REVIEW 4 major objections 4 minor 35 references
Torsional vibration of a coupled cylinder
T0 review · 4 major / 4 minor · reviewed 2026-08-07 · deepseek-v4-flash
Pith's one-line read Explicit displacement formulas for a vibrated two-section hollow cylinder under torsion, for ideal, soft, and rigid coupling, are derived in closed form via a finite Hankel transform and a Green's function representation, and the paper…
desk verdict Solid ideal-contact solution and a useful damage proxy, but the soft/rigid branches inherit unverified thin-layer asymptotics at the paper's own parameters. read the letter →
The pith
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
The reading
What carries the argument
The load-bearing object is the modified finite Hankel transform with kernel $K(\lambda_n, r)=J_2(\lambda_n a)Y_1(\lambda_n r)-Y_2(\lambda_n a)J_1(\lambda_n r)$, where the eigenvalues $\lambda_n$ are roots of $J_2(\lambda a)Y_2(\lambda R)-Y_2(\lambda a)J_2(\lambda R)=0$, together with the associated Green's function $G_{kn}(z,\eta)$ of the transformed one-dimensional problem. The transform eliminates the radial coordinate and exploits the free-side boundary conditions so that the radial derivatives reduce to $\lambda_n^2 u_{kn}(z)$, while the Green's function carries the vertical behavior and its prescribed jumps at the interface encode the coupling. The explicit displacements are then reassembled by the inverse transform, with the denominators $\Delta^I_{2n}$, $\Delta^S_{2n}$, $\Delta^R_{2n}$ whose zeros give resonance frequencies.
What would settle it
Compute the same steady-state torsional displacement with a high-resolution finite-element or boundary-element simulation for the cuprum--aluminium cylinder of Table 1 with a thin soft layer of height $h_0=0.01$ m and shear modulus $\mu_{\text{soft}}=3.285\times 10^9$ Pa, and compare the displacement and stress profiles at $z/H=0.25,0.5,0.75$ against the series (33); a mismatch beyond the claimed near-linear accuracy of the thin-layer model would falsify the soft-contact solution.
Extended reading notes
Core claim
The central claim is that equations (27), (33), and (39) provide the complete steady-state torsional displacement field of the coupled hollow cylinder for ideal, soft, and rigid contact, respectively, under arbitrary axisymmetric loading on the upper face. The derivation reduces the governing equation via a finite Hankel transform whose kernel is built from Bessel functions, turning the problem into a one-dimensional boundary value problem that is solved with a Green's function; the unknown interface jumps are then fixed algebraically by each contact condition. The authors report that soft contact produces markedly larger displacements than ideal or rigid contact, while ideal and rigid contact give nearly identical fields except near the base and at high aspect ratios, and they show that the resonance frequencies, obtained by phase-shift scanning of the closed-form solutions, differ substantially between the three couplings, with no shared eigenfrequencies in the studied range. They further claim that a weak interface can approximate a damaged region, with the mean displacement ratio following an essentially linear law in the shear-modulus ratio.
Load-bearing premise
The soft and rigid contact solutions rest on asymptotic thin-layer transmission conditions taken from Mishuris (2004a), and the paper does not verify these effective conditions against a direct numerical solution for the chosen material and geometry ratios; if those conditions are inaccurate at, say, $\mu_{\text{soft}}/\mu_k \approx 0.05$ and $h_0/H=0.1$, the corresponding central formulas would be wrong.
Editorial extensions
If this is right
- Engineers can compute torsional displacement and stress at an arbitrary point of a coupled cylinder directly from the series, without meshing, and can scan frequencies rapidly to find resonance locations.
- The three closed-form solutions allow a direct quantitative comparison of ideal, soft, and rigid coupling, showing, per the paper, that rigid coupling approximates ideal contact well while soft coupling departs strongly in displacement magnitude.
- The linear relation between the mean displacement ratio and the interface shear modulus gives a calibration rule: a measured mean displacement deficit at the top face pins down the effective interface stiffness.
- The radial distribution of the displacement ratio at the top face can serve as a non-destructive discriminator between uniform interfacial damage and a localized ring crack.
