REVIEW 1 major objections 5 minor 1 cited by
A decade of sub-arcsecond imaging with the International LOFAR Telescope
T0 review · 1 major / 5 minor · reviewed 2026-08-08 · deepseek-v4-flash
Pith's one-line read The International LOFAR Telescope can image the low-frequency sky at 0.3-arcsecond resolution over wide fields, and this review argues that this combination will remain unmatched even after SKAO begins operations.
desk verdict A competent, useful review of LOFAR sub-arcsecond imaging whose headline 'unparalleled in the SKAO era' claim is not yet quantitatively supported. read the letter →
The pith
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
The reading
What carries the argument
The load-bearing object is the International LOFAR Telescope itself: baselines up to roughly 2,000 km across Europe give 0.3-arcsecond resolution at 144 MHz, while the large primary beams of the stations keep a field of view of about 6.6 square degrees; an 8-hour observation fills the uv plane densely enough that the array behaves more like high-resolution interferometry than classical VLBI. On top of this sits a calibration chain — the LOFAR long-baseline calibrator survey, the LINC and LOFAR-VLBI pipelines, and facet-based direction-dependent calibration — that makes the data tractable. The scientific quantity that carries the uniqueness argument is brightness temperature, $T_b \propto \nu^{-1}\Omega^{-1}$, the flux density per unit solid angle expressed as an equivalent temperature: at 144 MHz with a 0.3-arcsecond beam, ILT images reach the roughly $10^5$ K threshold where compact emission cannot be explained by star formation and must be AGN, turning sub-arcsecond imaging into a blind statistical galaxy survey tool.
What would settle it
A quantitative end-to-end simulation of SKAO-Low's expected resolution, confusion limit, and brightness-temperature sensitivity over a wide field at 144 MHz would settle the claim: if SKAO-Low can identify AGN via $T_b \gtrsim 10^5$ K across a comparable area, the paper's central uniqueness claim is undercut.
Extended reading notes
Core claim
On the paper's own terms, the central claim is that the ILT's combination of sub-arcsecond resolution, large field of view, and low observing frequency is unique among current and planned facilities, and that it will remain unparalleled even in the era of the Square Kilometre Array Observatory. The evidence assembled is technical and observational: an 8-hour observation fills the uv plane densely out to about 1 Mλ; a sky survey of calibrators provides roughly one usable calibrator per square degree; and wide-field imaging has been demonstrated on the Lockman Hole and ELAIS-N1 fields at 0.3, 0.6, and 1.2 arcseconds. The scientific payoff is that high-resolution images reach brightness-temperature sensitivities around $10^5$ K, the threshold above which radio emission cannot be explained by star formation alone and must be AGN activity. The paper shows this capability in action — de-blending sources, matching HST and Chandra resolution, anchoring spectral-age fits, discovering a giant jet in a $z=4.9$ quasar, resolving strong lenses, and recovering emission from 0.3 arcsec to 80 arcsec in a single observation.
Load-bearing premise
The claim that the ILT will remain unmatched depends on SKAO-Low not achieving comparable resolution and brightness-temperature sensitivity at low frequencies, something the paper supports mainly by qualitative comparison rather than a full quantitative analysis.
Editorial extensions
If this is right
- LoTSS-HR will reprocess the LoTSS archive with the international stations, publishing 0.3-arcsecond cutouts of all sources brighter than 10 mJy plus full-field 1.2-arcsecond images, making it the widest high-resolution radio survey at any frequency by an order of magnitude.
- Brightness-temperature AGN identification becomes a statistical, wide-area method: the ELAIS-N1 demonstration covers 105 times more sky than the EVN GOODS-N survey and yields 51 times more AGN identifications, enabling the first radio luminosity functions split by physical process.
- The combination with WEAVE-LOFAR will give every LoTSS-HR source a spectroscopic redshift, opening redshift-resolved studies of AGN morphology and host galaxy properties.
- Matched-resolution multi-wavelength and spectral-age studies become possible for distant objects: the 54 and 144 MHz ILT data anchor the injection index in spectral-age fits for sources such as 4C 43.15 at $z=2.4$.
- A single ILT observation can be imaged from roughly 0.3 arcsec to 80 arcsec, simultaneously recovering compact AGN cores and Mpc-scale diffuse emission, as demonstrated for the Perseus cluster.
Reading between the lines
- The paper leaves implicit that the strongest test of its uniqueness claim is a quantitative SKAO-Low simulation rather than another survey demonstration.
- If LOFAR2.0's wider bandwidth and sidereal visibility averaging deliver the intended depth, ultra-deep sub-arcsecond surveys could push brightness-temperature AGN identification to fainter and more numerous objects than the current ELAIS-N1 result.
- The polarisation work suggests that once full-Jones calibration is public and residual instrumental polarisation is quantified, sub-arcsecond RM-synthesis maps could become a standard product for LOFAR deep fields.
- The success of LoTSS-HR will depend on whether roughly 20 to 30 automatic calibrators per wide field can be found reliably in all directions, not only in the fields demonstrated so far.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. This is a review article describing the technical methods, calibration strategies, and scientific results enabled by sub-arcsecond imaging with the International LOFAR Telescope (ILT) over the past decade. It covers the challenges of mismatched station fields of view, time and bandwidth smearing, u-v coverage, calibration signal-to-noise, and ionospheric effects, then summarizes the calibration pipeline (LINC and the LOFAR-VLBI pipeline) and highlights science applications including multi-wavelength studies, brightness-temperature-based AGN identification, spectral modelling, rare-object discovery, strong lensing, and the dynamic range of spatial scales. The manuscript also discusses ongoing work on wide-area surveys (LoTSS-HR), WEAVE-LOFAR, wide-field imaging, polarisation, and low-frequency (LBA) observations. The central claim is that the ILT's combination of sub-arcsecond resolution, large field of view, and low observing frequency is unique and will remain unparalleled even in the SKAO era.
