REVIEW 6 minor 19 references
Find k disjoint cycles of distinct lengths or delete O(k^6) vertices
Reviewed by Pith at T0; open to challenge. T0 means a machine referee read the full paper against a public rubric. the ladder, T0–T4 →
T0 review · glm-5.2
2026-07-09 23:49 UTC pith:E2JWU3DM
load-bearing objection First Erdős-Pósa theorem for cycles of distinct lengths; clean modular proof, honest about the gap between O(k^6 polylog(k)) and the conjectured O(k log k).
An ErdH{o}s-P\'osa theorem for cycles and faces of distinct lengths
The pith
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
Core claim
The central discovery is that the Erdős-Pósa duality between packing and covering extends to the setting where cycles must have distinct lengths, with the cycle spectrum Λ(G) (the set of all cycle lengths appearing in G) serving as the covering certificate. The key mechanism is Lemma 2.4: every subdivision of the 6k-prism contains at least k distinct cycle lengths. The proof partitions the 3k square cycles of the prism into three classes based on whether their symmetric difference with one of the two base cycles has positive, negative, or zero weight differential. A pigeonhole argument guarantees one class has size at least k, and within that class, nested symmetric differences produce a mon
What carries the argument
The proof combines three ingredients: (1) a tree-decomposition lemma (Lemma 2.1) showing that coloured subtrees of a tree either contain k disjoint members of distinct colours or admit a hitting set of size k-1; (2) the prism subdivision lemma (Lemma 2.4), which uses a weight argument on symmetric differences of cycles in the 6k-prism to guarantee k distinct cycle lengths; and (3) the Chekuri-Chuzhoy high-treewidth partition theorem, which decomposes a high-treewidth graph into k disjoint subgraphs each of treewidth Ω(k^2), each containing a subdivided 6k-prism. The lower bound construction uses a result of Hennecart-Robert-Yudin from additive combinatorics about sets whose sumset is much sm
Load-bearing premise
The load-bearing lemma is that every subdivision of the 6k-prism contains at least k distinct cycle lengths. The proof is short and uses a pigeonhole argument on the signs of weight differentials of symmetric differences between square cycles and a base cycle. If this lemma failed, the high-treewidth case of the main theorem would collapse.
What would settle it
Construct a subdivision of the 6k-prism with fewer than k distinct cycle lengths, which would refute Lemma 2.4 and break the proof of Corollary 2.6 and hence the main theorem. The authors' lower bound construction (Theorem 1.5) shows that ladders can have few cycle lengths, but prisms have more structure (two base cycles connected by rungs), and the lemma exploits this.
If this is right
- The theorem provides a structural certificate for graphs lacking many vertex-disjoint cycles of distinct lengths: the cycle spectrum of the remaining graph is small, which is a different kind of dual certificate than the usual forest condition in the classic Erdős-Pósa theorem.
- The lower bound construction using additive combinatorics (Theorem 1.5) shows that subdivided ladders can have as few as k^α cycle lengths for α ≈ 0.79, which means the prism-based approach cannot be directly improved to give better bounds without fundamentally different subgraph certificates.
- The surface embedding result (Theorem 1.4) extends the packing-covering duality to coloured faces at prescribed distances, with bounds depending polynomially on the genus, which could find applications in topological graph theory problems involving face packings.
- The conjectured optimal bound of O(k log k) for the hitting set size, if true, would simultaneously match the lower bound from the classic Erdős-Pósa theorem and the lower bound on the cycle spectrum, making the result tight in both parameters.
Where Pith is reading between the lines
- The fact that the problem does not reduce to a standard hypergraph packing-covering problem (as the authors note) suggests that the cycle spectrum serves as a genuinely new type of dual certificate, and the framework might extend to other packing problems where the objects to be packed are constrained by a global property like distinctness.
- The gap between the current O(k^6 polylog(k)) bound and the conjectured O(k log k) is substantial. The bottleneck is the high-treewidth regime and the use of the 6k-prism. A subgraph certificate that guarantees k distinct cycle lengths at lower treewidth than Ω(k^2) would directly improve the bound.
