citation observations for arXiv:2605.17534.
A citation records a reference. It does not transfer a finding from one paper to another.
Coverage vector
One-hop event checks from named stored sources.
Source: scholarly_work_events, retraction_status_cache, observed 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00
Pith citing papers itemized under the disclosed page cap.
Source: paper_references, paper_reference_links
A source-named dated measurement, never combined with another source.
Source: cited_works
Reference resolution
28 of 28 outbound references displayed
- verified exact19
- verified fuzzy8
- unresolved0
- parse uncertain0
- malformed identifier0
- metadata mismatch1
External citation measurements
No source-named external measurement is stored.
Outbound references
Observation 33b652a9-2f04-4e8f-97b5-2741dc3b9c0e · outbound
This paper cites retracted.
Reference 1
- Resolution
- verified fuzzy
- raw_fallback, observed 2026-05-22T10:46:26.817704Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation 2963e368-0d53-407e-bd65-1e4530bb1f8b · outbound
This paper cites upright man.
Reference 2
- Resolution
- verified fuzzy
- raw_fallback, observed 2026-05-22T10:46:26.811474Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation 068f61db-a1b3-42b4-afd1-670dac2d5336 · outbound
This paper cites an unresolved cited work.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms Unresolved cited work
Reference 4
- Resolution
- verified fuzzy
- raw_fallback, observed 2026-05-22T10:46:26.821154Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation 9f0e9da6-eb4b-4799-8ed1-46c150a04bfc · outbound
This paper cites retraction.
Reference 5
- Resolution
- verified fuzzy
- raw_fallback, observed 2026-05-22T10:46:26.804199Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation 981060f7-f0d5-4344-8c2c-fc3cf6f6301d · outbound
This paper cites copyright.
Reference 6
- Resolution
- verified fuzzy
- raw_fallback, observed 2026-05-22T10:46:26.800743Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation d11fbe71-d656-4f9f-99ba-66407bc59ab5 · outbound
This paper cites Self-Plagiarism in Academic Publishing: The Anatomy of a Misnomer.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms Self-Plagiarism in Academic Publishing: The Anatomy of a Misnomer
Reference 7
- Resolution
- verified exact
- doi, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.328539Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation 43655318-ca40-40ce-95a6-0d0886eb45b9 · outbound
This paper cites https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00367432 Barbour, B., and B.M.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00367432 Barbour, B., and B.M
Reference 8
- Resolution
- verified exact
- doi, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.345340Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation c8b40566-803f-43d1-8e56-ef5e38ab98ad · outbound
This paper cites PubPeer: Scientific Assessment without Metrics.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms PubPeer: Scientific Assessment without Metrics
Reference 9
- Resolution
- verified exact
- doi, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.309094Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation fded6a9f-a58e-4e73-8d7d-4e55ed43db46 · outbound
This paper cites Self‐plagiarism: An Odious Oxymoron.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms Self‐plagiarism: An Odious Oxymoron
Reference 10
- Resolution
- verified exact
- doi, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.362587Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation 3bc956f7-09da-431d-b83a-2b4d3d20422a · outbound
This paper cites General Relativity.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms General Relativity
Reference 11
- Resolution
- metadata mismatch
- arxiv_id, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.351432Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation db079030-43a4-4b33-bf7a-691788db11b2 · outbound
This paper cites UCL Press.
Reference 12
- Resolution
- verified exact
- doi, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.365585Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation 3bce0f08-f7e8-4c51-8a90-158b95dac097 · outbound
This paper cites Henri Poincare Saint Louis Lecture of 1904: Early Publication and International Dissemination.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms Henri Poincare Saint Louis Lecture of 1904: Early Publication and International Dissemination
Reference 13
- Resolution
- verified exact
- local_arxiv, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.337691Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation 2f3232ab-244e-4e88-85ea-380258a18b7c · outbound
This paper cites The Transformation of the Scientific Paper: From Knowledge to Accounting Unit.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms The Transformation of the Scientific Paper: From Knowledge to Accounting Unit
Reference 14
- Resolution
- verified exact
- doi, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.377871Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation 3e9ea2ea-d01f-4b11-93e8-a9c4665fd54d · outbound
This paper cites an unresolved cited work.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms Unresolved cited work
Reference 15
- Resolution
- verified exact
- doi, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.305031Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation 3f6de898-4f07-4155-939e-d5477b4e0efd · outbound
This paper cites The Extent and Causes of Academic Text Recycling or ‘Self-Plagiarism’.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms The Extent and Causes of Academic Text Recycling or ‘Self-Plagiarism’
Reference 16
- Resolution
- verified exact
- doi, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.381822Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation dbf5a6c2-2ad7-47e3-a144-7b325d79b1a7 · outbound
This paper cites (n.d.-b).