- Because setting $\omega=0$ reduces the governing equation to the Laplacian, the same formulas describe steady heat flux in a coupled cylinder, extending the model beyond mechanics.
Reading between the lines
- The Green's-function denominators suggest that resonance frequencies of the coupled cylinder could be studied as roots of the characteristic equations $\Delta^I_{2n}=0$, $\Delta^S_{2n}=0$, and $\Delta^R_{2n}=0$ directly, rather than by the scanning algorithm the paper uses; a root-finding analysis would test the robustness of the reported frequencies.
- The claim that a weak interface approximates a ring crack rests on comparing a smeared, uniform bond defect against a localized crack; a natural testable extension is to check whether the displacement ratio over $r$ can also recover the crack's angular extent or depth, not just its presence.
- The near-linearity of the mean displacement ratio in $\mu_1/\mu_0$ suggests the approximation may hold for a family of loading profiles $p(r)$, not just the quadratic loading used; verifying this would broaden the non-destructive testing recipe.
- Since the soft-interface law is an asymptotic thin-layer model, the paper's quantitative conclusions about soft contact inherit its accuracy limitations; one could construct a boundary-layer comparison against direct finite-element simulations at the chosen parameter ratios.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The manuscript studies steady-state torsional vibrations of an axisymmetric hollow cylinder made of two vertical sections with possibly different elastic materials, with a fixed base and an arbitrary torsional traction on the top face. Three interface models are considered: ideal bonding, a soft thin layer, and a rigid thin layer. The authors apply a finite Hankel transform and a one-dimensional Green's function to derive explicit series formulas for the displacement, given in Eqs. (27), (33), and (39) for ideal, soft, and rigid contact, respectively. Numerical results explore the displacement and stress fields, the influence of geometry and material parameters, resonance frequencies, and a damage-approximation method that replaces a damaged region by a weak interfacial layer. The paper claims complete explicit solutions for arbitrary axisymmetric loading, valid for different material properties in the two sections.
Significance. The topic is of practical interest, and the explicit formulas, if correct, would provide a fast semi-analytical tool for parametric studies of coupled cylinders and for non-destructive testing. The paper has several strengths: it gives closed-form inverse-transform representations, includes the useful limit checks that K_1=0 and K_2=0 recover ideal contact, and presents a broad numerical survey with tables and figures. However, the central derivation contains internal inconsistencies that affect the general case of different material wave speeds and the soft-contact formula, so the numerical conclusions and the damage-calibration method are not reliable as they stand. The significance of the paper therefore hinges on a substantial correction of the Green's function representation and of the printed final formulas.
major comments (4)
- [§3.3-§4] The representation (20)–(21) uses the same forcing term p_n sinh(γ_{2n} z)/(µ_2 γ_{2n} cosh(γ_{2n}H)) for both k=1 and k=2. For the lower section, however, the transformed equation (12) has coefficient γ_{1n}, and this forcing term is not a solution of u''_{1n} − γ_{1n}² u_{1n}=0 when c_1≠c_2. For n=0, substituting (23) into (13) gives u''_{10} + β_1² u_{10} = p_0(β_2²−β_1²) sin(β_2 z)/(µ_2 β_2 cos β_2 H), which is not zero unless β_1=β_2. The ideal-contact continuity condition [[u]]=0 at z=h is also violated: from (23) the jump equals −(µ_2−µ_1)/µ_1 u'_{20}(h+0)[G_{10}(h,h)−G_{20}(h,h)], which generally does not vanish. Since the paper explicitly treats different materials, as in the cuprum–aluminium example of Table 1, Eqs. (27), (33), and (39) are not valid in the paper's main setting, and the resonance frequencies in Fig. 4 are consequently unreliable. The solution should be re-derived with piecewise fundamental solutions in each section or with a correct bimaterial Green's function.
