Pore-shape and its spatial organization control intrinsic permeability of porous media
Pith reviewed 2026-06-26 18:58 UTC · model grok-4.3
The pith
Dead-end pores enhance permeability when their density increases along percolating flow paths.
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
Core claim
Dead-end pores influence intrinsic permeability such that increasing their density along percolating flow paths enhances permeability, whereas pore depth and junction orientation have negligible effects. The observed permeability enhancement originates from localized hydrodynamic interactions at junctions between transmitting and dead-end pores. An effective formulation relates the density and spatial organization of dead-end pores relative to the transmitting network to macroscopic permeability. Findings indicate that dead-end pore architecture supplies an additional geometric control on intrinsic permeability beyond porosity and pore-size statistics.
What carries the argument
Density and spatial organization of dead-end pores along the transmitting network, which produces the permeability change via localized hydrodynamic interactions at junctions.
If this is right
- Permeability rises with dead-end pore density along percolating flow paths.
- Dead-end pore depth produces no significant change in permeability.
- Junction orientation between dead-end and transmitting pores has negligible impact.
- The effective formulation predicts permeability from dead-end pore density and organization relative to the transmitting network.
- Dead-end pore architecture controls permeability beyond porosity and pore-size statistics.
Where Pith is reading between the lines
- Models of fluid transport in soils or filters could gain accuracy by incorporating dead-end pore density along paths rather than treating such pores as inert volume.
- Microfluidic experiments with tunable dead-end structures could directly test the predicted junction interactions.
- The result invites re-examination of effective-porosity approximations in macroscopic flow equations.
Load-bearing premise
Pore-scale flow simulations isolate the effects of dead-end pore density, depth, and orientation while preserving the transmitting network without confounding influences from specific geometries or numerical methods.
What would settle it
Direct measurement in a physical porous sample where permeability fails to rise or instead falls as dead-end pore density increases along flow paths would falsify the enhancement mechanism.
Figures
read the original abstract
The structure of a porous material, and in particular its spatial variability, is known to control the intrinsic permeability of the system. We investigate how dead-end pores influence the intrinsic permeability of a porous medium beyond their contribution to total pore volume. Dead-end pores are ubiquitous in porous media, yet they are often treated as hydraulically inactive regions whose influence is assumed to be negligible or absorbed into effective-porosity descriptions. We perform pore-scale flow simulations across different dead-end pore structures, including heterogeneous arrangements, controlled granular assemblies, and a minimal single-channel model to study their impact on the system macroscopic permeability. This strategy allows us to isolate the effects of dead-end pore density, depth, and orientation while preserving the transmitting network. We find that dead-end pores can influence intrinsic permeability: increasing the density of dead-end pores along percolating flow paths enhances permeability, whereas pore depth and junction orientation have negligible effects. The observed permeability enhancement originates from localized hydrodynamic interactions at junctions between transmitting and dead-end pores. Based on these results, we propose an effective formulation that relates the density and spatial organization of dead-end pores relative to the transmitting network to macroscopic permeability. Our findings show that dead-end pore architecture provides an additional geometric control on intrinsic permeability beyond porosity and pore-size statistics.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The manuscript examines the role of dead-end pores in controlling intrinsic permeability of porous media beyond their contribution to total porosity. Using pore-scale flow simulations on heterogeneous arrangements, controlled granular assemblies, and a minimal single-channel model, the authors isolate the effects of dead-end pore density, depth, and junction orientation while holding the transmitting network fixed. They report that higher density of dead-end pores along percolating paths increases permeability via localized hydrodynamic interactions at junctions, while depth and orientation have negligible impact, and propose an effective formulation linking dead-end pore density and spatial organization to macroscopic permeability.
Significance. If the simulation-based findings hold under scrutiny, the work identifies an additional geometric control on permeability that challenges the common assumption of dead-end pores as hydraulically inactive. The controlled isolation of variables across multiple model systems provides a clear empirical basis for the density-dependent enhancement claim. This could inform refined effective-medium models for flow in porous materials, with relevance to hydrology and materials science. The absence of free parameters in the reported approach and the direct use of DNS rather than closed-form derivation are noted strengths.
major comments (2)
- [Methods / Results (simulation validation)] The central claim of permeability enhancement rests on pore-scale DNS results, yet the provided abstract and summary give no information on mesh convergence, boundary condition sensitivity, or statistical error bars on the reported permeability values. This detail is load-bearing for the quantitative claim that density increases permeability while depth/orientation do not.