Reference 17
- Resolution
- verified fuzzy
- raw_fallback, observed 2026-05-22T10:46:26.814600Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation cb9c39ae-df4f-4985-a9d7-055de0827f39 · outbound
This paper cites an unresolved cited work.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms Unresolved cited work
Reference 18
- Resolution
- verified fuzzy
- raw_fallback, observed 2026-05-22T10:46:26.807978Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation c9c578b8-42bd-4be2-ac25-e33e4a67ae2f · outbound
This paper cites Physical Review: From the Periphery to the Center of Physics.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms Physical Review: From the Periphery to the Center of Physics
Reference 19
- Resolution
- verified exact
- doi, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.320509Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation 48743727-7491-4c9a-9044-2553dd8c1cd4 · outbound
This paper cites What’s in a Name? Scholarly Journal Title Changes and the Quest for International Visibility (1965-2020).
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms What’s in a Name? Scholarly Journal Title Changes and the Quest for International Visibility (1965-2020)
Reference 20
- Resolution
- verified exact
- doi, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.341581Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation 80de84cb-bf5f-4bf7-af5e-01c0436ea781 · outbound
This paper cites Die Naturwissenschaften: Zum fünfzigjährigen Bestehen der Zeitschrift.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms Die Naturwissenschaften: Zum fünfzigjährigen Bestehen der Zeitschrift
Reference 21
- Resolution
- verified exact
- doi, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.316596Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation 57b8ff2e-536c-479d-a278-f4ae85a8c301 · outbound
This paper cites The Oligopoly of Academic Publishers in the Digital Era.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms The Oligopoly of Academic Publishers in the Digital Era
Reference 22
- Resolution
- verified exact
- doi, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.332490Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation c7ecbdcd-64e3-422e-b598-68eb4a1f84f4 · outbound
This paper cites Naturwissenschaft und reale Außenwelt.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms Naturwissenschaft und reale Außenwelt
Reference 23
- Resolution
- verified exact
- doi, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.312735Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation 534fb697-51df-4960-b5c9-691bcc361ab3 · outbound
This paper cites Naturwissenschaft und reale Außenwelt.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms Naturwissenschaft und reale Außenwelt
Reference 24
- Resolution
- verified exact
- doi, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.355583Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
retraction . Source: retraction watch record 18531, observed 2026-07-08T21:54:32.552762+00:00. This notice travels one citation hop only.
Observation 80a29aaa-9711-4433-bc14-c7c152a7ca60 · outbound
This paper cites Sinn und Grenzen der exakten Wissenschaft.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms Sinn und Grenzen der exakten Wissenschaft
Reference 25
- Resolution
- verified exact
- doi, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.369383Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation 923a1de8-383b-4837-9275-d24f75d0c707 · outbound
This paper cites Research Misconduct and Its Federal Regulation: The Origin of the Office of Research Integrity.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms Research Misconduct and Its Federal Regulation: The Origin of the Office of Research Integrity
Reference 26
- Resolution
- verified exact
- arxiv_id, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.374501Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation 3d68fb72-c46f-4f02-962b-056cd482f037 · outbound
This paper cites Sinn und Grenzen der exakten Wissenschaft.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms Sinn und Grenzen der exakten Wissenschaft
Reference 27
- Resolution
- verified fuzzy
- raw_fallback, observed 2026-05-22T10:46:26.824154Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation 6bb7b01f-83ab-457b-932d-d11048238ed3 · outbound
This paper cites Adolf Naef (1883-1949): On Foundational Concepts and Principles of Systematic Morphology.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms Adolf Naef (1883-1949): On Foundational Concepts and Principles of Systematic Morphology
Reference 28
- Resolution
- verified exact
- doi, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.324279Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Observation b38e605f-582a-44cd-be34-2c2cf8025872 · outbound
This paper cites Dr Arnold Berliner (1862-1942), Physicist and Founding Editor of Naturwissenschaften.
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms Dr Arnold Berliner (1862-1942), Physicist and Founding Editor of Naturwissenschaften
Reference 29
- Resolution
- verified exact
- doi, observed 2026-05-22T09:31:22.359085Z
Source-reported events for the cited work
No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-07-12T06:30:05.999651+00:00.
Pith citing papers
No inbound Pith citation observations are available.