REVIEW 3 major objections 6 minor 1 cited by
Evolution of black hole echo modes and the causality dilemma
T0 review · 3 major / 6 minor · reviewed 2026-08-08 · deepseek-v4-flash
Pith's one-line read Echo modes take over the fundamental black hole ringdown mode.
desk verdict Solid analytic work on echo modes, but the universality claim overreaches—the continuous example shows only deformation, not a distinct branch takeover. read the letter →
The pith
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
The reading
What carries the argument
The central object is the Wronskian of the frequency-domain retarded Green's function, $m^{++}_1(\omega)m^{++}_2(\omega) + e^{2i\omega L}m^{-+}_1(\omega)m^{+-}_2(\omega) = 0$, equivalently written as $f(\omega) = -e^{2i\omega L}$ with $f = m^{++}_1 m^{++}_2/(m^{-+}_1 m^{+-}_2)$, where $m^{\pm\pm}_{1,2}$ are transmission and reflection coefficients of the two potential barriers. Equating real and imaginary parts gives the universal asymptotic spacing $\omega_R \simeq (n+1/2)\pi/L$ and $\omega_I \simeq -\ln f(\omega_R)/(2L)$, showing how the mode spacing and the damping decrease as $L$ grows. The second load-bearing object is the geometric-series expansion of the Green's function: the closed-form sum $S = a_1/(1-q)$ reproduces the full Wronskian roots including the echo modes, whereas any finite truncation $S_m = a_1(1-q^m)/(1-q)$ contains only the original poles. This resummation is what turns the echo modes from an artifact into a real spectral feature and resolves the causality puzzle.
What would settle it
Perform a high-accuracy numerical computation of the quasinormal spectrum for a realistic continuous black hole effective potential with a small, distant bump, and track the modes as the bump's position $L$ increases. If no separate echo-mode branch emerges with imaginary parts decreasing like $-\ln f(\omega_R)/(2L)$, and if no echo mode ever overtakes the fundamental mode, the claimed universality fails. Alternatively, in a measured ringdown's Fourier transform, look for the predicted transition: periodic peaks appearing at spacing $\pi/L$ as echoes become visible.
Extended reading notes
Core claim
The central claim is that the echo modes are not scattered overtones of the original black hole but a separate branch of quasinormal modes induced by the perturbative bump. Their frequencies satisfy the approximate relations $\omega_R \simeq (n + 1/2)\pi/L$ and $\omega_I \simeq -\ln f(\omega_R)/(2L)$, so both the real-axis spacing and the distance to the real axis shrink as the bump moves away (larger $L$). As $L$ grows, the low-lying modes spiral outward while the echo modes collectively rise toward the real axis; at a critical separation one echo mode acquires a smaller damping rate than the fundamental mode and takes it over, producing a jump in the real part of the fundamental frequency. The same takeover appears in the time domain as the transition from ringdown-dominated damping to periodic echo pulses. For the causality dilemma, the paper shows that the Green's function expanded as a geometric series has, in any finite truncation, only the original black hole poles; the echo poles appear only when the infinite sum is evaluated in closed form, $S = a_1/(1-q)$, which reproduces the full Wronskian. Echoes are therefore a collective phenomenon requiring the entire spectrum, and the early-time waveform is causally protected because the finite-sum terms contribute sequentially.
Load-bearing premise
The load-bearing premise is that the toy-potential results (disjoint square or delta barriers, and a continuous bell-shaped potential with a square bump) generalize unchanged to realistic continuous black hole effective potentials, an assumption the paper itself flags in Sec. V as potentially unsupported.
Editorial extensions
If this is right
- If the echo-mode branch exists, the apparent spectral instability of the fundamental mode is a takeover by an echo mode, so the instability and echoes are two faces of the same phenomenon.
- Fourier transforming a finite ringdown segment yields peaks at the real parts of echo modes; the spacing of these peaks encodes the distance $L$ to the perturbing structure, giving a direct observational handle on the location of the perturbation.
- Because any finite sum over bounces yields only the unperturbed poles, an observer who Fourier transforms only the early ringdown recovers the clean black hole fundamental mode; the spectrum inferred from a finite time window therefore appears to evolve as more of the waveform arrives, without any underlying time-dependence in the poles.
- The takeover point in $L$ marks a waveform transition from damped oscillations to periodic echoes; locating this transition in data can separate the ringdown phase from the echo phase in a principled way.
