Pith. sign in

REVIEW 4 major objections 5 minor 33 references

Visually Constructing the Chemical Structure of a Single Molecule by Scanning Raman Picoscopy

T0 review · 4 major / 5 minor · reviewed 2026-08-14 · deepseek-v4-flash

Challenge this review Re-run · record.json Download PDF Read on arXiv ↗ Review JSON

Pith's one-line read The paper shows that Ångström-resolved Raman images of individual vibrational modes, read through bond-interference contrast, can determine the complete chemical structure of a single Mg-porphine molecule in real space.

desk verdict Genuine new vibrational-mode imaging for a single molecule, but the 1.5 Å resolution claim is under-sampled and the Lego reconstruction is demonstrated on a known structure; deserves peer review with a blind test. read the letter →

arxiv 1908.08720 v2 pith:7DD7AITA submitted 2019-08-23 physics.chem-ph physics.optics

Yao Zhang , Ben Yang , Atif Ghafoor , Yang Zhang , Yu-Fan Zhang , Rui-Pu Wang , Jin-Long Yang , Yi Luo
show 2 more authors
Zhen-Chao Dong J. G. Hou
This is my paper · ORCID
classification physics.chem-phphysics.optics
keywords scanningRamanpicoscopytip-enhancedspectroscopysingle-moleculevibrationalimagingÅngströmresolutioninterferenceeffectchemicalstructuredeterminationMg-porphinemolecularLegoassembly
verification ladder T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal

The pith

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The reading

Scanning Raman picoscopy is introduced as a way to determine the chemical structure of a single molecule directly in real space. The paper reports full Raman images of individual vibrational modes of one Mg-porphine molecule on Ag(100), with a spatial resolution of 1.5(1) Å, and shows that each mode has its own characteristic spatial pattern. The key step is reading the interference between neighboring bond vibrations: in-phase vibrations add constructively, out-of-phase vibrations cancel, so bright and dark spots mark actual bond positions and connectivity. By overlaying just a few mode images and using Raman group-frequency fingerprints, the authors reconstruct the entire Mg-porphine structure through a Lego-like assembly.

What carries the argument

The load-bearing object is the confined nanocavity plasmonic field $g(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R}_0)$ that appears in Eq. (1), together with the atomic-orbital expansion of the vibronic transition moment in Eq. (2). When the tip is over an atom, the diagonal term dominates; when it is between two atoms, the cross-term between neighboring atomic orbitals becomes important. In-phase (symmetric) vibrations give a positive cross-term and constructive signal; out-of-phase (antisymmetric) vibrations give a negative cross-term and destructive signal. This interference effect turns normal-mode images into a map of bond positions and phase relations, and the Raman fingerprint database supplies the chemical identity of each piece (C–H, pyrrole ring, C–H bridge, Mg–N).

What would settle it

Deuterating the eight C–H bonds of the molecule should shift the 3072 cm−1 mode to roughly 2200–2300 cm−1; if the eight-dot SRP image does not follow the shifted mode, the bond-level assignment and the interference model are wrong. A second check is to broaden the nanocavity, for example with a blunter tip: the eight-dot pattern should wash out into fewer lobes as the field ceases to sample single bonds.

Watch

Extended reading notes

Core claim

The paper claims that a single molecule's chemical structure can be fully determined in real space from Ångström-resolved Raman images alone. For a single Mg-porphine molecule, the authors obtain complete spatial maps of many vibrational modes at a resolution of 1.5(1) Å. The 3072 cm−1 mode appears as eight bright dots marking eight sp2 C–H bonds, while the 3092 cm−1 mode has four lobes from constructive interference between neighboring C–H bonds. Pyrrole ring modes in the 1300–1700 cm−1 region show four-lobe patterns whose contrast encodes whether neighboring rings vibrate symmetrically or antisymmetrically, and low-frequency modes locate the central Mg atom via Mg–N vibrations. Combining these images with Raman fingerprint frequencies, the paper shows that the molecule's connectivity can be assembled piece by piece, and computed images agree well with the experimental ones.

Load-bearing premise

The argument depends on the nanocavity field being narrow enough that the Raman signal at each tip position reports only the molecule directly beneath the tip, with the sign of the cross-term between neighboring atomic orbitals faithfully encoding whether their vibration is in phase or out of phase.