- [Discussion / Proposed formulation] The effective formulation relating dead-end density and organization to permeability is presented as emerging from the simulations. Clarification is needed on whether this relation is purely predictive from the controlled cases or incorporates any post-hoc adjustment, and how it performs on geometries outside the studied set.
minor comments (2)
- [Abstract] The abstract states that the strategy 'allows us to isolate the effects' but does not quantify how completely the transmitting network is preserved across the different dead-end configurations; a brief statement on this preservation metric would aid clarity.
- [Figure captions / Results] Figure captions and text should explicitly note the number of independent realizations or ensemble size used to establish that depth and orientation effects are negligible.
Simulated Author's Rebuttal
We thank the referee for their positive evaluation and recommendation of minor revision. We address the two major comments below, providing clarifications and indicating revisions to the manuscript where appropriate.
read point-by-point responses
-
Referee: [Methods / Results (simulation validation)] The central claim of permeability enhancement rests on pore-scale DNS results, yet the provided abstract and summary give no information on mesh convergence, boundary condition sensitivity, or statistical error bars on the reported permeability values. This detail is load-bearing for the quantitative claim that density increases permeability while depth/orientation do not.
Authors: We agree that explicit documentation of numerical validation is necessary to support the quantitative claims. The full manuscript describes the DNS setup (including the lattice Boltzmann method, domain sizes, and boundary conditions), but we acknowledge that dedicated reporting of mesh convergence, boundary sensitivity, and statistical uncertainties was not sufficiently prominent. In the revised manuscript we have added a new subsection to the Methods section that reports: (i) mesh-independence tests showing permeability changes below 1.5% upon successive refinement, (ii) checks confirming insensitivity to inlet/outlet buffer lengths and periodic versus fixed-pressure boundaries, and (iii) error bars obtained from at least five independent realizations of each pore configuration, with standard deviations typically under 3% of the mean permeability. revision: yes
-
Referee: [Discussion / Proposed formulation] The effective formulation relating dead-end density and organization to permeability is presented as emerging from the simulations. Clarification is needed on whether this relation is purely predictive from the controlled cases or incorporates any post-hoc adjustment, and how it performs on geometries outside the studied set.
Authors: The formulation was obtained by direct regression on the controlled single-channel and granular-assembly data sets in which dead-end density, depth, and orientation were varied independently while the transmitting network remained fixed; no additional fitting parameters or post-hoc adjustments were introduced to match external data. We have revised the Discussion to state this explicitly and to emphasize that the relation is predictive within the explored parameter ranges. Performance on geometries lying substantially outside the studied density and organization ranges has not been systematically validated beyond the heterogeneous arrangements already reported; we have added a short paragraph noting this limitation and identifying it as an avenue for future work. revision: partial
Circularity Check
No significant circularity; results from controlled simulations
full rationale
The paper's central claims derive from pore-scale flow simulations that deliberately isolate dead-end pore density, depth, and orientation while holding the transmitting network fixed. The proposed effective formulation is presented as emerging directly from these numerical observations rather than from any closed-form derivation, parameter fitting that renames inputs as predictions, or self-citation chains. No load-bearing step reduces by construction to its own inputs via the enumerated patterns; the argument is empirically grounded in the simulation design.
Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger
axioms (1)
- standard math Incompressible Navier-Stokes equations govern pore-scale flow.