- [§4.2] The final soft-contact displacement (33) contains a sign error in the n-sum. The transformed-domain expression (31) has u_{kn}(z) = p_n sinh(γ_{2n}z)/(µ_2 γ_{2n} cosh γ_{2n}H) − [K_1 ∂G_{kn}/∂η + ((µ_2−µ_1)/µ_1)G_{kn}] p_n cosh(γ_{2n}h)/(µ_2 Δ^S_{2n}), whereas in (33) the same bracket enters with a plus sign before the n-sum. As a result, for K_1>0 the n>0 contributions in (33) have the opposite sign to those in (31), so (33) is not the inverse transform of (31). This sign error affects all soft-contact results in Section 5 and the damage approximation in Section 6, and it must be corrected before any quantitative conclusions are drawn.
- [§6] Equation (41) is not consistent with the preceding formulas. The denominator contains R^4 − a^2, while the corresponding ideal-contact displacement (27) has (R^4 − a^4)/4 in the n=0 term; the two expressions have different dimensions, so the printed denominator is dimensionally wrong. In addition, using the correct signs from Eqs. (31)–(33), the n-sum contribution in the numerator should be positive, not negative as printed. Consequently the least-squares fit ¯u = 1.000 + 0.02482 µ_1/µ_0 cannot be reproduced from the equations in the manuscript, and the proposed non-destructive-testing calibration is not verifiable as stated.
- [§2.2.2] The soft and rigid contact conditions (5) and (7) are leading-order thin-layer asymptotics from Mishuris (2004a). The paper does not state the asymptotic error order and uses parameters h_0/H=0.1, µ_soft/µ_2≈0.13, and µ_rigid/µ_2≈130 in Table 1, for which the first corrections to the reduced conditions are of order h_0/H and of the modulus contrast. Without an error estimate or a comparison against a full three-layer solution or a finite-element computation, the physical accuracy of the soft and rigid displacement fields at these parameters is unverified. This matters for Tables 2–3 and for the damage calibration in Section 6, which relies on the soft-contact model.
minor comments (4)
- [§3.1] Equation (10) has a sign error: the identity should read ∫ [∂/∂r(r ∂u/∂r) − (1/r)u] K dr = −λ_n² u_{kn}, since the kernel satisfies L[K] = −λ_n² K. The subsequent transformed equation (12) uses the correct sign, so the error appears to be typographical, but as printed Eq. (10) is inconsistent with Eq. (12).
- [§5.3.2] The conclusion that there are no shared eigenfrequencies between the three coupling cases is based on a finite frequency scan and should be qualified as a numerical observation, not a proven property.
- [§1] The paper claims to provide the first description of a vibrating hollow cylinder under torsion with 'differing loading on the upper and lower surfaces', but the problem statement has a fixed lower surface and loading only on the upper surface; this phrasing should be corrected.
- [§7] The concluding claim that the resonance method can achieve 'arbitrarily high levels of accuracy' is overstated, since the method relies on a phase-shift search and the authors themselves note that boundary-condition accuracy deteriorates near resonance.
Circularity Check
Main displacement derivation is self-contained; circularity is confined to Section 6, where the damage approximation leans on a self-cited prior paper and a least-squares fit to the model's own output.
-
self citation load bearing
[Section 6, 'Using an interfacial layer to approximate damage within a cylinder', final paragraph (p. 29), and the comparison with Zhuravlova et al. (2024).]
"To demonstrate that this is possible, we perform a comparison with Zhuravlova et al. (2024) which considered a ring crack within a single-material hollow cylinder."
The validation that a weak interfacial layer approximates a ring crack is anchored to the authors' own previous paper (Zhuravlova, Istenes, Peck, Protserov, Vaysfeld 2024), which has the same author set as the present manuscript. No independent experiment, finite-element benchmark, or re-derivation is supplied here; the non-destructive-testing inference about the 'type of damage present' is justified by 'see Zhuravlova et al. (2024), Fig. 4'. Thus a highlighted application claim is supported by a self-citation rather than by new independent evidence.
-
fitted input called prediction
[Section 6, immediately after Eq. (41) and Fig. 6, p. 28.]
"This is confirmed in Fig. 6, with least-squares analysis revealing that for the given material parameters and cylinder geometry ¯u can be accurately described by (to 4 significant figures) ¯u = 1.000 + 0.02482 µ1/µ0."