Significance. If the central uniqueness claim is accepted, this review provides a timely and useful community reference for the technical and scientific state of sub-arcsecond low-frequency radio astronomy. The manuscript is a well-organized synthesis of published work, with clear descriptions of the calibration pipeline, data products, and representative science cases. Its strengths include the documentation of publicly available pipelines (LINC, VLBI-cwl), the reproducibility of the described calibration strategy, and the use of peer-reviewed examples to illustrate each capability. The paper would be a valuable entry point for astronomers planning to use ILT high-resolution data. However, the forward-looking assertion that the ILT will remain 'unparalleled' in the SKAO era is the load-bearing claim and is currently supported by qualitative statements and a citation to an unpublished manuscript rather than by a quantitative comparison.
major comments (1)
- [Section 3 and Abstract] The central uniqueness claim is not quantitatively supported. The sentence 'Sub-arcsecond resolution also easily beats the confusion limit compared to the SKAO-Low at the same frequencies' (Section 3) is not accompanied by any numbers for SKAO-Low's synthesized beam, point-source sensitivity, brightness-temperature sensitivity, or confusion noise. The references given are 'Shimwell et al. submitted' (not yet public) and Sabater et al. (2021), which is a LoTSS deep-field paper that does not present an SKAO-Low comparison. Because the abstract states that the ILT 'will remain unparalleled even in the era of the Square Kilometre Array Observatory,' this comparison is load-bearing. The authors should either include a reproducible calculation based on SKAO-Low baseline specifications and expected sensitivity/confusion limits, or qualify the claim to state that a quantitative comparison is in preparation.
minor comments (5)
- [Section 3.2 and Figure 8 caption] There is an inconsistency in the stated observing time for GOODS-N: the text says the GOODS-N survey used 17.5 hours, while the Figure 8 caption says both surveys use ~32 hours of data. Please correct one of these statements.
- [Section 3.4] The sentence 'the number of sources increases inversely with the limiting flux density, and hence is proportional to the inverse square root of the observing time' contains a sign error: for a Euclidean source count N(>S) ∝ S^{-1} and a noise level S ∝ t^{-1/2}, the number of sources grows as t^{1/2}, not t^{-1/2}.
- [Section 3.2] The claim that 'the area covered by ELAIS-N1 is 105 times larger than that of GOODS-N' should be verified. Using the stated GOODS-N central radius of 7.5 arcmin and ELAIS-N1 area of 6.6 deg^2, the area ratio is approximately 130, not 105.
- [Section 4] The statement that LoTSS-HR 'is set to form the highest-resolution sky survey with a comparably wide effective sky coverage by over an order of magnitude at any radio frequency' is another forward-looking claim that would benefit from quantitative support or a reference to a more detailed forecasting paper.
- [Throughout] The manuscript contains several typographical and formatting issues: 'LOF AR' should be 'LOFAR', 'WEA VE' should be 'WEAVE', 'ELIAS-N1' should be 'ELAIS-N1', and 'William Hershel Telescope' should be 'William Herschel Telescope'.
Circularity Check
No circular reduction found: the 'unparalleled in the SKAO era' claim is under-supported but is a completeness gap, not a derivation from the paper's own inputs.
full rationale
This is a technical review rather than a derivation paper. Its technical statements are descriptive syntheses of published, publicly available work (e.g., Morabito et al. 2022 calibration strategy, Sweijen et al. 2022 full-field imaging, de Jong et al. 2024 ELAIS-N1 deep imaging) and are anchored in external benchmarks and public pipelines. No equation in the paper fits a parameter and then relabels that parameter as a prediction, and no claimed result is equivalent by construction to an input. The one forward-looking assertion in the Abstract — that the ILT 'will remain unparalleled even in the era of the Square Kilometre Array Observatory' — is supported in Section 3 by the sentence 'Sub-arcsecond resolution also easily beats the confusion limit compared to the SKAO-Low at the same frequencies (see, e.g., Shimwell et al. submitted, Sabater et al., 2021)' and by 'No other current or planned radio instrument is capable of this.' The Figure 7 caption similarly states that the ILT can observe 'well below the confusion limit of the SKAO-Low.' This is an under-supported comparison: no SKAO-Low sensitivity, resolution, or confusion-noise numbers are given, and the decisive comparison is to an unpublished submitted paper that is not in the reference list. However, that is a support and verifiability weakness, not a circularity. The uniqueness claim is not rendered true by the submitted citation as a matter of definition, nor is any fitted quantity from this paper being disguised as an independent prediction. The paper's extensive self-citations are descriptive and historical; they are not used to import an unproven uniqueness theorem or to forbid alternative instruments by fiat. Accordingly, no specific circular step can be exhibited, and the appropriate finding is no significant circularity.
Assumptions & free parameters
assumptions (3)
- domain assumption The radio brightness temperature limit for star formation is a hard physical ceiling at about 10^5 K (Condon 1992), so any source above it is AGN-dominated.
- domain assumption The Long Baseline Calibrator Survey (LBCS) sky density of about 1 calibrator per square degree is complete and representative across the sky.
- domain assumption SKAO-Low will not achieve comparable brightness-temperature sensitivity or sub-arcsecond resolution at about 144 MHz, as predicted by a submitted paper (Shimwell et al.).
Cite this review
Pith. "Pith review of A decade of sub-arcsecond imaging with the International LOFAR Telescope." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/56NMH7DU
@misc{pith2026250206946,
author = {Pith},
title = {Pith review of: A decade of sub-arcsecond imaging with the International LOFAR Telescope},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/56NMH7DU}},
note = {Machine review of arXiv:2502.06946}
}
read the original abstract
The International LOFAR Telescope (ILT) is a pan-European radio interferometer with baselines up to 2,000 km. This provides sub-arcsecond resolution at frequencies of <200 MHz. Since starting science operations in 2012, the ILT has carried out observations for the state-of-the-art LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey, which has 6 arcsec resolution at 144 MHz. Wide-area surveys at low frequencies, while scientifically productive, have to compromise on resolution. Sub-arcsecond imaging with the ILT has become more accessible over the last decade, thanks to efforts to build a publicly available pipeline using LOFAR-specific tools, which has resulted in a dramatic increase in the number of publications. The ILT's combination of resolution, field of view, and low observing frequency make it a unique instrument for a wide range of scientific applications, and it will remain unparalleled even in the era of the Square Kilometre Array Observatory. Here we provide an overview of the technical considerations and calibration methods sub-arcsecond imaging with the ILT. This is followed by a review of the unique capabilities unlocked by sub-arcsecond imaging with the ILT, using examples from the literature for demonstration. Finally we describe ongoing work including: surveying large areas of the sky at high resolution, going deeper in fields with excellent ancillary information, producing images of polarisation, and extending to lower frequencies (<100 MHz).
