Counted as completed checks in the claim sentence numerator.
Paper Integrity Record · LEDGER
The Curious Case of Max Planck retracted papers. When past scientific practices meet contemporary publishing norms
As of 1 June 2026, Pith completed 8 of 9 listed checks against arXiv:2605.17534. The completed checks produced 1 public finding within their stated scope. 1 check was skipped and produced no result.
This is a record of named checks, not a clean-status claim or a paper verdict.
Coverage vector
Skipped checks produced no result and say nothing about absence.
Listed checks
ai_meta_artifact
completedv1.0.0, observed 2026-06-01 23:43:57.676522+00:00
- Scope
- Paper body text scanned for literal AI-assistant artifacts.
- Completed surface
- Checked 1 reference.
doi_title_agreement
completedv1.0.0, observed 2026-05-26 00:32:51.521090+00:00
- Scope
- Cited titles compared with titles resolved from their DOI or arXiv identifier.
- Completed surface
- Checked 19 references.
doi_compliance
completedv1.0.0, observed 2026-05-25 02:12:36.511596+00:00
- Scope
- DOI and arXiv identifiers listed in the bibliography checked against named registries.
- Completed surface
- Checked 20 references.
claim_evidence
completedv1.0.0, observed 2026-05-24 23:03:37.037492+00:00
- Scope
- Recorded paper claims checked for the evidence artifacts they name.
- Completed surface
- Completed within the stated scope.
cited_work_retraction
completedv1.0.0, observed 2026-05-23 10:22:54.784088+00:00
- Scope
- Cited references checked for source-reported retractions or expressions of concern.
- Completed surface
- Checked 20 references. Recorded 1 finding from this run.
doi_compliance
completedv1.0.0, observed 2026-05-21 22:35:48.685183+00:00
- Scope
- DOI and arXiv identifiers listed in the bibliography checked against named registries.
- Completed surface
- Checked 15 references.
doi_title_agreement
completedv1.0.0, observed 2026-05-21 22:31:46.192241+00:00
- Scope
- Cited titles compared with titles resolved from their DOI or arXiv identifier.
- Completed surface
- Checked 15 references.
claim_evidence
completedv1.0.0, observed 2026-05-21 21:42:35.772807+00:00
- Scope
- Recorded paper claims checked for the evidence artifacts they name.
- Completed surface
- Completed within the stated scope.
ai_meta_artifact
skippedv1.0.0, observed 2026-05-19 21:33:23.617267+00:00
- Scope
- Paper body text scanned for literal AI-assistant artifacts.
- Reason
- Paper body text was unavailable.
Observations
Methods and limits
Each listed check names the surface it examined. A skipped, failed, partial, unavailable, not collected, not requested, or withheld check says nothing about what a completed check would have returned.
- Only checks with status completed enter the claim sentence numerator.
- Findings appear only from completed checks and only within the scope printed for that check.
- Severity labels describe one observation row. They do not roll up into a paper judgment.