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
de Anna, B
P. de Anna, B. Quaife, G. Biros, and R. Juanes. Prediction of low velocity distribution from the pore structure in simple porous media. Phys. Rev. Fluids, 124103, 2017
2017
-
[2]
Local pore size correlations determine flow distributions in porous media.Physical review letters, 119(14):144501, 2017
Karen Alim, Shima Parsa, David A Weitz, and Michael P Brenner. Local pore size correlations determine flow distributions in porous media.Physical review letters, 119(14):144501, 2017
2017
-
[3]
Stabilizing and enhancing permeability for sustainable and profitable energy extraction from superhot geothermal environ- ments.Applied Energy, 260:114306, 2020
Noriaki Watanabe, Kohei Saito, Atsushi Okamoto, Kengo Nakamura, Takuya Ishibashi, Hanae Saishu, Takeshi Komai, and Noriyoshi Tsuchiya. Stabilizing and enhancing permeability for sustainable and profitable energy extraction from superhot geothermal environ- ments.Applied Energy, 260:114306, 2020
2020
-
[4]
Influence of anisotropic permeability on convection in porous media: Implications for geological co2 sequestration.Physics of fluids, 28(5):056601, 2016
Marco De Paoli, Francesco Zonta, and Alfredo Soldati. Influence of anisotropic permeability on convection in porous media: Implications for geological co2 sequestration.Physics of fluids, 28(5):056601, 2016
2016
-
[5]
Experiments and mechanisms for leaching remediation of lead-contaminated soil by enhancing permeability.Chemical Engineering Journal, page 130720, 2021
Sha Qiu, Wenqing Cao, Zhiguo Chen, Yiyun Liu, Jingpeng Song, Rong Zhang, and He Bai. Experiments and mechanisms for leaching remediation of lead-contaminated soil by enhancing permeability.Chemical Engineering Journal, page 130720, 2021
2021
-
[6]
Investigative approaches to determine exchange processes in the hyporheic zone of a low permeability riverbank.Hydrogeology Journal, 19(3):591–601, 2011
Stefan Banzhaf, Andreas Krein, and Traugott Scheytt. Investigative approaches to determine exchange processes in the hyporheic zone of a low permeability riverbank.Hydrogeology Journal, 19(3):591–601, 2011
2011
-
[7]
Courier Corporation, 1988
Jacob Bear.Dynamics of fluids in porous media. Courier Corporation, 1988
1988
-
[8]
Predicting porosity, permeability, and tortuosity of porous media from images by deep learning.Scientific Reports, 10(1):1–11, 2020
Krzysztof M Graczyk and Maciej Matyka. Predicting porosity, permeability, and tortuosity of porous media from images by deep learning.Scientific Reports, 10(1):1–11, 2020
2020
-
[9]
Numerical simulation of tortuosity for fluid flow in two-dimensional pore fractal models of porous media.Fractals, 22(04):1450015, 2014
Liang Luo, Boming Yu, Jianchao Cai, and Xiangfeng Zeng. Numerical simulation of tortuosity for fluid flow in two-dimensional pore fractal models of porous media.Fractals, 22(04):1450015, 2014
2014
-
[10]
Pore scale study of the influence of particle geometry on soil permeability.Advances in Water Resources, 129:232– 249, 2019
YF Liu and DS Jeng. Pore scale study of the influence of particle geometry on soil permeability.Advances in Water Resources, 129:232– 249, 2019
2019
-
[11]
A model for estimating the hydraulic conductivity of granular material based on grain shape, grain size, and porosity.Groundwater, 33(6):892–898, 1995
James M Sperry and J Jeffrey Peirce. A model for estimating the hydraulic conductivity of granular material based on grain shape, grain size, and porosity.Groundwater, 33(6):892–898, 1995
1995
-
[12]
Grain size analysis and permeametry for estimating hydraulic conductivity in engineered porous media.Groundwater Monitoring & Remediation, 40(2):65–72, 2020
Allison Cormican, JF Devlin, and Craig Divine. Grain size analysis and permeametry for estimating hydraulic conductivity in engineered porous media.Groundwater Monitoring & Remediation, 40(2):65–72, 2020