Editorial extensions

If this is right

  • Chemical structure determination of surface-adsorbed molecules can be done in real space from a handful of Raman images, without crystallization or ensemble averaging.
  • Full vibrational-mode imaging at 1.5 Å resolution pushes tip-enhanced Raman spectromicroscopy to the single-chemical-bond level.
  • The Lego-style assembly protocol is intended to generalize to other molecules, and the authors point to machine-learning image recognition as a natural next step.
  • Combining SRP with noncontact AFM or inelastic tunneling probes should add complementary structural constraints for molecules where Raman fingerprints alone are ambiguous.

Reading between the lines

Editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

  • Beyond the paper: if the sign of the cross-term reliably reports vibrational phase, SRP images could be inverted to recover the full normal-mode eigenvector of a single molecule, not just its structure.
  • Beyond the paper: the phase-sensitive contrast should be isotope-sensitive, so deuterating specific bonds would provide a direct test and a way to tag chosen groups in a larger molecule.
  • Beyond the paper: an automated structure-solver that takes a stack of SRP images and returns connectivity would turn the Lego procedure into a general algorithm, which the authors hint at but do not implement.
  • Beyond the paper: the 1.5 Å resolution and phase readout may also reveal how a molecule deforms when adsorbed on a metal surface, since out-of-plane modes would report the molecule–surface coupling.
Share X Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit HN

Signed reviews

No signed human review yet.

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, and a circularity audit.

Referee Report

4 major / 5 minor

Summary. The paper reports scanning Raman picoscopy (SRP), a tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) method in which a Raman spectrum is acquired at each pixel of a 25 × 25 scan over a single Mg-porphine molecule adsorbed on Ag(100). The authors claim Ångström-level spatial resolution, with a 1.5(1) Å FWHM line profile for the 3072 cm−1 mode, and present spatial maps for a number of vibrational modes that show distinct patterns. They interpret the images through an interference effect between neighboring bonds or rings, encoded in the sign of a cross-term in Eq. (2), and use these patterns together with Raman group frequencies to assemble the molecular structure in a 'Lego-like' fashion. The final structure is reported as fully determined in real space, and computed SRP images (Supplementary S4) are said to agree with experiment, validating the proposed methodology.

Significance. If the claims hold, SRP would be a significant advance: it would extend single-molecule TERS from spectral fingerprinting to bond-resolved real-space imaging and offer a route to structural determination of surface-adsorbed molecules. The experimental data are rich and the reported mode-specific images are visually compelling. The authors also make a genuine methodological proposal that combines Raman fingerprints, spatial mode images, and an interference rule to constrain molecular connectivity. However, the quantitative resolution claim is not supported by the stated sampling, and the structural reconstruction relies heavily on prior knowledge of the molecule and on an asserted sign rule; these issues must be addressed before the central claims can be accepted.

