A bicriteria perspective on L-Penalty Approaches - A corrigendum to Siddiqui and Gabriel's L-Penalty Approach for Solving MPECs

This paper presents a corrigendum to Theorems 2 and 3 in Siddiqui S, Gabriel S (2013), An SOS1-Based Approach for Solving MPECs with a Natural Gas Market Application, Networks and Spatial Economics 13(2):205--227. In brief, we revise the claim that their L-penalty approach yields a solution satisfying complementarity for any positive value of L, in general. This becomes evident when interpreting the L-penalty method as a weighted-sum scalarization of a bicriteria optimization problem. We also elaborate further assumptions under which the L-penalty approach yields a solution satisfying complementarity.