- Standard time-domain fitting methods are unreliable for these waveforms (extracted frequencies shift with the chosen time interval and sampling rate), whereas the Fourier transform approach used here identifies the echo modes; this favors Fourier-based analysis for echo searches.
Reading between the lines
- If the spacing $\pi/L$ can be measured from echo peaks, it directly measures the distance to the perturbing structure, turning echo spectroscopy into a probe of near-horizon geometry without needing a full waveform model.
- The resummation argument implies that spectral quantities extracted from finite time windows are inherently window-dependent, suggesting that the apparent "fundamental-mode instability" is partly an artifact of truncating the Green's series while the true spectrum contains the echo branch.
- The same infinite-sum logic should apply to other wave equations with a potential bump, such as electromagnetic or scalar perturbations in curved spacetime; a testable extension is to check whether the echo-mode takeover occurs identically for each spin.
- For gravitational-wave data analysis, the transition point at takeover may serve as a natural separator between ringdown and echo phases, potentially improving parameter estimation for compact-object waveforms.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The paper studies the response of black hole quasinormal-mode (QNM) spectra to a small, distant potential bump, focusing on the so-called echo modes that lie almost parallel to the real frequency axis. For disjoint toy potentials (double delta and double square barriers), the authors derive asymptotic formulas for the echo-mode frequencies, show that the modes move toward the real axis with decreasing spacing as the bump distance L grows, and demonstrate numerically that one echo mode eventually overtakes the spiral of the original fundamental mode. They then consider a Pöschl-Teller potential with a superimposed square bump, analyze the causality dilemma of Hui et al. through the partial-sum versus infinite-sum form of the geometric series Green's function, and extract echo-mode frequencies from time-domain waveforms by Fourier analysis. The central claims are that echo modes form a distinct spectral branch for disjoint potentials, that this branch universally takes over the fundamental mode, and that the infinite-sum resummation resolves the apparent conflict between causality and spectral instability.
Significance. If the universality claim were established, the paper would provide a useful unified picture connecting QNM spectral instability, echo generation, and the causal structure of the Green's function. The analytic asymptotic formulas for the double-delta and double-square-barrier models are derived carefully and are consistent with the reported numerical roots, and the Fourier extraction of echo modes from time-domain data is a valuable, checkable numerical demonstration. The weak point is the extrapolation from disjoint toy models to realistic black hole potentials: the only non-disjoint example exhibits qualitatively different behavior, and the paper itself cautions that its toy-model conclusions may not generalize. The paper's value is therefore real but conditional on a substantial clarification or revision of the universality claim.
major comments (3)
- [Sec. IV, Eq. (34) and Fig. 4; also Abstract and Sec. VI] The continuous-potential example behaves qualitatively differently from the disjoint cases. The text states for the Pöschl-Teller-plus-bump potential that "there is only one branch" and that the QNM spectrum "deforms" as L increases, rather than developing a distinct echo branch that overtakes the fundamental mode. In contrast, the abstract and Sec. VI claim that echo modes form a novel branch and universally take over the fundamental mode. Sec. V further cautions that "conclusions drawn from such toy models may not generalize straightforwardly." This internal tension means the central universality claim is not supported by the evidence presented. The authors should either qualify the claim to disjoint/idealized potentials or provide an additional continuous example, with numerical or analytic evidence, in which a distinct echo branch emerges and overtakes the fundamental mode.
- [Sec. IV, Eq. (34)] The potential in Eq. (34) is not actually continuous. The square bump introduces jump discontinuities at x = L - σ/2 and x = L + σ/2, since VPT(L-σ/2)+ε does not equal VPT(L+σ/2) and neither matches the adjacent VPT values. Thus the example does not bridge from disjoint toy potentials to genuinely continuous black hole effective potentials such as the Regge-Wheeler potential. The paper's claim to have generalized the results to "a black hole metric with a continuous effective potential" is therefore not demonstrated by this example.
- [Sec. V, Eq. (45)] The statement that "the poles associated with the echoes do not emerge unless we include an infinite number of terms in the sum" is mathematically imprecise. The exact Green's function is algebraically a1/(1-q), so the echo poles are already present in the exact expression; what is true is that the partial sums in Eq. (44) do not contain those poles, and the infinite series representation diverges at them, so the poles are recovered only by analytic continuation or resummation. Since this point is load-bearing for the claimed reconciliation with the causality picture of Hui et al., the wording should be corrected to avoid the impression that the exact frequency-domain Green's function lacks echo poles for any finite truncation.
minor comments (6)
- [Sec. II, Eq. (28)] The phrase "as e2iωRL = −eiϕ(ω)" appears to be a typographical error. The phase condition should involve e^{2iω_R L} = -e^{iφ(ω)} (or an equivalent statement), with the minus sign already accounted for by the n+1/2 shift. Please clarify the notation.