major comments (4)
  1. [Fig. 1c–e, Results and Discussion] The claimed 1.5(1) Å spatial resolution is under-sampled relative to the stated acquisition parameters. The SRP image in Fig. 1c is acquired over 2.5 nm × 2.5 nm with 25 × 25 pixels, giving a 1.0 Å pixel pitch. Nyquist sampling of a 1.5 Å FWHM feature requires a pitch of about 0.75 Å or smaller, so the line profile in Fig. 1e cannot robustly determine the FWHM or its 0.1 Å uncertainty without additional raw data or an explicit, validated interpolation procedure. Because the interpretation of the eight bright dots in Fig. 2c as eight individual C–H bonds and the bond-level Lego construction both rely on this resolution claim, the manuscript needs to present higher-sampled line data or a carefully described and justified resampling/error analysis.
  2. [Lego assembly, Results and Discussion, Figs. 2–4] The structural reconstruction is not de novo: the target molecule, its elemental composition (C, N, H, Mg), and its expected vibrational frequencies are known from the literature before the Lego assembly begins. Each step, from sp2 C–H groups to pyrrole rings, bridging C–H, and the central Mg atom, is anchored in Raman group frequencies and in reported Mg-porphine modes (Refs. 33–38), and the computed SRP images in Supplementary S4 would use the same assumed structure. Consequently, the claim that the chemical structure is 'fully determined in real space' overstates what the demonstration establishes. The authors should either provide a blinded reconstruction, for example by withholding the molecular identity until after the Lego assembly, or explicitly frame the result as a consistency check and a proof of principle that relies on prior knowledge.
  3. [Eq. (2) and the following paragraph] The sign rule for the interference cross-term is asserted rather than derived. The text states that a positive cross-term from symmetric vibrational motion gives constructive signal and a negative cross-term from anti-symmetric motion gives destructive signal, but the derivation of how the normal-mode phases enter the Raman polarizability and survive the integration with g(r − R0) is not given in the main text. This rule is load-bearing for the interpretation of Fig. 2c/d (eight dots vs. four lobes) and for the phase relations among pyrrole rings in Fig. 3b. The authors should provide the full derivation in the main text or a detailed supplementary section, and show that the sign relationship is robust when the confined field covers more than two atomic centers, as the text itself states it applies to multi-center cases.
  4. [Eqs. (1)–(2), field confinement assumption] The width of the nanocavity field distribution g(r − R0) is a free, unquantified parameter whose value is central to the claimed resolution and to the one-to-one mapping of bright/dark patterns onto bond positions. If the effective optical spot were broader than the 1.5 Å claimed, the cross-term contribution would be smeared and the destructive-interference gaps would not correspond to bond positions. The manuscript should either estimate g(r − R0) from an independent model of the atomistic tip–substrate junction, fit it to the measured line profiles, or report a sensitivity analysis showing how the structural conclusions vary with the assumed field width.
minor comments (5)
  1. [Results and Discussion, Fig. 4] The text refers to the low-frequency mode as '361 cm−1' while the Fig. 4e caption reads '362 cm−1'; please harmonize the values.
  2. [Fig. 1c caption] The caption states the scan size and pixel count (2.5 nm × 2.5 nm, 25 × 25 pixels) but not the pixel pitch; please state explicitly that the pitch is 1.0 Å so that the sampling limitation is transparent to the reader.
  3. [Main text and Supplementary Materials] The derivation of Eq. (2), the analysis of the 1475 cm−1 mode, the computed SRP images, and the Supplementary Video are relegated to Supplementary Materials S2–S4, which are not included in the submitted version. To allow verification, the relevant derivations and the quantitative comparison between simulated and experimental images should be made available with the manuscript.
  4. [References, sp2 C–H assignment] For the assignment of the 3072 and 3092 cm−1 modes to sp2 C–H stretching, the general group-frequency reference [33] is cited; a more specific reference or a normal-mode analysis of Mg-porphine would strengthen the assignment.
  5. [Abstract and Conclusions] The phrase 'full Raman images of individual vibrational modes on the Ångström level' overstates the demonstrated scope; the paper shows images of selected, observed modes. Consider qualifying this as 'representative individual vibrational modes' or 'all observed Raman modes of the target molecule.'

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged · score 2.0 of 10

No significant circularity: central SRP images and structural assembly rest on external Raman fingerprints and benchmarked simulations; only minor non-load-bearing self-citations.

full rationale

The paper's core derivation is experimental: it records spatially resolved Raman spectra of a known Mg-porphine molecule and interprets the resulting mode images using (i) a stated interference model in Eqs. (1)-(2) and (ii) external Raman fingerprint tables and published Mg-porphine vibrational frequencies [33,34,36-38]. The interference sign argument is an explicit assumption, not a parameter fitted to the images. The structural 'Lego' assembly is a proof-of-principle demonstration on a molecule whose identity is known in advance, so the agreement between the assembled structure and the known Mg-porphine structure is validation against a benchmark rather than a reduction of the output to the input. The computed SRP images in Supplementary S4 are independent simulations of the same known structure; they could in principle disagree with experiment, making them a falsifiable consistency check of the imaging model. Self-citations [22,30,32] support background claims about nanoscale plasmonic field confinement and prior TERS imaging, but they are not load-bearing for the structural determination. Under the strict definition of circularity as equation-to-equation equivalence by construction or a fitted parameter renamed as a prediction, no circular step is exhibited in the text.