- The additive combinatorics construction showing that sumset-difference set gaps produce ladders with few cycle lengths hints at a deeper connection between additive structure in graphs and cycle length diversity, which could be a productive direction for related extremal questions.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The paper proves an Erdős-Pósa-type theorem for vertex-disjoint cycles of distinct lengths: for every k, every graph G either contains k vertex-disjoint cycles of pairwise different lengths, or admits a hitting set X of size O(k^6 polylog(k)) such that G−X has at most k−1 cycle lengths (Theorem 1.3). An analogous result for coloured faces of embedded graphs is also proved (Theorem 1.4), and a construction from additive combinatorics shows that subdivided ladders can have surprisingly small cycle spectra (Theorem 1.5), suggesting barriers to improving the main bound. The proof of the main theorem proceeds via a clean modular chain: a coloured-subtree lemma (Lemma 2.1) handles bounded-treewidth graphs; a prism cycle-length lemma (Lemma 2.4) combined with the Chekuri-Chuzhoy high-treewidth partition theorem handles the high-treewidth case. Lower bounds (Theorems 3.1, 3.2) show that both the k−1 bound on remaining cycle lengths and an Ω(k log k) lower bound on the hitting set size are best possible.
Significance. This is a significant contribution to the Erdős-Pósa literature. The problem of packing cycles of distinct lengths does not fit into the standard packing-covering hypergraph framework, making the dual certificate (bounding the cycle spectrum after deletion) a novel conceptual contribution. The proof is modular and relies on well-established external results (Birmelé-Bondy-Reed, Chekuri-Chuzhoy, Eppstein, Hennecart-Robert-Yudin) without circularity. The lower bound construction using additive combinatorics (Theorem 1.5) is a notable feature: it provides a concrete barrier showing that the prism-based approach cannot be straightforwardly improved via ladders, and it identifies a genuine obstruction. The algorithmic versions (Appendices A, B) add practical value. The surface embedding result (Theorem 1.4) extends the framework to a natural topological setting with a clean proof via radial graphs and local treewidth.
minor comments (6)
- The abstract states the hitting set bound as O(k^2 d g) while Theorem 1.4 states O(k^2 d(g+1)). These should be made consistent; the (g+1) form is more precise for g=0.
- In the proof of Lemma 2.4, the notation w(C1△Ci) is introduced without explicitly defining the symmetric difference of cycles as an edge set. A brief clarifying sentence would help the reader.
- Theorem 5.5 introduces the constant D = C/(1+C) < 0.4403, but the value of C is defined earlier in Section 5 as log 2 / log(1+√2) < 0.7865. A forward reference or restatement would improve readability.
- The reference [CM26] (Chudnovsky and Maier) is cited as a 2026 arXiv preprint; the authors should verify and update this reference if a published version is available.
- In Theorem 1.3, the algorithmic runtime O(18^{k^5} poly(k) |V(G)|^7) is stated but the derivation is deferred to Appendix A. A brief forward pointer in the main text would be helpful.
- Conjecture 6.1 proposes an optimal bound of O(k log k), which is a natural and important target. This conjecture is currently somewhat buried at the end of Section 6; the authors might consider highlighting it more prominently.
Circularity Check
No circularity found; derivation chain is self-contained against external benchmarks
full rationale
The paper's main theorem (Theorem 1.3) derives from a clean chain: Lemma 2.1 (proved from first principles via induction on trees) → Lemma 2.2 (application to tree-decompositions), combined with Corollary 2.6, which chains Theorem 2.3 (Birmelé-Bondy-Reed 2007, external), Lemma 2.4 (proved from first principles via a weight argument on prism symmetric differences), and Theorem 2.5 (Chekuri-Chuzhoy 2013, external). Theorem 2.7 simply combines Lemma 2.2 and Corollary 2.6. The lower bounds (Theorems 3.1, 3.2) are elementary constructions. Theorem 1.4 derives from Lemma 4.4 (proved in Appendix B) and Theorem 4.5 (proved from first principles), using Theorem 4.3 (Eppstein 2000, external) and Theorem 4.1 (Four Color Theorem + Heawood, external). Theorem 1.5 uses Theorem 5.3 (Hennecart-Robert-Yudin 1999, external). The algorithmic version (Appendix A) uses Theorem A.1 (Visser-Bodlaender 2025, external) and Theorem B.1 (Korhonen-Lokshtanov 2023, external). No load-bearing step reduces to a self-citation: all external results cited in the derivation chain are by non-overlapping author sets. The self-citations that do appear ([AGHK25], [CGH+26], [GHH26], [GHK+24], [GHK+25], [GKKW24]) occur only in the introductory literature survey and Section 6's discussion of extensions, never in the proof of any main result. No parameter is fitted to data and renamed as a prediction. No result is defined in terms of its own conclusion. The derivation is genuinely self-contained.
Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger
axioms (5)
- standard math Chekuri-Chuzhoy high treewidth partition theorem (Theorem 2.5): graphs of treewidth k contain h vertex-disjoint subgraphs of treewidth ≥ r when hr² ≤ k/polylog(k).
- standard math Birmelé-Bondy-Reed prism theorem (Theorem 2.3): graphs of treewidth Ω(k²) contain a subdivision of the k-prism.
- standard math Eppstein's local treewidth bound (Theorem 4.3): graphs of genus g with radius r have treewidth O(r(g+1)).
- standard math Hennecart-Robert-Yudin theorem (Theorem 5.3): for every n and α > C ≈ 0.7865, there exists A ⊆ ℤ with |A| ≥ n and |A+A| ≤ |A−A|^α.
- standard math Four Colour Theorem and Heawood's theorem (Theorem 4.1): graphs on surfaces of Euler genus g are ⌊(7+√(1+24g))/2⌋-colourable.
Cite this review
Pith. "Pith review of An Erd\H{o}s-P\'osa theorem for cycles and faces of distinct lengths." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/E2JWU3DM
@misc{pith2026260706869,
author = {Pith},
title = {Pith review of: An Erd\Hos-P\'osa theorem for cycles and faces of distinct lengths},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/E2JWU3DM}},
note = {Machine review of arXiv:2607.06869}
}
read the original abstract
We show that for every $k \in \mathbb{N}$, every graph $G$ contains $k$ vertex-disjoint cycles of different lengths, or there exists a set $X \subseteq V(G)$ with $|X| \in \mathcal{O}(k^6\mathsf{polylog}(k))$ such that $G-X$ has at most $k-1$ cycle lengths. We also prove analogous results for facial lengths of embedded graphs. Let $G$ be a graph with a closed 2-cell embedding $\psi$ on a surface $\Sigma$ of Euler genus $g$, let $c$ be a colouring of the faces $\mathcal{F}(\psi)$ of $\psi$, and let $R(G,\psi)$ be the radial graph of $(G, \psi)$. Then there exist $k$ faces $F_1, \ldots , F_k \in \mathcal{F}(\psi)$ that are given pairwise distinct colours by $c$ and are pairwise at distance at least $d$ in $\psi$, or there exists a set $X \subseteq V(G)$ of order at most $\mathcal{O}(k^2dg)$ such that $|\{ c(F) \mid F \in \mathcal{F}(\psi) \text{ and } V(F) \cap \bigcup_{x \in X} N^d_{R(G,\psi)}(x) = \emptyset \}| \leq k(k+2)$. Finally, using a result from additive combinatorics, we show that there are subdivided ladders with only a small number of cycle lengths. This suggests that it may be difficult to improve our bounds.
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
[AGHK25] Jungho Ahn, J. Pascal Gollin, Tony Huynh, and O-joung Kwon. A coarse Erdős-Pósa theorem. InProceedings of the 2025 Annual ACM-SIAM Symposium on Discrete Algorithms (SODA), pages 3363–3381. SIAM, Philadelphia, PA, 2025.doi:10.1137/1. 9781611978322.109. 16 [AH76a] K. Appel and W. Haken. The existence of unavoidable sets of geographically good confi...
work page doi:10.1137/1 2025
-
[2]
doi:10.1215/ijm/1256049012. [BBR07a] E. Birmelé, J. A. Bondy, and B. A. Reed. Brambles, prisms and grids. InGraph theory in Paris, Trends Math., pages 37–44. Birkhäuser, Basel,
-
[3]
URL:https: //doi.org/10.1007/978-3-7643-7400-6_4,doi:10.1007/978-3-7643-7400-6\_4. [BBR07b] Etienne Birmelé, J. Adrian Bondy, and Bruce A. Reed. The Erdős-Pósa property for long circuits.Combinatorica, 27(2):135–145, 2007.doi:10.1007/s00493-007-0047-0. [BGS22] Matija Bucić, Lior Gishboliner, and Benny Sudakov. Cycles of many lengths in Hamiltonian graphs....