- [Sec. II, Eq. (31)] The notation f(ω_R) is ambiguous because f is complex-valued and the imaginary part is set to zero in this approximation. Please state explicitly that the modulus is evaluated at the leading-order real frequency.
- [Sec. IV, Eqs. (38)-(39)] The passage from Eq. (38) to Eq. (39) drops both the constant ln[2/(\tildeϵ|sin πβ|)] and the difference L-σ in the prefactor. If this is intended as the lowest order, it should be stated explicitly; otherwise the numerical comparison to Fig. 4 is not well-defined.
- [Sec. IV, Fig. 4] Figure 4 does not overlay the analytic prediction of Eq. (39) with the numerical roots. A quantitative comparison would make the claim that Eq. (39) describes the deformed branch much more convincing.
- [Sec. V, Fig. 6] The identification of echo-mode peaks in the Fourier profiles is made visually with gray lines. A quantitative extraction (e.g., a table of peak locations versus the predicted ω_R values from Eq. (39)) would strengthen the claim that echo modes can be read off from the waveform.
- [Abstract and Sec. VI] The abstract states that the derivations are generalized to "a black hole metric with a continuous effective potential," but the example in Eq. (34) is discontinuous, as noted in the major comments. Please adjust the wording to match the actual example.
Circularity Check
No significant circularity: the QNM and echo-mode derivations are self-contained, with self-citations serving as supporting background rather than load-bearing input.
full rationale
The central derivation chain is self-contained. The echo-mode spectrum is obtained by solving the Wronskian condition in Eq. (8), equivalently f(ω) = -e^{2iωL} in Eq. (9), and the asymptotic formulas in Eqs. (30)-(31) and (39) follow by expanding the modulus and phase of f(ω), not by fitting. The numerical results in Figs. 1, 2, and 4 are independent root-finding checks of the same Wronskian. The causality argument in Sec. V uses only the geometric-series identity S_m = a_1(1-q^m)/(1-q) and its infinite-sum limit; the statement that the infinite resummation recovers the Wronskian roots is a consistency identity rather than a circular import. The self-citations [19], [26], and [28] are cited for background or as prior complementary studies, but the load-bearing equations, such as Eq. (8), Eq. (33), and Eqs. (36)-(39), are derived within the paper. The admitted caveat that conclusions from toy models may not generalize straightforwardly, and the qualitatively different continuous-potential example, are potential limitations on universality or correctness, not circularity. Therefore no specific reduction of a prediction to an input or to a self-citation chain was found.
Assumptions & free parameters
assumptions (6)
- standard math The QNM spectrum is determined by the roots of the Wronskian condition m++_1 m++_2 + e^{2iωL} m-+_1 m+-_2 = 0 (Eq. 8).
- domain assumption The perturbation is weak (v2 << v1 or epsilon << h) and the asymptotic regime has ωR >> |ωI|, justifying the expansions in 1/ωR.
- domain assumption The geometric series expansion of the Green's function in Eq. (41) can be resummed to the compact form S = a1/(1-q), whose poles coincide with the Wronskian roots, despite the causal truncation of the series at finite time.
- ad hoc to paper The behavior of disjoint-potential toy models (double delta, double square) extends to continuous potentials such as the modified Pöschl-Teller model of Eq. (34) and, further, to realistic black hole potentials.
- domain assumption The transit matrix element m+-_2(ω) for the perturbative bump is small enough that the deviation δω in Eq. (33) is small and the fundamental mode can be tracked continuously as L increases.
- standard math The asymptotic hypergeometric expansions in Appendix A (Eq. A5) are valid in the limits L >> 1 and large ω.