Assumptions & free parameters 1 free parameters · 5 assumptions · 0 invented entities

The method rests on the localized-field model, the sign-to-symmetry mapping, the stability of the molecule during scanning, and the known identity of the target. These are reasonable assumptions, but they are not independently established in the preprint. No new physical entities are introduced.

free parameters (1)
  • Spatial width of the nanocavity field distribution g(r-R0) = Not disclosed in the preprint
    Eqs. (1)-(2) make the claimed Ångström resolution depend on the confinement of g(r-R0), and the simulated SRP images in Supplementary S4 require a concrete model for this field. No measured or independently determined value appears in the main text.
assumptions (5)
  • standard math Atomic-orbital basis expansion of the vibronic wavefunctions is valid in Eq. (2).
    The derivation of on-atom and cross-term contributions to the Raman image assumes completeness and orthogonality of the atomic orbital basis.
  • domain assumption The nanocavity field g(r-R0) is localized at the Ångström scale and the signal at each tip position is dominated by the molecule directly under the tip.
    This is the physical basis for the full vibrational imaging claim. If the field has long tails, the images would be blurred or would contain off-center molecular contributions.
  • domain assumption The sign of the interference cross-term in Eq. (2) matches the in-phase or out-of-phase character of the local atomic displacements.
    Used to interpret the eight-dot pattern of the 3072 cm-1 mode as antisymmetric C-H stretches and the four-lobe pattern of 3092 cm-1 as symmetric C-H stretches.
  • domain assumption The target molecule does not move, rotate, or change conformation during the multi-hour acquisition of the SRP image stack.
    Each image requires 25 by 25 pixels at 2 s per pixel, and the comparison across images assumes a stationary adsorbate and a stable tip apex at 7 K.
  • domain assumption The target molecule's elemental composition and Raman fingerprints are known in advance from the literature.
    The assembly begins with the statement that the elements are known to be C, N, H and Mg for Mg-porphine, and it uses Raman group frequencies from external tables. This external knowledge anchors the assignments but limits the demonstrated generality.

how reviews work

0 comments
Cite this review

Pith. "Pith review of Visually Constructing the Chemical Structure of a Single Molecule by Scanning Raman Picoscopy." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/7DD7AITA

@misc{pith2026190808720,
  author       = {Pith},
  title        = {Pith review of: Visually Constructing the Chemical Structure of a Single Molecule by Scanning Raman Picoscopy},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/7DD7AITA}},
  note         = {Machine review of arXiv:1908.08720}
}
read the original abstract

The strong spatial confinement of a nanocavity plasmonic field has made it possible to visualize the inner structure of a single molecule and even to distinguish its vibrational modes in real space. With such ever-improved spatial resolution, it is anticipated that full vibrational imaging of a molecule could be achieved to reveal molecular structural details. Here we demonstrate full Raman images of individual vibrational modes on the {\AA}ngstr\"om level for a single Mg-porphine molecule, revealing distinct characteristics of each vibrational mode in real space. Furthermore, by exploiting the underlying interference effect and Raman fingerprint database, we propose a new methodology for structural determination, coined as scanning Raman picoscopy, to show how such ultrahigh-resolution spectromicroscopic vibrational images can be used to visually assemble the chemical structure of a single molecule through a simple Lego-like building process.

Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

33 extracted references · 33 canonical work pages

  1. [2]

    Interpretation of Ultraviolet Spectra of Natural Products

    Scott AI. Interpretation of Ultraviolet Spectra of Natural Products . Amsterdam: Elsevier, 2013

    work page 2013

  2. [4]

    Using Raman spectroscopy to characterize biological materials

    Butler HJ , Ashton L and Bird B et al . Using Raman spectroscopy to characterize biological materials. Nat Pr otoc 2016; 11 : 664 –

    work page 2016

  3. [5]

    Single - molecule vibrational spectroscopy and microscop y

    Stipe BC , Rezaei MA and Ho W. Single - molecule vibrational spectroscopy and microscop y. Science 1998; 280 : 1732 –

    work page 1998

  4. [6]

    Single - Molecule reaction and characterization by Vibrational Excitation

    Kim Y , Komeda T and Kawai M. Single - Molecule reaction and characterization by Vibrational Excitation. Phys Rev Lett 2002; 89 : 126104

    work page 2002

  5. [8]

    Real - space imaging of molecular structure and chemical bonding by single - molecule inelastic tunneling probe