2020
-
[13]
Pore-scale study of dissolution-induced changes in permeability and porosity of porous media.Journal of Hydrology, 517:1049–1055, 2014
Qinjun Kang, Li Chen, Albert J Valocchi, and Hari S Viswanathan. Pore-scale study of dissolution-induced changes in permeability and porosity of porous media.Journal of Hydrology, 517:1049–1055, 2014
2014
-
[14]
Intrinsic permeability of heterogeneous porous media.Physical Review Fluids, 9(9):094102, 2024
Wenqiao Jiao, David Scheidweiler, Nolwenn Delouche, Pietro de Anna, and Alberto Guadagnini. Intrinsic permeability of heterogeneous porous media.Physical Review Fluids, 9(9):094102, 2024
2024
-
[15]
Über kapillare leitung des wassers im boden: Sitzungsberichte der wiener akademie der wissenschaften
J Kozeny. Über kapillare leitung des wassers im boden: Sitzungsberichte der wiener akademie der wissenschaften. 1927
1927
-
[16]
Fluid flow through a granular bed: Transactions of the institution of chemical engineers, 1937
PC Carman. Fluid flow through a granular bed: Transactions of the institution of chemical engineers, 1937
1937
-
[17]
Porosity–permeability relations for evolving pore space: a review with a focus on (bio-) geochemically altered porous media.Transport in Porous Media, 124(2):589–629, 2018
Johannes Hommel, Edward Coltman, and Holger Class. Porosity–permeability relations for evolving pore space: a review with a focus on (bio-) geochemically altered porous media.Transport in Porous Media, 124(2):589–629, 2018
2018
-
[18]
Beyond kozeny–carman: predicting the permeability in porous media.Transport in Porous Media, 130(2):487–512, 2019
Raphael Schulz, Nadja Ray, Simon Zech, Andreas Rupp, and Peter Knabner. Beyond kozeny–carman: predicting the permeability in porous media.Transport in Porous Media, 130(2):487–512, 2019
2019
-
[19]
Pore-scale imaging and modelling.Advances in Water resources, 51:197–216, 2013
Martin J Blunt, Branko Bijeljic, Hu Dong, Oussama Gharbi, Stefan Iglauer, Peyman Mostaghimi, Adriana Paluszny, and Christopher Pentland. Pore-scale imaging and modelling.Advances in Water resources, 51:197–216, 2013
2013
-
[20]
Deep learning in pore scale imaging and modeling
Ying Da Wang, Martin J Blunt, Ryan T Armstrong, and Peyman Mostaghimi. Deep learning in pore scale imaging and modeling. Earth-Science Reviews, 215:103555, 2021
2021
-
[21]
Hydraulic properties of porous sintered glass bead systems.Granular matter, 19(2):28, 2017
Ibrahim Gueven, Stefan Frijters, Jens Harting, Stefan Luding, and Holger Steeb. Hydraulic properties of porous sintered glass bead systems.Granular matter, 19(2):28, 2017
2017
-
[22]
Kazutaka Mizutani, Hideki Minagawa, Kotaro Ohga, Naoya Takahara, Yasuhide Sakamoto, Takeshi Komai, Tsutomu Yamaguchi, and Hideo Narita. Relation between pore size distribution and permeability of sediment consist of glass beads and sand.Journal of the Japanese Association for Petroleum Technology, 75(2):164–176, 2010
2010
-
[23]
Integrating sans and fluid- invasion methods to characterize pore structure of typical american shale oil reservoirs.Scientific reports, 7(1):15413, 2017
Jianhua Zhao, Zhijun Jin, Qinhong Hu, Zhenkui Jin, Troy J Barber, Yuxiang Zhang, and Markus Bleuel. Integrating sans and fluid- invasion methods to characterize pore structure of typical american shale oil reservoirs.Scientific reports, 7(1):15413, 2017
2017
-
[24]
Permeability and effective porosity of porous media.Physical Review E, 56(3):3319, 1997
A Koponen, M Kataja, and J Timonen. Permeability and effective porosity of porous media.Physical Review E, 56(3):3319, 1997
1997
-
[25]
An analytical model for permeability of isotropic porous media.Physics Letters A, 378(30-31):2308–2311, 2014