Cite this review
Pith. "Pith review of Evolution of black hole echo modes and the causality dilemma." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/2Z7JK2AE
@misc{pith2026250205354,
author = {Pith},
title = {Pith review of: Evolution of black hole echo modes and the causality dilemma},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/2Z7JK2AE}},
note = {Machine review of arXiv:2502.05354}
}
read the original abstract
It has been shown that black hole quasinormal modes are subject to spectral instability, typically triggered by metric perturbations. These perturbations, which can introduce a minor bump in the effective potential of the wave equation, give rise to a novel branch of asymptotic quasinormal modes, dubbed the {\it echo modes}, which lie mainly parallel to the real frequency axis. This study explores the evolution of the echo modes and their interplay with the outward spiral motion observed in low-lying quasinormal modes. As the bump in the effective potential moves away from the central black hole, the echo modes collectively shift toward the real axis, with the spacing between successive modes decreasing uniformly. This collective motion occurs simultaneously with the spiral of the low-lying modes until the echo modes eventually take over the fundamental quasinormal mode. In the time domain, such a takeover coincides with a transition point for the temporal waveform, where the distinction between the original black hole's ringdown and the echoes becomes clear. This marks a transition in the characteristics of the waveform from primarily damped oscillations, dominated by the damping rate of the fundamental mode, to echo waves, characterized by periodic echo pulses. We argue that this phenomenon is universal by employing analytical and numerical analyses. We first elucidate our arguments using explicit but simplified toy models, where the effective potential barriers are disjoint. The derivations are then generalized to scenarios where perturbations are introduced on top of a black hole metric with a continuous effective potential. The observational implications, particularly the causality dilemma, are elaborated. We show that the echo modes can be extracted by applying the Fourier transform to ringdown waveforms, which can be important for gravitational wave observations.
Figures
Figures from the paper (4 more)
Forward citations
Cited by 1 Pith paper
-
A metric solution for rotating black holes embedded in dark matter halos with central spikes
A rotating black-hole metric with a dark-matter halo is derived, but the proposed halo profiles do not make the spacetime asymptotically flat as claimed.
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[23]
L. Hui, D. Kabat, and S.S.C. Wong, Quasinormal modes, echoes and the causal structure of the Green’s function, JCAP 12 (2019) 020
work page 2019
-
[1]
Abbottet al., Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger, Phys
Virgo, LIGO Scientific, B.P. Abbottet al., Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger, Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 061102 (2016)
work page 2016
-
[2]
Virgo, LIGO Scientific, B. P. Abbottet al. , Tests of general relativity with GW150914, Phys. Rev. Lett.116, 221101 (2016), [Erratum: Phys. Rev. Lett.121, 129902 (2018)]
work page 2016
-
[3]
Virgo, LIGO Scientific, B. P. Abbottet al., GW151226: Observation of Gravitational Waves from a 22-Solar-Mass Binary Black Hole Coalescence, Phys. Rev. Lett.116, 241103 (2016)
work page 2016
-
[4]
Virgo, LIGO Scientific, B. P. Abbottet al., GW170814: A Three-Detector Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Coalescence, Phys. Rev. Lett.119, 141101 (2017)
work page 2017
-
[5]
Amaro-Seoaneet al., (2017), Laser Interferometer Space Antenna, arXiv:1702.00786
LISA, P. Amaro-Seoaneet al., (2017), Laser Interferometer Space Antenna, arXiv:1702.00786
arXiv 2017
-
[6]
Luoet al., TianQin: a space-borne gravitational wave detector, Class
TianQin, J. Luoet al., TianQin: a space-borne gravitational wave detector, Class. Quant. Grav.33, 035010 (2016)
work page 2016
-
[7]
Y. Gong, J. Luo, and B. Wang, Concepts and status of Chinese space gravitational wave detection projects, Nature Astron. 5, 881-889 (2021)
work page 2021
Show all 31 references
-
[8]
Hu and Y.-L