Forward citations
Cited by 1 Pith paper
-
Characterising the response of an International LOFAR Station
International LOFAR stations are 20–45% more sensitive to sources on the rising side of the sky than the setting side, an asymmetry observed in all 11 tracked pulsars and across three stations.
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
write newline
" write newline " cite write " FUNCTION editor.postfix editor num.names #1 > "( )" "( )" if FUNCTION editor.trans.postfix editor num.names #1 > "( )" "( )" if FUNCTION trans.postfix translator num.names #1 > "( )" "( )" if FUNCTION authors.editors.reflist.apa5 'field := 'dot := field num.names 'numnames := numnames 'format.num.names := format.num.names na...
-
[2]
, " * write output.state after.block = add.period write newline
ENTRY address author booktitle chapter doi edition editor eid howpublished institution journal key keywords month note number organization pages publisher school series title type url volume year eprint archive archivePrefix primaryClass adsurl adsnote version label INTEGERS output.state before.all mid.sentence after.sentence after.block FUNCTION init.sta...
-
[3]
write newline
" write newline "" before.all 'output.state := FUNCTION if.digit duplicate "0" = swap duplicate "1" = swap duplicate "2" = swap duplicate "3" = swap duplicate "4" = swap duplicate "5" = swap duplicate "6" = swap duplicate "7" = swap duplicate "8" = swap "9" = or or or or or or or or or FUNCTION n.separate 't := "" #0 'numnames := t empty not t #-1 #1 subs...
-
[4]
write newline
" write newline "" before.all 'output.state := FUNCTION output.doi doi empty skip "doi:" doi * "" * output if FUNCTION format.archive archivePrefix empty "" archivePrefix ":" * if FUNCTION format.primaryClass primaryClass empty "" " [" primaryClass * "] " * if FUNCTION format.eprint eprint empty "" archive empty " https://arxiv.org/abs/" eprint * " " * " ...
-
[5]
write newline
" write newline "" before.all 'output.state := FUNCTION string.to.integer 't := t text.length 'k := #1 'char.num := t char.num #1 substring 's := s is.num s "." = or char.num k = not and char.num #1 + 'char.num := while char.num #1 - 'char.num := t #1 char.num substring FUNCTION find.integer 't := #0 'int := int not t empty not and t #1 #1 substring 's :=...
-
[6]
, " * write output.state after.block = add.period write newline
ENTRY address archive author booktitle chapter edition editor eprint howpublished institution journal key keywords month note number organization pages publisher school series title type url doi volume year archivePrefix primaryClass eid adsurl adsnote version label INTEGERS output.state before.all mid.sentence after.sentence after.block FUNCTION init.sta...
-
[7]
write newline
" write newline "" before.all 'output.state := FUNCTION n.dashify 't := "" t empty not t #1 #1 substring "-" = t #1 #2 substring "--" = not "--" * t #2 global.max substring 't := t #1 #1 substring "-" = "-" * t #2 global.max substring 't := while if t #1 #1 substring * t #2 global.max substring 't := if while FUNCTION word.in bbl.in capitalize " " * FUNCT...
-
[8]
Available from:
ENTRY address assignee author booktitle chapter cartographer day edition editor howpublished institution inventor journal key keywords month note number organization pages part publisher school series title type volume word year eprint doi url lastchecked updated archive archivePrefix primaryClass eid adsurl adsnote version label INTEGERS output.state bef...
Show all 89 references
-
[9]
write newline
" write newline "" before.all 'output.state := FUNCTION n.dashify 't := "" t empty not t #1 #1 substring "-" = t #1 #2 substring "--" = not "--" * t #2 global.max substring 't := t #1 #1 substring "-" = "-" * t #2 global.max substring 't := while if t #1 #1 substring * t #2 gl...
-
[10]
, Browne , I.W.A
barticle Biggs , A.D. , Browne , I.W.A. , Jackson , N.J. , York , T. , Norbury , M.A. , McKean , J.P. , Phillips , P.M. : Radio, optical and infrared observations of CLASS B0128 +437 . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 350 , 949 -- 961 ( 2004 ) 10.1111/j.1365-2...
2004
-
[11]
, Bruyn , A.G
barticle Brentjens , M.A. , Bruyn , A.G. : Faraday rotation measure synthesis . Astronomy and Astrophysics 441 , 1217 -- 1228 ( 2005 ) 10.1051/0004-6361:20052990 . ADS Bibcode: 2005A&A...441.1217B . Accessed 2024-12-02 barticle
2005 doi
-
[12]
, Jackson , N
barticle Badole , S. , Jackson , N. , Hartley , P. , Sluse , D. , Stacey , H. , Vives-Arias , H. : VLA and ALMA observations of the lensed radio-quiet quasar SDSS J0924 +0219: a molecular structure in a 3 \ mu\ Jy radio source . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Societ...
2020 doi
-
[13]
, Kondapally , R
barticle Best , P.N. , Kondapally , R. , Williams , W.L. , Cochrane , R.K. , Duncan , K.J. , Hale , C.L. , Haskell , P. , Małek , K. , McCheyne , I. , Smith , D.J.B. , Wang , L. , Botteon , A. , Bonato , M. , Bondi , M. , Calistro Rivera , G. , Gao , F. , Gürkan , G. , Hardcas...