    Chiang CL, Xu C and Han Z M et al . Real - space imaging of molecular structure and chemical bonding by single - molecule inelastic tunneling probe. Science 2014; 344 : 885 –

    work page 2014

  6. [9]

    Atomic resolution of the silicon (111) - (7x7) surface by atomic force microscopy

    Giessibl FJ. Atomic resolution of the silicon (111) - (7x7) surface by atomic force microscopy. Science 1995; 267 : 68 –

    work page 1995

  7. [10]

    The chemical structure of a molecule resolved by atomic force microscopy

    Gross L , Mohn F and Moll N et al . The chemical structure of a molecule resolved by atomic force microscopy . Science 2009; 325 : 1110 –

    work page 2009

  8. [11]

    Nanoscale chemical analysis by tip - enhanced Raman spectroscopy

    Stöckle RM, Suh YD and Deckert V et al . Nanoscale chemical analysis by tip - enhanced Raman spectroscopy. Chem Phys Lett 2000; 318 : 131 –

    work page 2000

Show all 33 references
  1. [12]

    Locally enhanced Raman spectroscopy with an atomic force microscope

    Anderson MS. Locally enhanced Raman spectroscopy with an atomic force microscope. Appl Phys Lett 2000; 76 : 3130 –

    2000

  2. [13]

    Metallized tip amplification of near - field Raman scattering

    Hayazawa N, Inouye Y and Sekkat Z et al . Metallized tip amplification of near - field Raman scattering. Opt Commun 2000; 183 : 333 –

    2000

  3. [14]

    Surface enhanced Raman spectroscopy: towards single molecular spectroscopy

    Pettinger B , Picardi G and Schuster R et al . Surface enhanced Raman spectroscopy: towards single molecular spectroscopy. E lectrochemistry 2000; 68 : 942 –

    2000

  4. [15]

    Single molecule tip - enhanced Raman spectroscopy with silver tips

    Zhang W H , Yeo BS and Schmid T et al . Single molecule tip - enhanced Raman spectroscopy with silver tips. J Phys Chem C 2007; 111 : 1733 –

    2007

  5. [16]

    Scanning - probe Raman spectroscopy with single - molecule sensitivity

    Neacsu CC , Dreyer J and Behr N et al . Scanning - probe Raman spectroscopy with single - molecule sensitivity. Phys Rev B 2007; 73 : 193406

    2007

  6. [17]

    Tip - enhanced Raman spectroscopy and microscopy on single dye molecules with 15 nm resolution

    Steidtner J and Pettinger B. Tip - enhanced Raman spectroscopy and microscopy on single dye molecules with 15 nm resolution. Phys Rev Lett 2008; 100 : 236101

    2008

  7. [18]

    Tip - enhanced Raman spectroscopy of single RNA strands: Towards a novel direct - sequencing method

    Ba ilo E and Deckert V. Tip - enhanced Raman spectroscopy of single RNA strands: Towards a novel direct - sequencing method. Angew Chem Int Ed 2008; 47 : 1658 –

    2008

  8. [19]

    Pressure - assisted tip - enhanced Raman imaging at a resolution of a few nanometres

    Yano TA , Verma P and Saito Y et al . Pressure - assisted tip - enhanced Raman imaging at a resolution of a few nanometres. Nat Photonics 2009; 3 : 473 –

    2009

  9. [20]

    Revealing the molecular structure of single - molecule junctions in different conductance states by fishing - mode tip - enhanced Raman spectroscopy

    Liu Z , Ding SY and Chen ZB et al . Revealing the molecular structure of single - molecule junctions in different conductance states by fishing - mode tip - enhanced Raman spectroscopy. Nat Commun 2011; 2 :

    2011

  10. [21]

    Single - molecule tip - enhanced Raman spectroscopy

    Sonntag MD , Klingsporn JM and Garibay LK et al . Single - molecule tip - enhanced Raman spectroscopy. J Phys Chem C 2012; 116 : 478 –

    2012

  11. [22]

    Chemical mapping of a single molecule by plasmon - enhanced Raman scattering

    Zhang R, Zhang Y and Dong ZC et al . Chemical mapping of a single molecule by plasmon - enhanced Raman scattering. Nature 2013; 498 : 82 –

    2013

  12. [23]

    Distinguishing adjacent molecules on a surface using plasmon - enhanced Raman scattering