-
[4]
[CC13] Chandra Chekuri and Julia Chuzhoy
doi:10.1016/0095-8956(71)90016-5. [CC13] Chandra Chekuri and Julia Chuzhoy. Large-treewidth graph decompositions and applications,
-
[5]
Large-Treewidth Graph Decompositions and Applications
URL:https://arxiv.org/abs/1304.1577,arXiv:1304.1577. [CGH+26] Rutger Campbell, J. Pascal Gollin, Meike Hatzel, O-joung Kwon, Rose McCarty, Sang-il Oum, and Sebastian Wiederrecht. The Erdős-Pósa property for circle graphs as vertex-minors. InProceedings of the 2026 Annual ACM-SIAM Symposium on Discrete Algorithms (SODA), pages 4930–4952. SIAM, Philadelphia...
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv doi:10.1137/1.9781611978971.178 2026
-
[6]
[CM26] Maria Chudnovsky and Ilya Maier
International Workshop on Computing by Graph Transformation (Bordeaux, 1991).doi:10.1016/0304-3975(93) 90064-Z. [CM26] Maria Chudnovsky and Ilya Maier. Induced cycles of many lengths.arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.06874,
-
[7]
[CvBJU20] Wouter Cames van Batenburg, Gwenaël Joret, and Arthur Ulmer
doi:10.1016/j.jctb.2020.09.010. [CvBJU20] Wouter Cames van Batenburg, Gwenaël Joret, and Arthur Ulmer. Erdős-Pósa from ball packing.SIAM J. Discrete Math., 34(3):1609–1619, 2020.doi:10.1137/19M1309225. [DJMM24] Vida Dujmović, Gwenaël Joret, Piotr Micek, and Pat Morin. Erdős-Pósa property of cycles that are far apart.Preprint,
-
[8]
Erd\H{o}s--P\'{o}sa property of cycles that are far apart
URL:https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.13893. [EP65] Paul Erdős and Lajos Pósa. On Independent Circuits Contained in a Graph.Canadian Journal of Mathematics, 17:347–352, 1965.doi:10.4153/CJM-1965-035-8. [Epp00] David Eppstein. Diameter and Treewidth in Minor-Closed Graph Families.Algorithmica, 27(3):275–291, June 2000.doi:10.1007/s004530010020. [GHH26] Maximilian...
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv doi:10.4153/cjm-1965-035-8 1965
-
[9]
[Gor24] Maximilian Gorsky.The Structure of (Even) Directed Cycles
ACM.doi:10.1145/3618260.3649682. [Gor24] Maximilian Gorsky.The Structure of (Even) Directed Cycles. PhD thesis, Technische Universität Berlin, September 2024.doi:10.14279/depositonce-21276. [GP25] Agelos Georgakopoulos and Panos Papasoglu. Graph minors and metric spaces.Com- binatorica, 45(3):Paper No. 33, 29, 2025.doi:10.1007/s00493-025-00150-6. 18 [Gro0...
-
[10]
[HJW19] Tony Huynh, Felix Joos, and Paul Wollan. A Unified Erdős–Pósa Theorem for Con- strained Cycles.Combinatorica, 39(1):91–133, February 2019.doi:10.1007/s00493- 017-3683-z. [HK24] Tony Huynh and O-Joung Kwon. On the Erdős-Pósa property for long holes inC4-free graphs.SIAM J. Discrete Math., 38(1):19–42, 2024.doi:10.1137/21M1435239. [HRY99] François H...