2023
-
[14]
: Polarization Imaging with LOFAR
bchapter Brentjens , M.A. : Polarization Imaging with LOFAR . In: Astrophysics and Space Science Library . Astrophysics and Space Science Library , vol. 426 , p. 159 ( 2018 ). 10.1007/978-3-319-23434-2_10 bchapter
2018 doi
-
[15]
, Schwab , F.R
bchapter Bridle , A.H. , Schwab , F.R. : Bandwidth and Time - Average Smearing . In: Synthesis Imaging in Radio Astronomy II , vol. 180 , p. 371 ( 1999 ). http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1999ASPC..180..371B Accessed 2017-12-04 bchapter
1999
-
[16]
, Sweijen , F
barticle Bonnassieux , E. , Sweijen , F. , Brienza , M. , Rajpurohit , K. , John Riseley , C. , Bonafede , A. , Jackson , N. , Morabito , L.K. , Brunetti , G. , Harwood , J. , Kappes , A. , Rottgering , H.J. , Tasse , C. , Weeren , R. : Spectral analysis of spatially resolved ...
2022 doi
-
[17]
, Venkattu , D
barticle Badole , S. , Venkattu , D. , Jackson , N. , Wallace , S. , Dhandha , J. , Hartley , P. , Riddell-Rovira , C. , Townsend , A. , Morabito , L.K. , McKean , J.P. : High-resolution imaging with the International LOFAR Telescope : Observations of the gravitational lenses ...
2022 doi
-
[18]
, White , R.L
barticle Becker , R.H. , White , R.L. , Helfand , D.J. : The FIRST Survey : Faint Images of the Radio Sky at Twenty Centimeters . The Astrophysical Journal 450 , 559 ( 1995 ) 10.1086/176166 . Accessed 2017-12-07 barticle
1995 doi
-
[19]
, Auger , M.W
barticle Collett , T.E. , Auger , M.W. , Belokurov , V. , Marshall , P.J. , Hall , A.C. : Constraining the dark energy equation of state with double-source plane strong lenses . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 424 , 2864 -- 2875 ( 2012 ) 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2...
2012
-
[20]
, Cotton , W.D
barticle Condon , J.J. , Cotton , W.D. , Greisen , E.W. , Yin , Q.F. , Perley , R.A. , Taylor , G.B. , Broderick , J.J. : The NRAO VLA Sky Survey . The Astronomical Journal 115 ( 5 ), 1693 -- 1716 ( 1998 ) 10.1086/300337 barticle
1998 doi
-
[21]
: Radio emission from normal galaxies
barticle Condon , J.J. : Radio emission from normal galaxies. Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics 30 , 575 ( 1992 ) 10.1146/annurev.aa.30.090192.003043 . Accessed 2021-09-21 barticle
1992
-
[22]
, Timmerman , R
barticle Cordun , C.M. , Timmerman , R. , Miley , G.K. , Weeren , R.J. , Sweijen , F. , Morabito , L.K. , Röttgering , H.J.A. : VLBI imaging of high-redshift galaxies and protoclusters at low radio frequencies with the International LOFAR Telescope . Astronomy and Astrophysics...
2023 doi
-
[23]
, Dijkema , T.J
barticle Gasperin , F. , Dijkema , T.J. , Drabent , A. , Mevius , M. , Rafferty , D. , Weeren , R. , Brüggen , M. , Callingham , J.R. , Emig , K.L. , Heald , G. , Intema , H.T. , Morabito , L.K. , Offringa , A.R. , Oonk , R. , Orrù , E. , Röttgering , H. , Sabater , J. , Shimw...
2019 doi
-
[24]
, Röttgering , H.J.A
barticle Jong , J.M.G.H.J. , Röttgering , H.J.A. , Kondapally , R. , Mingo , B. , Weeren , R.J. , Best , P.N. , Morabito , L.K. , Magliocchetti , M. , Oonk , J.B.R. , Villarrubia-Aguilar , A. , Vecchi , F.F. : Cosmic evolution of FRI and FRII sources out to z = 2.5 . Astronomy...
2024 doi
-
[25]
, Weeren , R.J
barticle Jong , J.M.G.H.J. , Weeren , R.J. , Sweijen , F. , Oonk , J.B.R. , Shimwell , T.W. , Offringa , A.R. , Morabito , L.K. , Röttgering , H.J.A. , Kondapally , R. , Escott , E.L. , Best , P.N. , Bondi , M. , Ye , H. , Petley , J.W. : Into the depths: Unveiling ELAIS - N1 ...
2024 doi
-
[26]
, Röttgering , H.J.A
barticle Dabhade , P. , Röttgering , H.J.A. , Bagchi , J. , Shimwell , T.W. , Hardcastle , M.J. , Sankhyayan , S. , Morganti , R. , Jamrozy , M. , Shulevski , A. , Duncan , K.J. : Giant radio galaxies in the LOFAR Two -metre Sky Survey . I . Radio and environmental properties ...
2020 doi
-
[27]
, Schlegel , D.J
barticle Dey , A. , Schlegel , D.J. , Lang , D. , Blum , R. , Burleigh , K. , Fan , X. , Findlay , J.R. , Finkbeiner , D. , Herrera , D. , Juneau , S. , Landriau , M. , Levi , M. , McGreer , I. , Meisner , A. , Myers , A.D. , Moustakas , J. , Nugent , P. , Patej , A. , Schlafl...
2019
-
[28]
, Smolčić , V
barticle Delvecchio , I. , Smolčić , V. , Zamorani , G. , Lagos , C.D.P. , Berta , S. , Delhaize , J. , Baran , N. , Alexander , D.M. , Rosario , D.J. , Gonzalez-Perez , V. , Ilbert , O. , Lacey , C.G. , Le Fèvre , O. , Miettinen , O. , Aravena , M. , Bondi , M. , Carilli , C....
2017
-
[29]
, van Weeren , R.J
botherref de Jong , J.M.G.H.J. , van Weeren , R.J. , Dijkema , T.J. , Oonk , J.B.R. , R \"o ttgering , H.J.A. , Sweijen , F. : Unlocking ultra-deep wide-field imaging with sidereal visibility averaging . arXiv e-prints, 2501--07374 (2025) 10.48550/arXiv.2501.07374 https://arxi...