The slope 0.02482 and intercept 1.000 are obtained by least-squares fitting to values of ¯u computed from the paper's own formula (41). The paper then inverts this fitted line to 'determine' the interface shear modulus µ0 from an observed displacement ratio (Section 6 and Section 7). Because the fit is made to the model's own output and the reported 0.01% relative error is measured against those same computed points, the calibration is internal to the model: the inferred µ0 is the value that makes the model reproduce itself, not an independently validated material parameter. This is a fitted relationship presented as a predictive engineering tool.
full rationale
The central derivation of the displacement formulas (27), (33), and (39) is not circular. The finite Hankel transform, Green's function representation, and the jump conditions are all solved self-consistently from the stated boundary value problem, with classical external references (Pathak and Singh 1982; Popov et al. 1999) for the transform and Green's function identities. The soft and rigid interface conditions are taken from Mishuris (2004a), an external source, not from the authors' own prior work, so no self-citation is load-bearing in the main derivation. The resonance-frequency search is a numerical post-processing of the derived solution. The circularity that exists is confined to Section 6: (i) the damage-approximation validation uses the authors' own 2024 ring-crack paper as the benchmark, making the non-destructive-testing claim rely on a self-citation; and (ii) the linear relation ¯u = 1.000 + 0.02482 µ1/µ0 is a least-squares fit to the model's own computed output, and is then inverted to infer the interface modulus. These issues affect a highlighted application rather than the core elastodynamic solution, so a moderate score is appropriate.
Assumptions & free parameters
free parameters (3)
- slope of linear damage approximation =
0.02482
- soft interface simulation parameters =
mu0 = 3.285e9 Pa, h0 = 0.01 m, rho0 = 5800 kg/m3
- rigid interface simulation parameters =
mu0 = 3.285e12 Pa, h0 = 0.01 m, rho0 = 5800 kg/m3
assumptions (6)
- standard math The displacement satisfies the classical linear elastodynamic equation for torsional motion, Eq. (3).
- standard math The finite Hankel transform with kernel K(lambda_n, r) and eigenvalues lambda_n diagonalizes the radial torsion operator, Eq. (10).
- domain assumption The soft interface conditions [[u]] = K1 du2/dz and [[tau]] = 0, with K1 = mu2 mu0^{-1} h0, are valid asymptotics for a thin weak layer.
- domain assumption The rigid interface conditions, including the equation of motion (7) for the interface displacement v(r), are valid asymptotics for a thin stiff layer.
- domain assumption A steady-state harmonic time dependence e^{i omega t} is assumed, with the base fixed and lateral surfaces traction-free.
- ad hoc to paper A ring crack in a single cylinder can be approximated by a homogeneous soft interfacial layer of height h0 and shear modulus mu0.
invented entities (1)
-
Weak interfacial layer as a proxy for a ring crack or damage region
Cite this review
Pith. "Pith review of Torsional vibration of a coupled cylinder." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/4CNFNY7A
@misc{pith2026250611582,
author = {Pith},
title = {Pith review of: Torsional vibration of a coupled cylinder},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/4CNFNY7A}},
note = {Machine review of arXiv:2506.11582}
}
read the original abstract
The torsion loading of a coupled cylinder, comprising distinct upper and lower cylindrical sections potentially made of different materials, is considered. The bottom of the cylinder is fixed in place, and induces the cylinder vibration. The torsion is applied via an arbitrary loading on the upper face. Three forms of coupling condition between the upper and lower cylinders are outlined: ideal, soft (weak), and rigid (hard/ stiff) contact. The resulting displacements and tangential stresses are obtained using the finite Hankel transform, and a Green's function representation of the displacement. Numerical results are provided, and the impact of the differing coupling conditions investigated for a range of cylinder geometries, material properties and vibration rates. The resonance frequencies of the coupled cylinder are determined. A method for using the coupled cylinder model to approximate the displacement of a cylinder containing a damaged region via a weak interfacial layer is outlined. The properties of the weak interface layer needed for this approximation are determined, and the advantages of its use in non-destructive testing are discussed.