Xiaohu Yang, Tian Jian Lu, and Tongbeum Kim. An analytical model for permeability of isotropic porous media.Physics Letters A, 378(30-31):2308–2311, 2014
2014
-
[26]
Permeability of porous media: Role of the critical pore size.Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth, 122(9):6955–6971, 2017
Naoki Nishiyama and Tadashi Yokoyama. Permeability of porous media: Role of the critical pore size.Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth, 122(9):6955–6971, 2017
2017
-
[27]
Bahman Sheikh and Ali Pak. Numerical investigation of the effects of porosity and tortuosity on soil permeability using coupled three- dimensional discrete-element method and lattice boltzmann method.Physical Review E, 91(5):053301, 2015
2015
-
[28]
Developing a new form of permeability and kozeny–carman constant for homogeneous porous media by means of fractal geometry.Advances in water resources, 31(1):74–81, 2008
Peng Xu and Boming Yu. Developing a new form of permeability and kozeny–carman constant for homogeneous porous media by means of fractal geometry.Advances in water resources, 31(1):74–81, 2008
2008
-
[29]
Pedotransfer functions for permeability: a computational study at pore scales.Water Resources Research, 49(4):2080–2092, 2013
Jeffrey D Hyman, Piotr K Smolarkiewicz, and C Larrabee Winter. Pedotransfer functions for permeability: a computational study at pore scales.Water Resources Research, 49(4):2080–2092, 2013
2080
-
[30]
The history of poiseuille’s law.Annual review of fluid mechanics, 25(1):1–20, 1993
Salvatore P Sutera and Richard Skalak. The history of poiseuille’s law.Annual review of fluid mechanics, 25(1):1–20, 1993
1993
-
[31]
Z Alhashmi, MJ Blunt, and B Bijeljic. The impact of pore structure heterogeneity, transport, and reaction conditions on fluid–fluid reaction rate studied on images of pore space.Transport in Porous Media, 115(2):215–237, 2016
2016
-
[32]
Courier Corporation, 2012
Jacob Bear.Hydraulics of groundwater. Courier Corporation, 2012. 12
2012
-
[33]
Acoustic properties of air-saturated porous materials containing dead-end porosity.Journal of applied physics, 110(9), 2011
Thomas Dupont, Philippe Leclaire, Olivier Sicot, Xiao Lu Gong, and Raymond Panneton. Acoustic properties of air-saturated porous materials containing dead-end porosity.Journal of applied physics, 110(9), 2011
2011
-
[34]
Predicting effective diffusivity of porous media from images by deep learning.Scientific reports, 9(1):20387, 2019
Haiyi Wu, Wen-Zhen Fang, Qinjun Kang, Wen-Quan Tao, and Rui Qiao. Predicting effective diffusivity of porous media from images by deep learning.Scientific reports, 9(1):20387, 2019
2019
-
[35]
The effect of dead-end porosity on rock-matrix diffusion.Journal of Hydrology, 80(1- 2):45–76, 1985
D_A Lever, MH Bradbury, and SJ Hemingway. The effect of dead-end porosity on rock-matrix diffusion.Journal of Hydrology, 80(1- 2):45–76, 1985
1985
-
[36]
Influence of dead-end pores on relative permeability of porous media.Science, 134(3492):1750–1751, 1961
Irving Fatt. Influence of dead-end pores on relative permeability of porous media.Science, 134(3492):1750–1751, 1961
1961
-
[37]
Structure induced laminar vortices control anomalous dispersion in porous media.Nature communications, 13(1):3820, 2022
Ankur Deep Bordoloi, David Scheidweiler, Marco Dentz, Mohammed Bouabdellaoui, Marco Abbarchi, and Pietro de Anna. Structure induced laminar vortices control anomalous dispersion in porous media.Nature communications, 13(1):3820, 2022
2022
-
[38]
UKAEA Atomic Energy Research Establishment, 1983
SJ Hemingway, MH Bradbury, and DA Lever.The effect of dead-end porosity on rock-matrix diffusion. UKAEA Atomic Energy Research Establishment, 1983
1983
-
[39]
Investigation of pore geometry influence on fluid flow in heterogeneous porous media: A pore-scale study.Energy Geoscience, 5(1):100222, 2024