-
[30]
, Riley , J.M
barticle Fanaroff , B.L. , Riley , J.M. : The morphology of extragalactic radio sources of high and low luminosity . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 167 , 31 -- 36 ( 1974 ) 10.1093/mnras/167.1.31P . Accessed 2017-12-04 barticle
1974 doi
-
[31]
, Duncan , K.J
barticle Gloudemans , A.J. , Duncan , K.J. , Saxena , A. , Harikane , Y. , Hill , G.J. , Zeimann , G.R. , Röttgering , H.J.A. , Yang , D. , Best , P.N. , Bañados , E. , Drabent , A. , Hardcastle , M.J. , Hennawi , J.F. , Lansbury , G. , Magliocchetti , M. , Miley , G.K. , Nann...
2022
-
[32]
, Hardcastle , M.J
barticle Gürkan , G. , Hardcastle , M.J. , Best , P.N. , Morabito , L.K. , Prandoni , I. , Jarvis , M.J. , Duncan , K.J. , Calistro Rivera , G. , Callingham , J.R. , Cochrane , R.K. , Croston , J.H. , Heald , G. , Mingo , B. , Mooney , S. , Sabater , J. , Röttgering , H.J.A. ,...
2019
-
[33]
, Orrù , E
barticle Govoni , F. , Orrù , E. , Bonafede , A. , Iacobelli , M. , Paladino , R. , Vazza , F. , Murgia , M. , Vacca , V. , Giovannini , G. , Feretti , L. , Loi , F. , Bernardi , G. , Ferrari , C. , Pizzo , R.F. , Gheller , C. , Manti , S. , Brüggen , M. , Brunetti , G. , Cass...
2019
-
[34]
, Sweijen , F
botherref Gloudemans , A.J. , Sweijen , F. , Morabito , L.K. , Farina , E.P. , Duncan , K.J. , Harikane , Y. , Röttgering , H.J.A. , Saxena , A. , Schindler , J.-T. : Monster radio jet ( 66 kpc) observed in quasar at z 5. Publication Title: arXiv e-prints ADS Bibcode: 2024arXi...
2024
-
[35]
, Weeren , R.J
barticle Groeneveld , C. , Weeren , R.J. , Miley , G.K. , Morabito , L.K. , Gasperin , F. , Callingham , J.R. , Sweijen , F. , Brüggen , M. , Botteon , A. , Offringa , A. , Brunetti , G. , Moldon , J. , Bondi , M. , Kappes , A. , Röttgering , H.J.A. : Pushing sub-arcsecond res...
2022 doi
-
[36]
, Weeren , R.J
barticle Groeneveld , C. , Weeren , R.J. , Osinga , E. , Williams , W.L. , Callingham , J.R. , Gasperin , F. , Botteon , A. , Shimwell , T. , Sweijen , F. , Jong , J.M.G.H.J. , Jansen , L.F. , Miley , G.K. , Brunetti , G. , Brüggen , M. , Röttgering , H.J.A. : Characterization...
2024 doi
-
[37]
: Spectral ageing in the era of big data: integrated versus resolved models
barticle Harwood , J.J. : Spectral ageing in the era of big data: integrated versus resolved models . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 466 , 2888 -- 2894 ( 2017 ) 10.1093/mnras/stw3318 . Accessed 2018-02-05 barticle
2017 doi
-
[38]
, Gürkan , G
barticle Hardcastle , M.J. , Gürkan , G. , Weeren , R.J. , Williams , W.L. , Best , P.N. , Gasperin , F. , Rafferty , D.A. , Read , S.C. , Sabater , J. , Shimwell , T.W. , Smith , D.J.B. , Tasse , C. , Bourne , N. , Brienza , M. , Brüggen , M. , Brunetti , G. , Chyży , K.T. , ...
1910
-
[39]
, Hardcastle , M.J
barticle Harwood , J.J. , Hardcastle , M.J. , Croston , J.H. : Spectral ageing in the lobes of cluster-centre FR II radio galaxies . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 454 , 3403 -- 3422 ( 2015 ) 10.1093/mnras/stv2194 . Accessed 2017-12-05 barticle
2015 doi
-
[40]
, Hardcastle , M.J
barticle Harwood , J.J. , Hardcastle , M.J. , Croston , J.H. , Goodger , J.L. : Spectral ageing in the lobes of FR - II radio galaxies: new methods of analysis for broad-band radio data . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 435 , 3353 -- 3375 ( 2013 ) 10.1093/mnr...
2013 doi
-
[41]
, Jackson , N
botherref Hartley , P. , Jackson , N. , Sluse , D. , Stacey , H.R. , Vives-Arias , H. : Strong lensing reveals jets in a sub- microJy radio quiet quasar. arXiv e-prints, 1901--05791 (2019). Accessed 2019-01-23 botherref
2019
-
[42]
, Mooney , S
barticle Harwood , J.J. , Mooney , S. , Morabito , L.K. , Quinn , J. , Sweijen , F. , Groeneveld , C. , Bonnassieux , E. , Kappes , A. , Moldon , J. : The resolved jet of 3C 273 at 150 MHz . Sub -arcsecond imaging with the LOFAR international baselines . Astronomy and Astrophy...
2022 doi
-
[43]
, Moldón , J
barticle Harris , D.E. , Moldón , J. , Oonk , J.R.R. , Massaro , F. , Paggi , A. , Deller , A. , Godfrey , L. , Morganti , R. , Jorstad , S.G. : LOFAR Observations of 4C +19.44: On the Discovery of Low -frequency Spectral Curvature in Relativistic Jet Knots . The Astrophysical...
2019 doi
-
[44]
, O'Sullivan , S.P
barticle Herrera Ruiz , N. , O'Sullivan , S.P. , Vacca , V. , Jeli \'c , V. , Nikiel-Wroczy \'n ski , B. , Bourke , S. , Sabater , J. , Dettmar , R.-J. , Heald , G. , Horellou , C. , Piras , S. , Sobey , C. , Shimwell , T.W. , Tasse , C. , Hardcastle , M.J. , Kondapally , R. ,...
2021 arXiv
-
[45]
, Badole , S
barticle Jackson , N. , Badole , S. , Morgan , J. , Chhetri , R. , Prūsis , K. , Nikolajevs , A. , Morabito , L. , Brentjens , M. , Sweijen , F. , Iacobelli , M. , Orrù , E. , Sluman , J. , Blaauw , R. , Mulder , H. , Dijk , P. , Mooney , S. , Deller , A. , Moldon , J. , Calli...