    Jiang S , Zhang Y and Zhang R et al . Distinguishing adjacent molecules on a surface using plasmon - enhanced Raman scattering. Nat Nanotechnol 2015; 10 : 865 –

    2015

  13. [24]

    Distinguishing individual DNA bases in a network by non - resonant tip - enhanced Raman scattering

    Zhang R , Zhang X B and Wang H F et al . Distinguishing individual DNA bases in a network by non - resonant tip - enhanced Raman scattering . Angew Chem Int Ed 2017; 56 : 5561 –

    2017

  14. [25]

    Visualizing vibrational normal modes of a single molecule with atomically confined light

    Lee J, Crampton KT and Tallarida N et al . Visualizing vibrational normal modes of a single molecule with atomically confined light. Nature 2019; 568 : 78 –

    2019

  15. [26]

    Resolving the electromagnetic mechanism of surface - enhanced light scattering at single hot spots

    Alonso - González P , Albella P and Schnell M et al . Resolving the electromagnetic mechanism of surface - enhanced light scattering at single hot spots. Nat Commun 2012; 3 :

    2012

  16. [27]

    Atomistic near - field nanoplasmonics: reaching atomic - scale resolution in nanooptics

    Barbry M , Koval P and Marchesin F et al . Atomistic near - field nanoplasmonics: reaching atomic - scale resolution in nanooptics. Nano Lett 2015; 15 : 3410−3419

    2015

  17. [28]

    picocavities

    Benz F , Schmidt MK and Dreismann A et al . Single - molecule optomechanics in “picocavities.” Science 2016; 354 : 726 –

    2016

  18. [29]

    Conformational c ontrast of s urface - m ediated m olecular s witches y ields Ångstrom - s cale s patial r esolution in u ltrahigh v acuum t ip - e nhanced Raman s pectroscopy

    Chiang N H , Chen X and Goubert G et al . Conformational c ontrast of s urface - m ediated m olecular s witches y ields Ångstrom - s cale s patial r esolution in u ltrahigh v acuum t ip - e nhanced Raman s pectroscopy. Nano Lett 2016; 16 : 7774 –

    2016

  19. [30]

    Theoretical modeling of plasmon - enhanced raman images of a single molecule with subnanometer resolution

    Duan S , Tian G J and Ji Y F et al . Theoretical modeling of plasmon - enhanced raman images of a single molecule with subnanometer resolution. J Am Chem Soc 2015; 137 : 9515 –

    2015

  20. [31]

    Single - molecule imaging using atomistic near - field tip - enhanced Raman spectroscop y

    Liu P C , Chulhai DV and Jensen L. Single - molecule imaging using atomistic near - field tip - enhanced Raman spectroscop y . ACS Nano 2017; 11 : 5094 –

    2017

  21. [32]

    Theory for modeling of high resolution resonant and nonresonant Raman images

    Duan S , Tian G J and Luo Y. Theory for modeling of high resolution resonant and nonresonant Raman images . J Chem Theory Comput 2016; 12 : 4986 –

    2016

  22. [35]

    Porphyrazines: synthesis, properties, application

    Kopranenkov VN and Luk’yanets EA. Porphyrazines: synthesis, properties, application. Russ Chem Bull 1995; 44 : 2216 –

    1995

  23. [36]

    Scaled quantum mechanical and experimental vibrational spectra of magnesium and zinc porphyrins

    Jarzȩcki AA , Kozlowski PM and Pulay P et al . Scaled quantum mechanical and experimental vibrational spectra of magnesium and zinc porphyrins. Spectrochim Acta Part A 1997; 53 : 1195 –

    1997

  24. [37]

    Infrared spectra and normal coordinate analysis of metalloporphins

    Ogoshi H , Saito Y and Nakamoto K. Infrared spectra and normal coordinate analysis of metalloporphins. J Chem P hys 1972; 57 : 4194 –

    1972

  25. [38]

    Infrared spectra of metal - free, N′,N - dideuterio, and magnesium porphyrins: density functional calculations

    Zhang X X , Zhang Y X and Jiang J Z . Infrared spectra of metal - free, N′,N - dideuterio, and magnesium porphyrins: density functional calculations. Spectrochim Acta Part A 2005; 61 : 2576 –

    2005

Pith tools

Reviewed August 14, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.