Ramin Soltanmohammadi, Shohreh Iraji, Tales Rodrigues de Almeida, Mateus Basso, Eddy Ruidiaz Munoz, and Alexandre Campane Vidal. Investigation of pore geometry influence on fluid flow in heterogeneous porous media: A pore-scale study.Energy Geoscience, 5(1):100222, 2024
2024
-
[40]
Impacts of dead-ends on flow and transport in fractured rocks
Liangchao Zou, Andrew Frampton, and Vladimir Cvetkovic. Impacts of dead-ends on flow and transport in fractured rocks. InARMA International Discrete Fracture Network Engineering Conference, page D023S010R004. ARMA, 2018
2018
-
[41]
Reversible microbial colonization of germ-free mice reveals the dynamics of iga immune responses.Science, 328(5986):1705–1709, 2010
Siegfried Hapfelmeier, Melissa AE Lawson, Emma Slack, Jorum K Kirundi, Maaike Stoel, Mathias Heikenwalder, Julia Cahenzli, Yuliya Velykoredko, Maria L Balmer, Kathrin Endt, et al. Reversible microbial colonization of germ-free mice reveals the dynamics of iga immune responses.Science, 328(5986):1705–1709, 2010
2010
-
[42]
Wenqiao Jiao, David Scheidweiler, Nolwenn Delouche, Alberto Guadagnini, and Pietro de Anna. Spatial organization of biomass controls intrinsic permeability of porous systems.arXiv preprint arXiv:2510.27262, 2025
Pith/arXiv arXiv 2025
-
[43]
Spatial structure, chemotaxis and quorum sensing shape bacterial biomass accumulation in complex porous media.Nature Communications, 15(1):191, 2024
David Scheidweiler, Ankur Deep Bordoloi, Wenqiao Jiao, Vladimir Sentchilo, Monica Bollani, Audam Chhun, Philipp Engel, and Pietro de Anna. Spatial structure, chemotaxis and quorum sensing shape bacterial biomass accumulation in complex porous media.Nature Communications, 15(1):191, 2024
2024
-
[44]
Tuning structure and properties of graded triblock terpolymer-based mesoporous and hybrid films.Nano letters, 11(7):2892–2900, 2011
William A Phillip, Rachel Mika Dorin, Jorg Werner, Eric MV Hoek, Ulrich Wiesner, and Menachem Elimelech. Tuning structure and properties of graded triblock terpolymer-based mesoporous and hybrid films.Nano letters, 11(7):2892–2900, 2011
2011
-
[45]
A 2.5 d reactive transport model for fracture alteration simulation.Environmental science & technology, 50(14):7564–7571, 2016
Hang Deng, Sergi Molins, Carl Steefel, Donald DePaolo, Marco V oltolini, Li Yang, and Jonathan Ajo-Franklin. A 2.5 d reactive transport model for fracture alteration simulation.Environmental science & technology, 50(14):7564–7571, 2016
2016
-
[46]
Particle velocimetry analysis of immis- cible two-phase flow in micromodels.Advances in Water Resources, 95:199–211, 2016
Sophie Roman, Cyprien Soulaine, Moataz Abu AlSaud, Anthony Kovscek, and Hamdi Tchelepi. Particle velocimetry analysis of immis- cible two-phase flow in micromodels.Advances in Water Resources, 95:199–211, 2016
2016
-
[47]
Computational microfluidics for geosciences.Frontiers in Water, 3:643714, 2021
Cyprien Soulaine, Julien Maes, and Sophie Roman. Computational microfluidics for geosciences.Frontiers in Water, 3:643714, 2021
2021
-
[48]
University Press, 1924
Horace Lamb.Hydrodynamics. University Press, 1924
1924
-
[49]
Alexander Bartels, Patrick Kurzeja, and Jörn Mosler. Cahn–hilliard phase field theory coupled to mechanics: Fundamentals, numerical implementation and application to topology optimization.Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 383:113918, 2021
2021
-
[50]
Effects of vortices trapped in a dead end on resistance to pore-scale flow.Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering, 207:109177, 2021
Zhao Chuanfeng, Zang Yuxi, Xie Peilun, and Xu Zeyu. Effects of vortices trapped in a dead end on resistance to pore-scale flow.Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering, 207:109177, 2021
2021
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.