2022
-
[46]
, Morganti , R
barticle Jurlin , N. , Morganti , R. , Sweijen , F. , Morabito , L.K. , Brienza , M. , Barthel , P. , Miley , G.K. : Nuclear regions as seen with LOFAR international baselines. A high-resolution study of the recurrent activity . Astronomy and Astrophysics 682 , 118 ( 2024 ) 10...
2024 doi
-
[47]
, Morganti , R
barticle Kukreti , P. , Morganti , R. , Shimwell , T.W. , Morabito , L.K. , Beswick , R.J. , Brienza , M. , Hardcastle , M.J. , Sweijen , F. , Jackson , N. , Miley , G.K. , Moldon , J. , Oosterloo , T. , Gasperin , F. : Unmasking the history of 3C 293 with LOFAR sub-arcsecond ...
2022 doi
-
[48]
, Sramek , R
barticle Kellermann , K.I. , Sramek , R. , Schmidt , M. , Shaffer , D.B. , Green , R. : VLA observations of objects in the Palomar Bright Quasar Survey . The Astronomical Journal 98 , 1195 -- 1207 ( 1989 ) 10.1086/115207 . Accessed 2017-12-18 barticle
1989 doi
-
[49]
, Croston , J.H
barticle Mingo , B. , Croston , J.H. , Best , P.N. , Duncan , K.J. , Hardcastle , M.J. , Kondapally , R. , Prandoni , I. , Sabater , J. , Shimwell , T.W. , Williams , W.L. , Baldi , R.D. , Bonato , M. , Bondi , M. , Dabhade , P. , Gürkan , G. , Ineson , J. , Magliocchetti , M....
2022 doi
-
[50]
, Croston , J.H
barticle Mingo , B. , Croston , J.H. , Hardcastle , M.J. , Best , P.N. , Duncan , K.J. , Morganti , R. , Rottgering , H.J.A. , Sabater , J. , Shimwell , T.W. , Williams , W.L. , Brienza , M. , Gurkan , G. , Mahatma , V.H. , Morabito , L.K. , Prandoni , I. , Bondi , M. , Ineson...
2019
-
[51]
, Deller , A.T
barticle Morabito , L.K. , Deller , A.T. , Röttgering , H. , Miley , G. , Varenius , E. , Shimwell , T.W. , Moldón , J. , Jackson , N. , Morganti , R. , Weeren , R.J. , Oonk , J.B.R. : LOFAR VLBI studies at 55 MHz of 4C 43.15, a z = 2.4 radio galaxy . Monthly Notices of the Ro...
2016 doi
-
[52]
: RMextract: Ionospheric Faraday Rotation Calculator botherref
botherref Mevius , M. : RMextract: Ionospheric Faraday Rotation Calculator botherref
-
[53]
, Jackson , N.J
barticle Morabito , L.K. , Jackson , N.J. , Mooney , S. , Sweijen , F. , Badole , S. , Kukreti , P. , Venkattu , D. , Groeneveld , C. , Kappes , A. , Bonnassieux , E. , Drabent , A. , Iacobelli , M. , Croston , J.H. , Best , P.N. , Bondi , M. , Callingham , J.R. , Conway , J.E...
2022
-
[54]
, Kondapally , R
barticle Morabito , L.K. , Kondapally , R. , Best , P.N. , Yue , B.-H. , Jong , J.M.G.H.J. , Sweijen , F. , Bondi , M. , Schwarz , D.J. , Smith , D.J.B. , Weeren , R.J. , Röttgering , H.J.A. , Shimwell , T.W. , Prandoni , I. : A hidden active galactic nucleus population: the f...
2025 doi
-
[55]
, Luichies , R
barticle McKean , J.P. , Luichies , R. , Drabent , A. , Gürkan , G. , Hartley , P. , Lafontaine , A. , Prandoni , I. , Röttgering , H.J.A. , Shimwell , T.W. , Stacey , H.R. , Tasse , C. : Gravitational lensing in LoTSS DR2 : extremely faint 144- MHz radio emission from two hig...
2021 doi
-
[56]
, Sweijen , F
barticle Morabito , L.K. , Sweijen , F. , Radcliffe , J.F. , Best , P.N. , Kondapally , R. , Bondi , M. , Bonato , M. , Duncan , K.J. , Prandoni , I. , Shimwell , T.W. , Williams , W.L. , Weeren , R.J. , Conway , J.E. , Calistro Rivera , G. : Identifying active galactic nuclei...
2022 doi
-
[57]
: Compression of interferometric radio-astronomical data
barticle Offringa , A.R. : Compression of interferometric radio-astronomical data . Astronomy and Astrophysics 595 , 99 ( 2016 ) 10.1051/0004-6361/201629565 . Accessed 2021-01-08 barticle
2016 doi
-
[58]
, Hardcastle , M.J
barticle Oei , M.S.S.L. , Hardcastle , M.J. , Timmerman , R. , Gast , A.R.D.J.G.I.B. , Botteon , A. , Rodriguez , A.C. , Stern , D. , Calistro Rivera , G. , Weeren , R.J. , Röttgering , H.J.A. , Intema , H.T. , Gasperin , F. , Djorgovski , S.G. : Black hole jets on the scale o...
2024 doi
-
[59]
: Absolute Energy Distribution in the Optical Spectrum of 3C 273
barticle Oke , J.B. : Absolute Energy Distribution in the Optical Spectrum of 3C 273 . Nature 197 , 1040 -- 1041 ( 1963 ) 10.1038/1971040b0 . ADS Bibcode: 1963Natur.197.1040O . Accessed 2024-09-03 barticle
1963 doi
-
[60]
, Shimwell , T.W
barticle O'Sullivan , S.P. , Shimwell , T.W. , Hardcastle , M.J. , Tasse , C. , Heald , G. , Carretti , E. , Br \"u ggen , M. , Vacca , V. , Sobey , C. , Van Eck , C.L. , Horellou , C. , Beck , R. , Bilicki , M. , Bourke , S. , Botteon , A. , Croston , J.H. , Drabent , A. , Du...