W.-R. Hu and Y.-L. Wu, The Taiji Program in Space for gravitational wave physics and the nature of gravity, Natl. Sci. Rev. 4, 685 (2017)
2017
-
[9]
Baibhav, E
V. Baibhav, E. Berti, and V. Cardoso, LISA parameter estimation and source localization with higher harmonics of the ringdown, Phys. Rev. D101, 084053 (2020)
2020
-
[10]
Nollert, About the Significance of QNMs of Black Holes, Phys
H.-P. Nollert, About the Significance of QNMs of Black Holes, Phys. Rev. D53, 4397 (1996)
1996
-
[11]
Nollert and R.H
H.-P. Nollert and R.H. Price, Quantifying excitations of quasinormal mode systems, Journal of Mathematical Physics40, 980 (1999)
1999
-
[12]
Daghigh, M.D
R.G. Daghigh, M.D. Green, J.C. Morey, Significance of Black Hole Quasinormal Modes: A Closer Look, Phys. Rev. D 101, 104009 (2020)
2020
-
[13]
W.-L. Qian, K. Lin, C.-Y. Shao, B. Wang, R.-H. Yue, Asymptotical quasinormal mode spectrum for piecewise approximate effective potential, Phys. Rev. D103, 024019 (2021)
2021
-
[14]
Jaramillo, R.P
J.L. Jaramillo, R.P. Macedo, and L. Al Sheikh, Pseudospectrum and Black Hole Quasinormal Mode Instability, Phys. Rev. X 11, 031003 (2021)
2021
-
[15]
Destounis, R.P
K. Destounis, R.P. Macedo, E. Berti, V. Cardoso, J.L. Jaramillo, Pseudospectrum of Reissner-Nordström black holes: Quasinormal mode instability and universality, Phys. Rev. D104, 084091 (2021)
2021
-
[16]
Jaramillo, R.P
J.L. Jaramillo, R.P. Macedo, L. Al Sheikh, Gravitational Wave Signatures of Black Hole Quasinormal Mode Instability, Phys. Rev. Lett.128, 211102 (2022)
2022
-
[17]
Gasperin, J.L
E. Gasperin, J.L. Jaramillo, Energy scales and black hole pseudospectra: the structural role of the scalar product, Class. Quant. Grav. 39, 115010 (2022)
2022
-
[18]
Ho-Yeuk Cheung, K
M. Ho-Yeuk Cheung, K. Destounis, R. Panosso Macedo, E. Berti, and V. Cardoso, Destabilizing the Fundamental Mode of Black Holes: The Elephant and the Flea, Phys. Rev. Lett.128, 111103 (2022)
2022
-
[19]
Qian, G.-R
W.-L. Qian, G.-R. Li, R. G. Daghigh, S. Randow and R.-H. Yue, On the universality of instability in the fundamental quasinormal modes of black holes, arXiv:2409.17026 [gr-qc]
-
[20]
Barausse, V
E. Barausse, V. Cardoso, P. Pani, Can environmental effects spoil precision gravitational-wave astrophysics?, Phys. Rev. D 89, 104059 (2014)
2014
-
[21]
Kyutoku, H
K. Kyutoku, H. Motohashi, and T. Tanaka, Quasinormal modes of Schwarzschild black holes on the real axis, Phys. Rev. D 107, 044012 (2023)
2023
-
[22]
Jaramillo, R.P
J.L. Jaramillo, R.P. Macedo, and L. Al Sheikh, Gravitational Wave Signatures of Black Hole Quasinormal Mode Instability, 17 Phys. Rev. Lett.128, 211102 (2022)
2022
-
[24]
Y. Yang, Z. F. Mai, R. Q. Yang, L. Shao and E. Berti, Spectral instability of black holes: Relating the frequency domain to the time domain, Phys. Rev. D110, 084018 (2024)
2024
-
[25]
Ianniccari, A
A. Ianniccari, A. J. Iovino, A. Kehagias, P. Pani, G. Perna, D. Perrone and A. Riotto, Deciphering the Instability of the Black Hole Ringdown Quasinormal Spectrum, Phys. Rev. Lett.133, 211401 (2024)
2024
-
[26]
Liu, W.L
H. Liu, W.L. Qian, Y. Liu, J.P. Wu, B. Wang and R.H. Yue, Alternative mechanism for black hole echoes, Phys. Rev. D 104, 044012 (2021)
2021
-
[27]
W. L. Qian, K. Lin, X. M. Kuang, B. Wang and R. H. Yue, Quasinormal modes in two-photon autocorrelation and the geometric-optics approximation, Eur. Phys. J. C82, 188 (2022)
2022
-
[28]
Li, W.-L
G.-R. Li, W.-L. Qian and R. G. Daghigh, Bifurcation and spectral instability of asymptotic quasinormal modes in the modified Pöschl-Teller effective potential, Phys. Rev. D110, 064076 (2024)
2024
-
[29]
de Prony, G., Journal de l’École Polytechnique1(2), 24 (1795); S. L. Marple, Digital spectral analysis with applications, (Prentice-Hall, New Jersey, 1987)
1987
-
[30]
Bueno, P.A
P. Bueno, P.A. Cano, F. Goelen, T. Hertog, and B. Vercnocke, Echoes of Kerr-like wormholes, Phys. Rev. D97, 024040 (2018)
2018
-
[31]
Berti, V
E. Berti, V. Cardoso, M. H. Y. Cheung, F. Di Filippo, F. Duque, P. Martens and S. Mukohyama, Stability of the fundamental quasinormal mode in time-domain observations against small perturbations, Phys. Rev. D 106, 084011 (2022)
2022
Reviewed August 8, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.
Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.