-
[11]
Polynomial Bounds in the Apex Minor Theorem
URL:https://www.numdam.org/item/AST_ 1999__258__173_0/. [HW25] Kevin Hendrey and David R. Wood. Polynomial Bounds in the Apex Minor Theorem, March 2025.arXiv:2503.04228,doi:10.48550/arXiv.2503.04228. [KK18] Naonori Kakimura and Ken-ichi Kawarabayashi. The Erdős-Pósa property for edge- disjoint immersions in 4-edge-connected graphs.J. Combin. Theory Ser. B...
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv doi:10.48550/arxiv.2503.04228 2025
-
[12]
[KKKX25] Ken-ichi Kawarabayashi, Stephan Kreutzer, O-joung Kwon, and Qiqin Xie
doi:10.1016/j.jctb.2020.05.002. [KKKX25] Ken-ichi Kawarabayashi, Stephan Kreutzer, O-joung Kwon, and Qiqin Xie. A half- integral Erdős-Pósa theorem for directed odd cycles.Journal of Combinatorial Theory, Series B, 172:115–145, May 2025.doi:10.1016/j.jctb.2024.12.008. [KKM11] Naonori Kakimura, Ken-ichi Kawarabayashi, and Dániel Marx. Packing cycles throug...
-
[13]
ACM.doi:10.1145/3564246.3585245. [Lic14] Nicolas Lichiardopol. Proof of a conjecture of Henning and Yeo on vertex-disjoint directed cycles.SIAM J. Discrete Math., 28(3):1618–1627,
-
[14]
doi:10.1137/ 130922653. [Liu21] Chun-Hung Liu. Packing and covering immersions in 4-edge-connected graphs.Journal of Combinatorial Theory, Series B, 151:148–222, November 2021.doi:10.1016/j. jctb.2021.06.005. [Liu22] Chun-Hung Liu. Packing topological minors half-integrally.Journal of the London Mathematical Society, 106(3):2193–2267, October 2022.doi:10....
work page doi:10.1016/j 2021
-
[15]
Journal of Combinatorial Theory, Series B , volume =
doi:10.1016/j.jctb.2017.01.004. [MT01] Bojan Mohar and Carsten Thomassen.Graphs on Surfaces. Johns Hopkins Studies in the Mathematical Sciences. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore,
-
[16]
Obstructions to Erd\H{o}s-P\'osa Dualities for Minors
[PPTW24] Christophe Paul, Evangelos Protopapas, Dimitrios M Thilikos, and Sebastian Wieder- recht. Obstructions to Erdős-Pósa Dualities for Minors, July 2024.arXiv:2407.09671. [Ree99] Bruce A Reed. Mangoes and Blueberries.Combinatorica, 19(2):267–296, February 1999.doi:10.1007/s004930050056. [RRST96] Bruce A Reed, Neil Robertson, Paul D. Seymour, and Robi...
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv doi:10.1007/s004930050056 2024
-
[17]
doi:10.1016/j.dam.2016.12.025. [Tho88] Carsten Thomassen. On the presence of disjoint subgraphs of a specified type.Journal of Graph Theory, 12(1):101–111, March 1988.doi:10.1002/jgt.3190120111. [Tuz90] Zsolt Tuza. A conjecture on triangles of graphs.Graphs Combin., 6(4):373–380,
-
[18]
[TY23] Robin Thomas and Youngho Yoo
doi:10.1007/BF01787705. [TY23] Robin Thomas and Youngho Yoo. Packing cycles in undirected group-labelled graphs. Journal of Combinatorial Theory, Series B, 161:228–267, July 2023.doi:10.1016/j. jctb.2023.02.011. [VB25] Jonne Visser and Hans L. Bodlaender. Deterministically countingk-paths and trees parameterized by treewidth in single-exponential time. In...
-
[19]
doi:10.4230/lipics.ipec.2025.20. [Ver16] Jacques Verstraëte. Extremal problems for cycles in graphs. InRecent trends in combinatorics, volume 159 ofIMA Vol. Math. Appl., pages 83–116. Springer, [Cham], 2016.doi:10.1007/978-3-319-24298-9_4. 20 A. An algorithmic proof of Theorem 1.3 We now present an algorithmic proof of Theorem 1.3. The key ingredient is t...
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.