2023 arXiv
-
[61]
, Baldi , R.D
barticle Panessa , F. , Baldi , R.D. , Laor , A. , Padovani , P. , Behar , E. , McHardy , I. : The origin of radio emission from radio-quiet active galactic nuclei . Nature Astronomy 3 , 387 -- 396 ( 2019 ) 10.1038/s41550-019-0765-4 . ADS Bibcode: 2019NatAs...3..387P . Accesse...
2019 doi
-
[62]
, Horellou , C
barticle Piras , S. , Horellou , C. , Conway , J.E. , Thomasson , M. , Palacio , S. , Shimwell , T.W. , O'Sullivan , S.P. , Carretti , E. , Šnidarić , I. , Jelić , V. , Adebahr , B. , Berger , A. , Best , P.N. , Brüggen , M. , Herrera Ruiz , N. , Paladino , R. , Prandoni , I. ...
2024 doi
-
[63]
: On the possibility of determining Hubble 's parameter and the masses of galaxies from the gravitational lens effect
barticle Refsdal , S. : On the possibility of determining Hubble 's parameter and the masses of galaxies from the gravitational lens effect . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 128 , 307 ( 1964 ) 10.1093/mnras/128.4.307 . Publisher: OUP ADS Bibcode: 1964MNRAS.12...
1964 doi
-
[64]
, Garrett , M.A
barticle Radcliffe , J.F. , Garrett , M.A. , Muxlow , T.W.B. , Beswick , R.J. , Barthel , P.D. , Deller , A.T. , Keimpema , A. , Campbell , R.M. , Wrigley , N. : Nowhere to Hide : Radio -faint AGN in GOODS - N field. I . Initial catalogue and radio properties . Astronomy & Ast...
2018 doi
-
[65]
, Varenius , E
barticle Ramírez-Olivencia , N. , Varenius , E. , Pérez-Torres , M. , Alberdi , A. , Pérez , E. , Alonso-Herrero , A. , Deller , A. , Herrero-Illana , R. , Moldón , J. , Barcos-Muñoz , L. , Martí-Vidal , I. : Sub-arcsecond imaging of Arp 299- A at 150 MHz with LOFAR : Evidence...
2018 doi
-
[66]
, Best , P.N
bchapter Smith , D.J.B. , Best , P.N. , Duncan , K.J. , Hatch , N.A. , Jarvis , M.J. , Röttgering , H.J.A. , Simpson , C.J. , Stott , J.P. , Cochrane , R.K. , Coppin , K.E. , Dannerbauer , H. , Davis , T.A. , Geach , J.E. , Hale , C.L. , Hardcastle , M.J. , Hatfield , P.W. , H...
2016 arXiv
-
[67]
, Best , P.N
barticle Sabater , J. , Best , P.N. , Tasse , C. , Hardcastle , M.J. , Shimwell , T.W. , Nisbet , D. , Jelic , V. , Callingham , J.R. , Röttgering , H.J.A. , Bonato , M. , Bondi , M. , Ciardi , B. , Cochrane , R.K. , Jarvis , M.J. , Kondapally , R. , Koopmans , L.V.E. , O'Sull...
2021
-
[68]
, Cotton , W.D
barticle Schwab , F.R. , Cotton , W.D. : Global fringe search techniques for VLBI . The Astronomical Journal 88 , 688 -- 694 ( 1983 ) 10.1086/113360 . Accessed 2021-01-27 barticle
1983 doi
-
[69]
: 3C 273 : A Star - Like Object with Large Red - Shift
barticle Schmidt , M. : 3C 273 : A Star - Like Object with Large Red - Shift . nat 197 , 1040 ( 1963 ) 10.1038/1971040a0 barticle
1963 doi
-
[70]
o ttgering , H.J.A. , Tasse , C. , van Weeren , R.J. , Williams , W.L. , Bonafede , A. , Bondi , M. , Br \
botherref Shimwell , T.W. , Hale , C.L. , Best , P.N. , Botteon , A. , Drabent , A. , Hardcastle , M.J. , Jeli \'c , V. , de Jong , J.M.G.H.J. , Kondapally , R. , R \"o ttgering , H.J.A. , Tasse , C. , van Weeren , R.J. , Williams , W.L. , Bonafede , A. , Bondi , M. , Br \"u g...
-
[71]
, Hardcastle , M.J
barticle Shimwell , T.W. , Hardcastle , M.J. , Tasse , C. , Best , P.N. , Röttgering , H.J.A. , Williams , W.L. , Botteon , A. , Drabent , A. , Mechev , A. , Shulevski , A. , Weeren , R.J. , Bester , L. , Brüggen , M. , Brunetti , G. , Callingham , J.R. , Chyży , K.T. , Conway...
2022
-
[72]
, Jeli \'c , V
barticle S nidari \'c , I. , Jeli \'c , V. , Mevius , M. , Brentjens , M. , Erceg , A. , Shimwell , T.W. , Piras , S. , Horellou , C. , Sabater , J. , Best , P.N. , Bracco , A. , Ceraj , L. , Haverkorn , M. , O'Sullivan , S.P. , Turi \'c , L. , Vacca , V. : LOFAR Deep Fields: ...
2023 arXiv
-
[73]
, Morabito , L.K
barticle Sweijen , F. , Morabito , L.K. , Harwood , J. , Weeren , R.J. , Röttgering , H.J.A. , Callingham , J.R. , Jackson , N. , Miley , G. , Moldon , J. : High-resolution international LOFAR observations of 4C 43.15. Spectral ages and injection indices in a high-z radio gala...
2022 doi
-
[74]
, Tasse , C
barticle Shimwell , T.W. , Tasse , C. , Hardcastle , M.J. , Mechev , A.P. , Williams , W.L. , Best , P.N. , Röttgering , H.J.A. , Callingham , J.R. , Dijkema , T.J. , Gasperin , F. , Hoang , D.N. , Hugo , B. , Mirmont , M. , Oonk , J.B.R. , Prandoni , I. , Rafferty , D. , Saba...