Figures
Figures from the paper (4 more)
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
write newline
" write newline "" before.all 'output.state := FUNCTION n.dashify 't := "" t empty not t #1 #1 substring "-" = t #1 #2 substring "--" = not "--" * t #2 global.max substring 't := t #1 #1 substring "-" = "-" * t #2 global.max substring 't := while if t #1 #1 substring * t #2 global.max substring 't := if while FUNCTION word.in bbl.in ":" * " " * FUNCTION f...
-
[2]
Akbarov, S., Bagirov, E., and Ipek, C. (2025). Influence of imperfect contact condition on dispersion of axisymmetric waves in bi-layered hollow cylinder with inhomogeneous initial stresses. International Applied Mechanics , 60(6):758--767
work page 2025
-
[3]
Akbarov, S., Kepceler, T., and Mert Egilmez , M. (2011). Torsional wave dispersion in a finitely pre-strained hollow sandwich circular cylinder. Journal of Sound and Vibration , 330(18):4519--4537
work page 2011
-
[4]
Akhmedov, N. and Ustinov, Y. A. (2009). Analysis of the structure of the boundary layer in the problem of the torsion of a laminated spherical shell. Journal of Applied Mathematics and Mechanics , 73(3):296--303
work page 2009
-
[5]
Argatov, I. and Mishuris, G. (2011). Frictionless elliptical contact of thin viscoelastic layers bonded to rigid substrates. Applied Mathematical Modelling , 35(7):3201--3212
work page 2011
-
[6]
Bigoni, D., Serkov, S., Valentini, M., and Movchan, A. (1998). Asymptotic models of dilute composites with imperfectly bonded inclusions. International Journal of Solids and Structures , 35(24):3239--3258
work page 1998
-
[7]
Dastjerdi, S., Malikan, M., Tahani, M., Kadkhodayan, M., and Ameli, A. (2025). On three-dimensional dynamics of smart rotating micro-disks. International Journal of Engineering Science , 211:104236
work page 2025
-
[8]
Deng, Y., Li, H., and Liu, H. (2020). Analysis of surface polariton resonance for nanoparticles in elastic system. SIAM Journal on Mathematical Analysis , 52(2):1786--1805
work page 2020
Show all 35 references
-
[9]
Dhua, S., Nath, A., and Maji, A. (2025). Effects of surface–interface theory on the circumferential shear horizontal wave in a piezoelectric composite cylinder. Mechanics of Advanced Materials and Structures , 0(0):1--22
2025
-
[10]
D., Ravichandran, K., and Padmanabhan, C
Ebenezer, D. D., Ravichandran, K., and Padmanabhan, C. (2015). Free and forced vibrations of hollow elastic cylinders of finite lengtha). The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America , 137(5):2927--2938
2015
-
[11]
and Nejad, M
Esfandyari, H. and Nejad, M. Z. (2025). Elastic analysis of uniform pressurized axisymmetric cylindrical shells made of saturated porous materials. Results in Physics , page 108194
2025
-
[12]
O., Lanzoni, L., and Tarantino, A
Falope, F. O., Lanzoni, L., and Tarantino, A. M. (2025). Experiments on the finite torsion of nearly incompressible rubber-like materials: Nonlinear effects, analytic modeling and rubber characterization. International Journal of Engineering Science , 211:104254
2025
-
[13]
and Krack, M
F\" o rster, A. and Krack, M. (2016). An efficient method for approximating resonance curves of weakly-damped nonlinear mechanical systems. Computers & Structures , 169:81--90
2016
-
[14]
and Meleshko, V
Grinchenko, V. and Meleshko, V. (1981). Harmonic oscillations and waves in elastic bodies . Naukova Dumka, Kyiv
1981
-
[15]
Hosseini-Hashemi, S., Ilkhani, M., and Fadaee, M. (2013). Accurate natural frequencies and critical speeds of a rotating functionally graded moderately thick cylindrical shell. International Journal of Mechanical Sciences , 76:9--20
2013
-
[16]
Korenev, B. (2002). Bessel Functions and Their Applications . CRC Press, London
2002
-
[17]
and Conway, H