2019
-
[75]
, Weeren , R.J
barticle Sweijen , F. , Weeren , R.J. , Röttgering , H.J.A. , Morabito , L.K. , Jackson , N. , Offringa , A.R. , Tol , S. , Veenboer , B. , Oonk , J.B.R. , Best , P.N. , Bondi , M. , Shimwell , T.W. , Tasse , C. , Thomson , A.P. : Deep sub-arcsecond wide-field imaging of the L...
2022 doi
-
[76]
, Shimwell , T
barticle Tasse , C. , Shimwell , T. , Hardcastle , M.J. , O'Sullivan , S.P. , Weeren , R. , Best , P.N. , Bester , L. , Hugo , B. , Smirnov , O. , Sabater , J. , Calistro-Rivera , G. , Gasperin , F. , Morabito , L.K. , Röttgering , H. , Williams , W.L. , Bonato , M. , Bondi , ...
2021
-
[77]
, Conway , J.E
barticle Varenius , E. , Conway , J.E. , Martí-Vidal , I. , Beswick , R. , Deller , A.T. , Wucknitz , O. , Jackson , N. , Adebahr , B. , Pérez-Torres , M.A. , Chyży , K.T. , Carozzi , T.D. , Moldón , J. , Aalto , S. , Beck , R. , Best , P. , Dettmar , R.-J. , Driel , W. , Brun...
2015
-
[78]
, Conway , J.E
barticle Varenius , E. , Conway , J.E. , Martí-Vidal , I. , Aalto , S. , Barcos-Muñoz , L. , König , S. , Pérez-Torres , M.A. , Deller , A.T. , Moldón , J. , Gallagher , J.S. , Yoast-Hull , T.M. , Horellou , C. , Morabito , L.K. , Alberdi , A. , Jackson , N. , Beswick , R. , C...
2016
-
[79]
, Haverkorn , M
barticle Van Eck , C.L. , Haverkorn , M. , Alves , M.I.R. , Beck , R. , Best , P. , Carretti , E. , Chy \.z y , K.T. , Farnes , J.S. , Ferri \`e re , K. , Hardcastle , M.J. , Heald , G. , Horellou , C. , Iacobelli , M. , Jeli \'c , V. , Mulcahy , D.D. , O'Sullivan , S.P. , Pol...
2018 arXiv
-
[80]
, Wise , M.W
barticle Haarlem , M.P. , Wise , M.W. , Gunst , A.W. , Heald , G. , McKean , J.P. , Hessels , J.W.T. , Bruyn , A.G. , Nijboer , R. , Swinbank , J. , Fallows , R. , Brentjens , M. , Nelles , A. , Beck , R. , Falcke , H. , Fender , R. , Hörandel , J. , Koopmans , L.V.E. , Mann ,...
2013
-
[81]
, Gasperin , F
barticle Weeren , R.J. , Gasperin , F. , Akamatsu , H. , Brüggen , M. , Feretti , L. , Kang , H. , Stroe , A. , Zandanel , F. : Diffuse Radio Emission from Galaxy Clusters . Space Science Reviews 215 , 16 ( 2019 ) 10.1007/s11214-019-0584-z . ADS Bibcode: 2019SSRv..215...16V . ...
2019 doi
-
[82]
, Shimwell , T.W
barticle Weeren , R.J. , Shimwell , T.W. , Botteon , A. , Brunetti , G. , Brüggen , M. , Boxelaar , J.M. , Cassano , R. , Di Gennaro , G. , Andrade-Santos , F. , Bonnassieux , E. , Bonafede , A. , Cuciti , V. , Dallacasa , D. , Gasperin , F. , Gastaldello , F. , Hardcastle , M...
2021
-
[83]
, Timmerman , R
botherref Weeren , R.J. , Timmerman , R. , Vaidya , V. , Gendron-Marsolais , M.-L. , Botteon , A. , Roberts , I.D. , Hlavacek-Larrondo , J. , Bonafede , A. , Brüggen , M. , Brunetti , G. , Cassano , R. , Cuciti , V. , Edge , A.C. , Gastaldello , F. , Groeneveld , C. , Shimwell...
-
[84]
, Williams , W.L
barticle Weeren , R.J. , Williams , W.L. , Hardcastle , M.J. , Shimwell , T.W. , Rafferty , D.A. , Sabater , J. , Heald , G. , Sridhar , S.S. , Dijkema , T.J. , Brunetti , G. , Brüggen , M. , Andrade-Santos , F. , Ogrean , G.A. , Röttgering , H.J.A. , Dawson , W.A. , Forman , ...
2016
-
[85]
, Helfand , D.J
barticle White , R.L. , Helfand , D.J. , Becker , R.H. , Glikman , E. , Vries , W. : Signals from the Noise : Image Stacking for Quasars in the FIRST Survey . The Astrophysical Journal 654 ( 1 ), 99 ( 2007 ) 10.1086/507700 . Accessed 2019-03-27 barticle
2007 doi
-
[86]
, Strom , R.G
barticle Willis , A.G. , Strom , R.G. , Wilson , A.S. : 3C236 , DA240 ; the largest radio sources known . Nature 250 , 625 -- 630 ( 1974 ) 10.1038/250625a0 . ADS Bibcode: 1974Natur.250..625W . Accessed 2024-11-19 barticle
1974 doi
-
[87]
, " * write output.state after.block = add.period write newline
ENTRY address archive author booktitle chapter doi edition editor eid eprint howpublished institution journal key keywords month note number organization pages publisher school series title type url volume year archivePrefix primaryClass adsurl adsnote version label extra.labe...
-
[88]
write newline
" write newline "" before.all 'output.state := FUNCTION add.period duplicate empty 'skip "." * add.blank if FUNCTION if.digit duplicate "0" = swap duplicate "1" = swap duplicate "2" = swap duplicate "3" = swap duplicate "4" = swap duplicate "5" = swap duplicate "6" = swap dupl...
-
[89]
write newline
" write newline "" before.all 'output.state := FUNCTION string.to.integer 't := t text.length 'k := #1 'char.num := t char.num #1 substring 's := s is.num s "." = or char.num k = not and char.num #1 + 'char.num := while char.num #1 - 'char.num := t #1 char.num substring FUNCTI...
Reviewed August 8, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.
Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.