Kuo, Y. and Conway, H. (1973). The torsion of composite tubes and cylinders. International Journal of Solids and Structures , 9(12):1553--1566
1973
-
[18]
Li, Y.-D., Zhao, H., and Xiong, T. (2013). The cylindrical interface crack in a layered tubular composite of finite thickness under torsion. European Journal of Mechanics - A/Solids , 39:113--119
2013
-
[19]
and Vernescu, B
Lipton, R. and Vernescu, B. (1996). Composites with imperfect interface. Proceedings: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences , 452(1945):329--358
1996
-
[20]
and Pustilnikov, L
Martynenko, N. and Pustilnikov, L. (1996). Finite integral transforms and their application to investigation of the systems with distributed parameters (in russian). Moscow: Nauka , 304(1986)
1996
-
[21]
Mikhasev, G. I. and Eremeyev, V. A. (2024). Effects of interfacial sliding on anti-plane waves in an elastic plate imperfectly attached to an elastic half-space. International Journal of Engineering Science , 205:104158
2024
-
[22]
Mishuris, G. (2004a). Imperfect transmission conditions for a thin weakly compressible interface. 2d problems. Archives of Mechanics , 56:103--115
2004
-
[23]
Mishuris, G., Movchan, N., and Movchan, A. B. (2006). Steady-state motion of a mode-iii crack on imperfect interfaces. Quarterly Journal of Mechanics and Applied Mathematics , 59:487--516
2006
-
[24]
Mishuris, G. S. (2004b). Mode iii interface crack lying at thin nonhomogeneous anisotropic interface. asymptotics near the crack tip. In Movchan, A. B., editor, IUTAM Symposium on Asymptotics, Singularities and Homogenisation in Problems of Mechanics , pages 251--260, Dordrech...
2004
-
[25]
Padovan, J. (1973). Natural frequencies of rotating prestressed cylinders. Journal of Sound and Vibration , 31(4):469--482
1973
-
[26]
Pathak, R. S. and Singh, O. P. (1982). Finite Hankel transforms of distributions. Pacific Journal of Mathematics , 99(2):439--458
1982
-
[27]
Popov, G., Abdimanov, S., and Ephimov, V. (1999). Green’s functions and matrixes of the one-dimensional boundary problems (in Russian) . Raczah, Almati
1999
-
[28]
and Craster, R
Postnova, J. and Craster, R. (2008). Trapped modes in elastic plates, ocean and quantum waveguides. Wave Motion , 45(4):565--579
2008
-
[29]
and Vaysfeld, N
Protserov, Y. and Vaysfeld, N. (2017). Torsion problem for elastic multilayered finite cylinder with circular crack. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics , 38(3):423--438
2017
-
[30]
and Protcerov, Y
Vaysfeld, N. and Protcerov, Y. (2017). Torsion problems of finite cylinders weakened by ring-shaped cracks. Procedia Structural Integrity , 3:526--544
2017
-
[31]
and Williams, K
Wang, H. and Williams, K. (1996). Vibrational modes of thick cylinders of finite length. Journal of Sound and Vibration , 191(5):955--971
1996
-
[32]
and Gong, Y
Wang, X. and Gong, Y. (1992). An elastodynamic solution for multilayered cylinders. International Journal of Engineering Science , 30(1):25--33
1992
-
[33]
Zhuravlova, Z., Istenes, I., Peck, D., Protserov, Y., and Vaysfeld, N. (2024). Hidden ring crack in a rotating hollow cylinder under torsion. International Journal of Engineering Science , 194:103976
2024
-
[34]
M., Zubov, L
Zingerman, K. M., Zubov, L. M., Belkin, A. E., and Biryukov, D. R. (2023). Torsion of a multilayer elastic cylinder with sequential attachment of layers with multiple superposition of large deformations. Continuum Mechanics and Thermodynamics , 35:1235–1244
2023
-
[35]
and Aboudi, J
Zohar, A. and Aboudi, J. (1973). The free vibrations of a thin circular finite rotating cylinder. International Journal of Mechanical Sciences , 15(4):269--278
1973
Reviewed August 7, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.
Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.